Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Sigh... Looks like this attempt to cause panic over the state of one's nonexistant immortal soul has failed outright, eh?
 
Several posts moved to AAH for personalising the discussion. Please remember to focus on the topic, and not individual members.

Back on topic from here please.

ETA: Forum Mgt posts moved to appropriate thread in FM. Do not ignore mod warnings. If you feel a topic is not worth rsponding to, don't respond to it. The topic definitely is not personalised discussion of an individual member.

Here's a reminder from the OP for those of you who are struggling:
<snip>let us first work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God.

<snip>you are not in any way committing yourselves to the admission that there exists God.

What we want to do is to arrive at a concept of God acceptable to both you and me, so that we can get some constructive exchange of ideas on the existence of God or His non-existence.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
Last edited:
Yrreg, before we "work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God", we need to know exactly which theology to concentrate on. Do we include all religions, or just Christianity? If Christian, do we include all sects, or just certain ones?
Exactly what small proportion of all the theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists are we looking at here?
 
The cool thing about faith is you get to customize it if you are confident enough to do that. Take Joseph Smith for instance. He came up with a mother in heaven.

The question you need to answer is, do you want to believe that Odin created the universe and everything?

I did try that approach as a teenager.
Odin and the rest of the gods of asgård is far more interesting than christ, so i decided on that as my religion.
The problem is that it is unvelievable, and so I gave up on religion.
 
Yrreg, before we "work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God", we need to know exactly which theology to concentrate on. Do we include all religions, or just Christianity? If Christian, do we include all sects, or just certain ones?
Exactly what small proportion of all the theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists are we looking at here?

Well, you can give up on getting any answers from you-know-who. You didn't post your questions in the form of "yes-no" interrogatories.
 
Well, you can give up on getting any answers from you-know-who. You didn't post your questions in the form of "yes-no" interrogatories.
I agree, but since these questions directly address the OP(unlike most of Yrreg's responses), I'm going to keep posting them until I get a coherent answer.
 
Think up your own kind and style of monotheism.

Well,

That's enough for me. I'm a theist now. Yrreg convinced me. I have seen the error of my thinking, and I hope you all do, too, before its too late.


Please report to the nearest monotheistic headman in your neighborhood for further instructions on the things to keep in your brain, and the things to enact in your muscles: to live in accordance with the monotheistic group that you happen to land onto and associate with in your neighborhood.


If you are not happy, then try another, and another.


If you are still not happy, do as I do:

Think out your own kind of self-help diy (do it yourself) system of monotheism.​



Good luck -- luck here means God, so Good luck means "Good God help you"!


Haha, Gotcha!




Yrreg
 
So, about this quintessential god, is it,

Anthropomorphic?
Male?
Female?
Omniscient?
Omnipotent?
Omnipresent?
 
Please report to the nearest monotheistic headman in your neighborhood for further instructions on the things to keep in your brain, and the things to enact in your muscles: to live in accordance with the monotheistic group that you happen to land onto and associate with in your neighborhood.


If you are not happy, then try another, and another.


If you are still not happy, do as I do:

Think out your own kind of self-help diy (do it yourself) system of monotheism.​



Good luck -- luck here means God, so Good luck means "Good God help you"!


Haha, Gotcha!




Yrreg

Ha Ha...Not
Are you purposely avoiding post #583? These questions are important as to determine what religion/religions are being discussed.

ETA: Is post #583 to difficult for you? Yes or No
 
Last edited:
Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things.

Yrreg, before we "work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God", we need to know exactly which theology to concentrate on. Do we include all religions, or just Christianity? If Christian, do we include all sects, or just certain ones?
Exactly what small proportion of all the theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists are we looking at here?


I have been trying to get you people to come to a concept of God that I first and then you will agree on for a hypothetical God, and work from that concept to discuss whether such a God exists or cannot exist.


At this point in time I have discovered that I will insist on my own concept of God which is:

An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

And another discovery is that I want to suggest to you people here, who don't want to accept for a concept of God on a hypothetical basis my concept of God, then not to post here, and even just to put me on ignore, so that you will not waste time and forum's bandwidth.


Someone, Wowbagger, brought up the need for empirical testing to ascertain the existence of such a God.

That is another discovery for me, that God if He does exist should be susceptible to empirical testing.


So I am now into the empirical testing of God; that is why I am asking people to list the organs of man for empirical testing of the existence of anything and everything that is outside man as inside man.

No one mentioned man's brain which I was hoping someone to bring up, so I took the initiative to bring it up in order to save so much time for everyone, and forum bandwidth.


Now my position is that man's brain is an organ of man's experience, empirical testing, the ultimate and the indispensable organ.

Man's brain is the organ for man to experience consciousness and reason and intelligence, and also to engage in consciousness and in reasoning and in processes of intelligent thinking.



This is thus my thesis at this point of the thread:

Man has empirical evidence of God with the use of his brain: to be conscious of things and to reason and think intelligently on things to arrive at the existence of God.​

What things?

Things like for example communication satellites and the moon, which both we see to be orbiting the earth, which earth we are consciously experiencing with our feet firmly planted on it.

------------------


I hate to say this, but I get the impression that either a lot of you guys are playing dumb or are really dumb.

Like the guy, an executive of a big fertilizer supply company, answering the question in a senate hearing:

Senator: Where did you get the fertilizer?

Fertilizer supplier: From the warehouse.
​




Haha, gotcha!



You know what, guys?

What we need are professional experts in conflict resolution to settle our conflicts, that should save us so much time and trouble, and the forum bandwidth.

That is why I am now into reading and thinking about conflict resolution, all kinds and manners of conflicts men engage in, and entertaining the thought of being a professional expert in this field, which can be a good enjoyable new livelihood undertaking.

Writing in web forum is enjoyable but non-paying, still as wise men tell us, important is to make enough money and do whatever you enjoy doing that is harmless.



And why should people who are in conflict get their conflict settled, and thereby miss having any purpose in and from existence, or the satisfaction of winning in a conflict?

There are conflicts and conflicts, ours here for myself and I hope for you also is an enjoyable game -- we are not going to kill each other over it.




Yrreg

N.B. I have not read the messages coming after this one from Czarcasm.
 
Man has empirical evidence of God with the use of his brain: to be conscious of things and to reason and think intelligently on things to arrive at the existence of God.
Your posts are somewhat confusing. I'll acquiesce to your demand regarding questions.


  • Is it your position that consciousness is empirical evidence of the existence of god?
  • Is it your position that the ability to reason and think intelligently empirical evidence of the existence of god?
I'm happy to accept your "concept of god".

  • Are the moon and satellites proof of the existence of god?
What we need are professional experts in conflict resolution to settle our conflicts, that should save us so much time and trouble, and the forum bandwidth.
Much of the conflict is the result of your unwillingness to answer questions or engage in discussion. If you would respond and answer questions things would go much smoother.

Please answer the questions.
 
Last edited:
So, about this quintessential god, is it,

Anthropomorphic?
Male?
Female?
Omniscient?
Omnipotent?
Omnipresent?

Yrreg, these are pertinent questions and are all in the form of yes no. Could you answer them?
 
Yrreg, before we "work out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists understand to be the quintessential concept of God", we need to know exactly which theology to concentrate on. Do we include all religions, or just Christianity? If Christian, do we include all sects, or just certain ones?
Exactly what small proportion of all the theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists are we looking at here?
These are not in the form of yes or no but if you could would you please answer them?
 
I point to information and the complexity of cell in the same sentence
and the response is "where?" (what) Where is the evidence?

I'm sorry but I already know of at least one other theist who would find
such a little more than amusing and ironic...

~Michael

How can we be sure you are not demon-possessed right now? Pride is a well known attribute of Satan.
 
That is another discovery for me, that God if He does exist should be susceptible to empirical testing.

Ok Yrreg, I'll acknowledge your concept of God as you have perceived it as a starting point.

Randfan's questions are significant as to what determines this God's abilities and how these God abilities are discovered through empirical testing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom