Well, I can't help myself. I must present the case for flu vaccine in all children. I actually recommend the vaccine for everyone. Influenza is one of the most underestimated deadly infectious diseases we have.
Here's how the vaccine myths originated.
US officials predict a deadly flu could be beginning after the
Swine Influenza A Outbreak, Fort Dix, New Jersey, 1976. Gerald Ford recommends everyone get a flu shot.
A couple (let me stress that) a couple cases of Guillain Barre Syndrome occur and early data suggests the flu vaccine might be associated with it. The press goes wild selling the story in their typically incorrect unscientific manner. The swine flu pandemic never materializes.
As public health should when new data suggests reevaluation of a vaccine, the vaccine recommendation was withdrawn. The press goes wild selling the story in their typically incorrect unscientific manner concocting a scandal because it sells news that the decision to vaccinate was wrong yadda yadda yadda...
Later data reanalysis shows the actual risk for GBS was partly attributed to increased surveillance and in only 2 years out of 30 was there an increase in GBS cases in flu vaccine recipients and that increase amounted to less than two excess cases of GBS per million doses of vaccine.
BMJ summary
In a fact finding session earlier this month, the committee heard reviews of studies since 1976, when the numbers of vaccine associated cases of the syndrome stopped the US immunisation campaign against "swine flu." By then, 45 million people had been vaccinated. Ultimately, 581 cases of Guillain-Barré syndrome were reported that year, said the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in Atlanta, Georgia.
Initial studies suggested a causal relation between Guillain-Barré syndrome and the vaccine. Subsequently this was challenged on several grounds, including that the cases had been gathered by public health officers who had not been trained to diagnose the syndrome; reports were not based on medical records; some cases accepted by the CDC failed to meet the criteria for the syndrome; and the publicity over the possible link had biased the reporting of cases.
A later study, in 1991, reviewed all the cases of the syndrome in adults (whether vaccinated or unvaccinated) from two states. Using a standard definition of Guillain-Barré syndrome, it rejected 29% of them, said Dr Robert Chen of the CDC’s immunisation safety branch.
A 1998 study, summarised for the committee, showed that if there was a risk of flu vaccine causing the syndrome, it was extremely small. Dr Tamar Lasky from the University of Maryland School of Medicine put it at between 1 and 2 cases per million vaccinated persons a year.
So as a result of a legitimate public health decision making process and a cautious change with new data, the public perception of the facts promulgated by the news media selling of a product (scandal and fear) was grossly distorted. And the public health officials also subject to political influence became shy to reverse the influenza vaccine caution.
The vaccine was conservatively recommended only for specific high risk groups. This led to only producing enough vaccine for limited use.
In addition, public perception of flu has been distorted because most people either think flu is similar to a mild URI, or they have even less of a clue and believe flu is a gastrointestinal virus causing minor nausea and vomiting aka the 'stomach flu'. And public perception of the flu vaccine is that it causes flu symptoms making it silly to get a vaccine to prevent a minor illness while the vaccine causes the same symptoms. This of course is totally erroneous and stems from the fact that we give flu vaccine when common viral URIs are occurring in the community and people believe that the temporal association between vaccine and unrelated illness is indeed evidence of a causal relationship. And there are a few misc. myths scattered about such as getting the vaccine means your lifetime immunity is weakened.
Now that we have a lot more data on the actual low risk of serious events following influenza vaccine, the public health recommendation has been widening the target groups but with consideration that the vaccine supply is not going to ramp up to vaccinate whole populations in a single season. And, public health is trying to make sure there is evidence for the recommendations so research is ongoing as well. One doesn't see whole populations studied in a single season either.
There are a number of things to consider here in deciding everyone should get flu shots. The biggest drawback is you need an annual vaccine. It is a luxury. If I were worried about justifying the cost in a national health insurance country, I'd offer it to people who were not in target groups at their expense until the data was in to justify the cost/benefit expenditure. I do think the data is beginning to show that vaccinating everyone decreases the influenza burden in high risk patients especially the elderly in sufficient numbers to reach that cost/benefit threshold.
But as far as recommending it on a medical risk/benefit basis, that's a no brainer. The vaccine is by far safer than the disease. And the morbidity and mortality of influenza is tremendous. Just because one is not in an identified risk group is no reason to feel safe. Influenza kills a number of otherwise healthy people every year. Even providers, because of the years of the conservative vaccine recommendations, are under the misconception influenza is only dangerous to the already infirm. Those of us in the infectious disease field know better.
And now there is a new risk of influenza emerging. MRSA USA300 strain which has become the dominant cause of community acquired drug resistant staph infections has also begun showing up more and more as invasive disease. Coupled with influenza, we are seeing an increase in fatalities in healthy people from secondary MRSA pneumonia following influenza.
I want myself and my own child vaccinated for flu every year and I'm not going to make a different recommendation for my patients. I know why the ACIP is conservative in this case and I can't justify limiting recommendations for my patients based on public health and political decision factors. In this case I have a more liberal recommendation based on the risk/benefit basis. I am less concerned about production shortages though when there was a vaccine shortage, I followed the public health rules.
Influenza is a deadly disease. Influenza vaccine is safe and relatively effective.