Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

You would have been better off to start with information that is transcribed, translated, recognized to provide instructions to form a particular operation, etc. . If I formulated an argument based on our uniform and repeated experience with such information, the conclusion would be that information needs an intelligence source. That would be closer to one of my arguments.
(emphasis mine) "If"? Why don't you just formulate the argument? Wouldn't that eliminate any possibility of a strawman?

Did you know that errors crop up in the transcription of the code? Did you know that primates, including humans, share many of the same transcription errors? Did you know that birds, fish and reptiles don't share those same transcription errors.

In fact, we can use the tree of life laid out before our ability to map the gene code to accurately predict the transcription errors shared between species?

Why can we do that?
 
Last edited:
Old argument from others perhaps. This is not my argument.

I consider the above in someways to be a strawman.

You would have been better off to start with information that is transcribed,
translated, recognized to provide instructions to form a particular operation,
etc. . If I formulated an argument based on our uniform and repeated experience with such information, the conclusion would be that information
needs an intelligence source. That would be closer to one of my arguments.

~Michael
So many words

So little content

Are you in politics or marketing or both?
 
Well threads develop, Czarcasm. This one is developing in a rather unusual way. The OP asked us to come to some concept of god which we could agree on, and this has been done insofar as Yrreg eventually presented his definition and several posters agreed to proceed on that basis. For myself I thought the aim of that was to clear the ground for a discussion and I imagined that having established agreed terms we would go on to discuss something: but for some reason that does not seem to be the case.

I do not know any longer what the topic is: if it is an agreed definition of god we have achieved that and there is no more to say: I suspect it is not. My impression is that the topic of the thread is Yrreg's deep philosophical insight: and the method of demonstrating that is insult and obfuscation. But I still hope to be proved wrong
I think that about covers it. There really has never been a discussion with Yrreg, and I don't think he actually desires one. I am not convinced he knows what an actual exchange of ideas would entail.
 
Here are your questions which I find to be apropos to the thread at the present point of development, apropos, i.e., on the basis of man's brain being the ultimate organ for the experience of everything, starting with consciousness and conscious reasoning and intelligent processes, and the use thereof.
Great, dictating strawmen again. Are these the questions people have actually presented, or are you just making stuff up as you go? I suppose I should be thankful it's not more than just words certain apologists enjoy shoving in other people's mouths.

1. Is it your position that consciousness is empirical evidence of the existence of god?
Are you and HypnoPsi channeling each other? Or are you both acting as receivers of the same minute consciousness?

2. Is it your position that the ability to reason and think intelligently empirical evidence of the existence of god?
I'm happy to accept your "concept of god".
I'm pretty sure then that this contradicts experience as a basis for your belief in God. :whistling

3. Are the moon and satellites proof of the existence of god?
No, no, the moon is proof of the existence of werewolves.

Answers:

1. Yes.

2. Yes.

3. Yes.
Sorry, I think I have to retake the test. I kind of cheated.
 
Here are your questions which I find to be apropos to the thread at the present point of development, apropos, i.e., on the basis of man's brain being the ultimate organ for the experience of everything, starting with consciousness and conscious reasoning and intelligent processes, and the use thereof.


1. Is it your position that consciousness is empirical evidence of the existence of god?

2. Is it your position that the ability to reason and think intelligently empirical evidence of the existence of god?
I'm happy to accept your "concept of god".

3. Are the moon and satellites proof of the existence of god?
​


Answers:

1. Yes.

2. Yes.

3. Yes.




Yrreg

How did you arrive at these answers Yrreg? It appears you have done no empirical testing for your conclusions. In fact, it seems the answers were chosen in a way that you were critical about:

I hate to say this, but I get the impression that either a lot of you guys are playing dumb or are really dumb.

Like the guy, an executive of a big fertilizer supply company, answering the question in a senate hearing:

Senator: Where did you get the fertilizer?

Fertilizer supplier: From the warehouse.
 
Please report to the nearest monotheistic headman in your neighborhood for further instructions on the things to keep in your brain, and the things to enact in your muscles: to live in accordance with the monotheistic group that you happen to land onto and associate with in your neighborhood.

HIGH PRIEST:
Great Wall Of Prophecy, reveal to us God's will that we may blindly obey.

PRIESTS:
(chanting) Free us from thought and responsibility.

HIGH PRIEST:
We shall read things off you.

PRIESTS:
(chanting) Then do them.

HIGH PRIEST:
Your words guide us.

PRIESTS:
(chanting) We're dumb.
 
Old argument from others perhaps. This is not my argument.

I consider the above in someways to be a strawman.

You would have been better off to start with information that is transcribed,
translated, recognized to provide instructions to form a particular operation,
etc. . If I formulated an argument based on our uniform and repeated experience with such information, the conclusion would be that information
needs an intelligence source. That would be closer to one of my arguments.

~Michael

You must know a lot about cellular biology.
 
Not ignoring you, just not certain what you want me to explain.

I have mentioned this before.....

I am not intentionally ignoring you Fiona, I am just uncertain what exactly
you want from me.

My statements were in reference to searching for objective truth assuming
that there is indeed a Creator. That is why I qualified the statement with
"IF."
So "IF" absolute reality is that there is indeed a Creator, THEN in a sincere
search for truth, my presentation of those facts would not matter. God
would set the standard for what is objective reality. He as the Owner of
the Universe therefore His Will and His Existence would set the Standard.
Our job would only be to discover that objective reality which is consistent
with the mind of God.

That is why I said it does not depend on my presentation, but on yours.
IOW, the way in which you present "fact"ors or data to discover truth
would be to your own fate. It would not depend I my weak presentation
of the facts. We start with assumptions when we interpret. Assumptions
plus observation (data) equals interpretation.

If you start with faulty assumptions (natural?) your conclusion will equal
your assumption. The real starting point is to start with assumptions which
are arrived at by deduction and observation.

That could be something as basic as our uniform and repeated experience
with information coming from an intelligent source. It is 100%. Unless you
want to make an unreasonable assertion that there is a mechanism that
exists which has formed "on its own." Once again, mechanics that are
moving forces are set into action. It is somewhat comical to assert a
mechanism which is its own cause. The clear difference with the Creator
is that God is not just a mechanism, He is the Creator of mechanism.

Everthing else is really foolishness when you dissect it to its basic assumptions which I am hoping we can get to in honesty.

This also, would not depend on my presentation, but in your own understanding and presentation (interpretation) of objective facts you
have discovered by deduction.
~Michael
 
So "IF" absolute reality is that there is indeed a Creator, THEN in a sincere search for truth, my presentation of those facts would not matter. God would set the standard for what is objective reality. He as the Owner of the Universe therefore His Will and His Existence would set the Standard.

Our job would only be to discover that objective reality which is consistent
with the mind of God.

A sincere search for truth would have to start with no assumptions about god. The data and arguments should lead to god and not the other way around.

If you start with the assumption that there is a god then you can rationalize anything to fit HIS WILL and HIS EXISTENCE and HIS STANDARD.

The standard should be absent preconditions or it ISN'T intellectually honest.
 
If information can come only from an intelligent source, the intelligent source must itself have an intelligent source.
 
The problem with the word "being."

Would "He is an Infinite Personal Existence beyond the dimensions
of time and space" or simple referred to Him as "the Creator" be a discription of a supernatural being?

The problem with the word "being" is not in its definiton, but in its perception
and connotation.

To many people, the word "being" carries with it either an implication or a
connotation which makes them THINK of something finite. That is the
reason many theists stray away from referring to God as a "being" rather
than the Creator.

Infinite Personal Existence beyond the dimensions of time and space, is still
not a good definition because it misses the connotation of a Loving Heavenly
Father Who desires to fellowship with His children (us.)

Many refer to Him as Heavenly Father with the knowledge that He is infinite.
Many prefer "Creator" when discussing it with non-theists because they do
not want to confuse them with the nomenclature of "supernatural being"
which could be an angel somewhere. A "supernatural being" can be created.
God the Father as an Infinite Personal Existence beyond the dimensions of
time and space gives the connotation of the fact that the Creator is not
finite, and is NOT created.

~Michael
 
The fallacy of thinking that is used to try and get out of it

If information can come only from an intelligent source, the intelligent source must itself have an intelligent source.

This is a perfect example of an argument that is incongruous to the premises.

Information does not equal intelligent source.

Information is the product of intelligence, they are not equal.

So the above is a pseudo claim and a misunderstanding of reality.

~Michael
 
.
Everthing else is really foolishness when you dissect it to its basic assumptions which I am hoping we can get to in honesty.

This also, would not depend on my presentation, but in your own understanding and presentation (interpretation) of objective facts you
have discovered by deduction.
~Michael

Did you "naturally" out of the blue decide or wonder if there was a "God" when you were younger or did the wondering and questioning occur after you heard or read about "God?"
 
Infinite Personal Existence beyond the dimensions of time and space...
Never mind the nonsensical nature of such a definition. Never mind that "infinite" implies time and space. It's the whole, invisible pink unicorn.

How can something be both infinite and beyond the dimension of time?

How can something be both invisible and pink?

Shhhhh..... logic and reason can only go so far...

Just remember the invisible pink unicorn loves you and the dissonance will fade.
 
Philosophical starting point. In complete agreement. No assumptions.

The standard should be absent preconditions or it ISN'T intellectually honest.

Yes. The philosophical starting point should be with no assumptions, but
only present and uniform observation.

~Michael
 
This is a perfect example of an argument that is incongruous to the premises.

Information does not equal intelligent source.

Information is the product of intelligence, they are not equal.

So the above is a pseudo claim and a misunderstanding of reality.

The premise being that there is a creator?
I agree that information does not equal an intelligent source.
If information is the product of intelligence, the intelligence surely must hae an intelligent source.
Or do you say that intelligence can exist without information?
 
This is a perfect example of an argument that is incongruous to the premises.

Information does not equal intelligent source.

Information is the product of intelligence, they are not equal.
To fit your argument to logic we would have to conclude that the intelligence has no information.
 
Yes. The philosophical starting point should be with no assumptions, but
only present and uniform observation.

~Michael
Michael,

Thank you very much for responding. I know you are getting hit with a lot of posts and I've been impatient with you in the past. I assure you that I will be patient now and I understand you have a lot of posts to respond to.

:)

ETA: If you have the opportunity I would appreciate a response to post 621.
 
Last edited:
Infinite Personal Existence beyond the dimensions of time and space, is still
not a good definition because it misses the connotation of a Loving Heavenly
Father Who desires to fellowship with His children (us.)

I dispute that an entity, as I know the term "entity," its denotation and connotations, could exist outside time. I am not certain of the meaning of "beyond" time...or for that matter, "outside of time."

Even if such an entity could exist outside/beyond time/space, or if it existed within as is logical, I've no reason to assume that it is even aware of me, or that it wants a personal relationship with anyone, or that an infinite being would even be capable of such relationships.

If it is extant beyond the known dimensions, it may not even perceive us. Yet, it could still be the creator of almost everything. (I still maintain the creator of everything isn't possible, see time argument.)
 
Not my argument, but you could learn about those too

That's fine.

Now, let's get to the point:

If I understand you, you claim that the universe IS the evidence for god because the universe appears designed.

Is this correct?

No. Although others could make that argument. That is not the argument
I am making here. You could look at the fine tuning of the universe and
see the improbabilites of all of the different laws existing by chance, such
as the laws of gravity or electromagnetism, but that would be yet another
argument.

You could also look at defined morphologies and argue for design as well,
but that would be yet another argument.

If the universe IS fine tuned THEN that would point to a Fine Tuner. If
birds and mammals and other species present a designed appearance of
specific definition rather than everything being randomly different, that
would be another argument.

My arguments right now are specifically dealing with factories that
are assembling polypeptides and also the fact that information of
such complexity clearly needs an intelligent source.

~Michael
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom