autism-vaccine link?

I found this site http://weeksmd.com/?page_id=402 via a search so I can't vouch for it, but it claims the report that it reproduces was government issued. It's dated June 15, 2000 and the information matches what I found when I was investigating back in 98 and 99.


I don't know how much conflict of interest exists on it today, but this is what I was finding when I investigated and got soured on following their recommendations. As far as the science speaking for itself, I addressed that earlier. Science has no voice.
Why am I not surprised to find this stuff completely exaggerated and taken out of context on the anti-vaxer web sites. Unbelievable.

First off, the report is 8 years old. The whole point of the investigation would have been to make corrections. I see no where there is any ongoing concerns.

Second, as I said this is incredibly overstated by the anti-vaxers.

CDC Advisory Committee members who are not allowed to vote on certain recommendations due to financial conflicts of interest are allowed to participate in committee deliberations and advocate specific positions.
Yeah, gee, the vaccine manufacturers are actually allowed to provide input on their products and research. Who else should present that information? It isn't like it is the only information the committee gets.

The Chairman of the CDC’s advisory committee until very recently owned 600 shares of stock in Merck, a pharmaceutical company with an active vaccine division.
This is the worst they found in this Congressional investigation? :rolleyes:

The current price of Merck shares is just under $42/share. Times 600 shares that is a whopping $25,200. I have that much in my savings account it is nothing for a upper middle income person to have that much. Can you imagine risking losing your 6 figure job over a $25K investment? This is a level of conflict of interest to worry about? I don't think so.

Sorry Beth, I'm not impressed and now I remember why I dismissed this stuff before. It's fine they had an investigation. It's fine they found some issues that needed correction and that the rules were a bit too lax. I would think after 8 years some corrective action was taken. This was hardly earthshaking in the first place.
 
When the ACIP are wrong they just recommend a second dose.

:duck:
OK Ivor. I'm calling this one an ignorant statement. I hope the tomato is an indication you are joking.

All vaccines are initially released with an unknown need for booster doses. How are you supposed to know if boosters will be needed 10 or 20 years out until 10 or 20 years goes by?
 
Compared to what?

What conditions are you prepared to *not* have treated so VZV can be eradicated?

You want the latest drugs for Breast Cancer, Parkinson's disease or Alzheimer's? Sorry, can't afford them. We spent the budget on chickenpox so Tarquin and Jemima's Mummy and Daddy can be good little worker bees and don't have to take a week or two off work to look after their kids.:D
How much money does your NHI put into the research on these conditions? Are you trying to compare allocation of treatment dollars as a lost opportunity for allocation of research dollars? Or are you saying the Brits are paying for vaccines while forgoing proven drugs for other ailments?
 
Last edited:
.....
I’m frequently wrong, but I seem to spend most of my discussions with you correcting your misinterpretations and inferences regarding what I’m trying to communicate. I rarely get to reconsider my actual opinions as you almost never discuss them, preferring to take offense at inferred insults......

As far as being ‘duped’ by drug companies, I did not say that nor do I think that. Bias is not synonymous with being duped. This is an example of you taking offense at something you've inferred from what I've said.
These are not mutually exclusive terms. I think both are true.
I said they were biased. I didn't say they were incompetent. Bias does NOT imply incompentence.
No cognitive dissonance at all for me. I think that I might draw the same conclusions they have if I had the same biases and background. I don’t think people are incompetent just because they have come to a different conclusion that I have. That particular belief is yours, not mine.
I have my own personal background, which is, of course, different that anyone else’s. I’m spent a reasonable amount of time for a lay person to study the issues. I’m entitled to develop my own opinion based on that. I’m more than willing to allow you yours. Why do you assail all those who hold different opinions on the matter?
You are not quite understanding what I am saying here. I am not personally offended in the least nor do I think you are saying any of us are duped.

But I am saying you cannot have it both ways. I've been trying to address the public misconceptions and invalid conclusions in a broader way than just what one person says. So my comments are in more general terms.

If one (not you) believes in the big pharma conspiracy or some version of it then in order for such a conspiracy to go undetected by the medical and scientific communities, one has to believe that medical and scientific communities are oblivious to the conspiracy. Otherwise, why would the conspiracy believer know about it but the medical and scientific communities not know about it? And if the medical and scientific communities are oblivious to the big pharma conspiracy then they have to be either fooled by big pharma or ignoring the research and just taking big pharma's word for it.

The problem with this is that would have to include thousands and thousands of people in those medical and scientific communities. Yet you (in this case you, Beth) saw the conflict of information noted in the Congressional hearings on the matter. Do you think the entire medical and scientific communities didn't notice and you did? Or do you think the entire medical and scientific communities just don't believe there is a risk of bias? And do you think out of everyone in the entire medical and scientific communities, none of them evaluated the evidence to check on the recommendations of the ACIP? Whether you think I am biased or not, do you think the entire medical and scientific communities are all biased. Not a single one of them is objective but you had no trouble being objective?

If anyone in the medical and scientific communities did notice the supposed conflict of interest and/or found disagreement with the recommendations based on independent review of the decisions, don't you think they would be speaking up? Do you think there is no one like me who happens to be in the specialty affected by vaccine recommendations who might have reviewed those decisions and spoken up if there was a problem?

Even I look for corroborating evidence of my conclusions. I would never think that I could review everything and get it right every time. Have you found anyone with substantial credibility that confers with your concerns there is a problem with the ACIP recommendations? Is there anyone in the medical and scientific communities who have said, look we found this conflict of interest and here is the bad recommendation that we think resulted from it?

It just isn't logical, Beth, that no one would have noticed, no one would have spoken up. So either there is a big pharma conspiracy and the medical and scientific communities are oblivious to it, or there is not a conspiracy and the medical and scientific communities are providing that oversight you think isn't being provided.
 
Last edited:
How much money does your NHI put into the research on these conditions? Are you trying to compare allocation of treatment dollars as a lost opportunity for allocation of research dollars? Or are you saying the Brits are paying for vaccines while forgoing proven drugs for other ailments?

Each year a budget is set for the NHS and Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) are supposed to stick to it. With this fixed amount of money, priorities have to be set. In general (and quite correctly IMO) these favour people who actually need medical care rather than those who would like medical care to make their lives more pleasant or convenient.
 
OK Ivor. I'm calling this one an ignorant statement. I hope the tomato is an indication you are joking.

All vaccines are initially released with an unknown need for booster doses. How are you supposed to know if boosters will be needed 10 or 20 years out until 10 or 20 years goes by?

Yes, it was a joke. As was my comment about Linda accepting bribes, BTW.
 
How much money does your NHI put into the research on these conditions? Are you trying to compare allocation of treatment dollars as a lost opportunity for allocation of research dollars? Or are you saying the Brits are paying for vaccines while forgoing proven drugs for other ailments?

There are certain areas of the health service in the UK which I believe to be woefully underfunded. Mental health for example. Access to psychological therapies is very low. If you are referred for treatment by mental heath services, in my experience, you can expect a very long wait, unless you are extemely ill and need an emergency referral. And of course sitting around waiting for that routine referral means a lot more people get into the position of becoming more severely ill that they need an emergency referral. There have also been controversies in recent years surrounding the circumstances in which you can get certain drugs for breast cancer and alzheimer's disease. So I can understand where Ivor is coming from on this issue - though I don't always agree that he is interpreting all of the data correctly. Perhaps it is a difference of perspective due to our different types of health service.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/global/main.jhtml?xml=/global/2006/06/21/he4alzheimer.xml
 
Last edited:
Mental health is underfunded everywhere. I fail to see how not using varicella vaccine will result in more dollars (pounds) used for mental health. If I were to evaluate the choice between mental health and varicella vaccine I'd need more data.

I'll say it again lest anyone has forgotten my position, if you want to evaluate varicella vaccine in the bigger picture and list lives saved per dollars spent and nothing was less efficient, then fine, pay for something else instead. I'm pretty sure you'd find a few other things to trade in first if you want to just measure bang for the buck.
 
Last edited:
Beth said:
I never admitted I don't have a better one. I think I have a far better approach than yours.

Okay. Why then when I asked your opinion as to what a better approach would be did you say

I don't know that I can help you?

Because you've already made it clear that the way I go about it wouldn't be useful to you.

Like I said, my advice will not be interest to you, then.

Like I said, it wouldn’t be advice for me as my kids are past the age where it is a consideration. It would, however, be of interest to me. Why are you being so coy about it?

I'm not being coy. I don't want to waste your time (and mine, for that matter).

I dunno. Don't you think that there will be just as many complaints (if not more) when anyone who has attended an educational conference, anyone who has done research on a vaccine, or anyone who has a position at an academic institution is excluded? Wouldn't they then be open to the criticism that they are lacking the experience which would give them the skills to make these decisions?

If you think that any of those things would require the person to disclose the activity in a conflict of interest statement, then I am grossly misunderstanding the requirements for that conflict of interest waiver. My understanding it is to disclose personal financial ties only, so such activities should not require a conflict of interest waiver to serve on the committee. Is that a mistaken impression? I don't recall seeing the activities you've mentioned listed on such forms and I have looked at them in the past.

eta: research was mentioned, but only research that was funded by manufacturers whose vaccines will be evaluated by the committee.

From that link you provided earlier, the conflicts listed included any research funding (some in amounts that were trivial) from a pharmaceutical company to the employers of the committee members (you'd be hard-pressed to find a university which has never participated in pharmaceutical research) (the committee members were not involved in that research at their institution), any research on vaccines regardless of the source of funding (since this included funding from the NIAID (a governmental source)), any funding from a pharmaceutical company that produces any vaccines (which takes care of the major manufacturers) regardless of amount or whether it was related to research on vaccines, and trivial honoraria for attendance at conferences (unspecified funding source). If the trivial and/or indirect financial benefit listed above is to be excluded, then you will end up excluding those people I mentioned earlier.

Why? It will only reflect my personal biases.
Linda
I am puzzled by your reluctance to give your opinion when you claim to have studied this area in depth. We all have personal biases. You’ve aroused my curiosity. What are your personal biases that you are so reluctant to display? Or is that you do not have any differences of opinion with the official recommendations – which would imply that my original assumption was correct despite your not having stated so previously?

You've just spent the last six pages explaining why my (and others') opinions are no more useful to you than those of the guy on the corner. You don't need to pretend to an interest in order to be polite. It doesn't hurt my feelings (honest). :)

Besides, I checked my schedule and this week I'm supposed to be hawking anti-depressants on the forum, so there's nothing in it for me.

Linda
 
Last edited:
fls said:
<snip>

You've just spent the last six pages explaining why my (and others') opinions are no more useful to you than those of the guy on the corner. You don't need to pretend to an interest in order to be polite. It doesn't hurt my feelings (honest).

Are you running for political office Linda? Never have I seen a more evasive set of answers to a straightforward question. Would it not be a good thing for us to know your biases? I'm reminded of our former Prime Minister refusing to say if his son had received the MMR vaccination at the height of the Vaccine/Autism scare.

ETA: Nice to know it isn't just me who she plays this game with.:)

Mental health is underfunded everywhere. I fail to see how not using varicella vaccine will result in more dollars (pounds) used for mental health. If I were to evaluate the choice between mental health and varicella vaccine I'd need more data.

I'll say it again lest anyone has forgotten my position, if you want to evaluate varicella vaccine in the bigger picture and list lives saved per dollars spent and nothing was less efficient, then fine, pay for something else instead. I'm pretty sure you'd find a few other things to trade in first if you want to just measure bang for the buck.

Mass vaccination is good at achieving horizontal equity (i.e. everyone with equal need treated the same), but compromises vertical equity (i.e. those with greater need provided with more treatment).
 
Last edited:
P: What’s wrong with me?
L: What do you think is wrong with you?
P: I’ve got a pain in my X. Is it Y?
L: Do you think it’s Y?
P: I don’t know. What do you think?
L: What difference will that make?
P: You’ll be able to treat me?
L: No, I’d just be expressing my bias. Let’s concentrate on what you think is wrong. Tell me more about Y.
P: Well I only know what I read on the internet.
L: Ah, so you haven’t done an exhaustive search of the literature on Y. Well I’ve given policy advice for conditions similar to Y.
P: What was your advice?
L: I can’t say. I’d just be expressing my bias.
P: So you won’t treat me?
L: Yes.
P: Is that ‘yes, you will treat me’, or ‘yes, you won’t treat me’?
L: Yes.
P: You will treat me?
L: Yes. What would you like to be treated for?
P: I’d like you to treat me for whatever is wrong with me.
L: What do you think is wrong with you?

Do you charge by the hour?
 
Because you've already made it clear that the way I go about it wouldn't be useful to you.
Might be useful to someone else besides me. Perhaps I could suggest your strategy to my daughter?
I'm not being coy. I don't want to waste your time (and mine, for that matter).
All the time I spend on this forum is a waste in the same way that any other form of amusement is.

You've just spent the last six pages explaining why my (and others') opinions are no more useful to you than those of the guy on the corner. You don't need to pretend to an interest in order to be polite. It doesn't hurt my feelings (honest). :)

Besides, I checked my schedule and this week I'm supposed to be hawking anti-depressants on the forum, so there's nothing in it for me.

I’m not pretending an interest. I really am interested and the more you defer me the more curious I become. It’s not that difficult. The recommendations are public. Which, if any, do you disagree with. You don’t even need to say why. I would really like to know. Perhaps you could deign to respond with a simple yes or no. Do you disagree with any of their recommendations?

From that link you provided earlier, the conflicts listed included any research funding (some in amounts that were trivial) from a pharmaceutical company to the employers of the committee members (you'd be hard-pressed to find a university which has never participated in pharmaceutical research) (the committee members were not involved in that research at their institution), any research on vaccines regardless of the source of funding (since this included funding from the NIAID (a governmental source)), any funding from a pharmaceutical company that produces any vaccines (which takes care of the major manufacturers) regardless of amount or whether it was related to research on vaccines, and trivial honoraria for attendance at conferences (unspecified funding source). If the trivial and/or indirect financial benefit listed above is to be excluded, then you will end up excluding those people I mentioned earlier.

I wasn't previously aware that they needed to report honariums, some of which were rather small. On the other hand, apparently some members did not bother to complete the required forms listing the companies that provided the funds, as was required by law. I do recall from my initial investigation that many of the financial disclosure forms were incomplete. But the small honariums are not the type of thing that concerns me. I don't think they should pose an obstacle to people serving on the committee though I think it is a good idea to have them publically listed.

On the other hand, there are cases like the following on the rotovirus vaccine:

Dr. Kathryn Edwards: Dr. Edwards received a contract from Wyeth Lederle for $255,023 per year from 1996 to 1998 for the study of pneumococcal vaccines. She also had numerous grants and contracts with the NIAID, an affected company, for the following amounts: $206,750 per year from 4/1/95 to 3/1/98 to study TB vaccines; $673, 373 a year from 1996-2003 to study mucosal vaccines; and $86,279 from 1997-1998 to study acellular pertussis/cell mediate immunity. These contracts and grants were deemed to potentially appear to be a conflict, but were subsequently waived. Dr. Edwards was allowed full participation in the meeting.

and

Dr. Mary Estes: At the time of the Rotashield approval meeting, Dr. Estes’ employer, Baylor College of Medicine, was receiving a large amount of funds for the development of rotavirus vaccines, including a $75,000 grant from American Home Products, the parent company of Wyeth-Lederle Vaccines and Pediatrics, and from the NIAID for $404,000 from 8/93 to 7/98. The FDA determined that the amount of funding is not large and represent[ed] a small portion of the University’s research budget. (Exhibit 61) Accordingly, this conflict was waived. Dr. Estes was also listed as the principal investigator for a grant from Merck for the development of a rotavirus vaccine. This conflict was also waived and Dr. Estes was given a full participation waiver for the meeting.


These are the types of substantive financial ties and conflicts of interest that I find to be a serious concern. The amounts Dr. Edwards had received were not trivial and were to her, not her institution. Dr Estes clearly has a vested interest in the vaccine since she was a principle investigator. These were members who voted on approval of the rotovirus vaccine. I’m sure you recall it. It was approved then pulled from the market 13 months later for problems. Problems that showed up in the clinical trials but were deemed ‘insignificant’ by the voting members of the committee. Somehow, I suspect that won’t count as evidence of bias affecting the decisions of the committee though.
 
Last edited:
Why am I not surprised to find this stuff completely exaggerated and taken out of context on the anti-vaxer web sites. Unbelievable.
I’m not sure what you are talking about here. I didn’t look around the site before posting the link. But only the report is posted at the page I linked, no commentary, and I don't see anything that was obviously taken out of context. The report appears to be reproduced in it's entirety.
First off, the report is 8 years old. The whole point of the investigation would have been to make corrections. I see no where there is any ongoing concerns.
Yes. As I stated earlier, this was shortly after the period when I had looked into it back in 98 & 99. As far as on-going concerns - have any corrective actions been taken as a result of this investigation and report? What were they? How effective were they? I'm no longer making decisions about vaccinations for my kids, so I haven't kept up. But until I see evidence that things have changed, I'll presume they haven't. That's the way a loss of credibility works. Once gone, it can be very difficult to recover. With effort, in 10 to 20 years they could have it back. Have they made that effort over the last 8?
Second, as I said this is incredibly overstated by the anti-vaxers.
Huh? Unless you are accusing me of being an anti-vaxer, I don’t know what you are talking about. And if you are calling me an anti-vaxer, you're the one making overblown statements.
Yeah, gee, the vaccine manufacturers are actually allowed to provide input on their products and research. Who else should present that information? It isn't like it is the only information the committee gets.

This is the worst they found in this Congressional investigation? :rolleyes:

The current price of Merck shares is just under $42/share. Times 600 shares that is a whopping $25,200. I have that much in my savings account it is nothing for a upper middle income person to have that much. Can you imagine risking losing your 6 figure job over a $25K investment? This is a level of conflict of interest to worry about? I don't think so.
I must disagree. I find it terribly worrisome and equally worrisome that other members of the profession do not consider it a problem. Such financial ties leads to bias in making judgments. Apparently, the investigators of this committee considered it a problem as well. It was not the most egregious of the financial ties, I think that honor would go to Dr. Edwards (See my response to Linda) but his might be considered the bigger problem because he was chairman of the committee. It would have been his responsibility to set a good example and make sure that the other members of the committee were also abiding by all the applicable regulations. That just wasn’t happening then. Do you have any evidence it’s happening now?

Sorry Beth, I'm not impressed and now I remember why I dismissed this stuff before. It's fine they had an investigation. It's fine they found some issues that needed correction and that the rules were a bit too lax. I would think after 8 years some corrective action was taken. This was hardly earthshaking in the first place.

So, now that I have provided evidence of substantial financial ties leading to biased decisions by the committee, you dismiss it as being “not impressed”. Well, you are right. I wouldn’t term it impressive either. I call it appalling. It’s also against the law: “The law also requires that advisory committee members disclose their financial interests and recuse themselves from matters in which they have an interest.”

Incidentally, your attitude and those of the other medical professionals posting here is remarkably similar to the one described by the investigators of this committee: “In many cases, significant conflicts of interest are not deemed to be conflicts at all.”

And you wonder why normal people pay attention to the anti-vaxers? Stuff like this along with reactions of medical professionals like you to the information has a lot to do with it. People like me hear something like “all the committee members have financial ties to vaccine manufacturers”. I looked into it and discovered it was true. You dismiss the concerns as ‘overblown’. I look at the rotovirus vaccine recall and feel they are quite valid. As a result, someone like me stops trusting in the committees recommendations and begins to refuse some vaccines.
 
Last edited:
Might be useful to someone else besides me. Perhaps I could suggest your strategy to my daughter?

Right. You're going to pass on advice that you consider useless to your daughter.

All the time I spend on this forum is a waste in the same way that any other form of amusement is.

I’m not pretending an interest. I really am interested and the more you defer me the more curious I become. It’s not that difficult. The recommendations are public. Which, if any, do you disagree with. You don’t even need to say why. I would really like to know. Perhaps you could deign to respond with a simple yes or no. Do you disagree with any of their recommendations?

Ah, c'mon. It's more amusing this way. Ivor's as happy as a pig in ****. Surely you wouldn't be so selfish as to take that away from him?

I wasn't previously aware that they needed to report honariums, some of which were rather small. On the other hand, apparently some members did not bother to complete the required forms listing the companies that provided the funds, as was required by law. I do recall from my initial investigation that many of the financial disclosure forms were incomplete. But the small honariums are not the type of thing that concerns me. I don't think they should pose an obstacle to people serving on the committee though I think it is a good idea to have them publically listed.

On the other hand, there are cases like the following on the rotovirus vaccine:

Dr. Kathryn Edwards: Dr. Edwards received a contract from Wyeth Lederle for $255,023 per year from 1996 to 1998 for the study of pneumococcal vaccines. She also had numerous grants and contracts with the NIAID, an affected company, for the following amounts: $206,750 per year from 4/1/95 to 3/1/98 to study TB vaccines; $673, 373 a year from 1996-2003 to study mucosal vaccines; and $86,279 from 1997-1998 to study acellular pertussis/cell mediate immunity. These contracts and grants were deemed to potentially appear to be a conflict, but were subsequently waived. Dr. Edwards was allowed full participation in the meeting.

and

Dr. Mary Estes: At the time of the Rotashield approval meeting, Dr. Estes’ employer, Baylor College of Medicine, was receiving a large amount of funds for the development of rotavirus vaccines, including a $75,000 grant from American Home Products, the parent company of Wyeth-Lederle Vaccines and Pediatrics, and from the NIAID for $404,000 from 8/93 to 7/98. The FDA determined that the amount of funding is not large and represent[ed] a small portion of the University’s research budget. (Exhibit 61) Accordingly, this conflict was waived. Dr. Estes was also listed as the principal investigator for a grant from Merck for the development of a rotavirus vaccine. This conflict was also waived and Dr. Estes was given a full participation waiver for the meeting.


These are the types of substantive financial ties and conflicts of interest that I find to be a serious concern. The amounts Dr. Edwards had received were not trivial and were to her, not her institution. Dr Estes clearly has a vested interest in the vaccine since she was a principle investigator. These were members who voted on approval of the rotovirus vaccine. I’m sure you recall it. It was approved then pulled from the market 13 months later for problems. Problems that showed up in the clinical trials but were deemed ‘insignificant’ by the voting members of the committee. Somehow, I suspect that won’t count as evidence of bias affecting the decisions of the committee though.

There were a handful of cases of intussusception in the clinical trials. The differences between placebo and vaccine groups wasn't significant, making it hard to conclude causality. It wasn't ignored however. This is the statement from the ACIP when the vaccine was released:

"In all studies of rhesus rotavirus vaccines combined, intussusception was noted in five of 10,054 (0.05%) recipients of any reassortant rhesus vaccine (two of these five children received RRV-TV) compared with one of 4,633 placebo recipients. The difference between the rates of intussusception in these groups was not statistically significant (p=0.92 for children receiving vaccine; p=0.45 for children receiving placebo), and the rates observed among vaccinated children were similar to those seen in comparison populations (86). Although the association of these events with RRV-TV appears to be temporal rather than causal, postlicensure surveillance is needed for these and other rare adverse events that might occur."

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00056669.htm

In addition to the VAERS follow-up, specific studies were initiated by the CDC to monitor the possibility that this represented a real problem.

Whether or not Dr. Edwards and Dr. Estes were biased in their opinions, it did not lead them to make decisions that were materially different from the other doctors on the committee who had never received any funding (directly or indirectly) from Wyeth, nor the thousands of other physicians and health-care workers or their employers who also review research on vaccines, in order to form their own opinions, who have not received funding from any pharmaceutical company.

Linda
 
Right. You're going to pass on advice that you consider useless to your daughter.
I don't know that I would consider it useless for her. It's useless for me because I'm not going to making such decisions in the future.
Ah, c'mon. It's more amusing this way. Ivor's as happy as a pig in ****. Surely you wouldn't be so selfish as to take that away from him?
Why don't you pm your answer then?

There were a handful of cases of intussusception in the clinical trials. The differences between placebo and vaccine groups wasn't significant, making it hard to conclude causality.
There were 5, according to the report, a rate of 1 in 2010. Do you know what sample size is required to make that value ~ 0.0005 a statistically significant finding at the 0.05 level in a single trial? Approximately 1,000,000. On the other hand, another trial of the same size with similar results could have established the signficance of that particular problem and it would have been resolved prior to approving the release of the vaccine to the public and later recalling it.
It wasn't ignored however. This is the statement from the ACIP when the vaccine was released:
"In all studies of rhesus rotavirus vaccines combined, intussusception was noted in five of 10,054 (0.05%) recipients of any reassortant rhesus vaccine (two of these five children received RRV-TV) compared with one of 4,633 placebo recipients. The difference between the rates of intussusception in these groups was not statistically significant (p=0.92 for children receiving vaccine; p=0.45 for children receiving placebo), and the rates observed among vaccinated children were similar to those seen in comparison populations (86). Although the association of these events with RRV-TV appears to be temporal rather than causal, postlicensure surveillance is needed for these and other rare adverse events that might occur."

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00056669.htm

In addition to the VAERS follow-up, specific studies were initiated by the CDC to monitor the possibility that this represented a real problem.
No they didn't ignore it completely, they just went ahead and approved it for release despite their knowledge of the problem. And people wonder why I didn't accept any newly approved vaccinations for my children!
Whether or not Dr. Edwards and Dr. Estes were biased in their opinions, it did not lead them to make decisions that were materially different from the other doctors on the committee who had never received any funding (directly or indirectly) from Wyeth, nor the thousands of other physicians and health-care workers or their employers who also review research on vaccines, in order to form their own opinions, who have not received funding from any pharmaceutical company.

Linda

Not only is it likely their votes were biased, it's also likely they led the other doctors to make vote for approval rather than insisting on another trial to make sure the problem wasn't vaccine related. That's how bias can work to result in poor decisions by a committee. That's why I don't trust the recommendations of this committee. Is there any evidence things have changed in the past 8 years?
 
Last edited:
I found this site http://weeksmd.com/?page_id=402 via a search so I can't vouch for it, but it claims the report that it reproduces was government issued. It's dated June 15, 2000 and the information matches what I found when I was investigating back in 98 and 99.
"§ The Chairman of the CDC’s advisory committee until very recently owned 600 shares of stock in Merck, a pharmaceutical company with an active vaccine division.

I don't know how much conflict of interest exists on it today, but this is what I was finding when I investigated and got soured on following their recommendations. As far as the science speaking for itself, I addressed that earlier. Science has no voice.

You stated members had hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of company stock.

When asked for evidence, you show me the quote above, which reveals that
Dr. Modlin owned 600 shares of stock in Merck as listed on his OGE 450. He serves on Merck’s Immunization Advisory Board but receives no remuneration. Dr. Modlin informed committee staff that he divested his shares in Merck some time in 1999.
Merck stock was worth around $70 a share in 1999. That means he owned $42 000 of stock.

Now he would not have been "given" this stock by Merck - he would have bought it himself. While there might be a theoretical temptation for someone to try and influence the share price to boost their own profits, do you really think that this eminent doctor would deliberately advocate something potentially harmful just to boost the share price of a company he owns stock in? Remember that Merk has a large portfolio of drugs, with statins being the big earners (and vioxx in the past). The influence of one doctor promoting one of the company's sideline vaccine products would be tiny. Even if he managed to boost the share price by say 5%, which is wildly optimistic, this would represent a possible few thousand dollars worth of personal profit.

If you think a doctor would jeopardise his career and reputation by taking the very risky course of deliberately distorting scientific conclusions and manipulating opinions you are sorely mistaken. If this is the low opinion you have of the medical profession, no wonder you find them untrustworthy.
 
Last edited:
I don't know that I would consider it useless for her. It's useless for me because I'm not going to making such decisions in the future.

Of course it's useless for her. It's based on the opinion of people you consider a useless source of information.

Why don't you pm your answer then?

Because it's otherwise completely uninteresting.

There were 5, according to the report, a rate of 1 in 2010. Do you know what sample size is required to make that value ~ 0.0005 a statistically significant finding at the 0.05 level in a single trial? Approximately 1,000,000. On the other hand, another trial of the same size with similar results could have established the signficance of that particular problem and it would have been resolved prior to approving the release of the vaccine to the public and later recalling it.

I don't understand your reasoning here. The results of all the pre-approval trials combined showed a total of five cases out of 10,054 compared to one out of 4633 in those given placebo. You say a sample size of 1,000,000 is needed in order to make that finding statistically significant, then you say a sample size of 10,000(or less - it's confusing because you talk about a single trial, yet the results are from multiple trials) would establish a significant difference. Wouldn't it just lead to the same conclusion again?

No they didn't ignore it completely, they just went ahead and approved it for release despite their knowledge of the problem. And people wonder why I didn't accept any newly approved vaccinations for my children!

But how could they possibly know that it was a problem when all they saw was something that occurred at a similar rate in the group given placebo, especially since it was biologically implausible? What if it had been a similar slight difference in the number of car accidents or distribution of astrological signs?

What kind of research are you involved in?

Not only is it likely their votes were biased, it's also likely they led the other doctors to make vote for approval rather than insisting on another trial to make sure the problem wasn't vaccine related. That's how bias can work to result in poor decisions by a committee. That's why I don't trust the recommendations of this committee. Is there any evidence things have changed in the past 8 years?

Yes, you've made it abundantly clear that we are all idiots being led by our noses. But in all honesty, I find it very hard to believe that the degree of distrust you exhibit would be influenced in the slightest by making changes in the process. If you're not going to be satisfied anyway (and I've seen no indication otherwise), why waste the effort?

Linda
 
FWIW medical professionals in this thread, I don’t think the ACIPs decisions would be overly influenced by the amounts of money reported. Having said that, most companies I’ve worked for have required all employees to avoid giving or receiving gifts of any sort if they're worth more than a few 10’s of dollars and/or may be seen as inappropriate.

Where I think the bias comes from is the desire to do the “right and proper” thing, as Deetee put it earlier. Medical professionals experience a biased sample of the population, simply because they work in an environment where most of the people they see are in need of medical care. They don’t put pictures of starving Africans on the TV just to fill up air time when charities want some of your money; they really do affect peoples’ behaviour.

I’m curious why the medical professionals in this thread appear to be more or less offended by some of the non-medical professionals not applying a hard accept/reject strategy with respect to the recommendations they (or the specialist expert groups they form) provide. Are medical professionals the only people allowed or qualified to use Bayesian reasoning? In my line of work (which involves quite a bit of signal processing), more often than not better results are obtained by delaying thresholding decisions for as long as possible in the signal chain, and using as much information over as much time as can be afforded. If there is very little time to reach a decision, the decision is made on the most significant piece of information available.

In the case of medical decisions, additional factors are the various value judgements, which typically result in deciding if the perceived benefit to one group is “worth” the inevitable reduction of treatment of another (given a fixed amount of resources).

Given these factors, I give each a weight and apply a hard threshold to come to a decision, which you are all well aware of so I will not bore you with it again, except to say the largest single weighting I give is to expert evidence-based medical recommendations, the next largest probably being my personal values with regards to how finite resources should be distributed. I think it is this latter input which I am out of step with most of the other posters in this thread (and probably the rest of the world:)).

So that’s my long, boring description of how I think I and others come to our decisions and why they are sometimes different, even when provided with the same evidence.
 
Last edited:
Of course it's useless for her. It's based on the opinion of people you consider a useless source of information.
Because it's otherwise completely uninteresting.
Still, you don't answer the question. Do you actually have a superior strategy to studying the information available and making up your own mind when you don't feel you can trust the experts? I am beginning to think not. At least, not one you have sufficient confidence in to put up for public scrutiny.

I don't understand your reasoning here. The results of all the pre-approval trials combined showed a total of five cases out of 10,054 compared to one out of 4633 in those given placebo.
That's a rate of 0.0005 in the vaccinated population compared to a rate of .0002 in the unvaccinated population - an increase of approximately 150%. However, the rates are so low that large sample sizes are required to determine if the increase is statistically significant at the 0.05 level. It wasn't enough to say definitely that the vaccine was the cause, but it was enough to decide that further research was appropriate in order to make the determination with a high level of confidence.

BTW, I didn't catch the base population rate earlier. A quick computation gives an p-value of 0.0693 for 5 out of 10054 with a probability of 1 in 4633. While not significant at the 0.05 level, it would have been quite appropriate to take this result as an indicating that further investigation is needed.

You say a sample size of 1,000,000 is needed in order to make that finding statistically significant, then you say a sample size of 10,000(or less - it's confusing because you talk about a single trial, yet the results are from multiple trials) would establish a significant difference. Wouldn't it just lead to the same conclusion again?
I'm sorry about the confusing terminology. But the answer is not necessarily. Multiple experiments (which can consist of many experimental units - in this case an experimental unit would be a person who was vaccinated) can provide superior discrimination over a single experiment with more units. Consider the Million $ challenge. The prelim and the final test can both have a p-value of 0.001 because when multiplied together, they give a probability of 0.000001.

I know it seems contrary to intuition at first, but it's major reason why an iterated approach to experimentation with relatively small numbers of experimental units in each iteration is a much better approach than a single large experiment. You can actually gain more information from fewer experimental units with this sort of approach.

You might try thinking of it this way: if the original result was due to chance, then the another experiment is very unlikely to produce the same effect. On the other hand, if it isn't due to chance, the probability of seeing increased rates in the vaccine population is high.

But how could they possibly know that it was a problem when all they saw was something that occurred at a similar rate in the group given placebo, especially since it was biologically implausible?
An increase of 150% is NOT a similar rate. It wasn't a statistically significant increase because when you have such low rates it is extremely difficult to reject the null of no difference. Recall that the probability of a type II error (which is what happened in this case) is unrelated to the stated confidence level and can be much much higher.
What if it had been a similar slight difference in the number of car accidents or distribution of astrological signs?
Do they keep track of those factors because they are a possible consequence of the vaccine? :)

What kind of research are you involved in?
Do you disagree with any of the current recommendations of the ACIP? I asked first.
Yes, you've made it abundantly clear that we are all idiots being led by our noses.
No, no, no. You're taking offense at something inferred that was not meant to be implied. Such a strategy is usually skeptigirl's baliwick not yours. I have never said you were anything but biased. We are all biased, including me. I've explicitly said, more than once, that doesn't imply incompetence. It certainly doesn't imply stupidity. Why are you taking offense now? This comes across to me as yet another ploy to avoid answering my question regarding your personal opinion. The best defense is a good offense?
But in all honesty, I find it very hard to believe that the degree of distrust you exhibit would be influenced in the slightest by making changes in the process.
You're wrong about that. I would be quite satisfied if I felt the committee was composed of relatively few biased individuals or had a reasonable distribution of various different biases represented, thus achieving something like balance. It is the law. Is it really asking too much for a national policy setting committee to abide by the laws and regulations that govern it? I don't think so, but if it is, then the laws and regulations should be changed not ignored. It's been 8 years. What has changed? Anything?
If you're not going to be satisfied anyway (and I've seen no indication otherwise), why waste the effort?
Linda
Because we're having a friendly conversation. Because I've answered your questions to the best of my ability. Because I asked politely. Because it's relevant to the conversation. Why do you keep refusing? It can't take more time or effort to answer the question than it does to keep evading it.

If you're not going to give an answer, could you at least give me an honest reason why not?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom