Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Whereas, for circumcision, you were looking at the action itself. There is no benefit in the action to society and the individual, I agree. But when you look at the BANNING of circumcision, rather than the ACT of circumcision itself, you can easily say the benefit to society is that religious freedom is not infringed.

This is pointless hair splitting. There isn't a difference between banning the act of circumcision and banning circumcision. Banning the act would, for all intents and purposes, ban circumcision.

But that really only applies for a blanket ban. The article in the OP isn't suggesting a blanket ban but a ban on infant circumcisions.
 
So it's you and Dave who get to decide? Who died and left you in charge?

The fact is that various religious groups want or will want to carry out various operations on their children, for religious reasons. Who will decide in each case who gets to do it and who doesn't?

Rolfe.

Because Dave and I are actually making progress in having this conversation come to a head, rather than constantly circling around giving the same arguments.
 
That still doesn't answer the question. Dave says if it was up to him, he'd ban all the operations we're talking about. Are you agreeing with him?

It's perfectly simple. One group wants to cut off a baby boy's prepuce. Another wants to create a ritual pattern of scars all over its face. Another wants to drop a little water on its forehead. Another wants to excise the labia of little girls and sew up the vulva. All for religious reasons.

Who decides which ones get to practise their religion and which don't?

Rolfe.
 
"This is a human rights issue," he said. "What you're doing is you're taking an infant and removing the most sensitive part of their body."

Is foreskin really that sensitive? I wouldn't know because mine was cut off when I was a baby. I am really glad it was too. I have asked quite a few women what they think about non circumcised penises and they say that they are weird and gross. Not too scientific, but it's good enough for me. I always find that dudes in pornos who are not circumcised look pretty goofy as well.
 
In post number 835, he doesn't quote any particular argument that have been made. So the absurd response has nothing to do with any arguments. Therefore, it is a slippery slope.

Post 835:

It seems to me the argument goes like this.
Religious group: What we do to our children is so minor and insignificant there's no reason to ban it. And besides, it's our tradition.

Everybody else: You call that minor? It's barbaric!

Religious group: You're just bigoted. It's nothing.

<snip>

Your debate-fu is weak, young grasshopper. The fact that he didn't quote a specific post of yours does not mean he wasn't referring to one - and in fact, anyone who's been following the thread knows he referred to most of your posts.

As a bonus, "the absurd response has nothing to do with any arguments, therefore it is a slippery slope", in addition to being based on an obviously false premise, is also a complete non-sequitur.
 
Is foreskin really that sensitive? I wouldn't know because mine was cut off when I was a baby. I am really glad it was too. I have asked quite a few women what they think about non circumcised penises and they say that they are weird and gross

Most of my friends are uncut (don't ask how I know please). They have no problems with the ladies. Perhaps you only met Catholic prudes?

I always find that dudes in pornos who are not circumcised look pretty goofy as well.

:confused:

I'm not going to be presumptions now, but, what?
 
Is foreskin really that sensitive? I wouldn't know because mine was cut off when I was a baby. I am really glad it was too. I have asked quite a few women what they think about non circumcised penises and they say that they are weird and gross. Not too scientific, but it's good enough for me. I always find that dudes in pornos who are not circumcised look pretty goofy as well.

It is a sensitive part of the body, yes, and plays a pretty important part in sexual stimulation when present.

As for the aesthetic side, it's very much an acquired taste. You don't really hear women complain about foreskins in countries where circumcision is rare.

In any case, while there certainly are people who prefer to have no foreskin, most of us believe it should be their own choice, not something forced on them as an infant.
 
Is foreskin really that sensitive?

I am not sure of the foreskin, but I am certain the combination gland/foreskin is extremely sensitive, and as has been pointed out earlier removal of the foreskin appears to result in extreme desensitivation of the gland.

I wouldn't know because mine was cut off when I was a baby. I am really glad it was too. I have asked quite a few women what they think about non circumcised penises and they say that they are weird and gross. Not too scientific, but it's good enough for me. I always find that dudes in pornos who are not circumcised look pretty goofy as well.

I cannot even begin to explain how utterly ridiculous that sounds.

Do you know of even a single case where a woman ended whatever would have turned into sex otherwise because the male was not circumcised and she thought that looked "gross" or "funny"? (As opposed to this being an indicator the guy simply failed to have the right religion, say.)

That aside: How many people would I need to find to tell you that some part of your body looked funny before you would happily chop off said body part?

And do you honestly think that that could ever be a good enough reason to allow parents to chop of said body parts of their children?

Are you seriously not aware of how utterly biased you are? Yes, I would consider myself fairly gross and funny looking if I woe up tomorrow and looked significantly different from what I look like today. If I woke up with a bigger nose I'd find that disturbing - but that honestly doesn't constitute a reason to modify any nose purely on the grounds that it is bigger or diferent than my own.

And yet again. I have to ask how you think Europeans manage to ever have sex? Woman should be fleeing bedrooms all over the place in hysterical giggles. Usually, they seem not to be doing that.
 
Ah, true. I didn't think of this problem at the time.

So I guess the answer to that previous question is that I don't think there should be any law banning anyone from doing it.

Why should people be allowed bits off their baby boys? Since you have agreed to drop the special exemption for religion, you must have another good reason to allow it.
 
Is foreskin really that sensitive? I wouldn't know because mine was cut off when I was a baby. I am really glad it was too. I have asked quite a few women what they think about non circumcised penises and they say that they are weird and gross. Not too scientific, but it's good enough for me. I always find that dudes in pornos who are not circumcised look pretty goofy as well.

Try going to another continent, say, europe, and yes the foreskin is sensible.
 
Last edited:
Ah, true. I didn't think of this problem at the time.

So I guess the answer to that previous question is that I don't think there should be any law banning anyone from doing it.

So circumcision has nothing to do with religious freedom. Glad we've sorted that out. You can one ditch your First Amendment "argument".
 
So circumcision has nothing to do with religious freedom.

bull...poopy.

as far as Jews & Muslims are concerned, circumcision of our infant boys is a very strong issue of religious freedom. it is one of the core rituals of our two religions.

pass this law and watch Jews, Muslims, and anyone else who supports religious freedom, hit the pavement in protest.
 
bull...poopy.

as far as Jews & Muslims are concerned, circumcision of our infant boys is a very strong issue of religious freedom. it is one of the core rituals of our two religions.

pass this law and watch Jews, Muslims, and anyone else who supports religious freedom, hit the pavement in protest.

Missing the point completely. If Nihilianth (and you as well for that matter) were consistent he would argue that circumcision would be allowable only for religious reasons so as not to violate your precious First Amendment. But in doing so he caught himself in a bind by creating a law which favors religion. His solution (open slather) takes the religious argument out of play.
 
You'd be surprised. I used to do ear piercings in a mall, and we wouldn't do it on children under the age of 3 months. People came up with children just out of the hospital looking to get it done. Three month olds didn't know what was going on, but surely they had no input about it. Those were the easy ones. It's the 4-7 year olds who said they wanted it but when the gun came close they would scream like crazy that were awful.

So you'd shoot holes in their ears with a gun, kind of wild west style trick shooting?

I'm personally impressed by both your skill and showmanship, but I can understand how it might frighten a small child.

Are you at least accredited by some kind of nationally recognized circus or traveling carnival?
 
bull...poopy.

as far as Jews & Muslims are concerned, circumcision of our infant boys is a very strong issue of religious freedom. it is one of the core rituals of our two religions.

pass this law and watch Jews, Muslims, and anyone else who supports religious freedom, hit the pavement in protest.

Can someone on the pro-circumcision side please explain why this is relevant? I will concede that when a bill involves a restriction on a religious practice, those on the religious side tend to irrationally oppose it, and the likelihood of the bill passing becomes lowered.

Other than that, why does it matter? It has been demonstrated that legislators do have the power to criminalize activities that are promoted by various religions. It has been demonstrated that the religious nature of an activity does not suffice as legal or moral justification for said action. So what else you got?
 
Can someone on the pro-circumcision side please explain why this is relevant? I will concede that when a bill involves a restriction on a religious practice, those on the religious side tend to irrationally oppose it, and the likelihood of the bill passing becomes lowered.

Other than that, why does it matter? It has been demonstrated that legislators do have the power to criminalize activities that are promoted by various religions. It has been demonstrated that the religious nature of an activity does not suffice as legal or moral justification for said action. So what else you got?

Petty chest thumping in the hope it'll scare people away from the discussion. What else could you do if your position is utterly meritless otherwise?
 
bull...poopy.

as far as Jews & Muslims are concerned, circumcision of our infant boys is a very strong issue of religious freedom. it is one of the core rituals of our two religions.

pass this law and watch Jews, Muslims, and anyone else who supports religious freedom, hit the pavement in protest.

I think you missed what this post was referring to
 
I'll let the Federal Appeals Court and SCOTUS decide that.

Wait..are you saying the U.S. Supreme Court could possibly invalidate your ancient religious tradition and you'd be cool with it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom