Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I think I'll stick with the opinion of the AAP, if you don't mind.

If they believe circumcision has some benefits, and therefore the decision should be left to the parents, that's good enough for me.
 
so, as a man, you are telling us that you find circumcised penises to be ugly and unattractive? interesting...

Most of them look terrible but some manage to look somewhat 'acceptable'.

you know, its funny. I've never heard a women EVER describe a circumcised penis as being scarred, ugly, or unattractive.

Oh i can guess how such an conversation would have gone. "Yeah i find circumcised penises to be disgusting! They look terrible and i couldn't see myself ever having sex with someone who has been circumcised. Oh what's that? You're circumcised with a disgustingly mutilated penis? Really?" Yeah...

In fact, I've heard women describe circumcised penises as being perfect.

I've heard people call people who are disgustingly fat and obese as being 'beautiful' yet strangely i don't consider the opinions of those people to have any value.

And using the logic that since people who aren't circumcised 'might' be bullied by the majority of people who are circumcised then logically circumcision should be banned here in Sweden since the far, far majority of people aren't circumcised here.
 
Do the majority of organisations fall in line with the AAP? What was the AAP's reasoning behind the decision?
Hate to be a cynic but you are giving off the impression that you've picked only the organisations vaguely supportive of circumcision rather than access the majority view.
 
Do the majority of organisations fall in line with the AAP? What was the AAP's reasoning behind the decision?

i can only speculate that the AAP looked at all of the evidence of circumcision having benefits, all the evidence of circumcision being harmful, and decided that the possible benefits outweight the possible harm.

why should I assume anything else?

from the AAP:

Scientific studies show some medical benefits of circumcision. However, these benefits are not sufficient for the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) to recommend that all infant boys be circumcised.
Because circumcision is not essential to a child's health, parents should choose what is best for their child by looking at theNbenefits and risks.​

and from the National Institute of Health:​

Possible benefits include a lower risk of urinary tract infections, penile cancer and sexually transmitted diseases. The risks include pain and a low risk of bleeding or infection. These risks are higher for older babies, boys and men. ​
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) does not recommend routine circumcision. Parents need to decide what is best for their sons, based on their religious, cultural and personal preferences.
 
Last edited:
http://kidshealth.org/parent/system/surgical/circumcision.html#

from the Nemours Association:

In addition to the medical issues discussed, religious and cultural beliefs often figure into the equation. Of course, if these are important to you, they deserve to be seriously considered.

Despite the possible benefits and risks, circumcision is neither essential nor detrimental to a boy's health. The AAP and the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) do not endorse the procedure as a way to prevent any of the medical conditions mentioned previously. The AAP also does not find sufficient evidence to medically recommend circumcision or argue against it.




...now, can someone please provide a study or recommendation from a renowned international or Western medical association, arguing that the harm of circumcision outweighs the benefits, and therefore should be discouraged...or even banned?
 
Last edited:
After a cursory check, it would seem that you're correct, though the AAP did not decide that the benefits outweigh the harm. The AAP seem to have decided there's very little in it, so do not recommend one way or the other.
Also, the AAP's stance that the decision should be left to the parents isn't a matter of science but morality, which is surely what is being discussed?
 
After a cursory check, it would seem that you're correct, though the AAP did not decide that the benefits outweigh the harm. The AAP seem to have decided there's very little in it, so do not recommend one way or the other.
Also, the AAP's stance that the decision should be left to the parents isn't a matter of science but morality, which is surely what is being discussed?

it does appear that they feel no overwhelming argument can be made for the medical need nor medical harm, of infant male circumcision..and decided to simply leave it to the parents.

I think their view, is a fair one.
 
http://www.aafp.org/online/en/home/clinical/clinicalrecs/children/circumcision.html

from the American Academy of Family Physicians

Summary

Considerable controversy surrounds neonatal circumcision. Putative indications for neonatal circumcision have included preventing UTIs and their sequelae, preventing the contraction of STDs including HIV, and preventing penile cancer as well as other reasons for adult circumcision. Circumcision is not without risks. Bleeding, infection, and failure to remove enough foreskin occur in less than 1% of circumcisions. Evidence-based complications from circumcision include pain, bruising, and meatitis. More serious complications have also occurred. Although numerous studies have been conducted to evaluate these postulates, only a few used the quality of methodology necessary to consider the results as high level evidence.

The evidence indicates that neonatal circumcision prevents UTIs in the first year of life with an absolute risk reduction of about 1% and prevents the development of penile cancer with an absolute risk reduction of less than 0.2%. The evidence suggests that circumcision reduces the rate of acquiring an STD, but careful sexual practices and hygiene may be as effective. Circumcision appears to decrease the transmission of HIV in underdeveloped areas where the virus is highly prevalent. No study has systematically evaluated the utility of routine neonatal circumcision for preventing all medically-indicated circumcisions in later life. Evidence regarding the association between cervical cancer and a woman’s partner being circumcised or uncircumcised, and evidence regarding the effect of circumcision on sexual functioning is inconclusive. If the decision is made to circumcise, anesthesia should be used.

The American Academy of Family Physicians recommends physicians discuss the potential harms and benefits of circumcision with all parents or legal guardians considering this procedure for their newborn son. (2001)
 
Last edited:
Taking it out of all the traditional religion baggage for a second:
Say we have an unrelated surgical procedure, which has no long term health benefits or risks to speak of (essentially). There is some debate over how fashionable the results of the procedure are, to the point where that argument can be dismissed.
The only significant factor we are left with, is the likely pain caused to the child, and the overall distress of the medical setting.
I have difficulty defending this procedure, as there is nothing which seems to counteract or level out those final points. What sort of thing would do it for you?
 
Why do you keep employing the same fallacies when it's been demonstrated that they are Sophistry?

You are conflating Child Caring with Child Abuse!

GB

He seems to feel that your somehow denying his manhood.
 
Wait, so the fact that there is no medical conclusion one way or another is evidence for a procedure being used on a child :confused: ?
 
Supporting the right of parents to decide for themselvs if they are going to circumcise their son, does not mean I believe that the act itself is good, bad, moral, immoral. It simply means I respect the right of parents to make the decision.

It is reasonable to expect that a person who supports the right of parents to do anything to their babies would have an opinion as to whether that thing was good or bad, moral or immoral.
It is immoral and bad in itself to support the right of parents to do something to their babies without thinking such a thing was good and moral.
And again Thunder seems to forget what he has posted. He has been saying adamantly that cicumcision is a good thing.
 
so we should not perform surgery on a child, because he might protest the idea once he turns 18?

"damn it dad, why did you remove my appendex!! I should have had the right to decide for myself what happens to my body!!"

This actully hilarious. A few posts back Thunder accused someone of misrepresenting what he has said.
And now here he is again with the same tired old misrepresentation.
Is he genuinely that stupid or can I safely say he is dishonest?
 
no. circumcision should not be forced upon an adult.

but children have less rights than adults, and therefore its ok for parents to have their child circumcised.

I believe in parental rights.

I find it hard to believe even Thunder could post this.
 
are you suggesting that no medical procedures should be performed upon a child, because as an adult he/she may decide that the procedure was wrong?

are you suggesting that NO decisions should may be made for a child, because when the child grows up he/she may decide that the decision was a mistake?

And, he does it again.
 
is it immoral to be deprived of a useless piece of skin?

huh

btw, if other posters care, why are you the ONLY one asking the question.....again..and again..and again?

anyway, time for another break. see you guys in a few.

Of course Thunder does put some of us on ignore. That makes it easier.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom