Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Circular assumptions about the universe and observations about matter.

The argument cannot be proven false; therefore, it is true.
The argument cannot be proven true; therefore it is false.

which are both fallacious.

Agreed 100%. It is nice to see consensus in this thread.

Q.E. but when you do, use deduction and not induction "first."

And don't start with a circular assumption.

~Michael
 
God is revealed in the masculine, but He is not simply a male or female.

So you think your god is male. This refutes the claims of another poster.

There is a difference between being male or female, and being revealed
in the masculine.

God is revealed in the masculine as a Heavenly Father but He has no
physical body that would limit Him to being seen as male or female.

Yeshau (Jesus) is the Man that God became. Jesus was clearly male.

God is a "He" in the scriptures because He is revealed in the masculine,
but this gender is not established by sex, but rather by standard.

~Michael
 
Attempting to stay on the topic of basic assumptions

Never mind that "infinite" implies time and space.

Beyond the limitations of time and space means that He does not move and
He is not limited to experiencing time in the same way in which we do.
(traveling from point to point takes time, etc. God does not travel).

This would be a long discussion about real time-space relationships. At this
point I would consider it another diversion into pragmatical theories in physics.

How can something be both infinite and beyond the dimension of time?
.[/QUOTE]

For the purposes of keeping it simple I will rephrase and say "Infinite Personal
Existences which is not limited to the restrictions of being constrained in time and space."

~Michael
 
..."Infinite Personal Existences which is not limited to the restrictions of being constrained in time and space."
I won't press you on it but this is a nonsensical statement. Something can't have always existed if there is no time. Personal or not.
 
Ah yes, natural selection...

Yes it is. natural selection and the self assembly of independantly functional substructures explains it all.

Please explain what you mean by the word "natural" in natural selection.

How do you gauge what is natural? What is "natural" specifically?

~Michael
 
Male or female is irrelevant to basic assumptions and basic evidence

So, this assumption is irrelevant and not up for discussion, but your other assumptions are?

Let's talk first about making "no" assumptions. I do not want to get into
a discussion about why God is reveal in the masculine because it does
not deal with the question of evidence and how we know what is evidence.

IOW, it is not a scientific discussion based on evidence, it is a different type
of discussion which has nothing to do with knowing there is a Creator.

~Michael
 
I'm still wondering Breckmin

Did you "naturally" out of the blue decide or wonder if there was a "God" when you were younger or did the wondering and questioning occur after you heard or read about "God?"

Your acknowledge of God started somewhere......
 
Let's talk first about making "no" assumptions. I do not want to get into a discussion about why God is reveal in the masculine because it does not deal with the question of evidence and how we know what is evidence.


Really? So now information is not evidence?

How odd.

IOW, it is not a scientific discussion based on evidence, it is a different type of discussion which has nothing to do with knowing there is a Creator.


Sounds perfect for this thread.
 
Once again, I could not quote your message, it keeps saying to enter the user name and
password as though I did not have permission or something.

RandFan<<Something can't have always existed if there is no time.>>

There is a difference between experiencing such time where time actually applies
and not being restricted by it. It is not nonsensical at all when you understand
the relationship between time and motion.

But it would be a long discussion. You might start with understanding what would
happen if you went back one second in time. You would not still be sitting at your
computer. You would be on the other side of the moon or some place in "outer space"
because of all galaxy motion(s). If you could be at multiple places in time, you would
begin filling up the universe with yourself.

No matter how fast you travel from point A to point B (if these are two separate points
in the universe) it will take time...

unless you are at both places at once.

It would be a long discussion. I would like to stay on the question of assumptions.

~Michael
 
Let's talk first about making "no" assumptions. I do not want to get into
a discussion about why God is reveal in the masculine because it does
not deal with the question of evidence and how we know what is evidence.

IOW, it is not a scientific discussion based on evidence, it is a different type
of discussion which has nothing to do with knowing there is a Creator.

~Michael

I agree with Hokulele: This seems a perfectly relevant topic of discussion. You have claimed that gender, specifically male gender, is a property of your god. As has already been mentioned, gender is a function of reproductive biology. The creator god that you've described would have no more need of gender than it would have need of a digestive tract or hair. It makes no logical sense. What does make logical sense is the idea that an ancient desert tribe with a male dominated society would create a specifically male god. It makes sense if they created their god in their own image.
 
Once again, I could not quote your message, it keeps saying to enter the user name and password as though I did not have permission or something.
I've reported this to forum management but I've not gotten a response. I'm sorry about that I don't know why it is happening.

It would be a long discussion. I would like to stay on the question of assumptions.
That's fine so long as you understand that your idea of god being outside of time and space is not supported by any theoretical physics. It is just saying "something miraculous happens". That's fine but don't think there is some answer to the nonsensical nature of the statement.
 
Let's talk first about making "no" assumptions. I do not want to get into
a discussion about why God is reveal in the masculine because it does
not deal with the question of evidence and how we know what is evidence.

IOW, it is not a scientific discussion based on evidence, it is a different type
of discussion which has nothing to do with knowing there is a Creator.

~Michael

Actually the gender reference is quite significant simply because in the Xtian faith God is regarded as the father and Christ is acknowledged as the son of man.
How would you know if this is true or not without questioning everything?
 
Last edited:
You're not ready for that discussion yet because you do not know there is a Creator

I agree with Hokulele: This seems a perfectly relevant topic of discussion.

It is a side tract from knowing first that there is a Creator.

You have claimed that gender, specifically male gender,

Masculine spirituality and the reasons for it, and the assumptions that
are actually "built" to get there are evasive to first assumptions.

is a property of your god. As has already been mentioned, gender is a function of reproductive biology.

You are putting the cart before the horse and misunderstanding an
original design in Creation and a consequential design and creaton that
appeared afterwards. It is a red herring to first knowing basic assumptions.

The creator god that you've described would have no more need of gender than it would have need of a digestive tract or hair.

It is not a question of need, it is a question of personal inclination and
origin.

It makes no logical sense.

That is because you are looking at it backwards.

What does make logical sense is the idea that an ancient desert tribe with a male dominated society would create a specifically male god. It makes sense if they created their god in their own image.

Using invalid induction again and looking at it backwards. It is not relevant
to the first discussion on scientific evidence for the Creator (whether male
or neutral). It is like trying to talk about "Who" gave you all the wonderful
things in life without knowing first that they were actually given to you and
they did not appear under your Christmas tree by random chance and the
present wrapping themselves.

It is a red herring based on a religious discussion which has not yet even
been substantiated to talk comparative religions until you first know absolutely there is a Creator (masculine or neutral).

If another theist wants to go there without laying down first foundational
assumptions from which to build upon, by all means, go for it, but you can
only do so within a closed set of agreed assumptions (which have not been
build up yet) that are based on historical evidences and comparative
religions, NOT the first scientific evidences which we discussing.

We can't logically talk about "Who" the Creator is until we know first absolutely that there IS a Creator.
~Michael
 
The Infinite Creator is not limited to three dimensional space

That's fine so long as you understand that your idea of god being outside of time and space is not supported by any theoretical physics.

Not all theoretical physics have be thoroughly published yet, so I do not
agree with the assertion that an Infinite Personal Existence is not timeless
as far as restrictions or is not transcendent above the three dimensional
universe.

~Michael
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom