Ban circumcision in San Fran???

You are unable to demonstrate that you DON'T support chopping off bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy.

babies are unable consent. does that mean we should not bathe them? not clothe them? not teach them to walk? not teach them to talk?

babies are unable to consent to life-saving medical proceduders, should we therefore not perform them?

a baby girl is unable to consent to clitoral reduction surgery. does that mean we should not perform it?

when a baby is born, it very often is not breathing. because it cannot consent, does that mean we should not smack its butt to get it to cry and therefore breath? the smack causes pain, which by your logic..is harm. therefore we have no right to smack the baby's butt?
 
Last edited:
babies are unable consent. does that mean we should not bathe them? not clothe them? not teach them to walk? not teach them to talk?

It is dishonest of you to simply ignore what has been clearly stated many times and respond with this peurile tripe.
 
It is dishonest....

it is very dishonest and uncivil of you to continuously accuse me of dishonesty. you've done it probably ten times now, often with no justification.

contrary to what you appear to believe, one is not dishonest simply due to their disagreement with you.
 
Last edited:
people here have accused me of hating babies & hating children.

people here have accused me of supporting child abuse.

people here have accused me of being a Conspiracy Theorist.

people here have accused me of being evil, due to my views.

.......please tell them to shut up as well.

Not...even...close. :)

see, here's the thing: if you really cared about the thread, and didn't instead simply see it as an opportunity to take random, childish and useless shots at me, you would know that I answered your question the first time you asked it.

This is just a sample of what you do, Thunder, and you do it over and over. You start up a thread with a stupid viewpoint and a fatuous argument, people chop it down while providing you with a series of logical points and important questions, you ignore them by picking out one sentence of what they've taken the time to write out for you to consider, and you act offended and play victim. It really does nothing to help you whatsoever, quite the opposite.

If you want to be taken credibly, if you want an argument, your wish has been granted since page one. You've just chosen to sit there and pout instead (see avatar for proof).

So really, who's being childish? Maybe if you had thicker skin... no, I won't even go there.
 
This is just a sample of what you do, Thunder, and you do it over and over. You start up a thread with a stupid viewpoint...

supporting the right of parents to circumcise their child, is not a stupid viewpoint.
 
i see and feel no evidence that I have been harmed.

smacking a baby to make it breath, causes pain. does that mean we should not do it?

Do you deny that the baby feels pain?

And you knowledge of childbirth is severely lacking. Babies are not smacked to make them breathe. They may sometimes have been in the past, but unlike circumcision, it was a necessary action. But this has been pointed out countless times.
 
babies are unable consent. does that mean we should not bathe them?
If a person who was bathed as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to bathe anymore, he can choose not to bathe anymore. If a person who was circumcised as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to be circumcised anymore, he is **** out of luck. This is an important difference.
not clothe them?
If a person who was clothed as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to wear clothes anymore, he can choose not to wear clothes anymore. If a person who was circumcised as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to be circumcised anymore, he is **** out of luck. This is an important difference.
not teach them to walk?
If a person who was taught to walk as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to walk anymore, he can choose not to walk anymore. If a person who was circumcised as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to be circumcised anymore, he is **** out of luck. This is an important difference.
not teach them to talk?
If a person who was taught to talk as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to talk anymore, he can choose not to talk anymore. If a person who was circumcised as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to be circumcised anymore, he is **** out of luck. This is an important difference.
babies are unable to consent to life-saving medical proceduders, should we therefore not perform them?
If a person who was given a life-saving procedure as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to be alive anymore, he can choose to not be alive anymore. If a person who was circumcised as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to be circumcised anymore, he is **** out of luck. This is an important difference.
when a baby is born, it very often is not breathing. because it cannot consent, does that mean we should not smack its butt to get it to cry and therefore breath? the smack causes pain, which by your logic..is harm. therefore we have no right to smack the baby's butt?
If a person who was made to breathe as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to breathe anymore, he can choose not to breathe anymore. If a person who was circumcised as a kid grows up and decides he doesn't want to be circumcised anymore, he is **** out of luck. This is an important difference.
 
Last edited:
really. nowhere on planet Earth are newborn babies smacked on the butt to get them breathing?

that's fascinating.

Ignoring my substantive point that in the past when it was done, it was done out of necessity. You may be able to find a bush hospital in Nigeria where such an antiquated procedure is used. It still doesn't change my substantive point.
 
it is very dishonest and uncivil of you to continuously accuse me of dishonesty. you've done it probably ten times now, often with no justification.

contrary to what you appear to believe, one is not dishonest simply due to their disagreement with you.

Here we go again. Every statement of dishonesty was justified.
Please quote one which was not and I will apologise.
I have not continuously done it. I have done it where you have demonstrated dishonesty. I have done so in a civil way.
Not once have I accused you of dishonesty simply because you have disagreed with me. That in itself is dishonest of you.
 
My point that it was done out of medical necessity is not wrong.

goalposts....moved. ;)

so, we have now established that its ok to perform a medical procedure upon an infant, or a child under the age of consent, if the procedure is deemed medically necessary. such a procedure can be performed even if the child does not want it, for he/she is too young to make such decisions for himself.

now, what exact type of medical necessity are we talking about here? are we talking about just physical health..or does this include mental health?

if a doctor informs a child's parents, that a clitoral reduction procedure is necessary for a girl's emotional and mental health..should the procedure be done? of course.

now, what if a doctor tells a child's parents that it is in the child's best mental health interests, to be circumcised...just like his father and the rest of his community? is that enough of a reason to perform the procedure?

I say yes. The mental health of a person is just as important, and sometime even more important, than physical health.
 
Here we go again. Every statement of dishonesty was justified.
Please quote one which was not and I will apologise.
I have not continuously done it. I have done it where you have demonstrated dishonesty. I have done so in a civil way.
Not once have I accused you of dishonesty simply because you have disagreed with me. That in itself is dishonest of you.

This is now perhaps the 15th time you have accused me of dishonesty. Its become a trend, not followed by anyone else in the thread. I guess we are done here.
 
Last edited:
This is now perhaps the 15th time you have accused me of dishonesty. Its become a trend, not followed by anyone else in the thread. I guess we are done here.

That's because there have been that many examples of dishonesty.
You stop doing it and I'll stop doing it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom