Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Oh for crying out loud, get a life. Medical professionals come from all walks of life with the same assortment of political and philosophical views as any slice of population with similar characteristics. Have you ever seen my posts in the political forums? Goodness, half the members posting there think I am the poster child of anti-corporate militantism. Where do you get the idiotic idea the community of medical professionals are some homogeneous group?...
Where I think the bias comes from is the desire to do the “right and proper” thing, as Deetee put it earlier. Medical professionals experience a biased sample of the population, simply because they work in an environment where most of the people they see are in need of medical care. They don’t put pictures of starving Africans on the TV just to fill up air time when charities want some of your money; they really do affect peoples’ behaviour.
You are mistaking recognition of your sometimes limited knowledge based conclusions with an opinion of your personal value or intelligence. That is your failure to recognize that in some cases, your conclusions truly are based in a lack of understanding of all the issues....I’m curious why the medical professionals in this thread appear to be more or less offended by some of the non-medical professionals not applying a hard accept/reject strategy with respect to the recommendations they (or the specialist expert groups they form) provide. Are medical professionals the only people allowed or qualified to use Bayesian reasoning? In my line of work (which involves quite a bit of signal processing), more often than not better results are obtained by delaying thresholding decisions for as long as possible in the signal chain, and using as much information over as much time as can be afforded. If there is very little time to reach a decision, the decision is made on the most significant piece of information available.
Think about it Ivor. You have been told that your opinions are valid, you are intelligent, you have some interesting ideas. But then when it comes to you drawing a conclusion because you truly lack a broader understanding of a particular issue, you refuse to accept that may be the actual reason and instead you chose to believe it is that your ideas are being discounted for arbitrary reasons.
Well, sometimes it is a values difference. I have been clear that is the case in some of your choices re dollars spent per life saved vs my choice of ease in saving that life. (Others may have different value differences between me you and them.) But there are other times, in particular your lack of understanding about the difference between zoster morbidity and mortality and primary varicella morbidity and mortality, where your lack of medical knowledge and not as you believe a difference in values or some discounting of the evidence you have presented that accounts for the different opinion between you and I....In the case of medical decisions, additional factors are the various value judgements, which typically result in deciding if the perceived benefit to one group is “worth” the inevitable reduction of treatment of another (given a fixed amount of resources).
Given these factors, I give each a weight and apply a hard threshold to come to a decision, which you are all well aware of so I will not bore you with it again, except to say the largest single weighting I give is to expert evidence-based medical recommendations, the next largest probably being my personal values with regards to how finite resources should be distributed. I think it is this latter input which I am out of step with most of the other posters in this thread (and probably the rest of the world).
So that’s my long, boring description of how I think I and others come to our decisions and why they are sometimes different, even when provided with the same evidence.