Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Are you seriously suggesting that circumcisions are performed for health reasons?

It seems circumcisions are performed for
. health reasons
. to uphold parental rights
. to maintain tradition
.to protect boys from bullying
.because the bible says so


I may have missed one or two
 
These generally supportive statements Thunder has been finding. I think one has to ask, who wrote them?

There are plenty senior doctors who are Jewish, in Britain certainly. It's practically the stereotypical Jewish momma thing. "My son, the doctor." And Jewish doctors have form in approaching this issue in the way Thunder is approaching it. And their non-Jewish colleagues have form in giving them a pretty free run, out of fear of being accused of anti-Semitism.

I've seen it all before, in my own profession, in the apologetics that go on for the obscenity that is shechita slaughter. Oh dear we can't criticise this, even though it is appallingly cruel, because we'd be called anti-Semitic.

I smell a similar genesis for the easy-ride circumcision guidelines.

Rolfe.
 
These generally supportive statements Thunder has been finding. I think one has to ask, who wrote them?

I knew this was coming. I didn't know when, or by who. But I knew this would eventually rear its ugly head.

There are plenty senior doctors who are Jewish, in Britain certainly. It's practically the stereotypical Jewish momma thing. "My son, the doctor." And Jewish doctors have form in approaching this issue in the way Thunder is approaching it. And their non-Jewish colleagues have form in giving them a pretty free run, out of fear of being accused of anti-Semitism.

I've seen it all before, in my own profession, in the apologetics that go on for the obscenity that is shechita slaughter. Oh dear we can't criticise this, even though it is appallingly cruel, because we'd be called anti-Semitic.

yep, here we go. now its all just a Jewish-doctor conspiracy. in both the USA and Britain.

whether its kosher slaughter regulations, or circumcision, these Jewish folks just keep imposing their way of life upon the apologetic Gentiles.

;)
 
Whether it's kosher slaughter or circumcision, these Jewish folk keep managing to get a free pass to keep on abusing babies and animals, because so many people are afraid of being branded anti-Semitic. And that's the simple fact.

I knew you'd indicate you'd read that post of mine, even though you have been systematically ignoring everything else I posted in this thread.

Rolfe.
 
Are you seriously suggesting that circumcisions are performed for health reasons?

are you seriously suggesting I should not follow the VERY experienced and VERY professional advise & opinions, of the NIH, BMA, AAP, and the New England Journal of Medicine? who should I follow instead?

JREF novices?

sorry, but here at JREF...we stick with the professionals.

we....at least some of do.
 
Whether it's kosher slaughter or circumcision, these Jewish folk keep managing to get a free pass to keep on abusing babies and animals, because so many people are afraid of being branded anti-Semitic. And that's the simple fact.

yes, damn these Jews. damn these Jews...and branding anti-Semites as anti-Semitic. who do these baby-abusing, livestock-butchering Jews think they are?

;)

your views are expressed very well, in this thread.

http://www.internationalskeptics.co...hp?t=183045&highlight=circumcision+conspiracy
 
Last edited:
are you seriously suggesting I should not follow the VERY experienced and VERY professional advise & opinions, of the NIH, BMA, AAP, and the New England Journal of Medicine? who should I follow instead?

JREF novices?

sorry, but here at JREF...we stick with the professionals.

we....at least some of do.

As usual, you didn't answer the question. You may be able to find a few circumcisions done for health reasons, but you know the vast majority are performed for religious or cultural reasons. The so-called, and disputed "health benefits" is a massive red herring. And I think you know this.
 
The argument concerning the hippocratic oath was a weird one:
The oath says do no harm.
Thus if a medical professional supports it, this proves it to be harmless.

In reality the oath is broken by every medical professional every year. It forbids euthenasia and abortion for a start...

Again, regardless of any long term effects, what reason would make an unnecessary, painful, permanent surgical operation moral?
 
The so-called, and disputed "health benefits" is a massive red herring.

that's quite an accusation to be made, against some very esteemed medical organizations and agencies.

oh, nevermind. these organizations most likely are filled with baby-abusing Jews, so they don't count.
 
These generally supportive statements Thunder has been finding. I think one has to ask, who wrote them?

There are plenty senior doctors who are Jewish, in Britain certainly. It's practically the stereotypical Jewish momma thing. "My son, the doctor." And Jewish doctors have form in approaching this issue in the way Thunder is approaching it. And their non-Jewish colleagues have form in giving them a pretty free run, out of fear of being accused of anti-Semitism.

I've seen it all before, in my own profession, in the apologetics that go on for the obscenity that is shechita slaughter. Oh dear we can't criticise this, even though it is appallingly cruel, because we'd be called anti-Semitic.

I smell a similar genesis for the easy-ride circumcision guidelines.

Rolfe.

This post stinks of antisemitism not because you're criticizing circumcision or shechita, but because you're stereotyping a whole class of people in a negative manner, solely on the basis of their religion. Hell, you even try to justify it on the basis of a stereotype that you state is a stereotype. Go figure that that would raise some hackles.

Plus, of course, this criticism is entirely content-free. Nothing in this post actually addresses the merit or demerits of circumcision. Your post is really just about Jews, and how they're spreading their awful influence surreptitiously. Those doctors can't be trusted because they're Jewish. Or more precisely, because they might be Jewish, since you don't even know. Again, go figure that that might rub people the wrong way.

You opened yourself up for accusations of antisemitism. Your preemptory defense doesn't get you off the hook on this one.
 
In reality the oath is broken by every medical professional every year. It forbids euthenasia and abortion for a start...

this thread is NOT about abortion, regardless of the fact that abortions do not apply to the Hyppocratic oath.
 
I know the thread isn't about abortion. I was giving examples to disprove the notion that no medical organisation would ever break the hippocratic oath.
 
that's quite an accusation to be made, against some very esteemed medical organizations and agencies.

oh, nevermind. these organizations most likely are filled with baby-abusing Jews, so they don't count.

Missing the point again. If circumcisions were done for health reasons in the main, the studies you selectively quote might just be relevant. They are not. They are red herrings.
 
This post stinks of antisemitism not because you're criticizing circumcision or shechita, but because you're stereotyping a whole class of people in a negative manner, solely on the basis of their religion. Hell, you even try to justify it on the basis of a stereotype that you state is a stereotype. Go figure that that would raise some hackles.

Plus, of course, this criticism is entirely content-free. Nothing in this post actually addresses the merit or demerits of circumcision. Your post is really just about Jews, and how they're spreading their awful influence surreptitiously. Those doctors can't be trusted because they're Jewish. Or more precisely, because they might be Jewish, since you don't even know. Again, go figure that that might rub people the wrong way.

You opened yourself up for accusations of antisemitism. Your preemptory defense doesn't get you off the hook on this one.


I think, quod erat demonstrandum.

I said plenty about circumcision earlier in the thread. I didn't get any response at all from the person (or people) in favour of the practice.

It's a fact of life that people in positions of influence will use that influence to favour their own personal viewpoint. It's a pity that in this case the history of the 20th century has caused the potential opposition to clam up for fear of being vilified.

Well, I don't care. I'm against child abuse and I'm against animal cruelty, no matter who does it, and you don't get a pass from me by bleating "anti-Semitism".

Rolfe.
 
This post stinks of antisemitism not because you're criticizing circumcision or shechita, but because you're stereotyping a whole class of people in a negative manner, solely on the basis of their religion.

indeed. he appears to be arguing that there is one and ONLY one reason the New England Journal of Medicine, the British Medical Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and the National Institute of Health...advocates for circumcision or simply says it should be left to the parents to decide, is because they are filled with Jews.

Jews, who will accuse anyone of anti-Semitism, if they dare to question their support of baby-male circumcision, kosher-slaughter rules, etc etc.

its very sad. I didn't want this debate to go there. :(
 
Too bad. It's gone there. You could have tried answering the serious points I and others were making, but no....

Oh, and by the way, I didn't say any of these organisations is "filled with Jews". I was pointing out that people will argue in favour of things they personally support, and that in this case the opposition tends to keep quiet for fear of exactly the sort of tirade you're working up to. It only takes one or two people to push this sort of crap, and the rest of the committee sits on its collective hands and squirms a bit, and it's a done deal. I've seen it again and again.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Well, I don't care. I'm against child abuse and I'm against animal cruelty, no matter who does it, and you don't get a pass from me by bleating "anti-Semitism".

you accused there four VERY esteemed and VERY professional organizations, of having the views they do simply because they are probably filled with Jews. and if they are not filled with Jews, then the Jews that are there have threatened to label anyone who questions them on these issues, an anti-Semite.

you argue this, with no evidence. just mere speculation. and then you add in this BS about kosher-slaughter rituals, as if that has ANYTHING to do with the thread.

don't act all shocked if someone accuses you of anti-Semitism, when you CHOOSE to express anti-Semitism.
 
Thunder, Rolfe is a woman, and she even said so in this thread. So much for taking notice of her arguments.
 
Too bad. It's gone there. You could have tried answering the serious points I and others were making, but no....

what evidence do you have that these four organizations have the view that they do on circumcision, do to dominance by Jews, or threats of accusations of anti-Semitism, from a minority of Jewish doctors?

where is your evidence?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom