Ban circumcision in San Fran???

No, but the quality of it, yes. And what would it matter? There's just no point, you're operating outside your rights and infringing on the personal rights of someone else to not have a part of them permanently and unnecessarily chopped off.

under the Civil Code of every state in the Union, children have less rights than their parents, and many of the rights of the child that we have as adults, are instead instilled upon the parent.

yes, children have less rights over their bodies & lives, than adults do. this is a good thing. children are not mature or inteligent enough to know what is best for them. that's why we leave it up to their parents.

do you REALLY want to give children the same rights as a 35 year old?

do you REALLY want to give children the right to refuse medical treatment, to work in a factory, to not go to school, to move out on their own, to do to their bodies whatever they see fit, to drink alchohol, to smoke, to use medical marijuana?
 
Last edited:
I'll request that you address the other parts of my post, which I'll link for you right here.

yes, children have less rights over their bodies & lives, than adults do. this is a good thing. children are not mature or inteligent enough to know what is best for them. that's why we leave it up to their parents.

do you REALLY want to give children the same rights as a 35 year old?

That's what you're forgetting, Thunder. This is a 35 year old's rights. It's a 15 year old's, a 35 year old's, and an 88 year old's if he's to be so lucky. These boys aren't babies or children forever.
 
Last edited:
wow, you really have problems understanding what other people say. I'm sorry to see this.

Supporting the right of parents to decide for themselvs if they are going to circumcise their son, does not mean I believe that the act itself is good, bad, moral, immoral. It simply means I respect the right of parents to make the decision.

get it? got it? no?

thought not. :boggled:

Actually I have an amazing ability to understand what people are saying. I just blow away the smoke of sophistry that some people use to hide what they are really saying.

And I prefer to support the rights of non-consenting persons to not have bits of their anatomy chopped off.

You seem to be the one with the comprehension problem. I would have to conclude, given your statements, that you wouldn't mind being a non-consenting person having bits of your anatomy chopped off.

GB
 
I would have to conclude, given your statements, that you wouldn't mind being a non-consenting person having bits of your anatomy chopped off.

my parents had my foreskin removed when I was 8-days old.

no big deal. I'm doing just fine...especially my penis.
 
cirumcision is an important part of our faith & culture.

why do you hate Jews & Judaism?

I'm Jewish, why do you hate me for insisting that non-consenting person's have the right to not have bits of their anatomy chopped off.


GB
 
would you like me to quote the book, chapter, and verse..of the Old Testament?

please don't ask me rhetorical questions that you CLEARLY know the answer to.

Well, no need to quote book, chapter and verse, but a rough outline would be helpful. I don't know much about the Jewish religion and wonder why, if it's something that is found in the Old Testament, that it's not part of Christianity in general? What makes it specifically Jewish? And Muslim? And not other religions? It seems weird.

Not to mention silly, and pointless.
 
my parents had my foreskin removed when I was 8-days old.

no big deal. I'm doing just fine...especially my penis.

Me too! :)

But I bet it was a big deal when you were 8 days old though! It's a good thing you can't remember the experience.

But we'll never know what we missed, which is why I support the right of non-consenting persons to not have bits of their anatomy chopped off.

GB
 
That's what you're forgetting, Thunder. This is a 35 year old's rights. It's a 15 year old's, a 35 year old's, and an 88 year old's if he's to be so lucky. These boys aren't babies or children forever.

so we should not perform surgery on a child, because he might protest the idea once he turns 18?

"damn it dad, why did you remove my appendex!! I should have had the right to decide for myself what happens to my body!!"

:boggled:
 
do I believe it is immoral to remove your child's foreskin without his consent?

I don't know.
Do you believe that it is immoral to deprive an adult of his foreskin without his consent? Should people have the right to deprive other adults of their foreskin without their consent?
 
Thunder... please tell me you can see the glaring fallacy that this is.

you think circumcision is barbaric, evil, horrible, child-abuse.

circumcision is an important part of all the main streams of Judaism...and is required of ALL males, including converts.

so, logic clearly states that since you have such a deep hatred for circumcision, you also deeply hate Judaism.
 
so we should not perform surgery on a child, because he might protest the idea once he turns 18?

"damn it dad, why did you remove my appendex!! I should have had the right to decide for myself what happens to my body!!"

:boggled:

Straw Man!

GB
 
Last edited:
God said:
I am God Almighty. Walk before Me and be perfect. I will make a covenant between Me and you, and I will increase your numbers very much.' [...] This is My covenant between Me, and between you and your offspring that you must keep: You must circumcise every male. You shall be circumcised through the flesh of your foreskin. This shall be the mark of the covenant between Me and you. 'Throughout all generations, every male shall be circumcised when he is eight days old. [This shall include] those born in your house, as well as [slaves] bought with cash from an outsider, who is not your descendant. [All slaves,] both houseborn and purchased with your money must be circumcised. This shall be My covenant in your flesh, an eternal covenant. The uncircumcised male whose foreskin has not been circumcised, shall have his soul cut off from his people; he has broken My covenant.

Dear God,

You sound like a weirdo. What on earth is your problem with foreskins?

Regards

-Matthew Best
 
cirumcision is an important part of our faith & culture.

Well, that's certainly a position that many hold. So why are you discussing the medical issue of potential benefits?

why do you hate Jews & Judaism?

Now that's plain silly. While the group that started the SF proposal has resorted to Anti-Semitic literature, I see no evidence of it in this thread.

would you like me to quote the book, chapter, and verse..of the Old Testament?

please don't ask me rhetorical questions that you CLEARLY know the answer to.

I have to wonder. Are you a practicing Jew? How familiar are you with the laws, traditions, and customs of Jews?

It may surprise you, but I would imagine there are others here who were raised in the Jewish faith. They may or may not be practicing Jews at this time, but may potentially understand their faith, customs, and laws a lot better than you do.

They may also be better at discerning anti-Semitism, no matter where or whom it originates from.

Just sayin'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom