Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I made the point on the first page of this rather sad thread that if circumcision was only available to people above the age of consent, it would hardly happen at all.
 
I made the point on the first page of this rather sad thread that if circumcision was only available to people above the age of consent, it would hardly happen at all.

It's a good point and it actually goes both ways, religious and purported medical. Why for example did those researching HIV in Africa jump from voluntary adult to involuntary infant? Because they know that they could never make their coverage goals coercing adults into circumcision.
 
As far as FGM goes, such as your big clit example, it is unlikely a doctor would suggest or perform such a surgery since it is prohibited by law to perform any type of genital alteration on an infant girl or child that is not medically therapeutic.
No, that's not quite true. "Enlarged clitoris" is basically a euphemism for "girl born with a penis", and reducing it is common practice; often for no other reason than that it "looks weird".

It is not good example for Thunder to use though as the practice is actually quite controversial for very much the same reasons as circumcision is controversial, thanks to intersex advocacy groups. It is actually even more problematic than circumcision as most circumcised men grow up not caring much about their circumcision, but most intersexed girls end up transitioning to a male identity and would have preferred if they had kept their "enlarged clitoris".

What counts as "medical necessity" is of course not clearly defined, and somewhat fluid. But in all these cases there seems to be a common message: stop messing with babies' genitals without medical necessity. Wait until they can decide for themselves.
 
I don't believe there's any evidence that the procedure is any less painful for a baby. The descriptions of babies' reactions indicate very severe pain, which as one paper explained, is in fact much worse for a baby because they lack the dampening mechanisms of adults. The only justification is that the baby doesn't consciously remember the procedure.

Circumcision in an adult could make use of proper anaesthesia techniques so that the patient is relaxed and comfortable during the procedure. In fact it does, when it is performed on an adult. The larger, mature organ is a much simpler surgical challenge, and the mistakes like skin bridges and removing too much really shouldn't happen at all. And postoperatively, the man is able to take care of himself, changing dressings and so on as he feels the need, rather than a helpless infant screaming uselessly with the wound adherent to a nappy.

It should be part of the Bar Mitzvah ritual.

Rolfe.
 
What kind of society do you live in, Thunder, where communal showers are common for children, and teasing a child for having normal, natural genitals is seen as a good reason for mutilating (St Paul's word) the child?

I left school 30 years ago and our gym had individual showers in both the girls and the boys' changing rooms. My daughter's school was built in 1884 and it has individual showers in the gym block. My sons' schools, both based in Victorian buildings and recently built, all have individual showers.

That's what I was just about to ask.

I have never seen the genitals of any of my peers, classmates, parents, etc. Even when I was in the Navy, in boot camp, where I had to shower with a dozen other guys every day, I didn't see anything. How could circumcised vs. not be a social issue? Who goes looking for that?
 
No, that's not quite true. "Enlarged clitoris" is basically a euphemism for "girl born with a penis", and reducing it is common practice; often for no other reason than that it "looks weird".

It is not good example for Thunder to use though as the practice is actually quite controversial for very much the same reasons as circumcision is controversial, thanks to intersex advocacy groups. It is actually even more problematic than circumcision as most circumcised men grow up not caring much about their circumcision, but most intersexed girls end up transitioning to a male identity and would have preferred if they had kept their "enlarged clitoris".

What counts as "medical necessity" is of course not clearly defined, and somewhat fluid. But in all these cases there seems to be a common message: stop messing with babies' genitals without medical necessity. Wait until they can decide for themselves.

Point taken. Though it is true that most FGM laws prohibit any degree of cutting that is not connected with a medically therapeutic need. What I would add though is that the "big clit" example might also be considered a birth defect or anomaly; a foreskin is neither. The closer example would still be universal FGM without describing some birth defect. A closer example of the 'big clit' example in boys might be those born with hypospadias or the condition where the foreskin doesn't properly form in which case circumcision, or some other procedure, might have to be (rightfully be) considered.
 
men without their foreskin are "damaged"...for life?

Yes, the lack of foreskin coupled with scarring and general ugliness and unattractiveness means that a perfectly normal looking penis is damaged for life, baring some kind of foreskin restoration but I've heard that it's far from perfect.

How much harder can it be to understand?
 
Yes, the lack of foreskin coupled with scarring and general ugliness and unattractiveness means that a perfectly normal looking penis is damaged for life,..


so, as a man, you are telling us that you find circumcised penises to be ugly and unattractive? interesting...

you know, its funny. I've never heard a women EVER describe a circumcised penis as being scarred, ugly, or unattractive. In fact, I've heard women describe circumcised penises as being perfect.

That's right, perfect. How's that work for ya?
 
What kind of society do you live in, Thunder, where communal showers are common for children,..

New York City. The showers in my high school are communal.

The camp that I worked in for five summers, has communal showers for the kids.

The first camp that I went to as a child, had communal showers.

Many of the hostels I've been to all over the USA, had communal showers.


I am confused by your shock about the existance of communal showers.
 
Last edited:
so, as a man, you are telling us that you find circumcised penises to be ugly and unattractive? interesting...

you know, its funny. I've never heard a women EVER describe a circumcised penis as being scarred, ugly, or unattractive. In fact, I've heard women describe circumcised penises as being perfect.

That's right, perfect. How's that work for ya?

WOW! That's a FANTASTIC reason to chop off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

(Not really ;) )

GB
 
you know, its funny. I've never heard a women EVER describe a circumcised penis as being scarred, ugly, or unattractive. In fact, I've heard women describe circumcised penises as being perfect.

That's right, perfect. How's that work for ya?

They probably didn't want to hurt your feelings. Understandable, indeed one might say admirable, behaviour.
 
They were being polite to you. Or kind. Or something.

You're hearing it now. A circumcised penis is a poor, scarred, naked thing, and I can only pity their owners.

Rolfe.
 
Actually, you have made it very clear that you HAVE made up your mind. I guess you have already forgotten that you said this:


Supporting the right of parents to decide for themselvs if they are going to circumcise their son, does not mean I believe that the act itself is good, bad, moral, immoral. It simply means I respect the right of parents to make the decision.

get it? got it? no?

thought not. :boggled:
 
Last edited:
New York City. The showers in my high school are communal.

The camp that I worked in for five summers, has communal showers for the kids.

The first camp that I went to as a child, had communal showers.

Many of the hostels I've been to all over the USA, had communal showers.


I am confused by your shock about the existance of communal showers.

The showers in my high school were communal too. Which is why I didn't shower there (it's a rather nasty way for Bullies to establish a pecking order...so to speak ;) ).

GB
 
Thunder: let's not lose track of our conversation. I know there are a lot of people with a lot of opinions flying around here, but I thought we were making a bit of useful progress.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom