Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Serious? I have made an effort here. The least you could do is meet me halfway.

Halfway of what?

The questions about amputating arms, fingers and earlobes specifically are relevant to the discussion and more than justified.

That you cannot answer them is a problem of your position and your ability to provide a rational justification for it: Your position simply leads to numerous inconsistencies.

The entire point of this discussion is to point those out and resolve them one way or another. But in order to do that they will have to be pointed out and discussed.

You seem to think that it is permissible at least to cut of a male baby's foreskin, yet you have a different opinion about

a) minor mutilations of female genitalia
b) larger mutilations of male genitalia
c) amputations of digits or parts thereof
d) amputations of earlobes

To further complicate your position, it seems that you think that circumcising a baby is no big deal but that you are quite happy that it should be illegal between adults.

Now the interesting question is: What are the rational, consistent reasons that underly all these judgments?

You have a problem explaining why it is okay to circumcise a boy but not okay to cut off his earlobes. If you are okay with cutting off earlobes you are definitely drawing the line at fingers. And all the justification you have been able to come up with is that one is worse than the other and that one simply doesn't pass your personal thresholds for being "bad enough".

The problem is, we are talking not about you cutting off your own foreskin but somebody else's. In a society where on of the most basic principles of freedom is that you cannot impose your own thresholds on other people without good reason that is simply not good enough: That you see no problem with cutting off a little baby's foreskin is no more justification for doing it than it would be for me if I saw no problem with cutting off your earlobes. I'd go to jail if I did it no matter how much I believed it wasn't a big deal.
 
Again, I totally welcome this challenge. This would be a good national debate to have.

Pass the law. It will be appealed in Federal court the next day. And then most likely that ruling would also get appealed.

Let the SCOTUS settle the issue, now and forever.
 
Parents should not be allowed to hit their children, any more than they should be allowed to cut bits off them.
None of this thread has been about what parents are allowed to do, it has been about what they should not be allowed to do.

The Canadian Supreme Court seems to differ: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadi...Youth_and_the_Law_v._Canada_(Attorney_General)

As does the Minnesota Supreme Court: http://www.wnd.com/?pageId=65997 (I personally think this goes a bit too far, though.)

The Supreme Court of the United States even says it is legal to do so in schools: http://www.corpun.com/counuss.htm

Unites States section in wiki said:
Despite some opposition to corporal punishment in the United States, the spanking of children is legal in all states.[18] Bans have been proposed in Massachusetts[19] and California[20][21] on all corporal punishment of children, including by parents, but these moves were heavily defeated.[22]

And Benatar cites the many problems done in psychological studies, as people are too quick to be polarized by this issue.

(The bolded is the problem in many debates, including this one earlier. People get too polarized far too easily to have any meaningful debates, and cannot see the forest for the trees. I admit I was the same way earlier myself.)

So, while you may not think that corporal punishment should be illegal or is immoral doesn't mean a thing in trying to overturn my argument about there being a fine line between abuse and proper punishment. And religious practices and severe barbarity (human sacrifice.)
 
Would you extend such thinking to other religious practices?

Not necessarily. There is most definitely a fine line between proper religious practices that do not harm or benefit society in any way, and religious practices that places unnecessary harm on society.

Here in Australia there are some Indigenous tribes that practise circumcision along with subsincision for socioreligous reasons. Do you think that these practices would not be a violation of a person's body?

I have never heard of subscinsion in my life. I looked it up real quick to see what you were talking about, and the photo looks pretty nasty. The wiki article doesn't mention any benefits, risks and/or harm associated with this practice.


As an aside I'd just like to point out that you can more or less discuss this in the context of the US Constitution's First Amendment since you've pretty much ignored all case law that does not support your claim and section 116 of the Australian Constitution is basically the establishment clause of the first amendment just reworded.

I have no idea what case laws you are talking about. Point me to one, and I shall be happy to read up on it. However, I must caution you that we are having this discussion based on the OP's article about a ban in San Francisco. I only care about American case law. You may most certainly post foreign case law where the opinions of a highly respected foreign official, such as Supreme Court Justice, to help solidify your arguments a bit more. But it still loses quite a bit of merit in discussions of US law.
 
They're not allowed to spank children everywhere, but more to the point is what parents ought to do, as kerikiwi said.

Do you mean "not allowed to spank child everywhere," meaning no government allows it? Or that parents are not allowed to "spank their kids in the face," or anywhere out in public that they please, such as a supermarket?

Kerikiwi's point doesn't negate my analogy of drawing a line between abuse and properly administered spanking; to religious practices, and religious practices which places far too much unnecessary harm on society.
 
From what I understand of how the USA handles religious freedom I think the religious groups affected would argue that simply prohibiting non-medical circumcision is a disproportionate measure. How that would stack up when the USA has laws that prohibits all types of female genital mutilation I don't know. I would also say this is the type of case that you do not want going to the supreme court given the ages of the justices currently serving as they will be of a generation that was brought up to consider the non-circumcised to be abnormal, and we see time and time again in these threads how difficult it is for folk to set that aside (and the cognitive dissonance they use to compartmentalise their approval of male genital mutilation).

Darat is pretty much right in regards to the view that a ban is a disproportionate measure, placing an unnecessary restriction on a rather benign religious rite.

No to answer this question:

It has been demonstrated that legislators do have the power to criminalize activities that are promoted by various religions. It has been demonstrated that the religious nature of an activity does not suffice as legal or moral justification for said action. So what else you got?

This is the whole reason why I brought up the WBC, libel, and yelling "FIRE! in a crowded theater. Religious rights are not the only thing which have been restricted and/or allowed despite immoral behavior.

In the WBC case, which is perhaps one of the most well-known cases in the Supreme Court in a long time, people perform incredibly immoral behavior. And yet, we allow them to do so in the name of the First Amendment right to free speech.

In the case of yelling "FIRE" in a crowded theater, we restrict this form of speech, despite the First Amendment. Same with libel and/or slander.

Likewise, when it comes to religious freedom, we restrict the right of religions to sacrifice human beings, but allow Muslims to wear burkhas in public.

I think these restrictions and allowances are all pretty reasonable. Indeed, I think they are all quite obvious, with the exception of the WBC case, as that is a much harder case to determine. It does place unnecessary risks in society, most of which has been stated earlier in this thread.

Constantly using the argument "but there are religious practices which are illegal!" does nothing for your case in passing a ban on circumcision, restricting the First Amendment right on religious freedom. In fact, it is a rather disingenuous argument to make, and is technically a non-sequitor.
 
Halfway of what?

The questions about amputating arms, fingers and earlobes specifically are relevant to the discussion and more than justified.

Not anymore. I think I have more than satisfied the differences and distinctions between all those examples. I remain unconvinced that removing the foreskin from a baby actually makes sexual stimulation any less enjoyable later in life. I most certainly enjoy it myself. A lot! Would I have enjoyed it "even more" if I had a foreskin? Who knows? Would you enjoy it any less without one? Who knows?

The point is, it is a benign procedure that does not affect the person whatsoever throughout their life.

That you cannot answer them is a problem of your position and your ability to provide a rational justification for it: Your position simply leads to numerous inconsistencies.

I have. I just don't think you like my answers, and you seem disagree without even trying to understand. I may be wrong in this assumption, but I highly doubt it.

The entire point of this discussion is to point those out and resolve them one way or another. But in order to do that they will have to be pointed out and discussed.

No they do not. It is like comparing apples to oranges. You first have to demonstrate beyond any reasonable doubt that having a circumcision affects men throughout their lives, and that they really resent the fact their parents did it to them when they were babies. And for that, you must provide some kind of professionally-done survey, that published the results, the methods, the questions used, the methods of choosing the respondents, and so forth.

Other than that, I can only assume that circumcised men don't seem to care one way or the other, and seems to enjoy active, healthy sex lives and are able to produce children at exactly the same rate as uncircumcised men. Cutting off fingers, arms, and earlobes places OBVIOUS restrictions on that person's ability to function up to their full potential.

You seem to think that it is permissible at least to cut of a male baby's foreskin, yet you have a different opinion about

You keep asking my opinions. Opinions are subjective. Subjective opinions have no place in creating laws. There are no courts in the country that I am aware of that will rule on something, based on subjective arguments.

a) minor mutilations of female genitalia

I do not know enough about female circumcision. Nobody has posted any information in here. I was only told to look up "type 1" or whatever. Only thing I have heard throughout this conversation, is that female circumcision is not at all comparable to male circumcision in how benign the procedure and results are.

b) larger mutilations of male genitalia

Such as.....? I honestly never remember hearing a question about this. Sorry, you have to be more specific. I honestly have no idea what you mean by "larger mutilations."

c) amputations of digits or parts thereof

Already covered ad nauseum. See above as well.

d) amputations of earlobes

Already covered ad nauseum.

To further complicate your position, it seems that you think that circumcising a baby is no big deal but that you are quite happy that it should be illegal between adults.

An adult is an adult. It is quite illegal to mess around with an adult body while they are lying unconscious on a hospital bed, beyond administering the required care.

Now the interesting question is: What are the rational, consistent reasons that underly all these judgments?

The questions you have asked are quite disingenuous at best.

You have a problem explaining why it is okay to circumcise a boy but not okay to cut off his earlobes.

Apparently you must have missed that part of the conversation. I have answered that question that was posed. Asking it 800 times over doesn't change the answer a whole lot without any kind of significant argument.

If you are okay with cutting off earlobes you are definitely drawing the line at fingers.

I would say "yes." But you must first understand fully what my answer to the earlobe and finger hypothetical situations were.

And all the justification you have been able to come up with is that one is worse than the other and that one simply doesn't pass your personal thresholds for being "bad enough".

Correct. The law does the same thing all of the time. Such as outlawing the act of yelling "FIRE!" in a theater being "much worse" than the WBC protesting at funeral. The reason why libel and slander is illegal, but you can criticize the Federal Government.I hate to make assumptions, so please correct me if I am wrong. But you really seem as though you are not understanding the whole concept of weighing the amount of harm any particular act may cause both personally and socially, with freedoms in the Constitution. You have also failed to show any case law in connection to this situation, other than the Smith case with Native Americans use of peyote. But I have demonstrated how and why that case does not apply to this situation.

The problem is, we are talking not about you cutting off your own foreskin but somebody else's. In a society where on of the most basic principles of freedom is that you cannot impose your own thresholds on other people without good reason that is simply not good enough: That you see no problem with cutting off a little baby's foreskin is no more justification for doing it than it would be for me if I saw no problem with cutting off your earlobes. I'd go to jail if I did it no matter how much I believed it wasn't a big deal.

This argument presents nothing that has already been covered. The biggest problem with your argument, is that you are talking about two unrelated adults, and comparing that situation to a parent's rights to raise their children how they want. Their rights to practice their religion with their children. The benign nature of circumcision, compared to the much more risky behavior with much more adverse effects of cutting off earlobes.

To be fair, the earlobe situation was that all the risks and adverse affects were hypothetically the exact same as circumcision. The religious factor is exactly the same, and the social consequences exactly the same. Therefore, the act of earlobe cutting should be just as legal as circumcision.

But IRL, it is far more complicated. You cannot just say "The social consequences, health risks, religious factors (there are none for earlobes!!)," and so forth are nothing alike. Not at all comparable.

This is the exact reason why you lose a lot of credibility in a court of law when you propose hypothetical after hypothetical.
 
...snip...

The point is, it is a benign procedure that does not affect the person whatsoever throughout their life.

...snip...

It's very easy to show that is not the case as for it to be benign it would have to be a change for the better. Also there is plenty of evidence from those who are for genital mutilation of infants that there are social stigma to having a penis that looks different. (Although of course those comments have to be taken with a large pinch of salt since they often display a lack of knowledge of the anatomy of a penis and how it functions during sex.)
 
Last edited:
It's very easy to show that is not the case as for it to be begin it would have to be a change for the better. Also there is plenty of evidence from those who are for genital mutilation of infants that there are social stigma to having a penis that looks different. (Although of course those comments have to be taken with a large pinch of salt since they often display a lack of knowledge of the anatomy of a penis and how it functions during sex.)

"A change for the better" is a subjective argument. I am not willing to see a law be passed criminalizing a practice based on subjective arguments.

The "social stigma" thing is kind of a non-sequitor, as people just don't go walking about with their privates showing. lol. :p

I also understand the way the penis works, and now understand more fully the functionality of the foreskin than I ever did before. (I actually learned quite a bit!)

But I rather think whatever increased sexual stimulation it MAY provide, doesn't change the fact that sex is still highly enjoyable without one. If there is even more to it than I thought, it is much like my earlier comparison of people in the 1930s living without XBox 360s. They would never have dreamed of such a device. Doesn't make their life any less fulfilling. Never experiencing a foreskin likewise doesn't make my sex life any less fulfilling.

ETA: Minor edits. Spelling error, punctuation, and changed the word "is" to "it."
 
Last edited:
"A change for the better" is a subjective argument. I am not willing to see a law be passed criminalizing a practice based on subjective arguments.

The "social stigma" thing is kind of a non-sequitor, as people just don't go walking about with their privates showing. lol. :p ...snip...

Read this thread (and the other threads) and you will see comments regarding the social stigma of having a penis that looks different - it is not my claim that it results in social stigmatisation.
 
Parents should not be allowed to hit their children, any more than they should be allowed to cut bits off them.
None of this thread has been about what parents are allowed to do, it has been about what they should not be allowed to do.

I'd say you're the one comparing apples to oranges now. That's every bit as silly as the comparing ear piercing to circumcision nonsense.
 
Now, my turn to go on the offensive here.

A lot of you are questioning me, expecting me to provide "good arguments" for circumcision ban to not be passed.

I would kindly like to ask the same of you. It is your duty....your burden....to be providing the arguments to have a law passed criminalizing behavior.

I find it quite unconvincing that you can have any reduced quality of sex life with a foreskin, than without. It seems as though men who are circumcised have just as fulfilling sex lives as those who are uncut. Demonstrate this to be objectively false. (I presume it would be quite impossible to do.)

I would also like demonstrated just how circumcision can possibly compare to cutting off fingers or any other limbs, and earlobes. (Impossible to do in my estimation. As only circumcision is done for religious purposes, and does not interfere whatsoever in allowing a person to live to their full potential.)

Demonstrate the similarities (and differences! They are just as important!) between female and male circumcision.

Demonstrate how society may benefit from a ban.

Demonstrate how the individual may benefit from a ban.

Illustrate how, exactly, you would propose enforcing the law, and punish violators. (Already covered, I know. But I would like this to be re-covered again, if you do not mind, under this more civilized discussion :) )

Your arguments must be overwhelming enough to convince me that this is a big enough of an issue to warrant society interfering with private familial matters, and how this may affect society in general. Why it is anyone's business why a parent decides this for their kids. You need to justify a rather extreme measure for something that doesn't appear to be such a big issue in this country at all.

I might remind you, that subjective arguments such as morality and aesthetics does not suffice in convincing me of anything. I just remain even further entrenched at being against a ban.
 
Read this thread (and the other threads) and you will see comments regarding the social stigma of having a penis that looks different - it is not my claim that it results in social stigmatisation.

Which thread? This current one, or some other one that it appears you forgot to link to?

I do remember someone earlier mentioning something about social stigma within this thread on your side of the debate. But I think you may be referring to those who make the argument that "women think it is more attractive, and could make your sex life even better," on my side of the debate. That is not an argument I have made, nor one that I condone.

Other than how women may view an uncut penis vs. a circumcised one, I have no idea where social stigmata plays a role in this debate. And the POV of women is a rather weak argument to begin with.
 
This thread and the threads that were linked to in post #6.

Oh. Well, I saw personal attacks, logical fallacies, and sarcasm gallore in the other threads rather quickly, and decided to completely ignore them. They were before my time anyway.

But as far as this thread is concerned, any arguments made about social stigma is besides the point. On the side of the debate calling for a ban, the argument that the reason why people do circumcison on their sons is for social reasons doesn't bear with my defense of religious freedom at all. Likewise, those who talk about how much more women like circumcised men who are against a ban also doesn't suffice as a good reason to be against a ban. I couldn't care less about that, and is too unpredictable about the child's future with any particular woman.

However, as I said earlier, a law must never discriminate. If people circumcise their sons for aesthetic reasons, doesn't mean that people legitimately circumcise them for religious reasons. I am only concerned about encroaching upon the religious rights. Therefore, all circumcisions must be allowed. That is my position.
 
Wildy said:
Would you extend such thinking to other religious practices?
Not necessarily. There is most definitely a fine line between proper religious practices that do not harm or benefit society in any way, and religious practices that places unnecessary harm on society.

Would you consider something like faith healing to be a practice that places unnecessary harm on society? Or polygamy? Or animal sacrifice?

I have never heard of subscinsion in my life. I looked it up real quick to see what you were talking about, and the photo looks pretty nasty. The wiki article doesn't mention any benefits, risks and/or harm associated with this practice.

But would you ban it?

I have no idea what case laws you are talking about. Point me to one, and I shall be happy to read up on it. However, I must caution you that we are having this discussion based on the OP's article about a ban in San Francisco. I only care about American case law.

Well one case that I posted a few pages back was Reynolds v. United States which found "religious duty was not a suitable defence to a criminal indictment".

Another case mentioned in this thread was Emplyment Division v. Smith which found that the state could deny unemployment for people who used peyote regardless of whether it was used for religious purposes or not.

What I did notice was that the precedent of the latter case was more or less overturned by the Religious Freedom Restoration Act which reinstated the Sherbert test from Sherbert v. Verner.

I'm doing some reading myself but Wikipedia has a list of Supreme Court cases involving the First Amendment.

One that I've found interesting so far is Prince v. Massachusetts which found that parental authority isn't absolute and can be restricted in the name of the child's welfare.

You may most certainly post foreign case law where the opinions of a highly respected foreign official, such as Supreme Court Justice, to help solidify your arguments a bit more. But it still loses quite a bit of merit in discussions of US law.

Which is why I'm not going to cite Australian case law. That and also because the High Court typically rules more narrowly on religious issues then the the US Supreme Court does. If you want you can read about it on Wikipedia.
 
Again I don't think there is anyone in this thread arguing anything different.

I do not support the legalization of female genetical cutting of ANY kind.

why? because I have yet to read any reasoning behind such procedures accept for sadistic or simply purposes of making life harder for women.

contrary to Jewish & Muslim circumcision rites, which have NO intent to cause harm or pain whatsoever.

it is seen as a commandment by "God", as a mark of the covenant between God and Abraham, and that's it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom