autism-vaccine link?

That is not how it works. That is so warped. Again you outline that you really have no clue. Good thing reality does not match your strange twisted viewpoint on budgets, funding decisions, etc.

And if you think you're just trying to be funny... I rather think you are just exposing your narrow-minded viewpoint of the whole entire subject.
 
Last edited:
I honestly would like to believe that a neutral presentation is the best approach - it is the approach that I prefer. But considering the biases I mentioned earlier, I suspect that all a neutral presentation accomplishes is to reinforce those biases. I think that in order to actually allow someone to consider an issue in a neutral manner, some attempt has to be made to counteract those biases.
We'll just have to disagree on this I guess. When I go looking for information or advice, I want it neutral rather than spun to counteract whatever biases the other person is assuming I have. I have a hard enough time trying to figure out their biases and take that into account. What you are saying you try to do just makes it more difficult to assess what you are telling me.
I don't know that I can help you. I'm not comfortable using myself as a gold-standard. I will admit to a little jealousy at how others seem to have the confidence to blithely act on what they know, but I tend to be more aware of what I don't know and wonder if that could make all the difference. That's not to say that I'm not suspicious of anything coming from 'experts' or a 'committee', for all the reasons you outlined earlier, but I obviously deal with my suspicions quite differently from you. Knowing that I am ignorant and likely to be biased, I can't place as much weight as you do on my own inclinations.
Hmmm. So you are comfortable complaining about my approach while you admit you don't have a better one and wish you felt as sure of yours as I seem to be of mine (you obviously don't know how wishy-washy I really am and how much dithering I do over all such decisions :)). The bottom line is, despite my dithering nature, I have to make such decisions in a reasonable timely matter and the ones we are discussing I made years ago.

Because it's clear to me that you went looking for reasons to justify your decision and stopped once you found them, without bothering to confirm whether or not they applied.
The problem with this assessment is it's wrong. The only alteration I made to the ACIP recommendations was using the killed polio vaccine rather than the live vaccine for my daugher (now 20) and that was at her father's insistence. The killed polio vaccine is now what is recommended. It was only after I found out about the bias in the ACIP committee membership that I started investigating vaccines and vaccine policy more thoroughly. I still got my kids most of the recommended vaccines, mainly I decline the newer ones. I was particularly glad I had done that when the rotovirus recall was issued.
You've dismissed the contributions of the professional process, and you are most confident in your own evaluation (to the exclusion of most anything else it seems). I didn't comment because I don't think I can say anything that would be interest to you, considering that most of that is foreign to my own way of thinking.
I haven't dismissed those contributions. As I said, I got my kids most of what is recommended. That isn't dismissal. That's because I did read up on it considered those professional evaluations you seem to think I've dismissed because I didn't follow them 100%.

It seems to me that that's the point of asking for advice from someone with expertise.
Linda

Where is the average person suppose to get that advice? Typically it comes from their pediatrician, who gets it from the ACIP (though I think it may be routed through their professional organization. If I can't trust the ACIP - and I don't think I can and I'm not alone in that assessment - then what can I do? I don't know any vaccine professionals personally. Most people don't. It's not a terribly common profession. I was stuck with trying to read through difficult technical material and decide for myself. In the end, I'm more than willing to accept the risk that comes with vaccines for serious diseases that are easily communicated. I'm not so willing to accept the risk of vaccination for minor diseases or STD's since, for my situation, the risk of the disease is quite low while the risk of increasing the number of vaccinations individuals receive over their lifetime remains unknown to all of us.

I don't have to justify this decision at all. My choices are just that, my choices. But I would like for professionals in the field to understand my concerns and work towards correcting the situation. I can't do more than write my congressman, which I have. You can spread the word amonst people working in the field that this is a concern and advocate for selecting committee members without such bias or with a similar bias in the opposite diretion to help achieve balance.

I wish to point out that you don't know whether or not I agree with the ACIP, as I've never told you that I do.
Sorry, I hadn't realized that. My apologies. Could you share with us any differences of opinion you might have with their recommendations? Thanks.
 
We'll just have to disagree on this I guess. When I go looking for information or advice, I want it neutral rather than spun to counteract whatever biases the other person is assuming I have. I have a hard enough time trying to figure out their biases and take that into account. What you are saying you try to do just makes it more difficult to assess what you are telling me.

I try to present information in as neutral a manner as possible - as I said I am most comfortable with that approach. If I notice a particular bias, I make a point of trying to address it (or at least I have until this point). That this is seen as being manipulative by you helps me understand some things which have had me puzzled. This has been useful

Hmmm. So you are comfortable complaining about my approach while you admit you don't have a better one

I never admitted I don't have a better one. I think I have a far better approach than yours.

The problem with this assessment is it's wrong. The only alteration I made to the ACIP recommendations was using the killed polio vaccine rather than the live vaccine for my daugher (now 20) and that was at her father's insistence. The killed polio vaccine is now what is recommended. It was only after I found out about the bias in the ACIP committee membership that I started investigating vaccines and vaccine policy more thoroughly. I still got my kids most of the recommended vaccines, mainly I decline the newer ones. I was particularly glad I had done that when the rotovirus recall was issued.

I meant your decision that the recommendations of the ACIP were untrustworthy, not your decision as to which vaccines to give your children.

I haven't dismissed those contributions. As I said, I got my kids most of what is recommended. That isn't dismissal. That's because I did read up on it considered those professional evaluations you seem to think I've dismissed because I didn't follow them 100%.

I meant the contributions of the profession toward confirming or denying the trustworthiness of the ACIP recommendations. Sorry that wasn't clear.

Where is the average person suppose to get that advice?

Isn't that the point of a personal physician?

Typically it comes from their pediatrician, who gets it from the ACIP (though I think it may be routed through their professional organization. If I can't trust the ACIP - and I don't think I can and I'm not alone in that assessment - then what can I do? I don't know any vaccine professionals personally. Most people don't. It's not a terribly common profession. I was stuck with trying to read through difficult technical material and decide for myself. In the end, I'm more than willing to accept the risk that comes with vaccines for serious diseases that are easily communicated. I'm not so willing to accept the risk of vaccination for minor diseases or STD's since, for my situation, the risk of the disease is quite low while the risk of increasing the number of vaccinations individuals receive over their lifetime remains unknown to all of us.

Like I said, my advice will not be interest to you, then.

I don't have to justify this decision at all. My choices are just that, my choices. But I would like for professionals in the field to understand my concerns and work towards correcting the situation. I can't do more than write my congressman, which I have. You can spread the word amonst people working in the field that this is a concern and advocate for selecting committee members without such bias or with a similar bias in the opposite diretion to help achieve balance.

I dunno. Don't you think that there will be just as many complaints (if not more) when anyone who has attended an educational conference, anyone who has done research on a vaccine, or anyone who has a position at an academic institution is excluded? Wouldn't they then be open to the criticism that they are lacking the experience which would give them the skills to make these decisions?

Sorry, I hadn't realized that. My apologies. Could you share with us any differences of opinion you might have with their recommendations? Thanks.

Why? It will only reflect my personal biases.

Linda
 
Compared to what?

What conditions are you prepared to *not* have treated so VZV can be eradicated?

You want the latest drugs for Breast Cancer, Parkinson's disease or Alzheimer's? Sorry, can't afford them. We spent the budget on chickenpox so Tarquin and Jemima's Mummy and Daddy can be good little worker bees and don't have to take a week or two off work to look after their kids.:D
It'll go on the WHO list along with measles and polio who have the funds to do this and have done so for smallpox despite competing demands for cash.
 
I try to present information in as neutral a manner as possible - as I said I am most comfortable with that approach. If I notice a particular bias, I make a point of trying to address it (or at least I have until this point). That this is seen as being manipulative by you helps me understand some things which have had me puzzled. This has been useful.
I’m glad you find our conversation useful. :)
I never admitted I don't have a better one. I think I have a far better approach than yours.
Okay. Why then when I asked your opinion as to what a better approach would be did you say
I don't know that I can help you?
At any rate, my decisions are made at this point, so you wouldn’t actually be helping me as it isn’t applicable to me anymore, you would simply be sharing with me what you think is the best approach.
I meant your decision that the recommendations of the ACIP were untrustworthy, not your decision as to which vaccines to give your children.
My decision that they were untrustworthy was based on that finding, it was not a decision made previous to that finding. I had read it somewhere but didn't believe it until I checked it out for myself. That was the point at which I lost faith in the vaccine recommendations and stopped simply following them for my children.
Isn't that the point of a personal physician?
Yes. But they cannot be expected to do all the research for themselves. It's reasonable for them to rely upon the recommendations of the ACIP. This is why I consider the credibility issue so important and why I have such resentment that the committee membership is biased.
Like I said, my advice will not be interest to you, then.
Like I said, it wouldn’t be advice for me as my kids are past the age where it is a consideration. It would, however, be of interest to me. Why are you being so coy about it?
I dunno. Don't you think that there will be just as many complaints (if not more) when anyone who has attended an educational conference, anyone who has done research on a vaccine, or anyone who has a position at an academic institution is excluded? Wouldn't they then be open to the criticism that they are lacking the experience which would give them the skills to make these decisions?
If you think that any of those things would require the person to disclose the activity in a conflict of interest statement, then I am grossly misunderstanding the requirements for that conflict of interest waiver. My understanding it is to disclose personal financial ties only, so such activities should not require a conflict of interest waiver to serve on the committee. Is that a mistaken impression? I don't recall seeing the activities you've mentioned listed on such forms and I have looked at them in the past.

eta: research was mentioned, but only research that was funded by manufacturers whose vaccines will be evaluated by the committee.

Why? It will only reflect my personal biases.
Linda
I am puzzled by your reluctance to give your opinion when you claim to have studied this area in depth. We all have personal biases. You’ve aroused my curiosity. What are your personal biases that you are so reluctant to display? Or is that you do not have any differences of opinion with the official recommendations – which would imply that my original assumption was correct despite your not having stated so previously?
 
Last edited:
What conditions are you prepared to *not* have treated so VZV can be eradicated?

You want the latest drugs for Breast Cancer, Parkinson's disease or Alzheimer's? Sorry, can't afford them. We spent the budget on chickenpox so Tarquin and Jemima's Mummy and Daddy can be good little worker bees and don't have to take a week or two off work to look after their kids.:D

We can do it all.
Think creatively - Can you find a better use for the squillions we are wasting by waging war in Iraq?

PS - thanks for the interesting info from the Annals.
 
We can do it all.
Think creatively - Can you find a better use for the squillions we are wasting by waging war in Iraq?

PS - thanks for the interesting info from the Annals.

Good point.

That reminds me: How's our £20 billion (:eye-poppi) NHS computer system coming along?
 
I know that many of the members of that committee have financial ties to vaccine manufactures. When I first investigated the matter, it was 100% of the members. It's not unusual for it to be more than half. 10% I could live with easily. 20% would cause me discomfort. More than that, I don't feel I can trust their recommendations.
Surely you should introduce some index of quality and not just quantity?
Should you not consider what is the precise nature of their potential conflict of interest?

What if a member says he has accepted funding from vaccine manufacturer A to deliver a talk at a conference? Does this automatically make his advice untrustworthy?

What if a member says he has accepted funding from vaccine manufacturer A to deliver a talk at one conference, and from competing vaccine manufacturer B to talk at another conference? Does this automatically make his advice trustworthy again, because the potential biases cancel themselves out?

I think you need to wake up and smell the coffee Beth. Medical leaders in superspecialised fields of medicine will always have what you term "financial ties" with drug or vaccine manufacturers. When I attend international conferences on HIV, it is not unusual for opinion leaders to be asked to appear on discussion panels and give talks in the drug sponsored satellite symposia. I can think of one leading UK researcher who appeared in 5 different symposia for "competing" drugs at the European AIDS conference in Madrid last year. Do I distrust his opinion as a result? No.

The drug companies like to have the "leading lights" appear at their own symposia, so they can attract more delegates to their discussions rather than their rivals. Obviously the aim is to hope to have some influence on all the potential prescribers in the audience, but the opinion leaders I know who take part are visibly very objective and unbiased. Drug companies do not expect to "buy" the loyalty of these sort of people - it would be pretty clear to everyone if someone tried to deliberately promote a point of view which was not evidence based.

I am reminded of a spat I once had with someone over the value of rubella vaccine. They argued that any evidence or pro-vaccination argument presented by the world's foremost expert on congenital rubella could be summarily dismissed as completely irrelevant. Why? The answer was that as the world's foremost expert he had been invited to several symposia sponsored in part by the rubella vaccine manufacturer, and therefore his opinion would be biased. It made me wonder if they would only accept the opinion of someone who was so inexperienced that they had never been honoured by an invitation to give a talk anywhere.

So what other conflicts of interest or financial ties do you refer to? If there is evidence that an opinion leader has been sponsored to produce a biased position paper or similar document, then I would agree that is totally unacceptable. But such people usually get rumbled, because they are subjected to constant exposure and scientific scrutiny from peers and public alike, and if they prduce innacurate information it is soon noted. Their careers and objectivity would be blighted, and I doubt they would risk doing such a thing.

Then there may be those who are not opinion leaders but who are merely small time researchers who may be tempted to promote a point of view because there may be some financial rewards for them. But they often get rumbled too, once their POV proves to be incorrect (Remember Andrew Wakefield?)
 
Last edited:
Surely you should introduce some index of quality and not just quantity?
Should you not consider what is the precise nature of their potential conflict of interest?
Yes. That's why I went to the trouble of actually finding and examining the conflict of interest statements that had been filed. They were not of the nature you indicate below. They were of tens, sometimes hundreds of thousands of dollars in stocks, consulting contracts and research funding.
I think you need to wake up and smell the coffee Beth. Medical leaders in superspecialised fields of medicine will always have what you term "financial ties" with drug or vaccine manufacturers.
My coffee smells delicious. I have "Jamacian Me Crazy" at the moment. :D I'm not talking about support to attend conferences and present papers, although I find it a bit disturbing that you do not feel it is worth of any sort of concern. Do you think that all medical professionals, unlike other people, are completely unaffected by such generosity?
Drug companies do not expect to "buy" the loyalty of these sort of people -
No, I don't think they "buy" loyalty any more than I think that they "buy" the loyalty of my congressional representative through their campaign donations. Save that type of phrasing for when you debate conspiracy theorists.

What I think is that it fosters bias on the part of the recipients of large amounts of money and I am not happy about it where ever I discover it in people who are supposed to be 'public servants". That it is endemic to entire industries I depend on is NOT a comforting thought to me, nor do I find it a reasonable defense of the practice. It indicates that the problem is systemic and therefore, it will be very hard to fix. It doesn't mean there isn't a problem so we should just continue merrily on with such practices being the norm.
Then there may be those who are not opinion leaders but who are merely small time researchers who may be tempted to promote a point of view because there may be some financial rewards for them. But they often get rumbled too, once their POV proves to be incorrect (Remember Andrew Wakefield?)
Wasn't it discovered that he had substantive financial ties that he had not disclosed at the time of the publication of his research? Why was it such a big deal when the facts about it came out? Do you suppose he alone was influenced by such financial ties while all other researchers are immune to such influences?
 
Last edited:
Perhaps Linda hasn't decided which pharmaceutical company to accept a bribe research funding from yet?

I don't know if Linda does research at all, much less in this area. Anyway, according to DeeTee, such conflicts are not an issue, they are standard operating procedure. Researchers just accept such funding from all of them. No need for members of the general public to be concerned about such business practices. Medical researchers are uninfluenced by accepting funding to promote and dissemenate their work, except for Wakefield. Clearly, influence due to financial ties only works when the researchers are anti-vax.

ETA: To be fair, I don't think 'bribe' is an appropriate word to describe the funding, anymore than it is an appropriate word to describe large campaign contributions to politicians. I just think that such contributions do influence how the recipient thinks of the giver.
 
Last edited:
Yes. That's why I went to the trouble of actually finding and examining the conflict of interest statements that had been filed. They were not of the nature you indicate below. They were of tens, sometimes hundreds of thousands of dollars in stocks, consulting contracts and research funding.
Evidence?

If true I would have some concerns. But nevertheless, the science should speak for itself.
 
Evidence?

If true I would have some concerns. But nevertheless, the science should speak for itself.

I found this site http://weeksmd.com/?page_id=402 via a search so I can't vouch for it, but it claims the report that it reproduces was government issued. It's dated June 15, 2000 and the information matches what I found when I was investigating back in 98 and 99.
"The CDC routinely grants waivers from conflict of interest rules to every member of its advisory committee.

§ CDC Advisory Committee members who are not allowed to vote on certain recommendations due to financial conflicts of interest are allowed to participate in committee deliberations and advocate specific positions.

§ The Chairman of the CDC’s advisory committee until very recently owned 600 shares of stock in Merck, a pharmaceutical company with an active vaccine division.

§ Members of the CDC’s advisory Committee often fill out incomplete financial disclosure statements, and are not required to provide the missing information by CDC ethics officials.

§ Four out of eight CDC advisory committee members who voted to approve guidelines for the rotavirus vaccine in June 1998 had financial ties to pharmaceutical companies that were developing different versions of the vaccine.

§ 3 out of 5 FDA advisory committee members who voted to approve the rotavirus vaccine in December 1997 had financial ties to pharmaceutical companies that were developing different versions of the vaccine

I don't know how much conflict of interest exists on it today, but this is what I was finding when I investigated and got soured on following their recommendations. As far as the science speaking for itself, I addressed that earlier. Science has no voice.
 
Last edited:
Not a dodge, just a realization the only reasonable people in this discussion who tend to favour the few vaccinations I question are HC and Deetee.

The fastest way to get someone to stop listening to you is treat them like an idiot. If this was the objective then you, EotE and Linda have excelled.
If I thought you were an idiot I wouldn't waste so much time talking to you. And, I have said repeatedly that you are not.

You missed my point while you were sulking about your feelings getting hurt. What I was trying to point out was that sometimes SOMETIMES SOMETIMES (got it) sometimes when a person does not have that broader view, it is easy to misinterpret some information.

In the case of the stats you posted about the zoster vs primary varicella, you are misinterpreting the meaning of the data.
 
Last edited:
Chicken pox, yes, on balance.
Flu - no, confine to selected target groups (I am not sure of the benefit in immunising all infants and would like to see clearer data)
Allow me to educate you on that flu vaccine one of these days. ;)

Thanks for the compliment, BTW.
 
Last edited:
The zoster vaccine is a different vaccine. You are aware of that I hope. In addition, there is already an entire population with latent varicella. What we do now with chicken pox vaccine is not going to affect the population this analysis was done on in a directly proportional way. Once again, your lack of broader information about zoster is affecting how you are interpreting this data.

You don't know that an increase in zoster cases from lack of natural exposure will represent as severe cases as the zoster cases here which result in severe disease. These people are getting shingles in spite of natural exposure. Their immune system then by definition is not managing to suppress the virus. I think that is one of the main pieces of information you keep ignoring.
 
Last edited:
I wish to point out that you don't know whether or not I agree with the ACIP, as I've never told you that I do.

Linda
That may be partly my fault. I said something in a couple posts then recognized I shouldn't be speaking for you.

My apologies.
 
It'll go on the WHO list along with measles and polio who have the funds to do this and have done so for smallpox despite competing demands for cash.
Right now the WHO recommendation is to vaccinate adults in countries with insufficient health care funds, not because of shingles but because of the risk of preventing childhood varicella only to increase the more dangerous adult primary varicella. In countries with adequate health care systems the vaccine is considered a reasonable choice. We can afford to save more lives.
 
Last edited:
Well, I can't help myself. I must present the case for flu vaccine in all children. I actually recommend the vaccine for everyone. Influenza is one of the most underestimated deadly infectious diseases we have.

Here's how the vaccine myths originated.

US officials predict a deadly flu could be beginning after the Swine Influenza A Outbreak, Fort Dix, New Jersey, 1976. Gerald Ford recommends everyone get a flu shot.

A couple (let me stress that) a couple cases of Guillain Barre Syndrome occur and early data suggests the flu vaccine might be associated with it. The press goes wild selling the story in their typically incorrect unscientific manner. The swine flu pandemic never materializes.

As public health should when new data suggests reevaluation of a vaccine, the vaccine recommendation was withdrawn. The press goes wild selling the story in their typically incorrect unscientific manner concocting a scandal because it sells news that the decision to vaccinate was wrong yadda yadda yadda...

Later data reanalysis shows the actual risk for GBS was partly attributed to increased surveillance and in only 2 years out of 30 was there an increase in GBS cases in flu vaccine recipients and that increase amounted to less than two excess cases of GBS per million doses of vaccine. BMJ summary
In a fact finding session earlier this month, the committee heard reviews of studies since 1976, when the numbers of vaccine associated cases of the syndrome stopped the US immunisation campaign against "swine flu." By then, 45 million people had been vaccinated. Ultimately, 581 cases of Guillain-Barré syndrome were reported that year, said the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in Atlanta, Georgia.

Initial studies suggested a causal relation between Guillain-Barré syndrome and the vaccine. Subsequently this was challenged on several grounds, including that the cases had been gathered by public health officers who had not been trained to diagnose the syndrome; reports were not based on medical records; some cases accepted by the CDC failed to meet the criteria for the syndrome; and the publicity over the possible link had biased the reporting of cases.

A later study, in 1991, reviewed all the cases of the syndrome in adults (whether vaccinated or unvaccinated) from two states. Using a standard definition of Guillain-Barré syndrome, it rejected 29% of them, said Dr Robert Chen of the CDC’s immunisation safety branch.

A 1998 study, summarised for the committee, showed that if there was a risk of flu vaccine causing the syndrome, it was extremely small. Dr Tamar Lasky from the University of Maryland School of Medicine put it at between 1 and 2 cases per million vaccinated persons a year.

So as a result of a legitimate public health decision making process and a cautious change with new data, the public perception of the facts promulgated by the news media selling of a product (scandal and fear) was grossly distorted. And the public health officials also subject to political influence became shy to reverse the influenza vaccine caution.

The vaccine was conservatively recommended only for specific high risk groups. This led to only producing enough vaccine for limited use.

In addition, public perception of flu has been distorted because most people either think flu is similar to a mild URI, or they have even less of a clue and believe flu is a gastrointestinal virus causing minor nausea and vomiting aka the 'stomach flu'. And public perception of the flu vaccine is that it causes flu symptoms making it silly to get a vaccine to prevent a minor illness while the vaccine causes the same symptoms. This of course is totally erroneous and stems from the fact that we give flu vaccine when common viral URIs are occurring in the community and people believe that the temporal association between vaccine and unrelated illness is indeed evidence of a causal relationship. And there are a few misc. myths scattered about such as getting the vaccine means your lifetime immunity is weakened.

Now that we have a lot more data on the actual low risk of serious events following influenza vaccine, the public health recommendation has been widening the target groups but with consideration that the vaccine supply is not going to ramp up to vaccinate whole populations in a single season. And, public health is trying to make sure there is evidence for the recommendations so research is ongoing as well. One doesn't see whole populations studied in a single season either.

There are a number of things to consider here in deciding everyone should get flu shots. The biggest drawback is you need an annual vaccine. It is a luxury. If I were worried about justifying the cost in a national health insurance country, I'd offer it to people who were not in target groups at their expense until the data was in to justify the cost/benefit expenditure. I do think the data is beginning to show that vaccinating everyone decreases the influenza burden in high risk patients especially the elderly in sufficient numbers to reach that cost/benefit threshold.

But as far as recommending it on a medical risk/benefit basis, that's a no brainer. The vaccine is by far safer than the disease. And the morbidity and mortality of influenza is tremendous. Just because one is not in an identified risk group is no reason to feel safe. Influenza kills a number of otherwise healthy people every year. Even providers, because of the years of the conservative vaccine recommendations, are under the misconception influenza is only dangerous to the already infirm. Those of us in the infectious disease field know better.

And now there is a new risk of influenza emerging. MRSA USA300 strain which has become the dominant cause of community acquired drug resistant staph infections has also begun showing up more and more as invasive disease. Coupled with influenza, we are seeing an increase in fatalities in healthy people from secondary MRSA pneumonia following influenza.

I want myself and my own child vaccinated for flu every year and I'm not going to make a different recommendation for my patients. I know why the ACIP is conservative in this case and I can't justify limiting recommendations for my patients based on public health and political decision factors. In this case I have a more liberal recommendation based on the risk/benefit basis. I am less concerned about production shortages though when there was a vaccine shortage, I followed the public health rules.

Influenza is a deadly disease. Influenza vaccine is safe and relatively effective.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom