autism-vaccine link?

I think it would be an interesting experiment to let groups of experts from different fields review the same evidence and see if they reach the same conclusion.
Again, you make the unsupportable claim that the non-experts would have a superior opinion and/or analytical skills to the experts in a field.

It's just as well we are generally not as unique as we like to think we are. EBM would be a lot less useful if individual responses to treatment could not be inferred from studies of populations.

.....
And here you conclude that EBM is dependent upon bias and opinion. Wouldn't EBM be more dependent upon the skills of the provider to correctly assess and interpret the evidence?

It's a wonder we can treat a bladder infection properly, what with all this bias interfering with our objectivity. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I thought this would be the most appropriate recent thread in which to post this.

There is an March 21 New York Times article on parents rejecting vaccination for their children: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/21/us/21vaccine.html
It's getting harder and harder to find that, "skip this ad" button. ;)

From the article:
......Alexandra Stewart, director of the Epidemiology of U.S. Immunization Law project at George Washington University, said many of these parents are influenced by misinformation obtained from Web sites that oppose vaccination.

“The autism debate has convinced these parents to refuse vaccines to the detriment of their own children as well as the community,” Ms. Stewart said.

While many parents meet deep resistance and even hostility from pediatricians when they choose to delay, space or reject vaccines, they are often able to find doctors who support their choice.
Both hostile and laissez faire attitudes of physicians contribute to the problem.


“I do think vaccines help with the public health and helping prevent the occasional fatality,” said Dr. Bob Sears, the son of the well-known child-care author by the same name, who practices pediatrics in San Clemente. Roughly 20 percent of his patients do not vaccinate, Dr. Sears said, and another 20 percent partially vaccinate.

“I don’t think it is such a critical public health issue that we should force parents into it,” Dr. Sears said. “I don’t lecture the parents or try to change their mind; if they flat out tell me they understand the risks I feel that I should be very respectful of their decision.”...[out of sequence]...There is substantial evidence that communities with pools of unvaccinated clusters risk infecting a broad community that includes people who have been inoculated.
Not a critical public health issue? Ignorant doctor. Here in this outbreak alone a couple kids suffered a preventable potentially fatal disease because other parents made an irresponsible choice.

BTW, Ivor, tell me this DR has the same biases you claim all Dr's get from med school and internships.


...According to a 2006 article in The Journal of The American Medical Association, exemption rates of 15 percent to 18 percent have been found in Ashland, Ore., and Vashon, Wash. In California, where the statewide rate is about 1.5 percent, some counties were as high as 10 percent to 19 percent of kindergartners.

In the San Diego measles outbreak, four of the cases, including the first one, came from a single charter school, and 17 children stayed home during the outbreak to avoid contracting the illness.
Our local Vashon Is. cluster is well known to those of us around here in the infectious disease field.
 
Last edited:
I get the impression that many of the unvaccinated are children of reasonably well educated parents. Is this because the parents think they know how to interpret the data or think they know more than the experts. I expect I have got that wrong, but are there any studies that have investigated this?
 
I get the impression that many of the unvaccinated are children of reasonably well educated parents. Is this because the parents think they know how to interpret the data or think they know more than the experts. I expect I have got that wrong, but are there any studies that have investigated this?
There are a number of well educated people in the anti-vaxer group. Sadly, education level is no assurance of critical thinking skills. That is one of the things I think we really need to address as promoters of skepticism and critical thinking.

The original autism-vaccine link myth began with a physician who believed an MMR caused his daughter's autism. And the couple who fought for the compensation for their daughter's autism in this thread included a neurologist dad and a nurse/attorney mom. They believe chelation therapy would help and were convinced that getting 9 vaccines at once was the problem despite the lack of evidence for either.

The fact that educated parents fall for the woo is also testimony to the fact that the woo promoters have slick arguments.

Factors Associated With Refusal of Childhood Vaccines Among Parents of School-aged Children
Parents of exempt children were significantly more likely than parents of vaccinated children to report low perceived vaccine safety and efficacy, a low level of trust in the government, and low perceived susceptibility to and severity of vaccine-preventable diseases. Parents of exempt children were significantly less likely to report confidence in medical, public health, and government sources for vaccine information and were more likely to report confidence in alternative medicine professionals than parents of vaccinated children....

...A higher proportion of parents of exempt children were older than the median (aged 36-40 years) compared with parents of vaccinated children (44.0% vs 35.9%, respectively; P = .02). Parents of exempt children were more likely to have higher than the median level of education (some college) than parents of vaccinated children (57.6% vs 47.2%, respectively; P<.02). Parents of exempt children and parents of vaccinated children were similar in terms of income (40.6% vs 41.1% with a family income greater than the median [$60 000-$69 999], respectively; P = .90) and race (94.5% white vs 91.7% white, respectively; P = .14).
 
Last edited:
skeptigirl said:
I think it would be an interesting experiment to let groups of experts from different fields review the same evidence and see if they reach the same conclusion.
Again, you make the unsupportable claim that the non-experts would have a superior opinion and/or analytical skills to the experts in a field.

I'm struggling to see where in the above statement I made those claims.

It's just as well we are generally not as unique as we like to think we are. EBM would be a lot less useful if individual responses to treatment could not be inferred from studies of populations.

.....
And here you conclude that EBM is dependent upon bias and opinion.

No, here I conclude EBM is dependent on assuming the observed characteristics of groups are useful in the treatment of individuals.

Wouldn't EBM be more dependent upon the skills of the provider to correctly assess and interpret the evidence?

Not really. So long as providers can follow an algorithm, EBM works fine. For example, Google and PubMed do a surprisingly good job of diagnosing difficult cases and they're just dumb search engines.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

BTW, Ivor, tell me this DR has the same biases you claim all Dr's get from med school and internships.

<snip>

How large a fraction of doctors share his point of view?

How many of this fraction are members on the ACIP?

Do you think an expert who shares his point of view would have an equal chance of getting on the ACIP compared to an expert who agrees with the majority opinion?
 
Ivor, you may be interested in the minutes of the JCVI's pneumococcal subgroup from this year.

They inform us that vaccine immunity may be as short as 1 year.
One important finding from the enhanced pneumococcal surveillance carried out by the HPA is that the duration of protection from the vaccine is shorter than previously estimated. Vaccine effectiveness falls significantly after one year following vaccination. Previous studies had estimated protection for around 5 years.

However, I am doubtful that this information can be trusted. The members of the panel are all doctors, and have "ties" to the big farmer. therefore they are all biased, and are twisting their data to show that pneumococcal vaccine is even more effective than generally appreciated, so they can get extra dosh from their share portfolios.

Hang on........ errr..
There seems to be a problem with my logic and reasoning somewhere there.....
Umm.... Someone help me out please?
 
Last edited:
Ivor, you may be interested in the minutes of the JCVI's pneumococcal subgroup from this year.

They inform us that vaccine immunity may be as short as 1 year.

However, I am doubtful that this information can be trusted. The members of the panel are all doctors, and have "ties" to the big farmer. therefore they are all biased, and are twisting their data to show that pneumococcal vaccine is even more effective than generally appreciated, so they can get extra dosh from their share portfolios.

Hang on........ errr..
There seems to be a problem with my logic and reasoning somewhere there.....
Umm.... Someone help me out please?


I think you've outsmarted your self here, DT. :D

They all have ties to big pharma and therefore it is in their self-interests to recommend that their patients have the pneumococcal vaccine every year - which can be conveniently given together with the annual flu vaccine! ;)

BJ
 
Anyway...

It seems that everyone here is concerned about possible conflicts of interest when there is a connection between those making the decisions and the pharmaceutical industry. There is just disagreement about how serious that conflict of interest is. For Ivor and Beth it makes them distrust the whole decision making process, but leaves them with no other option than to read up on it themselves and make their own decision. For others, like skeptigirl and Linda, this personal solution is flawed because neither Ivor nor Beth have the expertise to come to reliable conclusions about vaccines no matter how much they read up on the subject. In addition Skeptigirl and Linda believe that the distrust Ivor and Beth have in the process is the result of grossly overestimating the effect the conflict of interest has in the decision making process.

I agree that Ivor and Beth are not in a position to make reliable decisions about vaccines based on what they can glean from their reading of the material. On the other hand, I wonder whether the influence of the pharmaceutical industry is being downplayed a little by Skeptigirl and Linda.

My question is: It is possible to keep the pharmaceutical industry completely at arms length? Sure, they are a necessary source of information about vaccines, but should they be in on the actual decision making process? Is it possible to have experts on vaccines who have no connection at all with the pharmaceutical industry? A related concern is the financial relationship between the pharmaceutical industry and those medical professionals who are responsible for keeping other medical professionals up to date via CME activities.

BJ
 
Last edited:
Because Ivor continues to run round the mulberry bush, his arguments here are not what they appear.

So once again, let's review the train of thought.

We have organized groups of experts like the ACIP making vaccine recommendations in a public forum (they meet twice a year in a public session and publish details of the how and why they came to their recommendations).

After those recommendations are made there is ample opportunity for anyone to challenge a finding.

In addition to hundreds of thousands of health care providers and research scientists who read the published materials there are similar public health bodies reviewing the material independently for a number of other countries' own recommendations as well as the WHO reviews the materials for their own recommendations for countries with differing levels of public health infrastructure.

Generally speaking, countries with similar economic levels eventually adopt strikingly similar recommendations and only differ in when vaccine regimens are initially implemented. "Let Mikey try it" does occur on occasion and that is not a bad thing.

Despite this very large informal and formal peer review, we have Ivor who initially told Linda that the reviews by all the medical professionals were less than reliable because of shared biases within the medical community. And therein began the mulberry bush dash.

Linda (originally@Beth):You have dismissed over and over and over again the possibility that experts provide any oversight to the ACIP. In order to support this claim (which on the face appears ridiculous to anyone who is familiar with what opinionated jerks doctors are) there must be something preventing us from doing so. What is it? Bias alone won't do it unless we all have the exact same biases.

Ivor:You do share many of the same biases and you club together when you perceive an outside threat. All individuals who are members of a group do.
ETA: How often do you see one doctor criticizing another in public? Most professional organizations would consider this sort of behaviour as "bringing the profession into disrepute".


Deetee:The people who "club together" do so when there is a commonality of purpose. Being members of a widely disparate medical profession is no indication of this. God forbid, I have even been known to have commonality of purpose with people outside the medical profession.
Doctors are often extremely critical of each other. They sometimes do what you see on "House", but only behind closed doors, since to do so in public would have immediate medico-legal repercussions. I have been very critical of doctors (remember skeptidoc?) and medical woo homeopaths and CAM merchants. Publicly I have engaged and criticised medically-qualified HIV denialists and antivaccinationists in outlets such as the electronic BMJ and other journals (but one must always be careful not to overstep thresholds for libel). It always helps to criticise their opinions and conclusions rather than spray around ad homs....


Ivor@Deetee: Yes, individuals can belong to more than one group, and there can be overlapping sub-groups within larger groups.
Hey, you ought to see an electronic engineer looking over another engineer's code or circuit diagram.
I think there is a difference between criticising those who hold fringe views such as HIV denialists and believers in CAM, and those who hold more mainstream (but still questionable) views. The former are seen as traitors by the group and are often criticised more harshly than members of out-groups.
Would I be correct in thinking there is still quite a strict hierarchy / pecking order in medicine?


Skep: Care to define the parameters of this "club"?
And as for reluctance to criticize individuals, you'll find quite the opposite when it comes to criticizing the group or research findings. And you are talking about criticizing someone's practice decision. Do you think peer review of medical research is that ineffective? If so, you need to look again.


Ivor@Skep: I haven't studied it in depth, but one obvious parameter would be a set of shared values.
A group has both formal and informal regulatory mechanisms to maintain order, cohesion and status of members within it.
From Social Psychology 4th ed. Michael A Hogg. Graham M. Vaughan p 309:
Many, if not most, groups are also structured in terms of two kinds of members:

1) Those who best embody the group's attributes - core members who are highly prototypical of the group.

2) Those who do not - marginal or non-prototypical members.

Highly prototypical members often have significant influence over the group and may occupy leadership roles. Marginal members are an entirely different story.

Research by Marques and his colleagues shows that marginal members are often disliked by the group, and treated as 'black sheep' (Marques & Paez, 1994) or deviants. People whose attributes place them on the boundary between ingroup and outgroup are actually disliked more if they are ingroup members than outgroup members - they are treated as deviants or even traitors. One reason for this is that they threaten the integrity of group norms by undermining normative consensus within the group (e.g. Marques, Abrams, & Serodio, 2001). Paradoxically, for this very reason, marginal members serve an important function for groups - groups, particularly their leaders, can engage in a rhetoric of vilification and exclusion of marginal members precisely to throw into stark relief what the group is and what the group is not.

Skep: Ivor, I didn't need a definition of a "club". I needed your definition of who you were including in the imagined conspiracy you expressed in the following sentence, "You do share many of the same biases and you club together when you perceive an outside threat"

Ivor: Who said anything about a conspiracy? Do you think people behave differently when operating from a group perspective opposed to an individual one? I do.
To answer your question, I think the ACIP could be considered a sub-group within the larger group of medical professionals.


Skep: It never ceases to amaze me how people can maintain false beliefs by simply flitting from one concept to another when that concept is challenged.
Let's backtrack here, Ivor. Here is the exchange:
Linda: "Bias alone won't do it unless we all have the exact same biases."

Ivor: "You do share many of the same biases and you club together when you perceive an outside threat. All individuals who are members of a group do.
ETA: How often do you see one doctor criticizing another in public? Most professional organizations would consider this sort of behaviour as "bringing the profession into disrepute".

Your rationale for why the ACIP and any vaccine medical recommendations did not have effective oversight was due to these shared biases. I ask you, who is in this homogeneous group with shared biases? Because I think that is incredibly short sighted. There are waaaay too many scientists involved in vaccine research and medical providers who take the time to look at the research for there to be any homogeneous group with shared biases as you assert.
So I ask you again, who is this homogeneous group with shared biases that you are referring to? Define the parameters for inclusion in this group and explain how within the entire medical profession there are only these clones?


Ivor: I did not say medical professionals were a homogeneous group, just that they share a significant set of common values (or biases).
The first step in the filtering process would be being accepted into medical school by passing a clinical aptitude test and an interview. Next would be actually graduating from medical school. Then you have the initiation rite of being made* to work ridiculously long hours for a few years. Finally, you have the hierarchy of the medical system to keep subordinate members of the group in check and teach them how to behave if they want to progress within it.


Skep: I didn't go to medical school. I went to nursing school, as did a few thousand other advanced practice nurses. All biologists didn't go to medical school. All microbiologists and virologists didn't go to med school. Not all med schools in all countries are the same. Not all doctors who did go to medical school have the same biases.
Your have an imaginary view of health care researchers and providers that is invalid.


Ivor: Hmmm. Let's have a look at which group dominates the ACIP:

http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/recs/acip/members.htm

I count ten MDs, one JD (he must be a member at the same tennis club) and one NP (presumably there to clean up any mess, provide sexual favours to the doctors and make the coffee).
The vast majority of the other names on that page have MD tagged on the end of them too.


Deetee: Beth distrusts them because they are doctors who may have "financial ties" to industry.
Seems like you distrust them just because they are doctors.
ETA:
Potential conflict of interest: Author of the above post has MD after his name.


Ivor: Not 'distrust', just expect their recommendations to be influenced by the values doctors share having gone through a filtering process of medical school and post-graduate training to become doctors.

Skep: Round and round the mulberry bush,
skeptigirl chased the weasel.....
We know who is on the ACIP Ivor. We are talking about the entire medical community of providers and researchers who have been surprisingly silent in noticing much is wrong with the ACIP conclusions.
God that must be an amazing brain washing process.
I didn't go to med school Ivor. How did I become a clone?


Ivor: It's both selection bias and "brain washing", also known as education and experience.
Clone is your word, not mine, BTW.
Wouldn't you find it more amazing if people who train and often work closely together did *not* have a set of common values/biases?


Skep: So education and experience are really a disadvantage in evaluating a source?
And I don't know where you work, but I consider myself quite unique in the work settings I practice in.


Ivor: I think it would be an interesting experiment to let groups of experts from different fields review the same evidence and see if they reach the same conclusion.
It's just as well we are generally not as unique as we like to think we are. EBM would be a lot less useful if individual responses to treatment could not be inferred from studies of populations.
That's not to say we do not have lots of idiosyncratic features, just we also tend to share lots of things in common with groups we are members of.


Skep: Again, you make the unsupportable claim that the non-experts would have a superior opinion and/or analytical skills to the experts in a field.
And here you conclude that EBM is dependent upon bias and opinion. Wouldn't EBM be more dependent upon the skills of the provider to correctly assess and interpret the evidence?
It's a wonder we can treat a bladder infection properly, what with all this bias interfering with our objectivity. :rolleyes:
Ignorant doctor. Here in this outbreak alone a couple kids suffered a preventable potentially fatal disease because other parents made an irresponsible choice.
BTW, Ivor, tell me this DR has the same biases you claim all Dr's get from med school and internships.


Ivor: I'm struggling to see where in the above statement I made those claims.
No, here I conclude EBM is dependent on assuming the observed characteristics of groups are useful in the treatment of individuals.
So long as providers can follow an algorithm, EBM works fine. For example, Google and PubMed do a surprisingly good job of diagnosing difficult cases and they're just dumb search engines.
How large a fraction of doctors share his point of view?
How many of this fraction are members on the ACIP?
Do you think an expert who shares his point of view would have an equal chance of getting on the ACIP compared to an expert who agrees with the majority opinion?


Deetee: [snip] However, I am doubtful that this information can be trusted. The members of the panel are all doctors, and have "ties" to the big farmer. therefore they are all biased, and are twisting their data to show that pneumococcal vaccine is even more effective than generally appreciated, so they can get extra dosh from their share portfolios.
Hang on........ errr..
There seems to be a problem with my logic and reasoning somewhere there.....
Umm.... Someone help me out please?



Notice here how Ivor switches back and forth between his original point, the entire medical community who would oversee the ACIP decisions is biased to some degree, and a straw man, the ACIP itself has group bias. (I suspect this is an unconscious effort on Ivor's part, and it owes itself to the natural rationalization mental reflex we all share to some degree.)

How can we challenge the obvious, that the ACIP is a small group of people with similar backgrounds and can be expected to have some group think influences? No need to, it is a straw man.

The actual argument is that there is a natural very large informal and formal peer review of the completely transparent ACIP recommendations. The group is huge and diverse. They do not all have the same biases. They do not all come from medical schools. They have expertise. They read the research themselves. If the ACIP recommendations were unduly influenced by drug companies it would be extremely hard to conceal that fact. Because everyone looking at the recommendations does not have public health priority goals. Some have third party payer goals when scrutinizing the recommendations.

In all that, the ACIP has an excellent reputation and more than sufficient oversight of a transparent function of making vaccine recommendations.


Then there is Beth's criticism which I will give brief mention for completeness of the post:

Beth complains she cannot trust the decisions of the ACIP because 8 years ago a Congressional investigation revealed the members were getting cushy exemptions for their ties to the drug companies. But upon closer exam the worst offender listed had less than $50,000 dollars in Merck stock, worth only $25,000 with today's stock price. This is not an amount any intelligent person would risk their 6 figure job over and I'm pretty sure 6 figures represents the salaries members of the ACIP would be earning. The findings of the hearing as far as I can tell was that no significant problems were actually occurring but getting lax on the rules ran the risk of damaging public perception of the integrity of the group. I can only assume the CDC likely agreed and tightened up the ship.
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, I wonder whether the influence of the pharmaceutical industry is being downplayed a little by Skeptigirl and Linda.

My question is: It is possible to keep the pharmaceutical industry completely at arms length? Sure, they are a necessary source of information about vaccines, but should they be in on the actual decision making process? Is it possible to have experts on vaccines who have no connection at all with the pharmaceutical industry? A related concern is the financial relationship between the pharmaceutical industry and those medical professionals who are responsible for keeping other medical professionals up to date via CME activities.

BJ

I have been a vocal critic of the relationship between the pharmaceutical industry and medical professionals. However, I was hoping to get beyond a fairly simplistic characterization of that relationship as 'bad'. Is it really reasonable to assert that when your employer accepts research funds from a pharmaceutical company, that makes you an employee of that pharmaceutical company? The brush which has been used to tar all ACIP members is so broad that it cannot fail to paint all those people whose opinion we would otherwise desire. For example, it would certainly include me (not saying that I'm someone you would trust, but I am someone that would represent Beth's views), even though I (and the institution I am most closely involved with) fall at the (overly) restrictive end of the spectrum when it comes to relations with pharmaceutical companies. Because very little distinction has been made between different types of relationships, what sorts of effects can be reasonably expected, and the role of bias (other than its use as an ad hominem argument), there are no acceptable answers to your questions.

Linda
 
<snip>

Notice here how Ivor switches back and forth between his original point, the entire medical community who would oversee the ACIP decisions is biased to some degree, and a straw man, the ACIP itself has group bias. (I suspect this is an unconscious effort on Ivor's part, and it owes itself to the natural rationalization mental reflex we all share to some degree.)

How can we challenge the obvious, that the ACIP is a small group of people with similar backgrounds and can be expected to have some group think influences? No need to, it is a straw man.

How is it a straw man? Peer review by people with similar biases and values is not going to balance out their recommendations.

The actual argument is that there is a natural very large informal and formal peer review of the completely transparent ACIP recommendations.

Yes, there is. It's biased.

The group is huge and diverse.

Huge maybe. It is not diverse, unless you're using a definition of 'diverse' I'm unfamiliar with.

They do not all have the same biases.

I never said they did. I said they share values/biases.

They do not all come from medical schools.

Most train and work closely with each other.

They have expertise. They read the research themselves.

Yes, they have related expertise. No doubt they've read much of the same research and books too during their education, training and work.

If the ACIP recommendations were unduly influenced by drug companies it would be extremely hard to conceal that fact.

Not my argument.

Because everyone looking at the recommendations does not have public health priority goals. Some have third party payer goals when scrutinizing the recommendations.

Many of those third-party payers either spend their budgets for this year or they run the risk of having it cut next year. Some may even be interested in 'empire building'.

In all that, the ACIP has an excellent reputation and more than sufficient oversight of a transparent function of making vaccine recommendations.

<snip>

If only they would stop at just recommending vaccination.
 
Ivor, you may be interested in the minutes of the JCVI's pneumococcal subgroup from this year.

They inform us that vaccine immunity may be as short as 1 year.

However, I am doubtful that this information can be trusted. The members of the panel are all doctors, and have "ties" to the big farmer. therefore they are all biased, and are twisting their data to show that pneumococcal vaccine is even more effective than generally appreciated, so they can get extra dosh from their share portfolios.

Hang on........ errr..
There seems to be a problem with my logic and reasoning somewhere there.....
Umm.... Someone help me out please?

:D

Remind me: Where did I say doctors are, in general, deliberately dishonest?
 
It's a straw man, Ivor because I am not arguing that the ACIP has no collective bias.

I'm am refuting your absurd claim that the entire medical community from researchers to practitioners has the same bias.

More later, Happy Easter Bunnies to you all, back on Monday.
 
Last edited:
:D

Remind me: Where did I say doctors are, in general, deliberately dishonest?
Where did I say you said that?
I thought you'd be interested because of our previous debate about pneumovax.;)

Mind you, as BJ said, my attempt at irony failed because the JCVI will undoubtedly, as he says, now recommend yearly boosters!:rolleyes:
 
I started another thread without seeing this one

Much of this has been addressed in the comments above but here is my post entire:

I had a bit of a bone to pick with Randi about his recent comment about this controversy in SWIFT, so I emailed him and he replied quite promptly, to point out I said he said something he didn't say. Point taken. But, I thought I would start a thread so I can get some feedback from the Forum.

I was quite taken aback by his celebration of Wyeth Pharmaceuticals' recent court victory in vaccine/autism case as a victory for scientific skepticism. I have not read the decision so I don't have any other details beyond Randi's comments, but I'll look into it.
But since when is a court decision proof of anything other than a jury's willingness to agree with a lawyer?
I don't think this proves anything at all. Let me explain what I mean.

I am a little bit puzzled by the level of animosity towards this line of inquiry (whether vaccines can cause autism). It seems to me to be a quite reasonable one.

Whenever a population has a sudden and continuing increase in the incidence rate of a disease, whether or not people may have a genetic susceptibility to that disease, to ignore the possibility, and indeed, the likelihood, of an environmental factor would not be good science at all. This has been borne out time and again, with many different diseases.

A good example is the endometrial cancer epidemic in the early 1970s, which was proven to everyone's satisfaction to be caused by estrogen containing birth-control pills, which became massively popular in the mid-1960s. The sudden spike in incidence rates in California caught the attention of public health researchers.

They knew that the likelihood of a toxicological (carcinogenic) insult to the organ in question was high, in the past that has explained many such spikes in incidence rates. In other words, an environmental factor. An obvious culprit here, for a cancer of a female sex organ, was the female hormone estrogen. They (by they I mean Donald Austin et al) proposed a study, and requested, and got, health records from Kaiser California, but when he went to the manufacturer of the birth control pills to obtain prescription data of these drugs, they refused to give him the data. Coincidentally (or not, you decide) the manufacturer was Wyeth.

Anyway, they got the data eventually despite Wyeth's reluctance, did the study, and the association was so strong as to be incontrovertible. Several other studies done around the same time supported his findings.
The whole thing was founded on an educated guess, but no one today questions the causal association.

Now, endometrial cancer certainly has a genetic component. People are at increased risk if they have a family history, which is a good marker for genetic susceptibility. Deliver to that population a known carcinogen via a drug, and the genetically susceptible people are going to contract the disease at a higher rate.

So, of course some women who never took estrogen got endometrial cancer, and many who took estrogen did not. This does not change the fact of the causal association.
To say the case is "genetic" is only partly true, and, when used to imply that there is no other cause, somewhat intellectually dishonest, in my opinion.

Ditto for lung cancer and smoking. As I recall, "it's genetic" was one defense the tobacco companies used.

To me, the vaccine/autism question does not seem like hysterical hand-wringing of distraught parents, or ambulance chasing by lawyers, it seems like a very reasonable avenue of inquiry.

The fact is, we do not have adequate data, and we still don't know if vaccines might play a role in the onset of autistic spectrum disorder.

This is a very muddy question, since the time of diagnosis and the vaccine schedule are contemporaneous. But, that is precisely why it seems to me like a good place to start looking. The only way to tell is to do a well-designed case-control study, using the medical records of the kids. That has not happened.

What has happened, is that the IOM, and the California Dept. of Health and Human Services, issued reports that basically said "We did not see a decrease in the rate of autism diagnosis following the date when Wyeth told us it stopped putting mercury in the vaccine."

Well, this is a step in the right direction, but hardly definitive.

And then we have the Verstraaten paper, which, though peer-reviewed, has been widely criticized for it's methodological short-comings. That's it.

(Please forgive me for not citing this stuff properly, it's the weekend, I am supposed to be relaxing.)

Many researchers around the country have proposed well-designed case-control studies to get more information about this possible link. Not surprisingly (to me anyway), they were denied access to the vaccination records.

This is not hysterical hand-wringing, I repeat. It is sound reasoning.
We have a sudden, continuing increase in neurodevelopmental disorders.
Genetic susceptibility being well-considered, there is a very strong likelihood of an environmental factor, due to the sharp and steady increase in recent years. What that may be, I don't know, but investigating a known neurotoxin, mercury, present in the environment, at the time of the onset, seems like a good place to start.

What exactly is illogical about investigating that more thoroughly? How is that woo in any way? I submit to you that it is not. I also submit, that a retrospective measurement of incidence rates, without a control group or medical records, is almost utterly meaningless. Perhaps vaccine link theory of causation would be borne out by further study, perhaps not.

The point is, we need to do several well-designed case-control studies before we start saying we know it's not this or that.

This might also be a situation where we might not want to dismiss out of hand the parents' anecdotal evidence. By itself, it is scientifically worthless, but collected in a controlled fashion and weighed in the context of other evidence, this kind of data can be helpful in disease control.

For example consider the cholera outbreak in London, the advent of modern epidemiology. How did doctors determine who drank from which well? They simply asked. No one had to prove which well they drank from, it was not necessary. That is no different from asking a parent when they first noticed a difference in their child's behavior.

All I mean is, in context, if you have thousands of parents swearing that their child was fine until they got these shots, I don't think you can entirely dismiss that. It is another piece of the puzzle, no more and no less.

At any rate, these questions of public health are never very nicely cut and dried. Of course, Wyeth does not want to be on the hook for billions of dollars in compensation. The CDC will want to proceed VERY slowly, to avoid any disruption in the current mandated vaccine program.
If everyone suddenly stopped vaccinating their kids, the adverse public health impact might far outweigh anything currently being experienced by these unfortunate families.

These would be horrible choices to make, weighing the public good against an individual's harm, and I am glad I do not have to make them.

But please, extend a little skepticism to the claim currently being offered by Wyeth and the CDC, that the current absence of evidence is conclusive proof of no harm. That is ridiculous. I am not suggesting anyone here would think that, but I'm constantly surprised by the tone of people's reaction to this controversial issue.

As I said, I do not know the details of this recent court decision mentioned by Randi, but I posted in my comment the recent concession by the Dept. of Justice in a similar case in U.S. Court of Claims. Wyeth is not a defendant, it is the vaccine injury compensation program. Still, if we're matching court decisions, I've got one too.

I should add, regarding my example of the endometrial cancer epidemic, that the incidence rates DID fall after the doctors stopped prescribing the drug. This was the definitive proof the researchers needed to declare a causal association.
But remember, this was borne out by rigorous scrutiny, with all of the information; medical records and prescription data. That has not yet been done for thimerosal and autism, and now it is looking like it will never be done, since the CDC considers the case closed based on the current state of knowledge. I don't think that is scientifically sound, albeit from a layperson's perspective.

Anyway, that's all I wanted to say. Thanks for reading.

Lots of fodder for the nit-pickers. Bring on the pain, I can take it!
 
I have been a vocal critic of the relationship between the pharmaceutical industry and medical professionals.


Down here medical professionals tend to get pretty defensive at the mention of pharmaceutrical company influence. ABC radio did a piece some weeks back about how pharmaceutical company sponsors get to choose the speakers at medical professionals' CME (continuing medical education) activities. You get the impression form listening to the medical professionals who attend these functions that it is not possible for them to be influenced. I suppose the pharmaceutical company does all this out of the knidness of their hearts. :rolleyes:

However, I was hoping to get beyond a fairly simplistic characterization of that relationship as 'bad'. Is it really reasonable to assert that when your employer accepts research funds from a pharmaceutical company, that makes you an employee of that pharmaceutical company? The brush which has been used to tar all ACIP members is so broad that it cannot fail to paint all those people whose opinion we would otherwise desire. For example, it would certainly include me (not saying that I'm someone you would trust, but I am someone that would represent Beth's views), even though I (and the institution I am most closely involved with) fall at the (overly) restrictive end of the spectrum when it comes to relations with pharmaceutical companies.


In the above example, certain specialists who had been speakers at the CME events later felt it necessary to defend themselves, saying that they did not even know that the pharmaceutical company put their name forward. Which is sort of beside the point. Others had actually been tutored by the pharmaceutical company on how to present their talk!
But, yes, it is a matter of degree.

Because very little distinction has been made between different types of relationships, what sorts of effects can be reasonably expected, and the role of bias (other than its use as an ad hominem argument), there are no acceptable answers to your questions.


Are there really no acceptable answers?
What about some fairly strictly enforced quidelines/restrictions by the covering professional organisations? Might this not provide provide some useful answers to the problem of pharmaceutical company influence?
And I'm still wondering why it is not possible to keep pharmaceutical companies at arms length. Instead of pharmaceutical companies paying directly, the money could be put into a pool (raised as a levy?) and distributed by an independant committee for whatever they determine is the best use of resources.
 
http://www.slate.com/id/2123647/

http://www.time.com/time/printout/0,8816,1576829,00.html

Do keep in mind that the rates of autism are still lower than the rates for other diseases, like schizophrenia. The overwhelming evidence points to changing diagnosis criteria as the cause in the rise of autism rates in this century, and for putting other things under the autism umbrella that used to stand alone.

The rest of the evidence shows no reason for vaccines to cause autism, none whatsoever.

Rising evidence shows genetic anomalies are to blame. Genetic anomalies that are present no matter if the child ever came into any kind of contact with vaccines. The autism rates are the same amongst vaccinated and unvaccinated children.

So, who cares what role pharmaceutical companies play? Independent studies have refuted an autism connection to vaccine over and over again.

I'd personally prefer pharmaceutical companies to play a large role in vaccine recommendations as they have the information and personnel required to make vital decisions about them. They tend to want to make sure their stuff works right considering the money that goes into making, testing, and distributing them, and that includes to their own children. We're lucky that any even want to be involved with vaccines anymore at all considering all the headaches it brings. They have rules they have to follow, unlike the quacks that go on and on about miraculous food supplements.

The freakish double standards and hypocrisy reserved for people who actually have to know how their stuff works is insane compared to the leeway quacks have. It really boggles the mind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom