Ban circumcision in San Fran???

are you suggesting that no medical procedures should be performed upon a child, because as an adult he/she may decide that the procedure was wrong?

are you suggesting that NO decisions should may be made for a child, because when the child grows up he/she may decide that the decision was a mistake?
No, I am NOT suggesting that. Rather, I am posing a question: do you believe that it is immoral for an adult to be deprived of his foreskin without medical necessity and without his consent? You would have known that I was asking that question if you had read my post before mashing the "submit reply" button. You've wasted a LOT of posts pretending to not understand that question, then acknowledging that you understood the question, then announcing that you would answer the question, then not answering the question, then answering a different question. It would save everyone a whole lot of time and energy to just answer the question
 
I'm sorry you feel ignored.

:o

I'd be sorry that you ignored me. That was your chance to make everyone listen, or at least one person, really listen to what you had to your argument and if you are confident in your arguments you should've chopped me down and went out a winner. Now you just look bad.
 
No one really cares, my friend.
I care, other posters care, and if you were honest you would care too. Do you believe that it is immoral for an adult to be deprived of his foreskin without medical necessity and without his consent?
 
I care, other posters care, and if you were honest you would care too. Do you believe that it is immoral for an adult to be deprived of his foreskin without medical necessity and without his consent?

is it immoral to be deprived of a useless piece of skin?

huh

btw, if other posters care, why are you the ONLY one asking the question.....again..and again..and again?

anyway, time for another break. see you guys in a few.
 
Last edited:
huh. almost sounds like a threat.

"its a VERY bad idea, almost dangerous...to ignore me".

:D

Well you've failed yourself, that's what I'm saying. If you had a coherent argument that was your chance to share it and honestly be listened to. Unlike yourself I read and addressed each of your points in response to me and then some, you chose a sentence of my posts that I wrote objectively and implanted plenty of questions to fuel the conversation, and in grateful response I was lucky enough to get a sentence maybe with a comma every now and again.

You've outright lost now.
 
Thunder: let's not lose track of our conversation. I know there are a lot of people with a lot of opinions flying around here, but I thought we were making a bit of useful progress.

You weren't really. It's a damn shame though!


GB
 
so we should not perform surgery on a child, because he might protest the idea once he turns 18?

"damn it dad, why did you remove my appendex!! I should have had the right to decide for myself what happens to my body!!"

:boggled:

So far as I know they don't remove appendixes without medical need.
 
is it immoral to be deprived of a useless piece of skin?
The question. The question is "Do you believe that it is immoral for an adult to be deprived of his foreskin without his consent? Should people have the right to deprive other adults of their foreskin without their consent?".
btw, if other posters care, why are you the ONLY one asking the question.....again..and again..and again?
I'm not the only one. Heck even you said you would answer it.
 
You weren't really. It's a damn shame though!


GB

I think we did. We were definitely on the right track. As far as I can tell, that was the first real time he actually stopped and conceded his mind wasn't made up on that actual morality of it and that he was "far from" making his mind up.
 
If we start at the point of "it is not ok to permanently physically harm a child"
And then add in "sometimes it may be necessary to do this for medical reasons"

Then why are also providing an exception for circumcision?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom