Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Suggestion to atheists: do some reading of the early Christian church, instead of stuffing your brain organ with flying spaghetti.
I have done that. Your arrogant and smug attitude isn't helping anything.
 
You still have a number of points on previous pages to address. Communication satellites, yes we have brains - your questions which have been answered as you requested. Why are you ignoring these in favour of some wholly fallacious argument about comparative intelligence of animals and humans (who are, of course, animals).

Atheists are 'deviants' now? You must be sailing fairly close to a banning from here with your relentless insults.
 
Last edited:
I say human reason and intelligence.


Animals are intelligent and some of them a lot have been on earth millions even perhaps billions of years before us, and are still around, but they have not produced a Notre Dame, have not gone to the moon and back, and have not painted a Mona Lisa.

It's the opposable thumb problem, of course. Camels really, really want to build their own Notre Dame, but they lack opposable thumbs.

Dolphins are far smarter than we - they spend all day eating, playing, and f--- er, reproducing. There isn't much that hunts them, and they seem to lack politics, internet forums full of woo artists, and gods. Plus, when they do deign to approach land, it's often to gaze lovingly at bikini-clad humans.

Even dolphins can appreciate beauty.

(And the only reason anyone painted Mona Lisa was that he was trying to get into her pants.)

When they shall have done these things, then I will consider them to have reason and intelligence as good or better than ours.

And good thumbs, let's not forget that.

Personally, the first non-human animal that erects a temple to a non-existant deity is going to sorely disappoint me. Somehow, I imagine the poodle will be the first. They strike me as inanely dumb.

And hopefully they don't become atheists, deliberate deviants from people who know God.

Um... has anyone, anywhere, seen any animal life form worship a deity figure? Aside from insects that worship their queen, and dogs that worship Zsa Zsa Gabor.
 
And hopefully they don't become atheists, deliberate deviants from people who know God.




Yrreg
By which you mean the thing that created everything.
We canot be deliberate deviants from that which we do not accept exists.

Are there any gods you don't believe exist? Name one and tell us why you don't believe in its existence.
 
Well,

That's enough for me. I'm a theist now. Yrreg convinced me. I have seen the error of my thinking, and I hope you all do, too, before its too late.
 
But did Odin create the universe and everything?
The cool thing about faith is you get to customize it if you are confident enough to do that. Take Joseph Smith for instance. He came up with a mother in heaven.

The question you need to answer is, do you want to believe that Odin created the universe and everything?
 
Just mention something new you know.

I know you're requesting a simple Yes or No on this question, but to be fair to the question, I really have to go into some detail in my response.

Everything man knows is founded upon a combination of his past experiences AND upon his natural inclinations. An infant knows nothing, having had limited past experiences; yet an infant is capable of experiencing comfort versus discomfort, and learns to react in ways that causes his discomfort to lessen. It is fairly clear that every life form of any degree of complexity includes, in its basic genetic makeup, some simplified primal urges and needs that compel it to further learn about its world. Those that lack such pre-existing urges, after all, cannot survive long in the world.

So by the most technical of answers, I suppose I would have to answer, no. There are things man knows which are founded instead on primal instincts, rather than past experiences.

[...]



Posted by Z
The problem with comparing human-designed objects to naturally occuring ones, is that most human designs began with observation of existing objects, and attempting to replicate or mimic them. The wheel? Probably a slab of tree trunk or a round rock. The hammer? Most likely a thigh bone or a club of wood. The arrowhead? Plenty of sharp, pointy things laying around. Naturally occuring tools inspire man to make new tools; human ingenuity allows man to create more complex tools, but the initial 'designs' are nothing but copies of pre-existing things. Why, after all, did early aircraft designs look like birds or airborne seeds? Why do vehicles often resemble creatures in some ways? To look at human designs and try to infer a designer in nature is a completely backwards way of considering things.

To look at human designs and try to infer a designer in nature is a completely backwards way of considering things. -- Z​

Answer this question with Yes or No:


Everything man knows is founded on things he knew before. Yes No.
​

But I guess you will not answer this question with Yes or No, but you will keep away.

That is one of the non-thinking ways with atheists, they are into evasion or avoidance of answering questions.

Here is another question for you to answer with Yes or No:

You have a brain. Yes No.​


Primal instincts... [ Transeat.* ]



Just tell me one thing you know to be new to you that is not founded upon previous knowledge of mankind and of your own.


To be relevant to the context of what you say:

To look at human designs and try to infer a designer in nature is a completely backwards way of considering things.​




By the way, would you care to answer also with a Yes or a No:


You have a brain. Yes No.​




If you think that question is an insult on you, please put me on ignore.


It is useless to talk with people who bring in the accusation repeatedly that you are insulting them.




Yrreg

*Transeat = Latin, "let it pass."
 
Primal instincts... [ Transeat.* ]
No one says you have to post here. If you are agitated just think how we feel. You demand that people answer questions yet you won't answer them yourself.

Yes, I have a brain.

Let's assume that there is nothing I know that isn't founded on something else that I knew before it, so what?
 
Primal instincts... [ Transeat.* ]



Just tell me one thing you know to be new to you that is not founded upon previous knowledge of mankind and of your own.

At present, nothing. But my current state of knowledge is irrelevant in this discussion. I answered your question. There are things known by man that were not founded upon previous knowledge - in fact, anything learned by a newborn is founded only upon instinct and observation.

As I have no memory prior to my seventh birthday, I cannot name any one thing that was new to me that was not predicated upon by prior human knowledge. I could theorize - that fire is hot, that light is bright, etc. - but I lack memories in ignorance, just as I cannot remember a time that I didn't speak Spanish or English, or didn't know the entire cast of The Producers.

To be relevant to the context of what you say:

To look at human designs and try to infer a designer in nature is a completely backwards way of considering things.​

No, we never design something new, of whole cloth.

Sorry.

By the way, would you care to answer also with a Yes or a No:


You have a brain. Yes No.​

I would not care to answer also with a Yes or a No. I answered thusly, and stand by my answer:

Unlike a courtroom, where one is compelled to answer exactly as one is dictated to, I am free to answer as accurately as possible. One of the 'non-thinking ways' (to borrow your catchphrase) of theists (and conspiracists, coincidentally) is to ask questions while attempting to force answers into narrowly defined potential responses.

Do I have a brain? According to all available evidence, I believe that I do. I have never personally physically observed my brain, through any of my senses. But I do observe that other beings which appear to be like myself possess brains, and that the behaviours I am capable of are only possible by similarly constructed beings. While it is an assumption, I feel it is a fairly reasonable assumption that I do, in fact, have a brain.

By I, in this case, I am referring to the totality of my being - all conscious and non-conscious aspects of 'I' including my physical being, general social status, etc. I use 'I' in the broadest possible sense, since I feel it is very difficult to decide where I begin and end.

If this answer is beyond your comprehension, I'm sure you can find someone to translate it into easier-to-digest bits.

If you think that question is an insult on you, please put me on ignore.


It is useless to talk with people who bring in the accusation repeatedly that you are insulting them.

I have never claimed you are insulting me. I don't find it an insult at all. You're doing the best you can with the limited resources at your disposal. I applaud your efforts - though I do wish you were more responsive.
 
Last edited:
God the Father Almighty
Creator of heaven and earth
and everything.​
During the bronze age people were often ruled by kings and emperors who demanded supplication and long titles because of their egos. When humans created god they formed him in their image but chose to make them also in the image of petty tyrants.

2000 years later some people can't get out of the habit.
 
To look at human designs and try to infer a designer in nature is a completely backwards way of considering things. -- Z​


Answer this question with Yes or No:


Everything man knows is founded on things he knew before. Yes No.​

Everything man knows is learned by being taught from a basic foundation of ideas and discovery.
Evolution plays it's part by those individuals who, with their brilliant thinking outside the basic foundational box, advance these ideas further than what was previously thought of as not possible.

But I guess you will not answer this question with Yes or No, but you will keep away.

You believe your putting out difficult questions here? Give Me a break.

That is one of the non-thinking ways with atheists, they are into evasion or avoidance of answering questions.

Actually this is a better description of you.

Here is another question for you to answer with Yes or No:

You have a brain. Yes No.​


Yes, I've seen mine through an MRI. It looks exactly like pictures and models I've seen in biology.
 
Last edited:
Just tell me one thing you know to be new to you that is not founded upon previous knowledge of mankind and of your own.

I have one...Every next day!

To be relevant to the context of what you say:

To look at human designs and try to infer a designer in nature is a completely backwards way of considering things.​

Why?

By the way, would you care to answer also with a Yes or a No:


You have a brain. Yes No.​

2nd time answered. Yes

It is useless to talk with people who bring in the accusation repeatedly that you are insulting them.

Here is what you do...You think some people here are just being facetious with you, so you choose to ignore them.
Well of course they are, but why don't you put forth the effort to include them in this quest of yours? Don't you relish a difficult challenge?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom