autism-vaccine link?

But Linda and I find the ACIP recommendations are evidence based. So if we are not following the ACIP blindly, then the fact some pediatricians are doesn't imply the recommendations are faulty.
Right, whether or not other people follow the recommendations blindly doesn't imply they are faulty. But the fact that you and Linda agree might be due to the evidence or it might be due to you having the similar biases to those on the committee. I can't tell the difference.
So you, like Ivor, make the claim I am simply discounting your conclusions.
I am not discounting your conclusion. I am discounting your willingness to objectively examine evidence contrary to your established opinion. You seem very loath to change your opinion on any subject you discuss on this forum.
I propose that I have not been persuaded by your arguments and supporting evidence. To claim I have not given your arguments consideration because I didn't find them convincing is simply not correct. I am not asking you to repost the connections the ACIP members had with the pharmaceutical companies. I never disputed the relationships. I disputed the significance you claimed.
Okay. The 'significance', as you put it, is a subjective evaluation. You're entitled to hold a different opinion.
Connections or not, the ACIP decision making process is transparent. As such, if the industry influenced the recommendation, then the evidence would reveal that.
Okay. I look at the rotovirus recall, the recommendations for infants to be vaccinated against STD's, the continuing expansion of groups advised to get the seasonal vaccine as being being supportive of that possibility. Not proof, but evidence that could be interpreted that way. If you choose not to interpret the evidence that way, that's your perrogative.

I'm not trying to persuade you or Linda that I am right. I'm simply trying to explain my concerns and thought processes as to why I don't follow along with all recommendations blindly. For some reason, I was under the impression that you professionals were interested in understanding why intelligent people who have researched the issue to some extent don't always buy into the ACIP recommendations in toto.
I asked you for some corroboration that other professionals or scientists or anyone with sufficient education on the topic agreed that they also detected bias in the ACIP recommendations. It is one thing to claim there could be bias, but another to show there is bias. You have not shown that there is any actual bias. You have only shown that some individual members of the ACIP have also been employed by pharmaceutical companies from time to time.
There is a reason there are regulations against such individuals serving on those committees, a reason waivers must be applied for and made part of the public record. It's very difficult to show the effect of bias beyond reasonable doubt; takes a lot of research, mountains of data, and statistical analysis that has not, to the best of my knowledge, been done. In fact, such analysis is typically only done when a lawsuit is being prepared.

OTOH, having such biases part of the open records systems allows people like me to find out about it and make our decisions including that information. So I have. If you choose to think that they are uninfluenced by their connections, that's fine. You might well be right. Maybe such influences don't affect their decisions at all. But I can't easily tell one way or the other so the end result is the same - I can't trust their recommendations.
 
One reason why Skeptigirl may be loath to change her conclusions is because she may have come to them due to strong evidence, to which your claims cannot compare. Another may be that she's believing blindly and ignoring what you can offer, but I lean toward her having access to more evidence than do you.
 
Last edited:
I have seen skeptigirl and linda, more than anyone else, closely analyze and then expertly take apart Ivor's and Beth's "evidences" in a lot of detail.

For them to claim that Linda and Skeptigirl just don't agree or are just biased is complete nonsense.

Plain hypocritical, really.
 
Beth, I wonder if you wouldn't look at the lack of logic in your post.

You are simply speculating that I am not assessing the evidence but you have nothing to base that on except the fact I have not drawn the same conclusions you have drawn. You cannot support your assertion the ACIP is biased by ties to drug companies so rather than presenting evidence of that assertion you simply claim (as Ivor did in his cop out) that we are discounting you as a person and you claim that if you were to present evidence it would be summarily dismissed regardless of the merits.

Did it ever dawn on you that you might just be wrong?

... I'm simply trying to explain my concerns and thought processes as to why I don't follow along with all recommendations blindly. For some reason, I was under the impression that you professionals were interested in understanding why intelligent people who have researched the issue to some extent don't always buy into the ACIP recommendations in toto.
I was very interested and did look at the information you presented on this and I had not been aware of it previously and I appreciated your posting it.

... There is a reason there are regulations against such individuals serving on those committees, a reason waivers must be applied for and made part of the public record. It's very difficult to show the effect of bias beyond reasonable doubt; takes a lot of research, mountains of data, and statistical analysis that has not, to the best of my knowledge, been done. In fact, such analysis is typically only done when a lawsuit is being prepared.
With thousands of health care professionals and scientists looking at the ACIP work and their conclusions, that "lot of research" is done on an ongoing basis. Then you have the equivalent groups in other countries reevaluating those recommendations and making independent decisions to accept or reject those recommendations for their own countries.

...OTOH, having such biases part of the open records systems allows people like me to find out about it and make our decisions including that information. So I have. If you choose to think that they are uninfluenced by their connections, that's fine. You might well be right. Maybe such influences don't affect their decisions at all. But I can't easily tell one way or the other so the end result is the same - I can't trust their recommendations.
This is where the problem comes in that everyone else who looks at those ACIP recommendations are invisible to people such as yourself. All the rest of the medical profession and medical researchers are simply discounted as either, not bothering to look at the supporting material the ACIP used (that would be your claim that those professionals "blindly follow" the recommendations while you of course did not), as being duped by the drug companies (while you have that special ability to not be duped because you lack the medical community's bias), or as simply not existing (as if the ACIP were the only organization making public health recommendations).

Yet you claim to recognize there are individual providers who care about evidence based medicine. Then you take it back and claim they are biased, then you say you recognize they take the time to investigate, then you say they are incompetent because they are biased, then they are not...... and on and on you go switching your cognitively dissonant position of recognizing all health care professionals are not incompetent or blindly following biased recommendations but they must be because you have drawn the inconsistent conclusion that bias causes those health care professionals to not reach the same conclusion you have reached.

What special knowledge do you have, Beth, what skills do you possess, that allow you to see something others do not see?
 
Last edited:
Beth, what skills do you possess, that allow you to see something others do not see?


A third eye, paranoia really, about Big Pharma poisoning us all with needless concoctions, and so says other internet sites too.
 
Nice dodge of the issues I brought up, Ivor. If you can't address them, pretend you have and pretend your arguments were ignored.

Not a dodge, just a realization the only reasonable people in this discussion who tend to favour the few vaccinations I question are HC and Deetee.

The fastest way to get someone to stop listening to you is treat them like an idiot. If this was the objective then you, EotE and Linda have excelled.
 
DeeTee, just out of interest do you think the NHS should be providing chickenpox vaccines to all infants and flu jabs to everyone, or are you happy with their current policy? (You are in the UK, right? Or have I got you hopelessly confused with someone else?).
 
Busy medical people often rely on others to do their work for them in weighing up the evidence. Hence some may "blindly" follow the ACIP recommendations. This is entirely appropriate. Such sources of information are valid and strongly evidence-based.

No-one is claiming they are perfect, or that they do not need to evolve as more information is available, or that there are not some possible conflicts of interest, but plenty of others have objectively looked at the totality of evidence and concluded that recommendations like this represent best clinical practice. There will always be the potential for bias anywhere, but the science speaks for itself here.

It appears Beth cannot trust the ACIP's recommendations, not because she distrusts the evidence but because she does not know if there is any bias or conflict of interest in those responsible for formulating them. That says it all for me. I guess we can only conclude Beth never trusts anyone or anything, and finds life impossible to live because she is unable to decide anything.

These arguments are not dissimilar to those we hear sometimes from HIV deniers or creationists. They are fond of pointing to potential uncertainties or minor imperfections in a specific subspecialist area, in the hope that they can convince themselves (and or others) that this automatically negates the entire premise. I am reminded of those who, having studied the aerodynamics/mechanics of bumble bees, decided that there was no way they could fly, or those who use inconsistent radiometric values in a Burgess shale rock stratum to prove the world is only 6000 years old.

When intelligent people make up their minds about something, it requires a lot of evidence to change their viewpoint. Skeptigirl has made up her mind, and I think she has done so by looking at all the evidence (not just the bits she has chosen to see) and I think she possesses the ability to critically weigh up that evidence. Silly Green Monkey already said as much. If some here seem forthright and uncompromising I doubt this is because it is in our nature to be so, but because we strive to do our best for people and thirst for knowledge and truth, and we have made it our vocation to repel the constant challenges to what is a valid scientific position that we know (from unequivocal evidence) can saves lives. And some challenges, as anyone on the JREF will appreciate, are so bizarre or lacking in common sense that it is no wonder that a sense of frusrtation sets in.

Using the creationist comparison again, it matters little to me that there is someone who thinks the world is 6000 years old (other than a profound sense of dismay at the way science is regarded and how little critical skills seem to matter to our educationalists). Yet with vaccines, the direct consequences of this thinking are visible to those like skeptigirl and me. These are literally life and death decisions, and like her I get fed up with having to deal with the results of peoples' stupid decisions.

Aluta continua!
 
Last edited:
DeeTee, just out of interest do you think the NHS should be providing chickenpox vaccines to all infants and flu jabs to everyone, or are you happy with their current policy? (You are in the UK, right? Or have I got you hopelessly confused with someone else?).
Chicken pox, yes, on balance.
Flu - no, confine to selected target groups (I am not sure of the benefit in immunising all infants and would like to see clearer data)
 
Last edited:
What makes you doubt the increase in the incidence of HZ?
Not doubting it, I just think that on balance immunisation will do more good than harm. Give it to the adults too, though I know that you know that I know this makes it less cost effective.
 
You are simply speculating that I am not assessing the evidence but you have nothing to base that on except the fact I have not drawn the same conclusions you have drawn.
I am not speculating that you have not assessed the evidence. I think you have. Nor do I necessarily think you are wrong in your assessment of vaccines.
You cannot support your assertion the ACIP is biased by ties to drug companies so rather than presenting evidence of that assertion
I have presented evidence of their ties to drug companies. It’s part of the public record. It’s assumed such ties lead to bias, thus the requirement for waivers to the conflict of interest requirements in order for them to serve on the committee. For some reason, the medical profession seems to think they are above being influenced by financial ties and such waivers are standard operating procedure for this committee. I happen to think they are human and as prone to bias for that reason as all other humans.
Did it ever dawn on you that you might just be wrong?
I’m frequently wrong, but I seem to spend most of my discussions with you correcting your misinterpretations and inferences regarding what I’m trying to communicate. I rarely get to reconsider my actual opinions as you almost never discuss them, preferring to take offense at inferred insults.
I was very interested and did look at the information you presented on this and I had not been aware of it previously and I appreciated your posting it.
Thank you. I hope you can understand why I consider this information important enough that it completely undermines their credibility and is the reason I have lost faith in the committees decisions.
With thousands of health care professionals and scientists looking at the ACIP work and their conclusions, that "lot of research" is done on an ongoing basis. Then you have the equivalent groups in other countries reevaluating those recommendations and making independent decisions to accept or reject those recommendations for their own countries.
I mentioned that I think those are a good way to examine such decisions. Unfortunately, It was not an option that was available to me when I was making decisions for my children. It was difficult enough for me to research my countries decisions.
This is where the problem comes in that everyone else who looks at those ACIP recommendations are invisible to people such as yourself. All the rest of the medical profession and medical researchers are simply discounted as either, not bothering to look at the supporting material the ACIP used (that would be your claim that those professionals "blindly follow" the recommendations while you of course did not), as being duped by the drug companies (while you have that special ability to not be duped because you lack the medical community's bias), or as simply not existing (as if the ACIP were the only organization making public health recommendations).
I mentioned that I think some pediatricians blindly follow the recommendations. I don’t think this is inappropriate. Pediatricians have a lot to do and vaccines are only one small part of their practice and the information they need to stay up to date on.

As far as being ‘duped’ by drug companies, I did not say that nor do I think that. Bias is not synonymous with being duped. This is an example of you taking offense at something you've inferred from what I've said.
Yet you claim to recognize there are individual providers who care about evidence based medicine. Then you take it back and claim they are biased,
These are not mutually exclusive terms. I think both are true.
then you say you recognize they take the time to investigate, then you say they are incompetent because they are biased, then they are not......
I said they were biased. I didn't say they were incompetent. Bias does NOT imply incompentence.
and on and on you go switching your cognitively dissonant position of recognizing all health care professionals are not incompetent or blindly following biased recommendations but they must be because you have drawn the inconsistent conclusion that bias causes those health care professionals to not reach the same conclusion you have reached.
No cognitive dissonance at all for me. I think that I might draw the same conclusions they have if I had the same biases and background. I don’t think people are incompetent just because they have come to a different conclusion that I have. That particular belief is yours, not mine.
What special knowledge do you have, Beth, what skills do you possess, that allow you to see something others do not see?
I have my own personal background, which is, of course, different that anyone else’s. I’m spent a reasonable amount of time for a lay person to study the issues. I’m entitled to develop my own opinion based on that. I’m more than willing to allow you yours. Why do you assail all those who hold different opinions on the matter?
 
You are not being treated like an idiot Ivor. You clearly aren't in most areas (at least I hope you learn from the discussion in other areas). You're just being called on ignoring the evaluation of your opinion of what you think is evidence. If you can't stand the heat, then stay out of the kitchen. Or just learn from what others have graciously tried to tell you.
 
Not doubting it, I just think that on balance immunisation will do more good than harm. Give it to the adults too, though I know that you know that I know this makes it less cost effective.

Do you know by how much?

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/...ez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum

The burden of illness from herpes zoster (HZ) and postherpetic neuralgia (PHN) in the Australian community is high. The incidence and severity of HZ and PHN increase with age in association with a progressive decline in cell-mediated immunity to varicella-zoster virus (VZV). Antiviral medications (valaciclovir, famciclovir, aciclovir) have been shown to be effective in reducing much but not all of the morbidity associated with HZ and PHN, but are consistently underprescribed in Australia. Zoster-associated pain should be treated early and aggressively, as it is more difficult to treat once established. Clinicians should be proactive in their follow-up of individuals at high risk of developing PHN, and refer patients to a specialist pain clinic earlier, rather than later. A live, attenuated VZV vaccine (Oka/Merck strain, Zostavax [Merck Sharp & Dohme]) has proven to be efficacious in reducing the incidence of and morbidity associated with HZ and PHN in older adults. The vaccine's efficacy has been shown to persist for at least 4 years, but is likely to last a lot longer. Ongoing surveillance will determine the duration of protection and whether a booster dose is required. Clinicians should consider recommending the vaccine, which can be safely administered at the same time as the inactivated influenza vaccine, to all immunocompetent patients aged 60 years or older. Clinicians should refer to the Australian immunisation handbook for advice on the use of the live vaccine in immunosuppressed individuals.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/...nel.Pubmed_DiscoveryPanel.Pubmed_Discovery_RA

BACKGROUND: The Shingles Prevention Study showed that a varicella-zoster virus (VZV) vaccine administered to adults 60 years of age or older reduced the incidence of herpes zoster from 11.12 to 5.42 cases per 1000 person-years. Median follow-up was 3.1 years, and relative risk reduction was 51.3% (95% CI, 44.2% to 57.6%). OBJECTIVE: To assess the extent to which clinical and cost variables influence the cost-effectiveness of VZV vaccination for preventing herpes zoster in immunocompetent older adults. DESIGN: Decision theoretical model. DATA SOURCES: English-language data published to March 2006 identified from MEDLINE on herpes zoster rates, vaccine effectiveness, quality of life, medical resource use, and unit costs. Target Population: Immunocompetent adults 60 years of age or older with a history of VZV infection. Time Horizon: Lifetime. Perspective: U.S. societal. Interventions: Varicella-zoster virus vaccination versus no vaccination. Outcome Measures: Incremental quality-adjusted survival and cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) gained. Results of Base-Case Analysis: By reducing incidence and severity of herpes zoster, vaccination can increase quality-adjusted survival by 0.6 day compared with no vaccination. One scenario in which vaccination costs less than 100,000 dollars per QALY gained is when 1) the unit cost of vaccination is less than 200 dollars, 2) the age at vaccination is less than 70 years, and 3) the duration of vaccine efficacy is more than 30 years. Results of Sensitivity Analysis: Vaccination would be more cost-effective in "younger" older adults (age 60 to 64 years) than in "older" older adults (age > or =80 years). Longer life expectancy and a higher level of vaccine efficacy offset a lower risk for herpes zoster in the younger group. Other factors influencing cost-effectiveness include quality-of-life adjustments for acute zoster, unit cost of the vaccine, risk for herpes zoster, and duration of vaccine efficacy. LIMITATIONS: The effectiveness of VZV vaccination remains uncertain beyond the median 3.1-year duration of follow-up in the Shingles Prevention Study. CONCLUSIONS: Varicella-zoster virus vaccination to prevent herpes zoster in older adults would increase QALYs compared with no vaccination. Resolution of uncertainties about the average quality-of-life effects of acute zoster and the duration of vaccine efficacy is needed to better determine the cost-effectiveness of zoster vaccination in older adults.

Check out figure 2 on page 6.
 
Busy medical people often rely on others to do their work for them in weighing up the evidence. Hence some may "blindly" follow the ACIP recommendations. This is entirely appropriate.
I agree with this much.
No-one is claiming they are perfect, or that they do not need to evolve as more information is available, or that there are not some possible conflicts of interest, but plenty of others have objectively looked at the totality of evidence and concluded that recommendations like this represent best clinical practice. There will always be the potential for bias anywhere, but the science speaks for itself here.
I agree with this except for that last clause. The science does not speak for itself here. To non-medical Americans, the ACIP committee speaks for science here. That’s why I consider it so important to have an unbiased committee making the recommendations.
It appears Beth cannot trust the ACIP's recommendations, not because she distrusts the evidence but because she does not know if there is any bias or conflict of interest in those responsible for formulating them.
I know that many of the members of that committee have financial ties to vaccine manufactures. When I first investigated the matter, it was 100% of the members. It's not unusual for it to be more than half. 10% I could live with easily. 20% would cause me discomfort. More than that, I don't feel I can trust their recommendations.
That says it all for me. I guess we can only conclude Beth never trusts anyone or anything, and finds life impossible to live because she is unable to decide anything.
My, but that's a thoughtful and intelligent evidence based conclusion - NOT. :rolleyes:
These arguments are not dissimilar to those we hear sometimes from HIV deniers or creationists.
So being concerned about the fact that many of the people who decide vaccination policy for my country have established conflicts of interest in making those decisions is equivalent to denying HIV or evolution? No bias on your part or defensiveness of your profession showing up here. This is just another one of your evidence based conclusions. Shall I assume all your conclusions are equally valid and evidence-based?
 
Beth said:
That's not quite what I meant. How you ask or present each of those questions can lead to a different answer (like whether you present it as a gain or a loss). For example, if you need $80,000 for your child's college education, pointing out that banking your child's blood will allow you to save $60,000 toward the cost or banking your child's blood means you lose $20,000 of your college fund will get you two different answers. Which one is correct?

Neither. I’m quite aware that presentation of material can make a huge difference. But is there any legitimate reason for you, as a doctor, to put any sort of spin on the information?

Well, it depends upon whether you think I have a duty to help someone reach a decision that accurately reflects their own values, or whether my duty is to present information in a way that provides no assistance.

What's wrong with simply saying “banking your child's blood may be a lifesaving measure if he/she later comes down with leukemia or another disease that might be cured with their own stem cells. The risk of that is XX%. The cost is $20,000.”

There's nothing wrong with that if you don't care whether or not they make a decision that reflects the one they would make with complete knowledge (which as you pointed out earlier, we necessarily do not have). One can pre-suppose that providing people with the information you gave them above leads them to make good decisions. But that supposition ignores that the evidence says otherwise. People rarely make purely rational assessments of risk. We heavily discount future benefits or risks, we give up large benefits to avoid small risks, we worry about risks that are out of our control while downplaying those we can control, we overestimate ourselves and underestimate others so "it won't happen to me", and on and on. Anti-smoking campaigns, for example, attempt to counteract these problems by providing a more direct experience of future risks or by thwarting your ability to pretend that you (unlike everyone else) won't be subject to the addictive effects. You may consider that dishonest, but I consider it dishonest to ignore how people really think and pretend to some idealized version.

Why ‘spin’ the information you give them at all. What’s wrong with a neutral presentation?

I honestly would like to believe that a neutral presentation is the best approach - it is the approach that I prefer. But considering the biases I mentioned earlier, I suspect that all a neutral presentation accomplishes is to reinforce those biases. I think that in order to actually allow someone to consider an issue in a neutral manner, some attempt has to be made to counteract those biases.

Now, Linda, I like to go back to a topic that was discussed previously. I’m going to quote some of our previous posts to try and make it coherent.
If we keep on pretending that this issue has anything to do with knowledge about vaccines or knowledge about who should or should not be considered credible, I think we are missing the boat.

I’d like to know what you do think the important issue is if it isn’t either of those two things.

I think the issue is that knowledge/information isn't used to determine who should or should not be considered credible

When you say this, isn’t that a combination of those two things?

I don't understand your question.

That's what I suspected. You used yourself as the 'gold standard' by which to assess the performance of the committee (without confirming the validity of that standard) and made assumptions which justified a decision you had already made. And this is pretty consistent with our understanding of how people make and justify their decisions.
How exactly do you think I should evaluate the quality of their decisions rather than researching things for myself and seeing how often I agree with them? If I'm not going to use myself as the 'gold standard', what am I supposed to use to evaluate the quality of their decisions? You? Some other stranger on the internet?
You never actually answered this question. I would appreciate it hearing how you think others should evaluate the quality of policy decisions made by experts? This, btw, is a question that applies to far more things than vaccine policy. Our society has some very complicated mechanisms for setting policy. How can an individual who is not an expert in the area evaluate when a policy setting committee is making good choices and when they are not?

I don't know that I can help you. I'm not comfortable using myself as a gold-standard. I will admit to a little jealousy at how others seem to have the confidence to blithely act on what they know, but I tend to be more aware of what I don't know and wonder if that could make all the difference. That's not to say that I'm not suspicious of anything coming from 'experts' or a 'committee', for all the reasons you outlined earlier, but I obviously deal with my suspicions quite differently from you. Knowing that I am ignorant and likely to be biased, I can't place as much weight as you do on my own inclinations.

What's wrong with letting people who know what they're doing do the job?
Now we're back to the credibility issue. The people who know what they're doing do not necessarily have the best interests of me and my family in mind when they make their decisions. In fact, as I've read through their justifications for their decisions, it's clear they don't.
Ivan has given a pretty good summation of what he has done for research. You think it is insufficient. I have explained why I don’t feel I can trust the ACIP recommendations. You haven’t really commented much on that.

Because it's clear to me that you went looking for reasons to justify your decision and stopped once you found them, without bothering to confirm whether or not they applied. You've dismissed the contributions of the professional process, and you are most confident in your own evaluation (to the exclusion of most anything else it seems). I didn't comment because I don't think I can say anything that would be interest to you, considering that most of that is foreign to my own way of thinking.

So what exactly do you think people should do in terms of making these decisions for themselves. Do you think it’s best for everyone to just trust unquestioningly what the medical authorities tell them they should do? If not, what do you think is the best approach for people to take when making such decisions? If you think people should inform themselves of the benefits and risks before making a decision, one consequence of that approach is that some people will research the risks and benefits and come to different conclusions than you.

It seems to me that that's the point of asking for advice from someone with expertise.

Linda
 
How should evidence be presented to the members of the ACIP to counteract their biases rather than reinforcing them?
 
Right, whether or not other people follow the recommendations blindly doesn't imply they are faulty. But the fact that you and Linda agree might be due to the evidence or it might be due to you having the similar biases to those on the committee. I can't tell the difference.

I wish to point out that you don't know whether or not I agree with the ACIP, as I've never told you that I do.

Linda
 
There is the benefit of eradication to consider which to my mind would be worthwhile.

Compared to what?

What conditions are you prepared to *not* have treated so VZV can be eradicated?

You want the latest drugs for Breast Cancer, Parkinson's disease or Alzheimer's? Sorry, can't afford them. We spent the budget on chickenpox so Tarquin and Jemima's Mummy and Daddy can be good little worker bees and don't have to take a week or two off work to look after their kids.:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom