Are YOU a scientist? What publications do you have to your name?

What are your scientific credentials?

  • I am a qualified scientist (degree or above) with published scientific material

    Votes: 68 34.0%
  • I am a qualified scientist (degree or above) with no published scientific material

    Votes: 29 14.5%
  • I am an uqualified scientist, with published scientific material

    Votes: 5 2.5%
  • I am not a scientist, but enjoy discussing science here

    Votes: 65 32.5%
  • I am not a scientist, and hate discussing science here

    Votes: 1 0.5%
  • I am an unqualified scientist, but know more about my scientific area of interest than most qualifie

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • I am a crackpot

    Votes: 16 8.0%
  • I am a weasal-fish .... from planet X

    Votes: 14 7.0%

  • Total voters
    200
I should have said I was being sarcatsic more clearly. Sarcasm is amazingly impossible to tell online. Infact I'm going to get a mod to add it to the OP.

I thought it was obvious enough.

But if you ever doubt that your audience will get it, reach for a smiley. ;)
 
i just graduated with a BS in geology. i have 2 udergrad publications in GSA.
Where do i fit in?
 
Not really 'mere' undergraduate, within two months I will be fully qualfied.
May one enquire as to the basis of your apparent certainty concerning the passing of final exams?

And I'm "disputing much of the cosmology and physics that has been developed by great minds over the last 100 years." because there are viable alternatives that are written by qualified people, which I'm more than capable of compreheding and arguing about.
So we've noticed ... like your posts on magnetic reconnection, your flip-flops on Thornhill, your quoting of large slabs of material from a published paper without attribution, your common promises to answer questions on the material you post which seem to be never honoured, ...
 
May one enquire as to the basis of your apparent certainty concerning the passing of final exams?


So we've noticed ... like your posts on magnetic reconnection, your flip-flops on Thornhill, your quoting of large slabs of material from a published paper without attribution, your common promises to answer questions on the material you post which seem to be never honoured, ...


STOP this immediately. Another thread, please.

I'm fairly certain I'll pass, though I have booked in for accomodation next year, just incase I have to resit the last year.

Meanwhile, Neried, since you've posted in this thread at least make a contribution. Your qualficiations? What did you vote for?
 
Last edited:
Considering that I don't post under my own name, what makes you think that I would post my work here?

It kind of defeats the purpose...
 
You know, my job position doesn't say "scientist" per se, but I know a couple of people whose very job title is "scientist". It really means statistician...
 
STOP this immediately. Another thread, please.

[...]
But your lordship ...

[dripping sarcasm] ... I was only trying to emulate my role model ... [/dripping sarcasm]

Isn't there an idiom, in English, about sauce, the goose, and the gander?

ETA: the following are extracts from posts in this thread, by the same poster (no prizes for guessing who)

* "Me, personally, well, I've got hundreds of scientific publications to my name, all published in reputable peer reviewed journals, but would prefer to remain anonymous." (edit added much later: "Sarcasm intended. I voted for "I am not a scientist, but enjoy discussing science here", as I'm an undergraduate doing my year of a physics degree.") (the OP!)

* "Doh. I never really though [sic] about this very hard. Anyone can claim to be anyone here." (source)

* "I probably didn't set a good example by lying about my credentials in the OP (was supposed to be sarcastic, but I dont think most people appreciated that!). I did however vote correctly and say (since I'm an undergraduate) that I'm as of yet unqualified but just interested in science." (source)

On the one hand, it's good that you have fessed up to lying^; on the other hand, how do we know you're not lying about the undergrad-about-to-graduate claim?

^ at least this once; there are plenty of posts in other threads that would seem to point strongly to other examples of lying, not acknowledged as such (AFAIK)
 
Last edited:
I dont think you undersdtand the difference between lying and sarcasm. If you want to accuse me of lying you either a) Dont understand what sarcasm is b) Didn't realize my statement was sarcastic c) Are an idiot d) Are a huge idiot e) Trying to create an argument where I really am not going to engage in one.
 
I also remembered today that when in grad school pursuing my M.S. in physics, I coauthored an astronomy laboratory manual. The professor in charge of the course had the good graces to actually put my name on it as well :)

So I guess I am sort of a textbook contributor. Or, at least I was... once.

I like this thread. It has made me think about all the stuff that I've done over the years which I seem to have mostly forgotten.
 
Megalodon said:
Considering that I don't post under my own name, what makes you think that I would post my work here?

It kind of defeats the purpose...
Assuming the purpose is to remain anonymous. That is certainly not my purpose. :D

~~ Paul
 
What's your h-index? :)

I'd be wary of using that outside of a specific discipline and looking at the actual citataions or a citation index. My h-index is quite high I think - but only because I'm frequently cited by people who are exasperated by and disagreeing with me, or because I said something quotable, not because my few publications have merit! (And they are cited in papers from very different disciplines from my own, because of the nature of my work). Also if you publish lots your h-index I think might actually decline, even if some papers have an immense impact? So an h-index is useful, but not to be considered a perfect tool. Almost any working scientist has made more useful contributions than me, reagrdless of is they have many publications... :) It's a bit like judging musicians by Number 1 success - h-numbers reflect your visibility in a field, not your actual merits?

cj x
 
Just a couple of AAS degrees in Electrical and Electro-mechanical technologies, but I have held the positions of Senior Laboratory Technician (Engineering lab), Product Designer, Engineer, Project Engineer and Production Engineer. Although I have written countless reports, procedures, standards and specifications they all remain the proprietary property of the companies I worked for or their customers. I have never written anything published. My only generally distributed claim to fame is the ANSI C119.4 AA testing standard. We pioneered that testing protocol and I wrote the evaluation standard that my boss submitted to the C119.4 review board and became the AA certification. However, you will not find my name or the company’s name anywhere on that standard, while my boss’s name naturally appeared as a member of the review committee. I remember when he returned from that meeting, he handed me the minutes and asked what it was that the board had agreed to. I told him they agreed to exactly what I had sent him with, our new extreme duty testing standard.
 
I'm not a scientist but I'm excited to be able to claim that my work has been published in Nature. I won't reveal what it was because that destroys the kudos immediately :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom