Beth
Philosopher
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2004
- Messages
- 5,598
Right, whether or not other people follow the recommendations blindly doesn't imply they are faulty. But the fact that you and Linda agree might be due to the evidence or it might be due to you having the similar biases to those on the committee. I can't tell the difference.But Linda and I find the ACIP recommendations are evidence based. So if we are not following the ACIP blindly, then the fact some pediatricians are doesn't imply the recommendations are faulty.
I am not discounting your conclusion. I am discounting your willingness to objectively examine evidence contrary to your established opinion. You seem very loath to change your opinion on any subject you discuss on this forum.So you, like Ivor, make the claim I am simply discounting your conclusions.
Okay. The 'significance', as you put it, is a subjective evaluation. You're entitled to hold a different opinion.I propose that I have not been persuaded by your arguments and supporting evidence. To claim I have not given your arguments consideration because I didn't find them convincing is simply not correct. I am not asking you to repost the connections the ACIP members had with the pharmaceutical companies. I never disputed the relationships. I disputed the significance you claimed.
Okay. I look at the rotovirus recall, the recommendations for infants to be vaccinated against STD's, the continuing expansion of groups advised to get the seasonal vaccine as being being supportive of that possibility. Not proof, but evidence that could be interpreted that way. If you choose not to interpret the evidence that way, that's your perrogative.Connections or not, the ACIP decision making process is transparent. As such, if the industry influenced the recommendation, then the evidence would reveal that.
I'm not trying to persuade you or Linda that I am right. I'm simply trying to explain my concerns and thought processes as to why I don't follow along with all recommendations blindly. For some reason, I was under the impression that you professionals were interested in understanding why intelligent people who have researched the issue to some extent don't always buy into the ACIP recommendations in toto.
There is a reason there are regulations against such individuals serving on those committees, a reason waivers must be applied for and made part of the public record. It's very difficult to show the effect of bias beyond reasonable doubt; takes a lot of research, mountains of data, and statistical analysis that has not, to the best of my knowledge, been done. In fact, such analysis is typically only done when a lawsuit is being prepared.I asked you for some corroboration that other professionals or scientists or anyone with sufficient education on the topic agreed that they also detected bias in the ACIP recommendations. It is one thing to claim there could be bias, but another to show there is bias. You have not shown that there is any actual bias. You have only shown that some individual members of the ACIP have also been employed by pharmaceutical companies from time to time.
OTOH, having such biases part of the open records systems allows people like me to find out about it and make our decisions including that information. So I have. If you choose to think that they are uninfluenced by their connections, that's fine. You might well be right. Maybe such influences don't affect their decisions at all. But I can't easily tell one way or the other so the end result is the same - I can't trust their recommendations.