Are YOU a scientist? What publications do you have to your name?

What are your scientific credentials?

  • I am a qualified scientist (degree or above) with published scientific material

    Votes: 68 34.0%
  • I am a qualified scientist (degree or above) with no published scientific material

    Votes: 29 14.5%
  • I am an uqualified scientist, with published scientific material

    Votes: 5 2.5%
  • I am not a scientist, but enjoy discussing science here

    Votes: 65 32.5%
  • I am not a scientist, and hate discussing science here

    Votes: 1 0.5%
  • I am an unqualified scientist, but know more about my scientific area of interest than most qualifie

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • I am a crackpot

    Votes: 16 8.0%
  • I am a weasal-fish .... from planet X

    Votes: 14 7.0%

  • Total voters
    200
Naw, I'm just the editor who prettifies your manuscripts so the can be published. Worked for journals in the fields of astronomy and physics (my first love), chemistry, consumer behavioralism, psychology, and now, oncology.

I've always loved science, but went with a degree in English. Lazy turd.

Give us some tips!?!

What are very common examples of crappy writing you see?

What one thing most annoys you?

Is less always more?

Would you rather an author overuse the word "we" or write too much in the passive voice?

Is it ok to sometimes split infinitives?
More?!
 
{snip} Is it ok to sometimes split infinitives?
It is never ok to split an infinitive, even to emphatically make a point. You certainly would not want to boldly go where no man has gone before. That is the sort of pedantry up with which I shall not put.

And, don't get me started on beginning a sentence with the words 'and' or 'but'. Or obscenely dangling participles. Or sentence fractions.
 
Last edited:
eh, buying habits etc, that behavioral scientists studied and published and gave an important name. along the lines of behavior economics.

The only usage of "behavioralism that I ever saw was in Political Science, never in Psychology. Ever.
And we use the term "behavioral economics".
 
Last edited:
Give us some tips!?!

What are very common examples of crappy writing you see?

What one thing most annoys you?

Is less always more?

Would you rather an author overuse the word "we" or write too much in the passive voice?

Is it ok to sometimes split infinitives?
More?!

To be honest, I don't see crappy writing much. I don't enjoy reworking papers from scientists for whom English is a second language, but that's just me being too lazy to want to explain each change (which we have to do in the academic journal biz) rather than their writing being bad or anything.

Each journal has its own style (and usually a style guide), so the only thing that annoys me is when my fellow editors don't follow the same style (hence, more work for me at issue assembly time, and as I mentioned, I'm lazy).

As for the use of "we," I go by whatever style a particular journal uses. In the last journal, it was a huge no-no. The current one allows it.

I just realized how Switzerland I sound. 'Tis my work personality, I suppose, being cooped up in a cube :boxedin: (though I get to telework twice a week:D)

No split infinitives! no no, bad bpesta22, now off to the corner. No minties for you!
 
you ended that proposition with a preposition.
It's called polemic license. You neglected to capitalize the first letter of you sentense. do you think you can talk me on? Do you, punk ... ? Did I find five or six errors? To tell you the truth, in the excitement I lost track. Are you feeling lucky, punk ... ?
 
It's called polemic license. You neglected to capitalize the first letter of you sentense. do you think you can talk me on? Do you, punk ... ? Did I find five or six errors? To tell you the truth, in the excitement I lost track. Are you feeling lucky, punk ... ?

You peed ant!

And Sid, what would it take to again earn the minties?
 
There is no good reason why you shouldn't split an infinitive. Unless you are speaking Latin. ;)
 
I think sometimes they behave better when you separate them. It's like a time out.
 
Naw, I'm just the editor who prettifies your manuscripts so the can be published. Worked for journals in the fields of astronomy and physics (my first love), chemistry, consumer behavioralism, psychology, and now, oncology.

I've always loved science, but went with a degree in English. Lazy turd.
So, were you the one who removed three commas from the manuscript of my first paper, thus making it appear that I was claiming to have used photographic astronomy images from the 3rd millenium BC?
 
So, were you the one who removed three commas from the manuscript of my first paper, thus making it appear that I was claiming to have used photographic astronomy images from the 3rd millenium BC?


You weren't making that claim? My bad. Sorry about that.
 
Not a scientist, but will volunteer to be someone's experimental guinea pig for the right price. Also aspire to have a disease named after me some day.
 
Well, I'm almost done refereeing my first article (in a crummy journal, but I got 2 more reviews to do for better journals)... It almost feels good to recommend rejecting.
 
Does being a co-author count? Is it worth one point, or a fractional point?

Does citation of my lab count if I am a part-owner and did the actual work?

:confused:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom