Are YOU a scientist? What publications do you have to your name?

What are your scientific credentials?

  • I am a qualified scientist (degree or above) with published scientific material

    Votes: 68 34.0%
  • I am a qualified scientist (degree or above) with no published scientific material

    Votes: 29 14.5%
  • I am an uqualified scientist, with published scientific material

    Votes: 5 2.5%
  • I am not a scientist, but enjoy discussing science here

    Votes: 65 32.5%
  • I am not a scientist, and hate discussing science here

    Votes: 1 0.5%
  • I am an unqualified scientist, but know more about my scientific area of interest than most qualifie

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • I am a crackpot

    Votes: 16 8.0%
  • I am a weasal-fish .... from planet X

    Votes: 14 7.0%

  • Total voters
    200
I've been paid to write published articles, on many occasions, mostly about cement.
Pretty exciting stuff, eh?
Its been many years since then, and now I can't even spell.

For that matter, my spelling wasn't great then, either. But there were editors for that.
I wouldn't call me a scientist, though I invented a few construction methods, regarding extremely obscure aspects of concrete chemistry. Not the sort of stuff you'd whip out to impress a date.

Also was published in pop-science magazines for construction of passive solar buildings.
Last time was in the 80's.

I'm a total loser now, and get my writing ya-yas by promoting no-god as god at JREF.
Thanks for reminding me.
 
I've had worse. "This paper treats a trivial problem". Five year old mildly retarded children who were not toilet trained.
My speculation was that the reviewer was a person big in the "toilet training in a jiffy" field who I had some disagreements in the past.

Oh yes, I believe it.

Same paper with the "FIR/IIR" thing also had the statement "this author says that he can cancel aliasing, and we all know that nothing can cancel aliasing".

Now, you can't cancel aliasing at capture, but you can do just fine inside a filterbank, which was the issue under discussion.

Ditto another reviewer on the same paper who thought the term "Differential PCM" was obtuse, despite it being in common use for oh, 15 or so years.

The real problem was that it was an audio coding paper, and the reviewer clearly didn't think that it was possible for any bit-rate reduction to work, ever, never.

S/he finally admitted that, and got his/her butt tossed as a reviewer for that paper.

Then there was one of my papers on perceptual coding. It was about 1/4 signal processing, 1/4 psychoacoustics, 1/4 information theory, and 1/4 computer science (algorithms).

The CS guy thought the CS was trivial and the rest wasn't explained well enough.
The DSP guy thought the DSP was trivial and the rest wasn't explained well enough.
Repeat twice more...

(rolls eyes)

The amusing thing is that the two papers I'm talking about here are my most and second most cited papers... The first one is up in the hundreds, and the second one isn't too far behind...
 
I've had one paper published as sole author and have two as second author under review at the moment... just trying to get my publication requirements out of the way asap so I can concentrate on actually writing my damn thesis.
 
Wrote an advertisement, did you?

Nope, never written one for Nature as far as I know.

I created a collaborative article with Richard Wiseman. See, I managed to make it still sound credible even though it isn't. If you search "Tracy King" on nature.com it does come up in the search results, but is now behind a paywall, sadly. I mean happily.
 
Last edited:
Degreed scientist? Nope. My M.Sc. is actually an M.Sc.(A). A for Applied.

Published material? Related to science? Nothing. Unless you count that fact sheet on right hemisphere stroke I wrote for use at one hospital that I later found a plagiarized (and typo-riddled) copy of in use at an entirely different hospital and which may well be in use throughout the entire McGill hospital network by now.... though I hope that the other sites have versions that don't say "avoid direct requests" where it should say "avoid indirect requests".......

I've been told I may be asked to contribute to a conference paper on one of the projects I worked on when I was a lab assistant a few years ago, but I'm not holding my breath for that call. It's okay. The important thing about that project is that I got to be a voice in a computer game. That beats an obscure half-deserved author credit any day! :D
 
My name is on several publications but I've lost track of them. I did a fair bit of supportive analytical work for scientists in publish-or-perish institutions. Some of them were nice enough to list me as a co-author. I once did some work for a scientist employed at a facility that demanded at least four publications per year. He published twelve individual papers out of what took me half a day. Unremarkable stuff but he took the same piece of novel work and spun it in different ways to get one real fiding into two to four different journals. The presentation differed depending on the journa's specialty.

Most of my work is for private concerns and is sooper-secret, though. It gets reviewed by peers and those reviews are public but the work itself is confidential.

Frankly, publishing does nothing toward qualifying or disqualifying a scientist. It's merely something you do if you want to or have to. It's a fair amount of bother and it's a nice thing to put on a resume but there are many good scientists that have never published. I know several published scientists whom I woudn't trust to boil water, too.
 
Oy. I've had reviewers like that...

Ask me about the "FIR AND IIR are jargon, and do not belong in a published paper" event, maybe. Oy yoy. (This is like saying 'the' is jargon in signal processing terms.)
That's pretty mean. I once had a reviewer for the AIAA Journal tell me that I couldn't say 'electret microphone' I had to explain what that meant.

For the record I have h = 4 (I think), I work in a very low citing field, half of whom are in industry and don't publish much. And the four that contribute in no way represent my best work, really you could sweep them all away in a flood and no one would notice or care apart from one paper in Proc R Soc, and one currently under review for PNAS (which stands for Papers Not Accepted by Science, though not in this case).
 
Last edited:
I'm not a scientist, in fact I'm unusually educated. I have a post-grad diploma but I don't have a degree (enrolled in post-grad as a mature-age student with industry experience) or a PhD or anything fancy.

By the strangest of circumstances, I ended up with my name on a paper. If you take a look at the authors, I'm the one without a university affiliation.

Combinatorial enumeration of 2 x 2 ribbon patterns

Look Ma, I'm a published mathematician! :D
 
Rustum Roy springs to mind.:)
I have to call you on that, I suspect Nostrum Roy enjoys tea. However, I would not be surprised if he has forgotten how to make ice.

It's not just that Roy is blithely incompetent outside his specific field, he is a nasty, insulting person. He came to my attention in the early 80s when Republicans (in the USA), led by Ronald Ray-gun, started reducing funding for science research. Ronny also touted the notion of the "welfare queen" who lives luxuriously on the dole. When scientists complained about the reduced funding, Roy called us "welfare queens in white coats" while he had no qualms about accepting funds from the government for his own research.

I'm pretty sure I've got more. My real name is Ibid.
Hah, amateurs! Look-up Anon(ymous). In addition to chemistry, my ouevre contains many of the best poems, music and lyrics ever published. Quality matters more than quantity; as they say- it's not the size of the wave, it's the motion of the ocean. http://scienceblogs.com/neurotopia/2009/04/friday_weird_science_for_men_i.php
 
I am about to get my doctoral degree in occupational therapy. My focus is on biomechanics research (of the upper extremity mechanics of people who propel wheelchairs and have a a spinal cord injury.) I've got a manuscript but is is not published yet. So I guess I am sort of a fledgling scientist.
 
I am about to get my doctoral degree in occupational therapy. My focus is on biomechanics research (of the upper extremity mechanics of people who propel wheelchairs and have a a spinal cord injury.) I've got a manuscript but is is not published yet. So I guess I am sort of a fledgling scientist.
In organic chemistry one is considered to have fledged after accidentally causing a fire in the lab. At least, that was the standard before the Occupational Safety and Health Administration.
 
Naw, I'm just the editor who prettifies your manuscripts so the can be published. Worked for journals in the fields of astronomy and physics (my first love), chemistry, consumer behavioralism, psychology, and now, oncology.

I've always loved science, but went with a degree in English. Lazy turd.
 
Naw, I'm just the editor who prettifies your manuscripts so the can be published. {snip}

I've always loved science, but went with a degree in English. Lazy turd.
The first paper I had accepted by a major journal was edited by English major who substantially altered my punctuation. I appreciated it. I tried to learn; but, mostly, I did not look for that kind of editing in subsequent papers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom