Ban circumcision in San Fran???

The Canadian Supreme Court seems to differ: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadi...Youth_and_the_Law_v._Canada_(Attorney_General)

As does the Minnesota Supreme Court: http://www.wnd.com/?pageId=65997 (I personally think this goes a bit too far, though.)

The Supreme Court of the United States even says it is legal to do so in schools: http://www.corpun.com/counuss.htm
I said parents should not be allowed to hit their children, not that they are not allowed. What various courts have to say about various laws is irrelevant to that.
At the risk of certain people thinking I am equating slavery with corporal punishment: in the days when it was legal to hold slaves, the courts would have upheld that right. That would in no way detract from the moral position that slavery should be illegal.
You yourself argued that the law has nothing to do with morals. This discussion is not about what is allowed, but what should be allowed, so no number of legal decisions has any significance.
 
I do not support the legalization of female genetical cutting of ANY kind.

why? because I have yet to read any reasoning behind such procedures accept for sadistic or simply purposes of making life harder for women.

contrary to Jewish & Muslim circumcision rites, which have NO intent to cause harm or pain whatsoever.

it is seen as a commandment by "God", as a mark of the covenant between God and Abraham, and that's it.
.
And Abraham was crazy.
Blindly following the ravings of a crazy man is not something any educated person should choose.
Other than showing someone "you're in the club (and I wouldn't be looking, or care)" with circumcision, it serves no useful purpose.
 
Other than showing someone "you're in the club (and I wouldn't be looking, or care)" with circumcision, it serves no useful purpose.

yep, that's what its about. showing that you're "in the club".

it has no true functional purpose.

just like ear piercings. should it be illegal to pierce the ears of baby girls?
 
Would I have enjoyed it "even more" if I had a foreskin? Who knows? Would you enjoy it any less without one? Who knows?

The point is, it is a benign procedure that does not affect the person whatsoever throughout their life.
Well, which is it? Are the effects nonexistent or just unknown?
 
isn't the penil foreskin highly sensitive to rupture, tares, friction, etc etc?

doesn't it also get stuff stuck inside of it, that needs to be removed and cleaned?

I remember watching a program about British army training, and they showed this guy instructing new recruits how to properly shower. they HAD to pull back the foreskin and clean it all very well.

all I and other foreskin-free folks have to do, is just clean it just like a regular appendage. no special pulling back of anything required.

I'm glad I don't have to deal with that.
 
Last edited:
Sexually transmitted diseases

Human immunodeficiency virus

Main article: Circumcision and HIV
Over forty observational studies have been conducted to investigate the relationship between circumcision and HIV infection.[158] Reviews of these studies have reached differing conclusions about whether circumcision could be used as a prevention method against HIV.[159][160][161][162]



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circumcision#Sexually_transmitted_diseases

well, I am now fully convinced that circumcision, while NOT necessary, certainly does seem to somewhat reduce the risk of various STDs and other health issues.

see? it does have its benefits.

Do not post large amounts of text from other websites.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As ever a procedure looking for a reason - Thunder would you be for FGM if it reduced the risk of transmission of STIs?
 
isn't the penil foreskin highly sensitive to rupture, tares, friction, etc etc?

doesn't it also get stuff stuck inside of it, that needs to be removed and cleaned?

I remember watching a program about British army training, and they showed this guy instructing new recruits how to properly shower. they HAD to pull back the foreskin and clean it all very well.

all I and other foreskin-free folks have to do, is just clean it just like a regular appendage. no special pulling back of anything required.

I'm glad I don't have to deal with that.

So you're using the "5 fewer seconds in the shower" argument? That would be the same argument we could use for everyone shaving their head- because then we wouldn't have to wash hair, and wouldn't have to buy shampoo.

Also, hopefully most people wash between their butt cheeks, and their armpits. Those also use extra movement to get to.

Come on. it's no more difficult to teach a child to properly wash under his foreskin than it is to teach him how to properly wash his bum.
 
As ever a procedure looking for a reason - Thunder would you be for FGM if it reduced the risk of transmission of STIs?

no, because the clear & admitted purpose for FSM is to cause harm.

that's like justifying criminal decapitation because it reduces the likelyhood of a brain tumor.
 
Last edited:
no, because the clear & admitted purpose for FSM is to cause harm.

that's like justifying criminal decapitation because it reduces the likelyhood of a brain tumor.

The clear and admitted basis for male circumcision is religious, and the clear and admitted basis for continuing it in early American society is religiously-based prudishness. THAT'S IT. Saying it doesn't do "much" harm is not a good reason to continue the practice.
 
The clear and admitted basis for male circumcision is religious, and the clear and admitted basis for continuing it in early American society is religiously-based prudishness. THAT'S IT. Saying it doesn't do "much" harm is not a good reason to continue the practice.

we don't live in early American society, now do we?

and what does circumcision have to do with prudishness? do circumcised men not enjoy sex?
 
Please provide evidence of people who follow that custom saying their purpose is to cause harm.
You are just plain wrong.

  • FGM is often motivated by beliefs about what is considered proper sexual behaviour, linking procedures to premarital virginity and marital fidelity. FGM is in many communities believed to reduce a woman's libido, and thereby is further believed to help her resist "illicit" sexual acts. When a vaginal opening is covered or narrowed (type 3 above), the fear of pain of opening it, and the fear that this will be found out, is expected to further discourage "illicit" sexual intercourse among women with this type of FGM.
  • FGM is associated with cultural ideals of femininity and modesty, which include the notion that girls are “clean” and "beautiful" after removal of body parts that are considered "male" or "unclean".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_genital_mutilation#Reasons_for_Female_Genital_Mutilation




happy? these reasons seem pretty harmful to me.
 
So true.

I shall circumcise my frying pans for the same reason.

such stupidity does your side of the argument no good. but it does give me more reasons to ridicule the arguments of those who want to ban male infant circucision. ;)
 
Because, it makes it impossible to understand your argument when it comes to "choice." Basically, whether or not you have a foreskin, seems to be "6 of one, or half dozen of another." There is no reason to restrict a well-established religious practice of Jews, Muslims, and Christians, as protected in the First Amendment.
Not sure if I can be bothered to wade through this entire thread, but you've claimed the above at least twice before, and I dearly hope someone has corrected you already, but circumcism is not required of Christians, as it is of Jews and Muslims. I went to a Catholic boys senior school, and from locker room observations, there was only one kid in my class who was circumcised, and that was certainly seen as "unusual" enough to have the piss ripped out of him for it. Then again, the prevalence of circumcision in the UK is nowhere near that of the US.
 
Last edited:
It's always so disheartening to see beautiful men and boys be equipped with scarred and mutilated penises. The Jews, Muslims, Christians and other morons who do this to their children sure have a lot on their conscience.
 
happy? these reasons seem pretty harmful to me.

The people who follow that custom do not see it as harmful, just as those who circumcise baby boys do not see it as harmful.
In fact both see the custom as beneficial.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom