autism-vaccine link?

...

Where I think the bias comes from is the desire to do the “right and proper” thing, as Deetee put it earlier. Medical professionals experience a biased sample of the population, simply because they work in an environment where most of the people they see are in need of medical care. They don’t put pictures of starving Africans on the TV just to fill up air time when charities want some of your money; they really do affect peoples’ behaviour.
Oh for crying out loud, get a life. Medical professionals come from all walks of life with the same assortment of political and philosophical views as any slice of population with similar characteristics. Have you ever seen my posts in the political forums? Goodness, half the members posting there think I am the poster child of anti-corporate militantism. Where do you get the idiotic idea the community of medical professionals are some homogeneous group?

...I’m curious why the medical professionals in this thread appear to be more or less offended by some of the non-medical professionals not applying a hard accept/reject strategy with respect to the recommendations they (or the specialist expert groups they form) provide. Are medical professionals the only people allowed or qualified to use Bayesian reasoning? In my line of work (which involves quite a bit of signal processing), more often than not better results are obtained by delaying thresholding decisions for as long as possible in the signal chain, and using as much information over as much time as can be afforded. If there is very little time to reach a decision, the decision is made on the most significant piece of information available.
You are mistaking recognition of your sometimes limited knowledge based conclusions with an opinion of your personal value or intelligence. That is your failure to recognize that in some cases, your conclusions truly are based in a lack of understanding of all the issues.

Think about it Ivor. You have been told that your opinions are valid, you are intelligent, you have some interesting ideas. But then when it comes to you drawing a conclusion because you truly lack a broader understanding of a particular issue, you refuse to accept that may be the actual reason and instead you chose to believe it is that your ideas are being discounted for arbitrary reasons.

...In the case of medical decisions, additional factors are the various value judgements, which typically result in deciding if the perceived benefit to one group is “worth” the inevitable reduction of treatment of another (given a fixed amount of resources).

Given these factors, I give each a weight and apply a hard threshold to come to a decision, which you are all well aware of so I will not bore you with it again, except to say the largest single weighting I give is to expert evidence-based medical recommendations, the next largest probably being my personal values with regards to how finite resources should be distributed. I think it is this latter input which I am out of step with most of the other posters in this thread (and probably the rest of the world:)).

So that’s my long, boring description of how I think I and others come to our decisions and why they are sometimes different, even when provided with the same evidence.
Well, sometimes it is a values difference. I have been clear that is the case in some of your choices re dollars spent per life saved vs my choice of ease in saving that life. (Others may have different value differences between me you and them.) But there are other times, in particular your lack of understanding about the difference between zoster morbidity and mortality and primary varicella morbidity and mortality, where your lack of medical knowledge and not as you believe a difference in values or some discounting of the evidence you have presented that accounts for the different opinion between you and I.
 
Still, you don't answer the question. Do you actually have a superior strategy to studying the information available and making up your own mind when you don't feel you can trust the experts? I am beginning to think not. At least, not one you have sufficient confidence in to put up for public scrutiny.

I do think it is a worthwhile area for discussion. I've brought it up in other threads and even started a thread that is related to this subject. But I don't think I said I had a strategy for when I don't feel I can trust the experts, but rather when I don't feel I have expertise. In that case, I do make use of experts - those people you do not trust.

That's a rate of 0.0005 in the vaccinated population compared to a rate of .0002 in the unvaccinated population - an increase of approximately 150%. However, the rates are so low that large sample sizes are required to determine if the increase is statistically significant at the 0.05 level. It wasn't enough to say definitely that the vaccine was the cause, but it was enough to decide that further research was appropriate in order to make the determination with a high level of confidence.

BTW, I didn't catch the base population rate earlier. A quick computation gives an p-value of 0.0693 for 5 out of 10054 with a probability of 1 in 4633. While not significant at the 0.05 level, it would have been quite appropriate to take this result as an indicating that further investigation is needed.

Is it reasonable to use 1 in 4633 as a standard when it is really an estimated parameter? Wouldn't it be more appropriate to perform a comparison of the two values?

The p-values in the article were quoted as p=0.92 and p=0.45. I realize the details aren't given, but (if possible) can you explain what about the analysis that they did you consider wrong?

I'm sorry about the confusing terminology. But the answer is not necessarily. Multiple experiments (which can consist of many experimental units - in this case an experimental unit would be a person who was vaccinated) can provide superior discrimination over a single experiment with more units. Consider the Million $ challenge. The prelim and the final test can both have a p-value of 0.001 because when multiplied together, they give a probability of 0.000001.

I know it seems contrary to intuition at first, but it's major reason why an iterated approach to experimentation with relatively small numbers of experimental units in each iteration is a much better approach than a single large experiment. You can actually gain more information from fewer experimental units with this sort of approach.

You might try thinking of it this way: if the original result was due to chance, then the another experiment is very unlikely to produce the same effect. On the other hand, if it isn't due to chance, the probability of seeing increased rates in the vaccine population is high.

I was thinking that a repetition of p=0.45 wouldn't get you to p=0.05.

An increase of 150% is NOT a similar rate. It wasn't a statistically significant increase because when you have such low rates it is extremely difficult to reject the null of no difference. Recall that the probability of a type II error (which is what happened in this case) is unrelated to the stated confidence level and can be much much higher.

On the other hand, an increase of 0.03% seems like hardly any difference at all. With such small numbers, and with the p-values that they were using for guidance, it would be hard to justify any other measure than the one they recommended.

Do they keep track of those factors because they are a possible consequence of the vaccine? :)

Intussusception wouldn't be considered a possible consequence of the vaccine, either.

Do you disagree with any of the current recommendations of the ACIP? I asked first.

Of course - get 5 physicians in a room and you'll hear 8 dissenting opinions.

No, no, no. You're taking offense at something inferred that was not meant to be implied. Such a strategy is usually skeptigirl's baliwick not yours.

I'm sorry - I should have used a smiley. I wasn't' offended at all. I thought my statement was sufficiently over the top.

I have never said you were anything but biased. We are all biased, including me. I've explicitly said, more than once, that doesn't imply incompetence. It certainly doesn't imply stupidity. Why are you taking offense now? This comes across to me as yet another ploy to avoid answering my question regarding your personal opinion. The best defense is a good offense?

You have dismissed over and over and over again the possibility that experts provide any oversight to the ACIP. In order to support this claim (which on the face appears ridiculous to anyone who is familiar with what opinionated jerks doctors are) there must be something preventing us from doing so. What is it? Bias alone won't do it unless we all have the exact same biases.

You're wrong about that. I would be quite satisfied if I felt the committee was composed of relatively few biased individuals or had a reasonable distribution of various different biases represented, thus achieving something like balance. It is the law. Is it really asking too much for a national policy setting committee to abide by the laws and regulations that govern it? I don't think so, but if it is, then the laws and regulations should be changed not ignored. It's been 8 years. What has changed? Anything?

The reason I think you're being disingenuous in your claim that you would be satisfied is because you have no idea whether your complaints are valid, but you are willing to act as though they are, you already dismissed the possibility that balance could counteract bias when you said that the biases you presume (without evidence) are present in two of the members serves to poison the entire committee and by extension the entire physician and healthcare worker community, and you have consistently grossly exaggerated and even misrepresented the potential for conflict of interest that was present at the time you did your investigation (for example, your statements that 100% of the committee members have financial ties to vaccine manufacturers or that hundreds of thousands of dollars of stock were involved - statements that are both untrue). I think you think that you are being sincere, but I'm not going to ignore the signs that are staring me in the face.

Because we're having a friendly conversation. Because I've answered your questions to the best of my ability. Because I asked politely. Because it's relevant to the conversation. Why do you keep refusing? It can't take more time or effort to answer the question than it does to keep evading it.

It seems to me that it should have been pretty clear that I was referring to the effort to make changes in the process, since the sentence you quote immediately follows (within the same paragraph) the one where I talk about making changes in the process. I'm not sure why you decided I was talking about whether it was worth the effort for me to talk to you, but I assure you that I wasn't.

Linda
 
Last edited:
I do think it is a worthwhile area for discussion. I've brought it up in other threads and even started a thread that is related to this subject. But I don't think I said I had a strategy for when I don't feel I can trust the experts, but rather when I don't feel I have expertise. In that case, I do make use of experts - those people you do not trust.
Then, when you claimed to have a superior strategy, you were basicallly talking about just trusting in what the experts advise you to do. Okay. I agree, when I feel I can trust in the experts, I am quite happy to take their advice. Thanks for answering the question.

Incidentally, one way to describe my strategy, which is to accept vaccines that have been in use for many years and reject newly approved ones until potential problems have been identified and corrected, is basically a strategy that tries to compensate for the bias I feel is inherent in the committee decisions rather than a total rejection of their advice.

Is it reasonable to use 1 in 4633 as a standard when it is really an estimated parameter? Wouldn't it be more appropriate to perform a comparison of the two values?
It would, but without the sample size of the placebo group, that's not a comparison I can make.
The p-values in the article were quoted as p=0.92 and p=0.45. I realize the details aren't given, but (if possible) can you explain what about the analysis that they did you consider wrong?
You'd have to link to the article you're referring to because I can't find those numbers in the report I linked to. Without seeing the numbers in context, I can't explain anything about them.

I was thinking that a repetition of p=0.45 wouldn't get you to p=0.05.
True

On the other hand, an increase of 0.03% seems like hardly any difference at all. With such small numbers, and with the p-values that they were using for guidance, it would be hard to justify any other measure than the one they recommended.
We’ll just have to disagree on that point. I think that a committee without bias and without voting members who were vested in getting the vaccine approved, the decision might well have been different. I see it as a clear example of the effect of bias on the committees decisions.
Intussusception wouldn't be considered a possible consequence of the vaccine, either.
And yet, apparently it is. Go figure. I guess that why it’s so important to do tests and then pay attention to the results. You can learn about stuff you wouldn’t have suspected previously.
Of course - get 5 physicians in a room and you'll hear 8 dissenting opinions.
Then why are you so reluctant to discuss your personal opinion here?
You have dismissed over and over and over again the possibility that experts provide any oversight to the ACIP.
Excuse me – what oversight are you talking about? You said " the thousands of other physicians and health-care workers or their employers who also review research on vaccines, in order to form their own opinions, who have not received funding from any pharmaceutical company." Who are these thousands of people who are investing the time and effort necessary to provide this oversight? How does it work? In addition, there are health-care workers who dispute the recommendations and advise their patients against vaccines. They are typically derided as anti-vaxers and dismissed. So, what oversight are you talking about here?
In order to support this claim (which on the face appears ridiculous to anyone who is familiar with what opinionated jerks doctors are) there must be something preventing us from doing so. What is it? Bias alone won't do it unless we all have the exact same biases.
Tell you what, you explain to me who has oversight over the committee and how they function to exercise that oversight and correct what they feel are poor decisions and I’ll buy into your claim that the oversight actually exists.

The reason I think you're being disingenuous in your claim that you would be satisfied is because you have no idea whether your complaints are valid, but you are willing to act as though they are
Yes, I prefer to err on the side of caution with my children’s health. When the risk of the disease is small, the unknown risks of vaccines takes precedence in my opinion.
you already dismissed the possibility that balance could counteract bias when you said that the biases you presume (without evidence) are present in two of the members serves to poison the entire committee and by extension the entire physician and healthcare worker community, and you have consistently grossly exaggerated and even misrepresented the potential for conflict of interest that was present at the time you did your investigation (for example, your statements that 100% of the committee members have financial ties to vaccine manufacturers or that hundreds of thousands of dollars of stock were involved - statements that are both untrue). I think you think that you are being sincere, but I'm not going to ignore the signs that are staring me in the face.
Hmmm….the report I linked to stated that 100% of all committee members had conflicts of interest statements filed. So that wasn’t an exaggeration. And I did not claim they had “hundreds of thousands of dollars of stock were involved” I said something like tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in stocks, consulting contracts and research funding. I was working from memory when I posted that, but I have shown it to be true. Dr. Edwards had received hundreds of thousands of dollars in research funding. I may not have been as clear in my wording as I could have been, but your accusation of insincerity seems as inappropriate as the ignoring of the serious conflicts of interest that have been shown to exist.

My concerns about such conflicts of interests were validated by a government investigation of the committee practices about a year after I did my own research. They also found such conflicts of interest to be a significant concern. Why do you dismiss it as unimportant. Doesn’t it bother you at all? Does it bother you that such conflicts lead to distrust and rejection of the committee's recommendations?

It seems to me that it should have been pretty clear that I was referring to the effort to make changes in the process, since the sentence you quote immediately follows (within the same paragraph) the one where I talk about making changes in the process. I'm not sure why you decided I was talking about whether it was worth the effort for me to talk to you, but I assure you that I wasn't.

Linda

Thanks for the clarification about what you were referring to. I notice, however, that you haven’t addressed what I said last time.

Is it really asking too much for a national policy setting committee to abide by the laws and regulations that govern it? I don't think so, but if it is, then the laws and regulations should be changed not ignored. It's been 8 years. What has changed? Anything?
 
Last edited:
Hmmm….the report I linked to stated that 100% of all committee members had conflicts of interest statements filed. So that wasn’t an exaggeration. And I did not claim they had “hundreds of thousands of dollars of stock were involved” I said something like tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in stocks, consulting contracts and research funding. I was working from memory when I posted that, but I have shown it to be true. Dr. Edwards had received hundreds of thousands of dollars in research funding. I may not have been as clear in my wording as I could have been, but your accusation of insincerity seems as inappropriate as the ignoring of the serious conflicts of interest that have been shown to exist.
Beth, I am still bemused that you feel any financial link to be sufficient to be (a) A source of potential conflict of interest and (b) serious enough for you to distrust the individual concerned and any recommendation they might make when acting in their capacity as experts on panels such as the ACIP.

It has been pointed out to you what these "financial ties" consist of in the majority of cases - things like honoraria for symposium attendance and so on. You seem now to agree this does not amount to a significant conflict of interest - fine. Having shares in a drug company is unlikely to be of any significant influence, even when the stock holding seems to be quite a lot of money, as I have pointed out. So we are left with research grant funding from or via drug companies, which is again hardly unusual to find for someone who is an active researcher in the vaccine field. The majority of research funding comes from these sources. Since none of this money is for the personal use or benefit of the researcher, how can this be such a serious issue? At best all this can do is boost their "street cred" and show their employers that they can attract appreciable grant funding and therefore are worth having around by improving their institution's research ranking.

I have to ask, who would you have on these committees before you feel that you could trust their advice? If you rule out the medical experts and eminent researchers in that specific field of study (these are the ones who get to attend symposia and who can attract grant money for research studies) all you are left with is a bunch of insignificant, inexperienced also-rans, who may be completely free from any potential conflict of interest but who will know next to nothing about the medical field they are being asked to advise upon.

I know whose advice I would prefer to rely on.
 
<snip>

Bias alone won't do it unless we all have the exact same biases.

<snip>

Linda

You do share many of the same biases and you club together when you perceive an outside threat. All individuals who are members of a group do.

ETA: How often do you see one doctor criticizing another in public? Most professional organizations would consider this sort of behaviour as "bringing the profession into disrepute".
 
Last edited:
Then, when you claimed to have a superior strategy, you were basicallly talking about just trusting in what the experts advise you to do. Okay. I agree, when I feel I can trust in the experts, I am quite happy to take their advice. Thanks for answering the question.

I didn't say that I trust in what the experts advise. I said that I make use of experts. For example, if I don't trust what the ACIP recommends, I make use of other experts in the field.

It would, but without the sample size of the placebo group, that's not a comparison I can make.

It was my understanding that 4633 was the size of the placebo group.

You'd have to link to the article you're referring to because I can't find those numbers in the report I linked to. Without seeing the numbers in context, I can't explain anything about them.

I provided the link when I first quoted the article, but here it is again.

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00056669.htm

But now I'm curious. You were willing to use those numbers just now to say that the conclusions of the committee were unreasonable, yet you base this on an analysis and interpretation which you admit you undertook without adequate information or understanding.

We’ll just have to disagree on that point. I think that a committee without bias and without voting members who were vested in getting the vaccine approved, the decision might well have been different. I see it as a clear example of the effect of bias on the committees decisions.

Yet you provide no objective support for your opinion, while the committee conclusions were what would be expected from making a cautious, but objective evaluation of the available information.

And yet, apparently it is. Go figure. I guess that why it’s so important to do tests and then pay attention to the results. You can learn about stuff you wouldn’t have suspected previously.

Which is exactly what the committee did.

Then why are you so reluctant to discuss your personal opinion here?

Come on. Is whether I'd recommend the first dose of MMR at 12 months and the second at 18 months really of any interest?

Excuse me – what oversight are you talking about? You said " the thousands of other physicians and health-care workers or their employers who also review research on vaccines, in order to form their own opinions, who have not received funding from any pharmaceutical company." Who are these thousands of people who are investing the time and effort necessary to provide this oversight?

People who are doing their job.

How does it work?

They perform research, they write review articles, they write editorials in medical journals, they make recommendations to relevant institutions/organizations, they give presentations at conferences, they whine and complain and argue, they advise their patients, they participate in congressional hearings and legal proceedings, etc.

In addition, there are health-care workers who dispute the recommendations and advise their patients against vaccines.

If someone is advising their patients not to take vaccines (I assume you mean all vaccines rather than individual vaccines?), then they are allowing their biases to over-ride their responsibility to their patients. Should we not be concerned about that?

They are typically derided as anti-vaxers and dismissed. So, what oversight are you talking about here?

Tell you what, you explain to me who has oversight over the committee and how they function to exercise that oversight and correct what they feel are poor decisions and I’ll buy into your claim that the oversight actually exists.

Surprise me, then.

Hmmm….the report I linked to stated that 100% of all committee members had conflicts of interest statements filed. So that wasn’t an exaggeration.

Filing a conflict of interest statement is not the same as having a financial tie to a vaccine producer (it includes any sources of potential conflict as well as ties that are trivial or indirect).

And I did not claim they had “hundreds of thousands of dollars of stock were involved” I said something like tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in stocks, consulting contracts and research funding.

You're right. The quote I saw was truncated after stocks.

I was working from memory when I posted that, but I have shown it to be true. Dr. Edwards had received hundreds of thousands of dollars in research funding. I may not have been as clear in my wording as I could have been, but your accusation of insincerity seems as inappropriate as the ignoring of the serious conflicts of interest that have been shown to exist.

Except that I never stated that I was ignoring the serious conflicts of interest.

My concerns about such conflicts of interests were validated by a government investigation of the committee practices about a year after I did my own research. They also found such conflicts of interest to be a significant concern. Why do you dismiss it as unimportant. Doesn’t it bother you at all? Does it bother you that such conflicts lead to distrust and rejection of the committee's recommendations?

I've never dismissed it as unimportant.

Thanks for the clarification about what you were referring to. I notice, however, that you haven’t addressed what I said last time.

Is it really asking too much for a national policy setting committee to abide by the laws and regulations that govern it? I don't think so, but if it is, then the laws and regulations should be changed not ignored. It's been 8 years. What has changed? Anything?

The question I am interested in is whether or not the ACIP makes reasonable recommendations - if it serves its intended purpose. I am also interested in whether it abides by the laws and regulations that govern it, but I don't really trust regulations to ensure that a particular outcome is reached. That is, I don't lose trust in the ACIP if I lose trust in the process, because I don't necessarily trust the process to begin with. My trust (as it were) depends upon the results.

Now you claim that people, such as yourself, would trust the process if it strictly followed specific laws/regulations/guidelines. And I'm willing to buy that. What I'm not sure about is what proportion of people who choose not to vaccinate their children do so because they have knowledge of the degree to which the process strictly follows these laws and find them wanting, as opposed to people who assume this is the case, depend upon information intended to mislead, or have reasons unrelated to the process. I'm not convinced that the proportion of people that actually know how well the laws are followed now and choose not to trust the results is anything but tiny. Which means that making a big effort to reform the process wouldn't make much impact, if any, on vaccination rates, while other measures could make a greater impact. For example, reform would have no influence on whether or not you trust the ACIP, since it doesn't look like you would discover it had taken place and you would continue to act on your pre-conceived ideas.

Linda
 
You do share many of the same biases and you club together when you perceive an outside threat. All individuals who are members of a group do.

ETA: How often do you see one doctor criticizing another in public? Most professional organizations would consider this sort of behaviour as "bringing the profession into disrepute".
The people who "club together" do so when there is a commonality of purpose. Being members of a widely disparate medical profession is no indication of this. God forbid, I have even been known to have commonality of purpose with people outside the medical profession.;)

Doctors are often extremely critical of each other. They sometimes do what you see on "House", but only behind closed doors, since to do so in public would have immediate medico-legal repercussions. I have been very critical of doctors (remember skeptidoc?) and medical woo homeopaths and CAM merchants. Publicly I have engaged and criticised medically-qualified HIV denialists and antivaccinationists in outlets such as the electronic BMJ and other journals (but one must always be careful not to overstep thresholds for libel). It always helps to criticise their opinions and conclusions rather than spray around ad homs....
 
Last edited:
While this has been an interesting conversation, I can no longer participate. I broke my index finger and typing is now a slow and difficult process. So I'll just be lurking for the next 6 weeks.
 
While this has been an interesting conversation, I can no longer participate. I broke my index finger and typing is now a slow and difficult process. So I'll just be lurking for the next 6 weeks.

At first I read your post as "...I broke my index finger typing...". My immediate thought was "I know conversing on the forum can be frustrating at times, but isn't typing so hard you snap a finger a bit over the top?":D

Hope it heals soon.;)
 
You do share many of the same biases and you club together when you perceive an outside threat. All individuals who are members of a group do.

ETA: How often do you see one doctor criticizing another in public? Most professional organizations would consider this sort of behaviour as "bringing the profession into disrepute".
Care to define the parameters of this "club"?

And as for reluctance to criticize individuals, you'll find quite the opposite when it comes to criticizing the group or research findings. And you are talking about criticizing someone's practice decision. Do you think peer review of medical research is that ineffective? If so, you need to look again.
 
While this has been an interesting conversation, I can no longer participate. I broke my index finger and typing is now a slow and difficult process. So I'll just be lurking for the next 6 weeks.
Sorry to hear that. Take care.
 
The zoster vaccine is a different vaccine. You are aware of that I hope.
Out of interest, how is it different specifically? It is the same attenuated varicella virus surely? According to this website the shingles vaccine is the same as the chickenpox vaccine.
 
The people who "club together" do so when there is a commonality of purpose. Being members of a widely disparate medical profession is no indication of this. God forbid, I have even been known to have commonality of purpose with people outside the medical profession.;)

Yes, individuals can belong to more than one group, and there can be overlapping sub-groups within larger groups.

Doctors are often extremely critical of each other. They sometimes do what you see on "House", but only behind closed doors, since to do so in public would have immediate medico-legal repercussions.

Hey, you ought to see an electronic engineer looking over another engineer's code or circuit diagram.

I have been very critical of doctors (remember skeptidoc?) and medical woo homeopaths and CAM merchants. Publicly I have engaged and criticised medically-qualified HIV denialists and antivaccinationists in outlets such as the electronic BMJ and other journals (but one must always be careful not to overstep thresholds for libel). It always helps to criticise their opinions and conclusions rather than spray around ad homs....

That's why I like you.:) I agree ad homs should be avoided (unless they're funny).

I think there is a difference between criticising those who hold fringe views such as HIV denialists and believers in CAM, and those who hold more mainstream (but still questionable) views. The former are seen as traitors by the group and are often criticised more harshly than members of out-groups.

Would I be correct in thinking there is still quite a strict hierarchy / pecking order in medicine?
 
While this has been an interesting conversation, I can no longer participate. I broke my index finger and typing is now a slow and difficult process. So I'll just be lurking for the next 6 weeks.

Well, that sucks.

Linda
 
Out of interest, how is it different specifically? It is the same attenuated varicella virus surely? According to this website the shingles vaccine is the same as the chickenpox vaccine.
The dose is hugely different.

And while that may seem irrelevant, the studies and use of the vaccine are not 100% comparable.
 
Care to define the parameters of this "club"?

I haven't studied it in depth, but one obvious parameter would be a set of shared values.

And as for reluctance to criticize individuals, you'll find quite the opposite when it comes to criticizing the group or research findings. And you are talking about criticizing someone's practice decision. Do you think peer review of medical research is that ineffective? If so, you need to look again.

A group has both formal and informal regulatory mechanisms to maintain order, cohesion and status of members within it.

From Social Psychology 4th ed. Michael A Hogg. Graham M. Vaughan p 309:

Many, if not most, groups are also structured in terms of two kinds of members:

1) Those who best embody the group's attributes - core members who are highly prototypical of the group.

2) Those who do not - marginal or non-prototypical members.

Highly prototypical members often have significant influence over the group and may occupy leadership roles. Marginal members are an entirely different story.

Research by Marques and his colleagues shows that marginal members are often disliked by the group, and treated as 'black sheep' (Marques & Paez, 1994) or deviants. People whose attributes place them on the boundary between ingroup and outgroup are actually disliked more if they are ingroup members than outgroup members - they are treated as deviants or even traitors. One reason for this is that they threaten the integrity of group norms by undermining normative consensus within the group (e.g. Marques, Abrams, & Serodio, 2001). Paradoxically, for this very reason, marginal members serve an important function for groups - groups, particularly their leaders, can engage in a rhetoric of vilification and exclusion of marginal members precisely to throw into stark relief what the group is and what the group is not.
 
It may have already been mentioned, but the ACIP is now recommending all 60+ year-olds get the varicella zoster vaccine.

ETA: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/564920

ETA2: The dose in the Zoster version is x18 the Varicella version
I am appalled!
They want to pump these dear old biddies, many of whom are sitting ducks for Alzheimers, with 18 X the dose of evil toxins, antifreeze and aluminium (sorry, aluminum) that they would give to younger healthy humans? This is nothing but legalised euthanasia.
;)
 
Last edited:
Ivor, I didn't need a definition of a "club". I needed your definition of who you were including in the imagined conspiracy you expressed in the following sentence, "You do share many of the same biases and you club together when you perceive an outside threat"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom