Are YOU a scientist? What publications do you have to your name?

What are your scientific credentials?

  • I am a qualified scientist (degree or above) with published scientific material

    Votes: 68 34.0%
  • I am a qualified scientist (degree or above) with no published scientific material

    Votes: 29 14.5%
  • I am an uqualified scientist, with published scientific material

    Votes: 5 2.5%
  • I am not a scientist, but enjoy discussing science here

    Votes: 65 32.5%
  • I am not a scientist, and hate discussing science here

    Votes: 1 0.5%
  • I am an unqualified scientist, but know more about my scientific area of interest than most qualifie

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • I am a crackpot

    Votes: 16 8.0%
  • I am a weasal-fish .... from planet X

    Votes: 14 7.0%

  • Total voters
    200
Yeah, me and Steve Hawking

Actually, I did speak at a chapter meeting of a scientific society which was being cohosted by a section of the Royal Society of Chemistry. Some time later it came to me that I can claim to have addressed the Royal Society. So I do.
 
Coming on late, I can lay claim to publishing an article on determining porous particle density of fluidized powders back in the '80's. Later on I published an in-house derivation (purely mathematical) in determining the degree of wetting zeolites with doping solutions containing metal ions.
 
Don't know, don't care.
I only ask for the humor of it. IT's become some what of a thing recently. People have used it like some magical wand to offer respect for a person, rather than simply listen to thier statements or read thier papers.

As a pre-tenure faculty, I distinctly dislike the idea that it will factor into my package.
 
Also if you publish lots your h-index I think might actually decline, even if some papers have an immense impact?
No.
THe H-index is simply calculated as X number of papers that were referenced at least X times.

So if you have an H-index of 4, that means 4 of your papers were referenced at least 4 times.

An H-index of 8 means 8 papers 8 times... And so forth.

The bench mark I've heard is that for tenure, you should have 1 or 2 h-index factors for each year pretenure.
As such, if you go up in 6 years, then you should have an h-index of 6 to 12.

But like you said, it is highly dependant upon the field and the nature of your work. One of my least interesting papers was cited the most. While, What I consider the most important papers that I published are barely getting noticed.
 
No.
THe H-index is simply calculated as X number of papers that were referenced at least X times.

So if you have an H-index of 4, that means 4 of your papers were referenced at least 4 times.

An H-index of 8 means 8 papers 8 times... And so forth.

The bench mark I've heard is that for tenure, you should have 1 or 2 h-index factors for each year pretenure.
As such, if you go up in 6 years, then you should have an h-index of 6 to 12.

But like you said, it is highly dependant upon the field and the nature of your work. One of my least interesting papers was cited the most. While, What I consider the most important papers that I published are barely getting noticed.

I think things like h index; citation rates and impact factors are important but not everything. At least they offer some numbers to back up a record and take out a tiny bit of the subjectivity which lets senior faculty be political instead of objective.

I personally like the h index-- though mine's not high-- I just think it's a clever metric.

What field are you in?
 
No.
THe H-index is simply calculated as X number of papers that were referenced at least X times.

So if you have an H-index of 4, that means 4 of your papers were referenced at least 4 times.

An H-index of 8 means 8 papers 8 times... And so forth.

The bench mark I've heard is that for tenure, you should have 1 or 2 h-index factors for each year pretenure.
As such, if you go up in 6 years, then you should have an h-index of 6 to 12.

But like you said, it is highly dependant upon the field and the nature of your work. One of my least interesting papers was cited the most. While, What I consider the most important papers that I published are barely getting noticed.

The only formula I know is
A scientist has index h if h of [their] Np papers have at least h citations each, and the other (Np - h) papers have at most h citations each.
under which a decline is possible?

Not sure!
cj x
 
Well, I only have 2 peer reviewed papers published as 1st author so far, but between them they've been cited 44 times altogether!
 
No.
THe H-index is simply calculated as X number of papers that were referenced at least X times.

So if you have an H-index of 4, that means 4 of your papers were referenced at least 4 times.

An H-index of 8 means 8 papers 8 times... And so forth.

The bench mark I've heard is that for tenure, you should have 1 or 2 h-index factors for each year pretenure.
As such, if you go up in 6 years, then you should have an h-index of 6 to 12.

But like you said, it is highly dependant upon the field and the nature of your work. One of my least interesting papers was cited the most. While, What I consider the most important papers that I published are barely getting noticed.


Hunh. Dunno. I probably have an 'h' index of at least 15. But who knows. some of my papers are annoyingly well cited.
 
Pesta,
Funny you should say that. One of the reviewers got all over the "You can only show behavioral change in a single subject design, we dont need no steenkin group designs, we are the Radical Behaviorists!" mode.
Luckily, s/he was overruled.

To answer your question, I was trained in the standard quasi-Hullian learning theory mode back in the old shul.
But I got better.
 
Last edited:
Pesta,
Funny you should say that. One of the reviewers got all over the "You can only show behavioral change in a single subject design, we dont need no steenkin group designs, we are the Radical Behaviorists!" mode.
Luckily, s/he was overruled.

To answer your question, I was trained in the standard quasi-Hullian learning theory mode back in the old shul.
But I got better.

Oy. I've had reviewers like that...

Ask me about the "FIR AND IIR are jargon, and do not belong in a published paper" event, maybe. Oy yoy. (This is like saying 'the' is jargon in signal processing terms.)
 
Funny, I did that with your abstract. I'm lecturing on the second half of the memory chapter in intro tomorrow.
 
I like reading behaviorist research-- even though I am a cognitivist.

Reviewers can be quite mean too :(
 
Oy. I've had reviewers like that...

Ask me about the "FIR AND IIR are jargon, and do not belong in a published paper" event, maybe. Oy yoy. (This is like saying 'the' is jargon in signal processing terms.)

I've had worse. "This paper treats a trivial problem". Five year old mildly retarded children who were not toilet trained.
My speculation was that the reviewer was a person big in the "toilet training in a jiffy" field who I had some disagreements in the past.
 
I think things like h index; citation rates and impact factors are important but not everything. At least they offer some numbers to back up a record and take out a tiny bit of the subjectivity which lets senior faculty be political instead of objective.

I personally like the h index-- though mine's not high-- I just think it's a clever metric.
Certainly it has a use. But It seems to only serve to cause conflicts. I've heard excuses already made about why a high H-Factor doesn't count if it includes your grad year papers.
What field are you in?
Biomaterials/Chemical Engineering.
 
I think the index has some value, but wonder about which journals are included. Who decides? I had one in the Worm Runners Digest, did that count? What about the "We publish anything if you pay $$ a page?
We had someone always coming up for promotion. The articles were usually one page correlational studies in The Journal of Polymorphous Perverversity, or something. Someone asked, "Why are these articles so short?"
"Either because he is very concise or very cheap."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom