Ban circumcision in San Fran???

no, the sources I quoted clearly see the female human beings as naturaly unclean, impure, immoral, prone to infidelity, illecit acts, and immodest behavior.

meanwhile, Jews & Muslims circumcise their infant boys for one and only one reason, and it has NOTHING to do with immorality, modesty, sexuality, infidelity, etc etc.

...and yet, for some reason certain folks wish to act willfully ignorant and see no real difference between male and female circumcision.

why is that?
This in no way refutes the post is appears to be in response to.
Both groups of people see their custom as not harmful, but as beneficial.
Why they do it does not change that fact. One group does it because of a false belief that the female is naturally unclean, the other does it because of a false belief that a god wants them to.
But both see it as not harmful. They see it as beneficial. One group thinks they are improving the female, the other thinks they are making god happy.
 
This in no way refutes the post is appears to be in response to.
Both groups of people see their custom as not harmful, but as beneficial.

really?

in many years of Jewish education, I have not heard ONCE that circumcision was beneficial in any way.

not once was that reasoning used to justify it. not from my Rabbis and not from my very religious relatives.

keep making stuff up. ;)

They see it as beneficial.

wrong.

the other thinks they are making god happy.

wrong again. wow, if all others who are against circumcision know THIS little about why Jews and Muslims circumcise, then I guess we really have nothing to worry about.

honestly, if you are going to attempt to speak with authority as to why folks do things you object to, you really should do a few minutes of research into why they actually do it.

but please, continue speaking from ignorance on the matter. sure makes me feel more confident on the ultimate failure of this law.
 
Last edited:
You just told us that the "real reason" is a commandment from God, so kerikiwi is absolutely spot on and in agreement with you to identify the benefit as making God happy.
 
really?

in many years of Jewish education, I have not heard ONCE that circumcision was beneficial in any way.

not once was that reasoning used to justify it. not from my Rabbis and not from my very religious relatives.

They don't see keeping in good with god as beneficial? That leaves two possibilities: keeeping in good with god is seen as harmful, or keeping in good with god is seen as neutral: neither beneficial nor harmful.
 
hey, if you guyz can liken male baby circumcision to teenage female genital mutilation and various torture methods of the Spanish Inquitision,

Nobody did. Your comprehension and reasoning skills are weak, but there is little we can do about that.
 
....what

....do


....you


...think?

Don't know - you've never heard of people going through with circumcision due to societal norms (as evidenced in the post by TB), yet you said that's exactly what you did.

So, you'll forgive any sort of confusion on my part.
 
Would you consider something like faith healing to be a practice that places unnecessary harm on society? Or polygamy? Or animal sacrifice?



But would you ban it?



Well one case that I posted a few pages back was Reynolds v. United States which found "religious duty was not a suitable defence to a criminal indictment".

Another case mentioned in this thread was Emplyment Division v. Smith which found that the state could deny unemployment for people who used peyote regardless of whether it was used for religious purposes or not.

What I did notice was that the precedent of the latter case was more or less overturned by the Religious Freedom Restoration Act which reinstated the Sherbert test from Sherbert v. Verner.

I'm doing some reading myself but Wikipedia has a list of Supreme Court cases involving the First Amendment.

One that I've found interesting so far is Prince v. Massachusetts which found that parental authority isn't absolute and can be restricted in the name of the child's welfare.

Dammit!! I had a response written up! GAH!

To make a long story short, I stand corrected about laws granting religious exemptions, as in the case of the Amish not having to send children to school, and the peyote case with the Religious Freedom Restoration Act which was passed in response to Smith vs. unemployment.

I had also mentioned that many of the court cases which restricts First Amendment rights, as I have said, took into consideration the effects a certain practice has on society, and the effects a ban has on society. They take into serious consideration individual rights vs social interests. If social interests outweighs individual rights, it is totally legal to pass a restriction on said ban. Such as yelling FIRE! in a crowded theater, libel/slander laws, obviously human sacrifices (don;t think there was any court decisions on this, but most certainly if it ever did come up, a ban would be overwhelmingly supported by the SC), and so forth. There is a whole string of Supreme Court decisions which have upheld the interests of society. There are also a whole string of SC decisions upholding individual rights. The most compelling of which was Snyder vs. WBC.

I have skimmed through several cases, and have yet to find any that is nearly as hard a decision to make. Such as WBC, and circumcision. The Smith vs unemployment certainly is a compelling case to look at in this situation. the the ultimate end results allow Native Americans an exemption to the ban on peyote.

Which is why I'm not going to cite Australian case law. That and also because the High Court typically rules more narrowly on religious issues then the the US Supreme Court does. If you want you can read about it on Wikipedia.

Sure. I'll get around to it sometime tomorrow I think. Thanks. :)
 
The foreskin serves a purpose. I posted this link much earlier. Read it. Nihilanth apparently did.

http://www.cirp.org/library/sex_function/

clearly a biased site with a clear agenda.

for example:

It plays an important role in normal human sexual response and is necessary for normal copulatory behavior.40 An understanding of this role is now emerging in the scientific literature. Removal of the foreskin (circumcision) interferes with normal sexual function.

I, my father, my uncles, my cousins, all function normally, as far as sex is concerned. I have never heard of any of my Jewish male friends or non-Jewish male friends who were circumcised, of having any sexual disfunction due to this procedure.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom