Ban circumcision in San Fran???

http://www.calcatholic.com/news/newsArticle.aspx?id=33652525-d9da-437f-8936-f6f8747ff153

Archishop of San Francisco comes out against circumcision ban:

“Apart from the religious aspect, the citizens of San Francisco should be outraged at the prospect of city government dictating to parents in such a sensitive matter regarding the health and hygiene of their children,” wrote Archbishop Niederauer.

The archbishop is an idiot. (He's not a member here, is he? I can say that, can't I?)
 
so, lets see where the pathetic insults now stand, with the opponents of baby-boy circumcision.

those who support it are or have:

-eyesight problems.
-evil.
-barbaric.
-child abuse.
-hating children.
-hating babies.
-anti-Semitic.
-Conspiracy Theorist.

-and now, if they are a male and were circumcised, they are not a real man.

wow, your method of debate is quite interesting. what do you guys call it?
 
Sorry about the aggression from some people Thunder. I'd be interested to hear your reply to my query though :)
 
http://www.bma.org.uk/ethics/consen...rcumcision2006.jsp#Nontherapeuticcircumcision

The British Medical Association on circumcision when not a medical necessity.

Non-therapeutic male circumcision
Male circumcision that is performed for any reason other than physical clinical need is termed non-therapeutic (or sometimes “ritual”) circumcision. Some people ask for non-therapeutic circumcision for religious reasons, some to incorporate a child into a community, and some want their sons to be like their fathers. Circumcision is a defining feature of some faiths.

There is a spectrum of views within the BMA’s membership about whether non-therapeutic male circumcision is a beneficial, neutral or harmful procedure or whether it is superfluous, and whether it should ever be done on a child who is not capable of deciding for himself. The medical harms or benefits have not been unequivocally proven but there are clear risks of harm if the procedure is done inexpertly. The Association has no policy on these issues. Indeed, it would be difficult to formulate a policy in the absence of unambiguously clear and consistent medical data on the implications of the intervention. As a general rule, however, the BMA believes that parents should be entitled to make choices about how best to promote their children’s interests, and it is for society to decide what limits should be imposed on parental choices. What those limits currently are is discussed below, together with the legal and ethical considerations for doctors asked to perform non-therapeutic circumcision.
 
now, does anyone have anything.....from a renowned medical institution or agency in the West, that says that circumcision causes more bad than good..and should be discouraged if not made illegal?
 
....
http://www.bma.org.uk/ethics/consen...rcumcision2006.jsp#Nontherapeuticcircumcision

The British Medical Association on circumcision when not a medical necessity.

Non-therapeutic male circumcision
Male circumcision that is performed for any reason other than physical clinical need is termed non-therapeutic (or sometimes “ritual”) circumcision. Some people ask for non-therapeutic circumcision for religious reasons, some to incorporate a child into a community, and some want their sons to be like their fathers. Circumcision is a defining feature of some faiths.

There is a spectrum of views within the BMA’s membership about whether non-therapeutic male circumcision is a beneficial, neutral or harmful procedure or whether it is superfluous, and whether it should ever be done on a child who is not capable of deciding for himself. The medical harms or benefits have not been unequivocally proven but there are clear risks of harm if the procedure is done inexpertly. The Association has no policy on these issues. Indeed, it would be difficult to formulate a policy in the absence of unambiguously clear and consistent medical data on the implications of the intervention. As a general rule, however, the BMA believes that parents should be entitled to make choices about how best to promote their children’s interests, and it is for society to decide what limits should be imposed on parental choices. What those limits currently are is discussed below, together with the legal and ethical considerations for doctors asked to perform non-therapeutic circumcision.
 

the BMA also says this:

It is important that doctors consider the child’s social and cultural circumstances. Where a child is living in a culture in which circumcision is required for all males, the increased acceptance into a family or society that circumcision can confer is considered to be a strong social or cultural benefit. Exclusion may cause harm by, for example, complicating the individual’s search for identity and sense of belonging. Clearly, assessment of such intangible risks and benefits is complex.

and this:

The BMA is generally very supportive of allowing parents to make choices on behalf of their children, and believes that neither society nor doctors should interfere unjustifiably in the relationship between parents and their children.
 
Last edited:
again, does anyone...

and I mean ANYONE...have any report from a renowned Western medical agency or organization that states that male infant circumcision creates more harm than good..and should be discouraged if not made illegal?
 
http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmoa0802556

The New England Journal of Medicine declares the "potential public health benefits of circumcision":

Conclusions

In addition to decreasing the incidence of HIV infection, male circumcision significantly reduced the incidence of HSV-2 infection and the prevalence of HPV infection, findings that underscore the potential public health benefits of the procedure. (ClinicalTrials.gov numbers, NCT00425984 and NCT00124878.)



I mean, come on guys, its the New England Journal of Medicine we're talking about here. :)
 
Last edited:
I think the point has been well made that long term health effects are basically negligible. The case of circumcision remains a question of morality though, which every group you have mentioned is not an authority on, no matter what their qualifications.
The case still needs to be made that, regardless of long term health, it is ok to put a child through an unnecessary and permanent surgical procedure.
 
Last edited:
interesting.

no links.

random studies, with no name of who did them or what agency/organization they are associated with.

do I even need to comment on such information?

:boggled:

Darat got them from Wikipedia, unless you think he was lying. But I'm unsurprised you ignore
them.


In any case, as Darat said in that post it's a red herring as circumcision is not done for health reasons.
 
Last edited:
The case still needs to be made that, regardless of long term health, it is ok to put a child through an unnecessary and permanent surgical procedure.

The Hippocratic oath first says: do no harm

The doctors at the NIH, the AAP, the BMA, and the New England Journal of Medicine, would be VIOLATING THEIR OATH, if they knowingly advised society to leave it to the parents to make the decision, if they believed that ANY harm could actually be done by the procedure.

That said, being that the NIH, the AAP, the BMA, and the NEJM all seek to defer to the parents to make the decision, due to the lack of overwhelming evidence of harm being caused, I will trust these four organizations over my own unprofessional opinion.
 
Darat got them from Wikipedia, unless you think he was lying. But I'm unsurprised you ignore them.

oh really? Wikipedia did the studies?

fascinating. I didn't know Wikipedia did such things.


thank you for enlightening me as to the capabilities of Wikipedia to educate the planet.


...now, Lionking, do you think it is wrong of me to trust the findings & opinions of the National Institute of Health, the American Academty of Pedicatrics, the British Medical Association, and the New England Journal of Medicine?

cause honestly, I think if I did NOT trust their clearly expert professional views on this matter, I would be no better than many of the CTists I debate.
 
Last edited:
A few posts back Thunder accused someone of misrepresenting what he has said.
And now here he is again with the same tired old misrepresentation.
Is he genuinely that stupid or can I safely say he is dishonest?
False dichotomy :)
 
What the deuce? You reported me? I didn't say anything bad at all...


I think he means he reported the other people, not you.

He probably reported me for suggesting that maybe circumcision had an effect on eyesight, because he couldn't seem to read part of my post even when I repeated it with the words in bold red large-font.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom