Ban circumcision in San Fran???

But you don't know how much better it might have been if you'd been left as God intended you to be.

Rolfe.

Utterly irrelevant. Possibly the silliest point attempted in this "never to be agreed upon" topic. You are not the only person who goes down this sidetrack, you have much company.
 
Again, you are free to have it performed on your children or not. Like abortion, don't push your beliefs on those that do want it done.

Yes, at the moment people are free to do it to their children.
That's the whole point: they shouldn't be. They should be free to do it to themselves.
Are there any things people might do to their children which you think they should be prevented from doing? Or does the 'don't push your beliefs' cover all possibilities?
If not, why not?
 
But what if there was a religion out there that went around circumcising unconscious people?
Honest question for Nihilianth, should that be legal?

That's a whole other issue, and has nothing to do with parents making decisions for their newborns.
 
The law shouldn't single out religion, race, or sex.

The proposed law is doing none of those things.
Have you not been arguing that the law should refrain from banning practices if they are religiously based? Is that not singling out religion?


(Since I am on ignore, I doubt there will be an answer)
 
CE you brought up a good point in the first few pages of this thread, which I'll bring up for posterity's sake:

Why do the religious feel the need to butcher the perfection that is God's handiwork?

I agree. It's a good question. One that I cannot answer, for it would be far too long at this point. The answer of which I don't happen to particularly agree with (what with me not really believing in the Bible a whole lot personally and all. At least, not the OT.)
 
The law shouldn't single out religion, race, or sex.

Exactly. No exemptions based on religion, race or sex.

No problem.

Okay, so have we finally reached agreement here?

All are in favour of banning circumcision of both males and females with no exceptions until the person reaches the age of maturity of 18 and can only be circumcised if they consent to it?

Thunder?

Nihilianth?
 
Last edited:
no ending in sight i see.

ETA: why don't you all just leave it at that already?
Some people will want to do circumcisions and some people don't want it done. Whoopee doo.

Again, you are free to have it performed on your children or not. Like abortion, don't push your beliefs on those that do want it done.

If there were a Thanks or a Rep button, this post deserves it. Pretty much sums up everything I have said in a nice and neat little package. Thanks. :cool:

Like I said, I think the best course of action at this point, is to just allow this thread to die it's death in a peaceful manner. All those I placed on ignore, I will undo it, so long as personal attacks come to a peaceful end as well.
 
If there were a Thanks or a Rep button, this post deserves it. Pretty much sums up everything I have said in a nice and neat little package. Thanks. :cool:

Like I said, I think the best course of action at this point, is to just allow this thread to die it's death in a peaceful manner. All those I placed on ignore, I will undo it, so long as personal attacks come to a peaceful end as well.

The thread continues because some people disagree with you.

Your position is that it should be the choice of a parent to have their children circumcised.

The opposition to that believe it shouldn't be.

There's no point in Arus808 saying why don't you just agree to the very thing opposed and stop arguing because both you and he are simply saying, "Why not just concede the debate and stop arguing?"

No! Because all the rational arguments are on our side!
 
If there were a Thanks or a Rep button, this post deserves it. Pretty much sums up everything I have said in a nice and neat little package. Thanks. :cool:

Like I said, I think the best course of action at this point, is to just allow this thread to die it's death in a peaceful manner. All those I placed on ignore, I will undo it, so long as personal attacks come to a peaceful end as well.


Without your stubborn ignorance this thread would have never reached 24 pages. We are used to deal with Thunder.
 
The proposed law is doing none of those things.
Have you not been arguing that the law should refrain from banning practices if they are religiously based? Is that not singling out religion?


(Since I am on ignore, I doubt there will be an answer)

The parentheses is quite wrong, as I have decided this thread has lived far beyond it's usefulness, and no reason to leave with any hard feelings IMO.

Now, to honestly answer your question above the parenthesis, to be fair, I responded to this question:

"So tell me Nihilianth, should the law allow circumcision for only religious reasons?"

I responded with saying "the law is not meant to single out religion, race, or sex." Which is quite true.

As for these questions you asked me:

"Have you not been arguing that the law should refrain from banning practices if they are religiously based?"

Yes, I have. And I still maintain that position.

Is that not singling out religion?

No, it is not. Not technically, anyway. Because anyone can still practice it, for whatever reasons they may have other than religion. But the religion aspect must be maintained as a defense against a ban, because that is specifically in the Constitution.

It wouldn't be unlike trying to ban people from covering their faces in public. You should not ban people form doing this, for there are Muslims who do so out of their religion. Since it is a religious practice among Muslims and is still legal, defending the Muslims' rights to do this is not technically "singling them out," since everyone is allowed to do it for whatever reason currently, be it trick-or-treating, or being severely cold outside. Or just plain being silly.

Basically, defending something which is currently legal isn't necessarily singling anything out. Or rather, it is only rational to do so in the case of religion, since it is protected in the Constitution. Otherwise, you can have society trying to impose their will on a certain religion, like Islam. You could, for example, make it illegal for people to kneel and pray while facing east at noon-time in public. People do not do this, unless they are Muslim. And so, the defense against a law making this illegal should be the right to practice one's religion, specifically, Muslims, "singling them out," in defense against the proposed ban. But the law cannot say, for instance, say "Only Muslims are allowed to kneel and pray at noontime, facing east," or alternatively "Muslims are not allowed to kneel and pray, facing east."

Therefore, the defense will say that EVERYBODY should be allowed to kneel at noontime and pray, facing east if they so wish. Making it technically not singling anyone out, while still referring to the First Amendment rights of Muslims who do so because of their religion.
 
Last edited:
Exactly. No exemptions based on religion, race or sex.

No problem.

Okay, so have we finally reached agreement here?

All are in favour of banning circumcision of both males and females with no exceptions until the person reaches the age of maturity of 18 and can only be circumcised if they consent to it?

Thunder?

Nihilianth?

This is why you have ended up on ignore. It doesn't work that way, you see. Please, I ask of you to politely read very carefully every word I am about to say on this "point" that you brought up, and exactly why it is an erroneous conclusion.

While there can be no laws on the books that single out a religion, it doesn't work the other way around. While there may be people who practice something for a secular reason, and while society has a secular reason for wanting something banned, that doesn't mean is doesn't violate the Constitutional right of those who practice it for religious purposes.

The Constitution protects people from, and for religion, you see. The government cannot force you to believe in something, or to perform some religious rites. The government also cannot force people to NOT practice a religious rite (within reason, of course. And circumcision happens to be the question here, of which I am not going to talk about any longer. We can just agree to disagree, if you will, about circumcision in particular. Perhaps this could be split off into another thread? I wouldn't mind continuing a discussion along this vein, so long as it doesn't get personal.)

Anyway, as I was saying, the Constitution and what is written therein must be considered by responsible citizens of the USA. If there is a well-known, and widely-practiced ritual that doesn't really harm anyone or society, a ban on that particular practice shouldn't be passed. Because religion is written into the Constitution as a protection of our freedoms, it only makes sense to defend a practice based on that particular freedom.

On the other hand, a law itself cannot allow some in society to do something based on religion, but punish those who do it for secular purposes. Drug laws are probably the closest examples to a "violation" of this rule that I can think of. And even then, it is still technically illegal for Native Americans to chew peyote. But many states choose not to enforce these laws against the NAs, for it is a part of their religion, and does not put undue harm on others or society.

See the difference? Or are you confused still?
 
The thread continues because some people disagree with you.

Your position is that it should be the choice of a parent to have their children circumcised.

The opposition to that believe it shouldn't be.

There's no point in Arus808 saying why don't you just agree to the very thing opposed and stop arguing because both you and he are simply saying, "Why not just concede the debate and stop arguing?"

No! Because all the rational arguments are on our side!

I am sorry you think this way. However, it is quite untrue, because you have to deal with parents' rights, and religious freedom. By admitting "all the rational arguments are on our side! reveals that you haven't even listened, or at least attempted to understand those who are opposed.

Now, stop right there, because I know what you are going to say. You are going to mention about the right of the individual to choose what to do to their own bodies, and so forth. Those arguments and mine have been all used up a long time ago. There is nothing further to say that hasn't already been said. Which is why Arus808's post is the winning post IMO. And why I am calling for a truce to just agree to disagree.

All we can do, is just sit back, and wait to see what happens in San Francisco. If the ban passes, it means there was more support for the ban. If it does not, then it means too many people must think it must impose on the First Amendment.

If the ban happens to pass, we can further sit and wait and see if a lawsuit comes up in the courts. If the courts decides in favor of the plaintiff, depending on the arguments presented, it will be because it truly is a Constitutional issue.

Unless you want to argue that the Constitution is irrational, we can have that discussion in another thread.
 
This is why you have ended up on ignore. It doesn't work that way, you see. Please, I ask of you to politely read very carefully every word I am about to say on this "point" that you brought up, and exactly why it is an erroneous conclusion.

While there can be no laws on the books that single out a religion, it doesn't work the other way around. While there may be people who practice something for a secular reason, and while society has a secular reason for wanting something banned, that doesn't mean is doesn't violate the Constitutional right of those who practice it for religious purposes.

The Constitution protects people from, and for religion, you see. The government cannot force you to believe in something, or to perform some religious rites. The government also cannot force people to NOT practice a religious rite (within reason, of course. And circumcision happens to be the question here, of which I am not going to talk about any longer. We can just agree to disagree, if you will, about circumcision in particular. Perhaps this could be split off into another thread? I wouldn't mind continuing a discussion along this vein, so long as it doesn't get personal.)

Anyway, as I was saying, the Constitution and what is written therein must be considered by responsible citizens of the USA. If there is a well-known, and widely-practiced ritual that doesn't really harm anyone or society, a ban on that particular practice shouldn't be passed. Because religion is written into the Constitution as a protection of our freedoms, it only makes sense to defend a practice based on that particular freedom.

On the other hand, a law itself cannot allow some in society to do something based on religion, but punish those who do it for secular purposes. Drug laws are probably the closest examples to a "violation" of this rule that I can think of. And even then, it is still technically illegal for Native Americans to chew peyote. But many states choose not to enforce these laws against the NAs, for it is a part of their religion, and does not put undue harm on others or society.

See the difference? Or are you confused still?

Within reason, of course.

Yes, of course. And then the question arises, "Is circumcision within reason?" And those who are arguing here say, "No" or "Maybe not" or "I don't think so".
 
Within reason, of course.

Yes, of course. And then the question arises, "Is circumcision within reason?" And those who are arguing here say, "No" or "Maybe not" or "I don't think so".

Right. And I can certainly agree to disagree with you on this. I have no problems with your opinions on the matter, and I think I understand them quite well. But I still have my opposing views on the same topic. Therefor, the discussion has reached an impasse.

Truce?
 
Pharonisation might be an acceptable example of this.

Sorry, but what is pharonisation? I've tried looking for it and the only results are this thread, and a bunch of mirrors for some Scottish newspaper comment thread where some guy says "It's too horrible to explain here".
 
Sorry, but what is pharonisation? I've tried looking for it and the only results are this thread, and a bunch of mirrors for some Scottish newspaper comment thread where some guy says "It's too horrible to explain here".

I don't know but if you don't want to see what some people do with it, do not look at the BME site.
 
I'm surprised it's not better explained than that - unless I've spelled it wrong. It's a particularly extreme form of female sexual mutilation.

Some people think that's just fine though, for exactly the same reasons Nihilianth gives for believing male circumcision is fine.

Who gets to make the decision on what is fine, then?

Rolfe.
 
That wasn't the comparison I was making. I was making the comparison between two moral dilemmas. You and others were making the argument that "it is immoral." I was making the argument that morality doesn't matter, and is not an argument to use when making and enforcing laws.

OK, let's use harm to society and to the individual. Let's look at three cases - WBC's freedom of speech, an unnecessary incision in a baby's arm, and infant circumcision. Lat's also assume that freedom of religious expression is equally important to all three, so we can leave it out of the comparison.

WBC:
Harm to society: Breach of the peace, incitement to riot.
Harm to the individual: Emotional distress.
Benefit to society: Freedom of speech is not infringed.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

Unnecessary incision in baby's arm:
Harm to society: Probably none.
Harm to the individual: Physical trauma, pain.
Benefit to society: None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

Infant circumcision:
Harm to society: Probably none.
Harm to the individual: Physical trauma, pain, permanent body modification.
Benefit to society: None.
Benefit to the individual affected: None.

So, based on cost/benefit analysis, the most harmful of these, and therefore the first choice for banning, which is not currently prohibited; the second most harmful is an unnecessary incision in the arm, which is currently prohibited; and the least harmful, and the only one with any compensatory benefits, is the WBC's freedom of speech.

Therefore, it's consistent, both internally and with existing laws, for the WBC to be allowed freedom of speech and for circumcision to be banned.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom