Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Right. And I can certainly agree to disagree with you on this. I have no problems with your opinions on the matter, and I think I understand them quite well. But I still have my opposing views on the same topic. Therefor, the discussion has reached an impasse.

Truce?

If you prefer. I was ready to bow out of the discussion anyway.
 
I still want to know who gets to decide which operations are permitted to be performed on infants for religious purposes.

Rolfe.
 
I still want to know who gets to decide which operations are permitted to be performed on infants for religious purposes.

Rolfe.

Well, apparently governments do. Are there any countries where the procedure is illegal?
 
Sorry, I wasn't clear. I wanted to know, in this discussion we're having about whether or not certain procedures should be allowed, who gets to make the decision on which are and which aren't?

Rolfe.
 
1. I have admitted to when I used a slippery slope argument.

That doesn't really have anything to do with anything.

2. There was nothing in that post to suggest he used Reductio ad absurdum.

Yes, there was. It was a reductio ad absurdum, because it explained why an argument was wrong. If it had been an argument against circumicision, it would have been a slippery slope, but since it was a refutation of an argument by pointing out that the argument leads to an absurd conclusion, it was a reduction ad absurdum.

I would hope that you at least learn this much from the thread. It will save you a world of trouble in future discussions.
3. I was responding to someone whom I did not have on ignore, who reponded in the positive about a ridiculous arguments.

That doesn't really change anything I've said.

4. The bolded is bordering on the personal attack. Which is something I have yet to do. Would be nice if the amount of this kind of abuse in this thread could come to an end. It doesn't help your image any.

It's a piece of friendly advice - what you're doing really does make you look childish, and it lowers your chances of ever convincing anyone greatly. But if you feel it was abuse, report it, and let the mods decide. Should they decide I was out of line, I'll not contest the decision. At any rate, responding with a personal attack of your own is not helpful.

ETA: In any case, I did state that I seem to be failing to be convincing anyone the ban is wrong, and everyone seems to fail to convince me that it is right. And that this thread has gone on long enough. Should just agree to disagree, and let it die it's death.

That's fine, and nobody's forcing you to stay in the thread. However, if you're expecting everyone to stop posting while you continue to express arguments people disagree with, you're in for a long, disappointing haul. If you want out, you'll have to stop posting.
 
OK, let's use harm to society and to the individual. Let's look at three cases - WBC's freedom of speech, an unnecessary incision in a baby's arm, and infant circumcision. Lat's also assume that freedom of religious expression is equally important to all three, so we can leave it out of the comparison.

WBC:
Harm to society: Breach of the peace, incitement to riot.
Harm to the individual: Emotional distress.
Benefit to society: Freedom of speech is not infringed.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

Unnecessary incision in baby's arm:
Harm to society: Probably none.
Harm to the individual: Physical trauma, pain.
Benefit to society: None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

Infant circumcision:
Harm to society: Probably none.
Harm to the individual: Physical trauma, pain, permanent body modification.
Benefit to society: None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

So, based on cost/benefit analysis, the most harmful of these, and therefore the first choice for banning, which is not currently prohibited; the second most harmful is an unnecessary incision in the arm, which is currently prohibited; and the least harmful, and the only one with any compensatory benefits, is the WBC's freedom of speech.

Therefore, it's consistent, both internally and with existing laws, for the WBC to be allowed freedom of speech and for circumcision to be banned.

Dave

Are you talking about the banning of something, or the action of something? I see a slight technicality with with this comparison that I don't think you intentionally meant to introduce. I think this side-by-side comparison is fair, except for one thing.

With the WBC, you are looking at the banning of protests at funerals. So the benefit to society is that Freedom of Speech is not infringed. Had you looked at the action of the protests itself, there are no benefits to society for that particular event.

Whereas, for circumcision, you were looking at the action itself. There is no benefit in the action to society and the individual, I agree. But when you look at the BANNING of circumcision, rather than the ACT of circumcision itself, you can easily say the benefit to society is that religious freedom is not infringed.

So, taking the technicality into consideration, I propose two things to look at: The practice itself, and a law banning said practice:



WBC Practice:
Harm to society: Breach of the peace, incitement to riot.
Harm to the individual: Emotional distress.
Benefit to society: None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

WBC Ban:
Harm to society: Infringement on freedom of speech.
Harm to the individual affected: None.
Benefit to society: Theoretical reduced risk of incitement to riot. (No evidence a riot would occur. So you can argue "None.")
Benefit to the individual affected: Able to bury loved one in peace. Only get one shot at doing so.


Incision in baby's arm Practice:
Harm to society: Probably none.
Harm to the individual: Physical trauma, pain. None with anesthetics
Benefit to society: None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

Incision in baby's arm Ban:
Harm to society: Infringement on religious practice, and parents' rights.
Harm to the individual: Baby: None. Parents: Infringement of religious freedom, and parents' rights
Benefit to society: Probably None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

Infant circumcision Practice:
Harm to society: Probably none.
Harm to the individual: Physical trauma, pain, permanent body modification.
Benefit to society: None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

Infant circumcision Ban:
Harm to society: Infringement on religious freedom and parents' rights.
Harm to the individual: None.
Benefit to society: None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None, really. (Reduced "choices" in one's life, I suppose.)

When looking at all of these comparisons, it isn't so cut-and-dried. The WBC definitely poses a greater threat to society than the other two, with incitement to riot, and reduce moral. It poses much greater emotional scarring than the other two, and so affects the families trying to bury their loved ones in peace to a much greater extent. And so both society and private families are negatively affected to a rather large degree.

However, the arguments for banning funeral protests do not outweigh the Constitution, despite some of the risks involved in such behavior. Society wouldn't really benefit from the ban. Expect maybe with reduced risk of violence. The individuals affected would benefit from being able to bury their loved ones in peace, and they only have one shot at doing so.

With the infants, the risks in the procedures are some temporary pain and suffering that is rather quickly and completely forgotten. An incision in a baby's arm doesn't necessarily mean there is going to be any pain and suffering at all, for a local would easily take care of that. There is no harm to society with this practice.

However, I don't think the arguments for banning a rather simple and benign procedure outweighs the Constitution, despite some risks involved in such behavior. Society wouldn't really benefit from the ban, with no exceptions. The individual wouldn't really be affected, except perhaps to give them a choice later in life. But later in life, it isn't exactly that big a deal at all, so I dunno about this one.
 
If there were a law that only allowed circumcision for religious reasons - which, I seem to recall, you said you wouldn't object to - then it would be singling out religion.

Dave

Ah, true. I didn't think of this problem at the time.

So I guess the answer to that previous question is that I don't think there should be any law banning anyone from doing it.
 
How many times does it have to be explained to you that this is not what "religious freedom" means and that this is neither how the constitution is meant to work nor how it actually does work?

Uh, we only have this go off of:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

I am not sure how many time this needs to be posted. It's pretty straight-forward: "Congress shall make no law prohibiting the free exercise [of religion.]"

So, uh, yea. That's exactly what it means. Are there exceptions to this: Absolutely. But we already went over all of those. I think that Dave and I are making some real progress, by making some comparisons that we both can seem to agree on that is neither too extreme, nor too mundane.

The differences are in the details. There are still differences in our own opinions about whose rights are more important. Which is exactly where we need to be, because those are exactly the questions that the Courts decide on. And never are thee kinds of decisions easy to make. I just happen to rather err on the side of no changes being made to the law, when it comes down to the question of whose freedom is more important if a practice doesn't really harm society or the individual to any great extent.
 
Sorry, I wasn't clear. I wanted to know, in this discussion we're having about whether or not certain procedures should be allowed, who gets to make the decision on which are and which aren't?

Rolfe.

It isn't terribly practical to come up with thousands of different hypotheticals about "which" operations could be done. Dave and I have settled on two hypotheticals: WBC and freedom of speech as a different right that doesn't really have anything to do with religion, and an incision on a baby's arm that does have to do with a hypothetical religious medical procedure, but is not really permanent, and is currently illegal in real life.
 
That doesn't really have anything to do with anything.



Yes, there was. It was a reductio ad absurdum, because it explained why an argument was wrong. If it had been an argument against circumicision, it would have been a slippery slope, but since it was a refutation of an argument by pointing out that the argument leads to an absurd conclusion, it was a reduction ad absurdum.

In post number 835, he doesn't quote any particular argument that have been made. So the absurd response has nothing to do with any arguments. Therefore, it is a slippery slope.
 
I have changed my mind. I now welcome this law.

I shall enjoy the smackdown it gets from the Federal courts.
 
Uh, we only have this go off of:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

No, we do not have "only this".

We have well over 200 years of application of said law; interpretations, commentary, legal history and legal theory. And then we have your ignorant opinion.

I am not sure how many time this needs to be posted. It's pretty straight-forward: "Congress shall make no law prohibiting the free exercise [of religion.]"

You don't have to keep posting it at all. We heard you the first time. You were wrong then, and you are wrong. Try to get your head wrapped around the idea that people who disagree with you might possibly have reasons for their dissagreement other than not having understood you let alone simply not having read what you said.

So, uh, yea. That's exactly what it means.

It simply does not mean what you think it means.

In fact, you couldn't be more wrong.

It could not be more obvious how wrong you are.

If you were right, then it would be unconstitutional to ban human sacrifice as long as it was a religious practice. Do you not see how utterly, utterly ridiculous it is to suggest that the constitution would - either in theory or in practice - protect whatever crime or atrocity you could think of solely because it was committed in the name of religion?

Are there exceptions to this: Absolutely. But we already went over all of those.

What you fail to understand is that those are not "exceptions" at all. Outlawing human sacrifices within a religious ceremonies is not an exception to the standards of the constitution. It is entirely compatible with the wording and the intention thereof.

Law doesn't work with "exceptions". (At least not the way you think it does.) The constitution does not even in theory protect ritual human sacrifice under any circumstances. There isn't even a conflict of interests between different rights granted by the constitution here.

How do you imagine these "alleged" exceptions come to be? Who decides, and on what grounds, when it is reasonable to make an exception to the constitution?

Are you able to point out just documented instance of such an exception being made? (Don't get me wrong here: I don't care to hear what laws you think constitute such an exceptions - I want to see where lawmakers or whoever you think is responsible for these exceptions called what they did an exception to the rules set forth in the constitution and justify doing it.)

I think that Dave and I are making some real progress, by making some comparisons that we both can seem to agree on that is neither too extreme, nor too mundane.

This is relevant how?

The differences are in the details. There are still differences in our own opinions about whose rights are more important. Which is exactly where we need to be, because those are exactly the questions that the Courts decide on. And never are thee kinds of decisions easy to make. I just happen to rather err on the side of no changes being made to the law, when it comes down to the question of whose freedom is more important if a practice doesn't really harm society or the individual to any great extent.

How lucky that you are the ones who decides what harm is and where "great extend" begins. Can I come and chop random bits off of your body?
 
Rolfe said:
I wanted to know, in this discussion we're having about whether or not certain procedures should be allowed, who gets to make the decision on which are and which aren't?


It isn't terribly practical to come up with thousands of different hypotheticals about "which" operations could be done. Dave and I have settled on two hypotheticals: WBC and freedom of speech as a different right that doesn't really have anything to do with religion, and an incision on a baby's arm that does have to do with a hypothetical religious medical procedure, but is not really permanent, and is currently illegal in real life.


So it's you and Dave who get to decide? Who died and left you in charge?

The fact is that various religious groups want or will want to carry out various operations on their children, for religious reasons. Who will decide in each case who gets to do it and who doesn't?

Rolfe.
 
So, taking the technicality into consideration, I propose two things to look at: The practice itself, and a law banning said practice:

Let's stick to a hypothetical law banning said practice, as it may be inferred that any benefits and harm from the practice itself are negated by an effective ban.

WBC Ban:
Harm to society: Infringement on freedom of speech.

You left out "Infringement on religious freedom." The WBC claims to be a church, and therefore claims the protection afforded by freedom of religion. That's rather a dritical point; it means that there is automatically greater harm to society from a WBC ban, as it includes the same form of harm as the others plus another form.

Harm to the individual affected: None.
Benefit to society: Theoretical reduced risk of incitement to riot. (No evidence a riot would occur. So you can argue "None.")[/quote]

We know that crimes have been committed against members of the WBC in response to their protests - specifically, tyre slashing (property damage). We can therefore include a reduced risk of incitement to commit crimes in general.

Benefit to the individual affected: Able to bury loved one in peace. Only get one shot at doing so.


Incision in baby's arm Ban:
Harm to society: Infringement on religious practice, and parents' rights.
Harm to the individual: Baby: None. Parents: Infringement of religious freedom, and parents' rights
Benefit to society: Probably None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

Avoidance of physical trauma and pain.

Infant circumcision Ban:
Harm to society: Infringement on religious freedom and parents' rights.
Harm to the individual: None.
Benefit to society: None.

Infringement on children's rights.

Benefit to the individual affected: None, really. (Reduced "choices" in one's life, I suppose.)

You seem to be trying desperately hard to deny the existence of a benefit while at the same time admitting that one exists. Why not just be honest with yourself and accept that choice to the individual is a benefit?

And, according to the stipulation above, we can add avoidance of physical trauma, pain and irreversible body modification.

When looking at all of these comparisons, it isn't so cut-and-dried. The WBC definitely poses a greater threat to society than the other two, with incitement to riot, and reduce moral. It poses much greater emotional scarring than the other two, and so affects the families trying to bury their loved ones in peace to a much greater extent. And so both society and private families are negatively affected to a rather large degree.

In order to reach that conclusion, you've omitted or marginalised three factors that argue against your case.

With the infants, the risks in the procedures are some temporary pain and suffering that is rather quickly and completely forgotten. An incision in a baby's arm doesn't necessarily mean there is going to be any pain and suffering at all, for a local would easily take care of that. There is no harm to society with this practice.

And yet, this practice would clearly be illegal; it would constitute an assault.

However, I don't think the arguments for banning a rather simple and benign procedure outweighs the Constitution, despite some risks involved in such behavior.

It doesn't need to "outweigh the Constitution"; the Constitution does not make illegal acts legal if they are done under the protection of religion.

Dave
 
If so, I hereby veto all of them.

Dave

Which leads us to the interesting question what happens if you two disagree.

(I think it was in King of Queens where the parties have an alternating veto right. An incredibly interesting concept.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom