autism-vaccine link?

Yeah, ain't it strange how things get updated and improved over 20+ years in evidence-based medicine. Real surprise there. *rolls eyes*

Go take some classes people!
 
Ok.

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/rr5606a1.htm?s_cid=rr5606a1_e

By my count (comparing like for like topics) I make it: ACIP ~169 studies vs. Cochrane: 163 studies.

Why are you confining it to like topics?

Quite a lot. Let me rephrase the question: How am I to decide between experts like Tom Jefferson et al., who appear to think the current seasonal influenza vaccination policy in the US is based more on optimism and hope than the evidence, and the ACIP?

What I think I've done is looked at their respective conclusions, interpretations and sources of evidence, as well as reading discussions of articles in medical journals.

Do you think this is a reasonable strategy for trying to decide which experts are more likely to be correct? If not, how should I be making up my mind on these kind of issues?

Why are trying to decide?

Well if you're trying to get people to do something (such as have a seasonal flu vaccination), conformity is a better result than compliance.

I'm not trying to get you to do anything.

Linda
 
How exactlly do you think I should evaluate the quality of their decisions rather than researching things for myself and seeing how often I agree with them? If I'm not going to use myself as the 'gold standard', what am I supposed to use to evaluate the quality of their decisions? You? Some other stranger on the internet?

What's wrong with letting people who know what they're doing do the job?

What's wrong with presenting the relevant information and allowing people to form their own conclusions rather than trying to 'make them feel they would have come to the same conclusion'? The former recognizes that different people have different criteria they use to make decisions while the second is pure manipulation. Why should I trust someone who trying to manipulate me to get me to do what they want me to do?

I'm not talking about manipulation. I'm talking about recognizing that the way we present information influences whether or not a particular decision reflects reality. For example, in a study looking at how well physicians estimate the likelihood of a specific diagnosis when given the results of a diagnostic test, the accuracy varied greatly depending upon how the information was presented. Is it manipulation to choose to present it in such a way as to improve accuracy?

For the example I gave earlier about cord blood, which was the right way to present the choice and which was deceitful manipulation?

Linda
 
Why are you confining it to like topics?

Because many of the ACIP references are to do with issues not directly related to vaccine effectiveness, such as safety and implementation.

Why are trying to decide?

One reason is because of the differences between US and UK vaccination policies. With different recommendations from the ACIP in the US and the JCVI in the UK, I'm interested in trying to discover why the differences exist.

I'm not trying to get you to do anything.

Linda

Ah-ha! Reverse psychology wont not work on me!;)
 
What's wrong with letting people who know what they're doing do the job?
Now we're back to the credibility issue. The people who know what they're doing do not necessarily have the best interests of me and my family in mind when they make their decisions. In fact, as I've read through their justifications for their decisions, it's clear they don't.

I'm not talking about manipulation. I'm talking about recognizing that the way we present information influences whether or not a particular decision reflects reality. For example, in a study looking at how well physicians estimate the likelihood of a specific diagnosis when given the results of a diagnostic test, the accuracy varied greatly depending upon how the information was presented. Is it manipulation to choose to present it in such a way as to improve accuracy?

That isn't what you said originally. I was responding to the comment you made
presenting information in a way that allows someone to feel like they would have come to the same conclusion
I call that manipulation.
For the example I gave earlier about cord blood, which was the right way to present the choice and which was deceitful manipulation?
Linda

What was wrong with the way you presented it, giving both sides? It is a matter is risk (what if your child needs those stem cells someday?) versus the cost, which includes not having the money available for other things, like college savings or a home in a better neighborhood. What is more important to those people making the decision? What is their child's risk of leukemia? What is their financial situation? What are their priorities? What is wrong with presenting them with as much relevant information as they need/want to make a decision and letting them make their own choice based on thier own hopes and fears for their child?
 
Ivor you are rehashing the same crap you already hashed. You ignored the expert medical opinions explaining to you your lack of understanding on this issue. This is one of your problems, when things are explained to you and supported you can't let go of your previously formed convictions

If boosting from external exposure to natural varicella is a lost benefit after mass vaccination, then vaccine boosters are by far superior to allowing the fatalities and serious long term effects from infection to continue.

Do you even remember how this conversation went before? You prefer to let a few people die and others suffer serious consequences from varicella because you personally think the cost benefit ratio of vaccination isn't worth it. Remember, Ivor?

Zoster IS varicella. Claiming zoster is somehow more dangerous is patently absurd. You are saying we should let an early infection kill people to prevent a later recurrence in survivors. All because you don't think the cost of vaccination will save enough lives to be worth what you as a taxpayer might have to spend.

The best use of health care dollars and resources can only be looked at in total. You can't look at vaccines alone and ignore a million dollars spent on a single premature infant. If you want to address the per capita cost of lives saved with vaccines then you have to look at the per capita cost of lives saved with each health care intervention. Vaccines would not top the list in per capita costs per lives saved.

If you want to make the absurd argument that varicella vaccine is dangerous because zoster might increase, then you need to go to med school because all the explaining to you that you are not making a valid argument is lost in your ignorance about the two stages of the same infection. It is not a matter of your sources. They only support the cost benefit argument. It is a matter of your ignorance about chicken pox and zoster.
 
Really?...
Because he questions the current policy in the US of promoting the flu vaccine for practically everybody.

http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/333/7574/912

Gap between policy and evidence

The large gap between policy and what the data tell us (when rigorously assembled and evaluated) is surprising. The reasons for this situation are not clear and may be complex. The starting point is the potential confusion between influenza and influenza-like illness, when any case of illness resembling influenza is seen as real influenza, especially during peak periods of activity. Some surveillance systems report cases of influenza-like illness as influenza without further explanation. This confusion leads to a gross overestimation of the impact of influenza, unrealistic expectations of the performance of vaccines, and spurious certainty of our ability to predict viral circulation and impact. The consequences are seen in the impractical advice given by public bodies on thresholds of the incidence of influenza-like illness at which influenza specific interventions (antivirals) should be used.20

The confusion between influenza and influenza-like illness is compounded by the lack of accurate and fast surveillance systems that can tell what viruses are circulating in a setting or community within a short time frame, and after the "season" is finished give an accurate picture of what went on to enable better forecasting of future trends.21 Accurate surveillance must be based on a properly worked out sampling system for cases of influenza-like illness that meet set criteria, with accurate and quick feedback of a presumptive microbiological diagnosis. Without this, we cannot generalise from random sampling.

Another reason may be "availability creep." In their efforts to deal with, or be seen to deal with, policy makers favour intervention with what is available—registered influenza vaccines. A similar philosophy is the "we have to make decisions and cannot wait to have perfect data" approach. This attitude may have an altruistic basis but has two important consequences. Firstly, it uses up resources that could be invested in a proper evaluation of influenza vaccines or on other health interventions of proven effectiveness. Secondly, the inception of a vaccination campaign seems to preclude the assessment of a vaccine through placebo controlled randomised trials on ethical grounds. Far from being unethical, however, such trials are desperately needed and we should invest in them without delay. A further consequence is reliance on non-randomised studies once the campaign is under way. It is debatable whether these can contribute to our understanding of the effectiveness of vaccines. Ultimately non-randomised designs cannot answer questions on the effects of influenza vaccines.
Is he talking nonsense?
Yes. I don't know about the UK, this is from the BMJ, but I do know about the USA.

First, any professional looking at studies of ILI vs Influenza knows full well the difference. ILI is used as a measurable outcome because viral cultures on large segments of the population are not practical or necessary.

As far as good data to actually translate the disease burden, in the US we sample viral cultures from a very large number of sentinel sites and the % of ILI which is influenza as well as the typing of another subsample from the positive samples are done weekly from September through May.

All this guy is saying is he laments the less than perfect research that is actually done. His complaint that the current research is inadequate is grossly overstated.
 
Last edited:
Ivor you are rehashing the same crap you already hashed. You ignored the expert medical opinions explaining to you your lack of understanding on this issue. This is one of your problems, when things are explained to you and supported you can't let go of your previously formed convictions

If boosting from external exposure to natural varicella is a lost benefit after mass vaccination, then vaccine boosters are by far superior to allowing the fatalities and serious long term effects from infection to continue.

Do you even remember how this conversation went before? You prefer to let a few people die and others suffer serious consequences from varicella because you personally think the cost benefit ratio of vaccination isn't worth it. Remember, Ivor?

Zoster IS varicella. Claiming zoster is somehow more dangerous is patently absurd. You are saying we should let an early infection kill people to prevent a later recurrence in survivors. All because you don't think the cost of vaccination will save enough lives to be worth what you as a taxpayer might have to spend.

The best use of health care dollars and resources can only be looked at in total. You can't look at vaccines alone and ignore a million dollars spent on a single premature infant. If you want to address the per capita cost of lives saved with vaccines then you have to look at the per capita cost of lives saved with each health care intervention. Vaccines would not top the list in per capita costs per lives saved.

If you want to make the absurd argument that varicella vaccine is dangerous because zoster might increase, then you need to go to med school because all the explaining to you that you are not making a valid argument is lost in your ignorance about the two stages of the same infection. It is not a matter of your sources. They only support the cost benefit argument. It is a matter of your ignorance about chicken pox and zoster.

I am linking to epidemiological studies, performed by experts in their field.

I'm not interpreting the raw data; other experts are.

Yet somehow you see the data and interpretations of it experts (generally outside the US) are basing their decisions on as MY crap?

:boggled:

BTW, nice to see the patronising medical professional coming out. Is it a module you have to take, or do you acquire it automatically on qualifying from a medical school?
 
Ok.

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/rr5606a1.htm?s_cid=rr5606a1_e

By my count (comparing like for like topics) I make it: ACIP ~169 studies vs. Cochrane: 163 studies.
...
I cannot find the Cochrane link you refer to. I just reviewed the 3 Cochrane reviews on influenza vaccine in the elderly, healthy children and healthy adults, and they all found a positive benefit outcome or not enough data for some populations.

Here's an example of how to misread a Cochrane review:

http://www.cochrane.org/reviews/en/ab001269.html
Vaccines for preventing influenza in healthy adults

Jefferson TO, Rivetti D, Di Pietrantonj C, Rivetti A, Demicheli V
Summary
There is not enough evidence to decide whether routine vaccination to prevent influenza in healthy adults is effective

Influenza is a virus which causes symptoms of fever, headache, aches and pains, cough and runny noses. It can last for weeks and lead to serious illness, even death. It spreads easily and new strains develop regularly. The World Health Organization recommends each year which strains should be included in vaccinations for the forthcoming season. People considered at risk are offered vaccination to prevent complications and as a public health measure in many countries. The review of trials found vaccinations against influenza avoided 80% of cases at best (in those confirmed by laboratory tests, and using vaccines directed against circulating strains), but only 50% when the vaccine did not match, and 30% against influenza-like illness, in healthy adults. It did not change the number of people needing to go to hospital or take time off work. Some vaccines cause pain and redness at the site of injection, muscle ache, and other very rare serious harms such as transient paralysis.
"At best 80%"? That's bad? I think not. Even 50% reduction in disease burden is worthwhile.

30% decrease in ILI? Well, d'uh. ILIs include many non-flu infections.

Lost work and hospitalizations unchanged? Again, this doesn't say anything except in those studies that looked at those outcomes there was no difference. That doesn't negate the benefit in other studies by any means. And it doesn't tell you that a meta-analysis of any kind of large data base supports that finding.

Vaccines cause pain and redness at the site of injection, muscle ache, and other very rare serious harms such as transient paralysis. "Very rare" is actually less than 1 excess case of GBS per million doses of influenza vaccine in 2 years out of 30 in the USA data review.

Ooooo..pain and redness at the injection site, that's a tragedy.

For someone unfamiliar with the morbidity and mortality of influenza in previously healthy children and adults, you could not adequately assess the meaning of this review. In addition, a fatality from secondary pneumonia will not always show up as an influenza death. That is the likely to be the case for MRSA pneumonia deaths currently occurring subsequent to influenza infections.

You cannot get the full picture and make a reasonable assessment of the meaning of Cochrane reviews unless you have additional expertise. Reading a medical text is not the same as experience and an education and lots of reading.
 
Last edited:
That isn't what you said originally. I was responding to the comment you made I call that manipulation.

I didn't mean anything different between those two examples (other than in one case the 'reality' would be the accuracy of the diagnosis and in the other it would be the accuracy of the risk assessment).

What was wrong with the way you presented it, giving both sides? It is a matter is risk (what if your child needs those stem cells someday?) versus the cost, which includes not having the money available for other things, like college savings or a home in a better neighborhood. What is more important to those people making the decision? What is their child's risk of leukemia? What is their financial situation? What are their priorities? What is wrong with presenting them with as much relevant information as they need/want to make a decision and letting them make their own choice based on thier own hopes and fears for their child?

That's not quite what I meant. How you ask or present each of those questions can lead to a different answer (like whether you present it as a gain or a loss). For example, if you need $80,000 for your child's college education, pointing out that banking your child's blood will allow you to save $60,000 toward the cost or banking your child's blood means you lose $20,000 of your college fund will get you two different answers. Which one is correct?

Linda
 
I am linking to epidemiological studies, performed by experts in their field.

I'm not interpreting the raw data; other experts are.

Yet somehow you see the data and interpretations of it experts (generally outside the US) are basing their decisions on as MY crap?

:boggled:

BTW, nice to see the patronising medical professional coming out. Is it a module you have to take, or do you acquire it automatically on qualifying from a medical school?
I am being patronizing to you, Ivor, because in this case it aptly applies.

It is frustrating and tedious to have to explain to someone who doesn't have broad expertise in something why it is their conclusions are wrong. Fortunately Linda is helping. :D
 
Last edited:
So what are you arguing here Ivor? Flu vaccine or varicella vaccine? Summarize your points. Posting citations that support the use of these vaccines is all I see in your links except the BMJ editorial and that just said he would prefer more evidence to base public health decisions on. That one person's personal view was hardly as condemning as you imply.
 
Is this your reading list from your course work or are you claiming you have a medical education because you read the texts?

No, it's my reading/learning for pleasure and no, I am not claiming to have a medical education, nor will I after reading/working through the above (and more).

I'm considering a career move to the medical electronics sector in the next few years.
 
I am being patronizing to you, Ivor, because in this case it aptly applies.

It is frustrating and tedious to have to explain to someone who doesn't have broad expertise in something why it is their conclusions are wrong. Fortunately Linda is helping. :D

I'll stop being tedious tonight and continue tomorrow. Goodnight.
 
No, it's my reading/learning for pleasure and no, I am not claiming to have a medical education, nor will I after reading/working through the above (and more).

I'm considering a career move to the medical electronics sector in the next few years.
Ivor is brighter than most doctors, and, more importantly, uses his critical skills as well as any of them. The fact that his opinions can lack the context and perspective of those who work in the medical field cannot be held against him. It is up to us to help his opinions evolve.

I can compliment in a patronising manner along with the best of them....
;)
 
I could go along with that Deetee if Ivor didn't continually rehash the same stuff over and over carrying it to the next thread and posting as if no one had yet challenged his tunnel vision.
 
So what are you arguing here Ivor? Flu vaccine or varicella vaccine? Summarize your points. Posting citations that support the use of these vaccines is all I see in your links except the BMJ editorial and that just said he would prefer more evidence to base public health decisions on. That one person's personal view was hardly as condemning as you imply.

Varicella vaccine:

The all the cost-effectiveness studies I have seen to date have been performed assuming a single dose would be required. It is now know at least two are required, and the possibility of having to vaccinate a load more people against HZ for the next 20-30 years is looking more likely. IIRC, the HZ vaccine is an even more expensive than the Varicella vaccine.

It seems bizarre to me (as an engineer who has worked on high-volume cost-sensitive projects worth hundreds of millions, where adding less than 10% to the estimated manufacturing cost is questioned), that a 200-400% increase is being ignored in the US, especially when one of the primary reasons given for the introduction of the vaccine was that is was cost-effective.

Seasonal flu vaccine:

My main puzzlement is over how the ACIP in the US can conclude from the evidence that vaccinating 73%-100% of the US population is justified, whereas in the UK, the JCVI looking at practically the same evidence recommends only specific at-risk groups, health care workers and people over the age of 65. The UK policy is similar to the ACIP 1983 one I linked to earlier.

I was particularly interested in the article by Tom Jefferson because he highlights the burden of Influenza-A/B as a proportion of Influenza + Influenza-Like-Illness may typically only be ~15% (again, IIRC). So that raises the question of why invest so much in the flu vaccine when 85% of people who have flu-like symptoms are not going to benefit?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom