Ban circumcision in San Fran???

you think circumcision is barbaric, evil, horrible, child-abuse.

circumcision is an important part of all the main streams of Judaism...and is required of ALL males, including converts.

so, logic clearly states that since you have such a deep hatred for circumcision, you also deeply hate Judaism.

That's Illogical! Clearly you need a course in logic.

GB
 
Do you believe that it is immoral to deprive an adult of his foreskin without his consent?

no. circumcision should not be forced upon an adult.

but children have less rights than adults, and therefore its ok for parents to have their child circumcised.

I believe in parental rights.
 
Last edited:
you think circumcision is barbaric, evil, horrible, child-abuse.

circumcision is an important part of all the main streams of Judaism...and is required of ALL males, including converts.

so, logic clearly states that since you have such a deep hatred for circumcision, you also deeply hate Judaism.

No. I have such a deep hatred for parents choosing to have someone else's body butchered up for religious reasons. The fact that it's a practice in Judaism is totally unrelated and unimportant.

I think deep down you know it was a bit silly, at least I hope so. Is there any chance you can concede that point?

so we should not perform surgery on a child, because he might protest the idea once he turns 18?

Pretty much.

"damn it dad, why did you remove my appendex!! I should have had the right to decide for myself what happens to my body!!"

:boggled:

Expand on this. Was the appendix endangering his life? Did the appendix have to be removed for serious health reasons? Or did the dad just say to the doctors, "just take out his appendix, please, just put him through potentially dangerous and ultimately pointless surgery in the off-chance that he gets an appendix infection later in life"?
 
under the Civil Code of every state in the Union, children have less rights than their parents, and many of the rights of the child that we have as adults, are instead instilled upon the parent.

yes, children have less rights over their bodies & lives, than adults do. this is a good thing. children are not mature or inteligent enough to know what is best for them. that's why we leave it up to their parents.

do you REALLY want to give children the same rights as a 35 year old?

do you REALLY want to give children the right to refuse medical treatment, to work in a factory, to not go to school, to move out on their own, to do to their bodies whatever they see fit, to drink alchohol, to smoke, to use medical marijuana?

Under the Civil Code everyone has the right to not have bits of their anatomy chopped off!

Why do you hate Civil Rights?

GB
 
I think deep down you know it was a bit silly, at least I hope so. Is there any chance you can concede that point?

silly? sure why not.

but just because I see it as silly, doesn't mean parents shouldn't have the right to make a silly choice.

there is nothing illegal about making silly choices.
 
no. circumcision should not be forced upon an adult.

but children have less rights than adults, and therefore its ok for parents to have their child circumcised.

I believe in parental rights.

Following your own "logic," parents have the right to beat the crap out their kids (why do you hate kids?).

Thank God (ironically) that's against the law.


GB
 
And you know that... how, exactly?

because I was raised by a father who went to an Orthodox Jewish school until he was 18. I went to Hebrew School until I was 13. I had a Bar-Mitzvah. My aunt, uncle, and cousins are all Orthodox Jews, and we discuss Judaism and its rituals regularly.

I own a Bible and have read through the sections dealing with the Mitzvot numerous times.
 
silly? sure why not.

but just because I see it as silly, doesn't mean parents shouldn't have the right to make a silly choice.

there is nothing illegal about making silly choices.

It is illegal to chop off bits of most non-consenting persons' anatomies. Why do you have a double standard?


GB
 
silly? sure why not.

but just because I see it as silly, doesn't mean parents shouldn't have the right to make a silly choice.

there is nothing illegal about making silly choices.

I'm talking about your line of logic, which is just a simple fallacy that I was hoping you really knew was a fallacy, but you're just provoking people.
 
no. circumcision should not be forced upon an adult.

but children have less rights than adults, and therefore its ok for parents to have their child circumcised.

I believe in parental rights.
That's not what I asked, so I'll take this opportunity to make the question more specific: do you believe that it is immoral for an adult to be deprived of his foreskin without medical necessity and without his consent? Should people have the right to deprive other adults of their foreskin without medical necessity and without their consent?
 
because I was raised by a father who went to an Orthodox Jewish school until he was 18. I went to Hebrew School until I was 13. I had a Bar-Mitzvah. My aunt, uncle, and cousins are all Orthodox Jews, and we discuss Judaism and its rituals regularly.

I own a Bible and have read through the sections dealing with the Mitzvot numerous times.

It's a good thing that not everyone believes that the Bronze Age practices in the Bible should be followed. Why do you hate gay people?

GB
 
Last edited:
do you believe that it is immoral for an adult to be deprived of his foreskin without medical necessity and without his consent? Should people have the right to deprive other adults of their foreskin without medical necessity and without their consent?

no, no adult should have a circumcision forced upon them.

but we aren't talking about adults, now are we?
 
Surely physical harm, which leaves marks long into adulthood, doesn't count under parenting rights?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom