Are the Markets all Manipulated or not?

Fair enough, Kev. But do you understand why ZH is considered "not a reliable/good source", and considered kind of on par with infowars.com?

I understand that many people here want to think that, (infowars is pushing it a bit far) so it must infuriate them how early and correct they continually are.

A better question would be do you understand the difference between traders and economists? ZH is not written by, or for, economists. Modern economics is in fact, Woo.

Do you see why someone like me (I'm not really an economics expert, but I've spent 30 minutes or so a day for about 6 years trying to figure out economics) might write them off? I mean, they don't seem to even have an internally coherent working theory of economics. They just publish any and every idea that seems extreme and extremely alarming.

not really true, here's an interview detailing what they are trying to achieve, I believe they succeed.

What do you make of Taibbi's economic journalism, or NakedCapitalism?

not familiar with either really.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough, Kev. But do you understand why ZH is considered "not a reliable/good source", and considered kind of on par with infowars.com?

Do you see why someone like me (I'm not really an economics expert, but I've spent 30 minutes or so a day for about 6 years trying to figure out economics) might write them off? I mean, they don't seem to even have an internally coherent working theory of economics. They just publish any and every idea that seems extreme and extremely alarming.?

The fact that one of their writers signs himself Tyler Durden is pretty much proof positive they're in the tinfoil hat brigade (or at the very minimum have poor taste in cinema)
 
The fact that one of their writers signs himself Tyler Durden is pretty much proof positive they're in the tinfoil hat brigade (or at the very minimum have poor taste in cinema)

this is possibly the most uninformed comment I have ever read on the subject. Anonymity does however torpedo the pseudoskeptics favourite tactic here, that of "shoot the messenger", and so they are left with no other recourse than dismissal on principle. (or putting their fingers in their ears and going NUNUNUNUNU!!!!)

http://www.peakprosperity.com/blog/...en-can-us-avoid-free-falling-bankruptcy/49554

2. Is "Tyler Durden" a real person or a collective of editors? What advantages does ZH gain by operating under pseudonyms and what does it lose?

A: Tyler Durden is the embodiment of the idea that the only thing that matters is content. And since ideas tend to be ephemeral, the right question is not who or what he or she may be, but what the sought-after goal is. To wit: content, especially in the context of often complicated financial matters, succeeds in its goal not if it convinces, but if it makes the reader think and reevaluate existing preconceptions.

Often, that involves forcefully breaking (and sometimes destroying) established, often petrified, structures and modes of thought, and who better to achieve this than Tyler Durden.

Additionally, by avoiding the same “personality cult” trap with which traditional corporate-entrenched media often attempts to lure its ideological opponents, we enjoy forcing them to acknowledge just how much (or, much more often, how little) of the actual content they can overturn in order to establish the veracity of their ideas.

Naturally, on the other end of the contextual spectrum, there is the recently popular phenomenon of WikiLeaks. But that is a topic for another day.
 
Last edited:
I understand that many people here want to think that, (infowars is pushing it a bit far) so it must infuriate them how early and correct they continually are.

A better question would be do you understand the difference between traders and economists? ZH is not written by, or for, economists. Modern economics is in fact, Woo.



.

I agree that a lot of modern economics is woo. But not all of it.

There are a few academic economists who have an operating theory of economics, which is accessible to all, who were screaming about the housing bubble (and the impending economic collapse) by 2003-2005 or so, and continue to make accurate predictions.
Dean Baker, Bill Black, Krugman, and Michael Hudson come to mind.

Turned out they were all members of an email list "exposed" by...lol...Andrew Breitbart.
Taibbi wrote about this:
http://www.rollingstone.com/politic...-street-is-bigger-than-left-vs-right-20111017

Baker, Black, Yves Smith etc are pretty meticulous. They're so correct so often that I did (shamefully) read their emails, that Breitbart "exposed".

And what I found was that all of them are exactly who they say they are, holding the opinions they publicly say they hold. It was so "Woah" that I almost immediately closed out the window and felt fairly ashamed for reading their emails.

Really, reading people's hacked emails is not something otherwise "good people" do. But I was curious. I wanted to know their agenda.

I think it was a website called "bigGovernment.com" or something like that which published their emails.

So, what's your story, Kev? Why do you see ZH as a reliable source?

FWIW, I found this, written around 2003:
http://www.outstitute.org/blog/download/MichaelHudson/Hudson_RoadToSerfdom.pdf

Do you think I'm foolish for looking to Hudson et al for economic analysis?
 
I agree that a lot of modern economics is woo. But not all of it.

There are a few academic economists who have an operating theory of economics, which is accessible to all, who were screaming about the housing bubble (and the impending economic collapse) by 2003-2005 or so, and continue to make accurate predictions.
Dean Baker, Bill Black, Krugman, and Michael Hudson come to mind.

I dont really know Baker or Hudson, but prefer to follow money managers with longterm track records ideally with their own "skin in the game", and coincidentally, many of them are featured or contributors to..

So, what's your story, Kev? Why do you see ZH as a reliable source?

ZH are 100% reliable with the verifiable facts. they do however fill in any gaps with sarcastic and bearish overtones, I am well aware of this.

A reliable source? They are a source, and continually provide the bearish counterpoint to the lamestream media's sugar and honey coated nonsense. they are fast onto the news, often first, and provide a unique "trader's eye" view of the financial world.

they also from time to time write fairly seminal pieces of their own, rather than from the contributors. Here is one such:

The Bronze Swan Arrives - is this China's Lehman moment?

The Bronze Swan Arrives: Is The End Of Copper Financing China's "Lehman Event"?
Submitted by Tyler Durden on 05/23/2013

In all the hoopla over Japan's stock market crash and China's PMI miss last night, the biggest news of the day was largely ignored: copper, and the fact that copper's ubiquitous arbitrage and rehypothecation role in China's economy through the use of Chinese Copper Financing Deals (CCFD) is coming to an end.

Copper, as China pundits may know, is the key shadow interest rate arbitrage tool, through the use of financing deals that use commodities with high value-to-density ratios such as gold, copper, nickel, which in turn are used as collateral against which USD-denominated China-domestic Letters of Credit are pleged, in what can often result in a seemingly infinite rehypothecation loop (see explanation below) between related onshore and offshore entities, allowing loop participants to pick up virtually risk-free arbitrage (i.e., profits), which however boosts China's FX lending and leads to upward pressure on the CNY.

Since the end result of this arbitrage hits China's current account directly, and is the reason for the recent aberrations in Chinese export data that have made a mockery of China's economic data reporting, China's State Administration on Foreign Exchange (SAFE) on May 5 finally passed new regulations which will effectively end such financing deals.

The impact of this development can not be overstated: according to independent observers, as well as firms like Goldman, this will not only impact the copper market (very adversely) as copper will suddenly go from a positive return/carry asset to a negative carry asset leading to wholesale dumping from bonded warehouses, but will likely take out a substantial chunk of synthetic shadow leverage out of the Chinese market and economy.

One month later..

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-06-20/here-whats-going-china-bronze-swan-redux

Here Is What's Going On In China: The Bronze Swan Redux

A month ago, when stock markets around the globe were hitting all time highs, we wrote "The Bronze Swan Arrives: Is The End Of Copper Financing China's "Lehman Event"?" which as so often happens, many read, but few appreciated for what it truly was - the end of a major shadow leverage conduit (one involving unlimited rehypothecation at that),and the collapse of a core source of shadow liquidity.

One month later, China's "Lehman event" is on the verge of appearing, and with Overnight repo rates hitting 25% last night, coupled with rumors of bank bailouts rampant, it very well already may have but don't expect the secretive Chinese politburo and PBOC to disclose it any time soon. So now that the market has finally once again caught up with reality, for the benefit of all those who missed it the first time, here is, once again, a look at the arrival of China's Bronze Swan.

I didnt see this anywhere else, but thanks to ZH (alone) I knew all about what was potentially coming in China imminently, a month ago.

The FT started on it yesterday I think. you know, stuff like this, over and over for a few years. Their outcome predictions may not always come true, but their own research, news & insight from Hedgie world often genuinely isn't available anywhere else on the web.

do I believe everything I read on there, especially from contributors? No.

Do I generally take seriously the possibility with major ZH authored articles, that they could be right yet again? oh yes.

FWIW, I found this, written around 2003:
http://www.outstitute.org/blog/download/MichaelHudson/Hudson_RoadToSerfdom.pdf

Do you think I'm foolish for looking to Hudson et al for economic analysis?

I'll check him out and get back to you.
 
Modern economics is in fact, Woo.

Re: your sig, can you tell me exactly when the world will find out it's bankrupt?

I'm not a trader or economist. I'm a working stiff with a 401(k). I use my wages to buy food, shelter, energy, cars, etc. But the bulk of my net worth is the 401(k) which is value based largely on opinion. If everybody tried to cash out, pretty soon no one could cash out. It's even the same with a passbook savings account (can those exist at interest rates near 0%?)

When I try to understand economics I am hampered by primitive thinking, to whit: So-called "wealth" means nothing to me except that some day I'll use it to buy stuff. Even the value of gold is an opinion - based on a trend for hundreds/thousands of years. I'll always be able to trade the gold for stuff, presumably, except for clean water when there is no clean water, gasoline when there is no gasoline or food when there is no food.

I must be truly primitive because it's the only way I can think. My withheld 401(k) contributions did OK, on paper, because I was/am content just to beat inflation. Even that's not so great because the premise is when I retire I will be in a lower tax bracket than I was when I received the wages, which is probably not true. My higher-earning field went bust and I'm in a lower-earning field. It's OK, because every month I get enough cash to pay for the shelter/food/energy I need that month. I don't care about "things" beyond a few obvious items like a reliable car. I also like to consume "travel," which isn't a thing but which is based on things(!) like the value of airplanes and jet fuel and surplus shelter in the form of "lodgings."

Can you tell where this is going? Even if I had a "foolproof" moneymaking scheme, it doesn't matter, because "money" is abstract. This bugged me even when I was a kid. The stuff that holds its value is ... stuff, if it's maintained, or in its original wrapper, or whatever. So I thought, does that mean canned food and bottled water, firewood, a bicycle, a physical house? But if it comes to that ... well, the world wakes up and finds everyone's is broke, because their 401(k) statement is a piece of paper. And their cash. And gold, well, gold is pretty, but it's still an opinion.

On further thought I realized there is only one safe investment - guns and ammo. Because then if I don't have stuff I can take someone else's.

Through the 401(k) I bought a bunch of "income" vs. "growth" stocks/bonds because I didn't think things could keep growing forever, you know? When I bought my house, I didn't consider it an investment. A tax write-off, sure, but the idea that housing would increase infinitely in value was just wrong, IMO. No, if we were overbuilt on houses, they would just be surplus lumber or stucco (what is that good for?). Termite food. And as far as I can tell this is what happened. Houses for a lot of people seemed like a sure thing and interest rates were low and demand drove prices up, to the point where it made sense to build them on spec.

The builder wanted a contract to build my house. They were built one at a time. Then a subdivision next door sprang up very quickly and remained virtually vacant. Lights went on and off, trash bins moved to curbs but I never saw anyone. I later looked up ownership and almost all the names were Chinese, Vietnamese or Armenian. It seemed clear that a group of investors (speculators) had built them, then the bubble burst and millions of people could either not obtain a mortgage or service the one they had.

Now: Is my "stuff" view insane? Is reality the sum on the bank statement, or is reality that all economic well-being comes down to stuff?

Sorry if this is off-topic. Market manipulation (this is sad) doesn't bother me as long as they let me keep a little - enough to compensate for loss of purchasing power when I paid in. The thing that scares me most is the possibility I'm right.
 
Correction to rant above: I probably will be in a lower tax bracket when (if) I retire.

I'm sorry if this is not the thread for it, but what I posted above reflects a real limitation on my part. I think in very concrete terms, and I would like to build a more sophisticated understanding of economics. Can anyone recommend some reading? I subscribe to the Economist and enjoy it, because many of the articles are based on very concrete things. When the discussion gets more abstract my comprehension plummets.

And I desperately want to avoid, for now, any text with an agenda beyond educating the reader. As spin-free as possible.
 
Re: your sig, can you tell me exactly when the world will find out it's bankrupt?

I certainly wish I could amigo. The only realistic answer anybody has for this is that:

it would be naive for anybody to think they can predict the circumstances of the end of a 70 year debt supercycle with any accuracy - Kyle Bass

I'm not an economist either, and only an amateur and relative beginner trader, nor am I American so I'm entirely unqualified to comment on your finances, but with regards this:

When I try to understand economics I am hampered by primitive thinking, to whit: So-called "wealth" means nothing to me except that some day I'll use it to buy stuff.

Now: Is my "stuff" view insane? Is reality the sum on the bank statement, or is reality that all economic well-being comes down to stuff?

No, I don't think it's insane at all, I've argued the same myself here.

Currency is only a (transient) claim on the real wealth. All paper assets are in fact, and there are a few hundred trillion x the amount of them compared to real stuff now too, so the eventual forced unwind and write down of trillions in unpayable debt (leveraged, securitized and derivated) is not going to be pretty.

people seem to have different ways of dealing with this possibility, the vast majority just prefer not to think about it and will convince themselves it can never happen, so they don't have to think about it.

I still think that maths is still maths and that the Princeton PHDs and their "models" will fail at changing the rules and be sideswiped by their unintended and unforseen consequences as usual.

The thing that scares me most is the possibility I'm right.

yea, know this feeling too. sorry cant be any more help.
 
kevsta said:
The fact that one of their writers signs himself Tyler Durden is pretty much proof positive they're in the tinfoil hat brigade (or at the very minimum have poor taste in cinema)

this is possibly the most uninformed comment I have ever read on the subject. Anonymity does however torpedo the pseudoskeptics favourite tactic here, that of "shoot the messenger", and so they are left with no other recourse than dismissal on principle. (or putting their fingers in their ears and going NUNUNUNUNU!!!!)

http://www.peakprosperity.com/blog/straight-talk-tyler-durden-can-us-avoid-free-falling-bankruptcy/49554

2. Is "Tyler Durden" a real person or a collective of editors? What advantages does ZH gain by operating under pseudonyms and what does it lose?

A: Tyler Durden is the embodiment of the idea that the only thing that matters is content. And since ideas tend to be ephemeral, the right question is not who or what he or she may be, but what the sought-after goal is. To wit: content, especially in the context of often complicated financial matters, succeeds in its goal not if it convinces, but if it makes the reader think and reevaluate existing preconceptions.

Often, that involves forcefully breaking (and sometimes destroying) established, often petrified, structures and modes of thought, and who better to achieve this than Tyler Durden.

Additionally, by avoiding the same “personality cult” trap with which traditional corporate-entrenched media often attempts to lure its ideological opponents, we enjoy forcing them to acknowledge just how much (or, much more often, how little) of the actual content they can overturn in order to establish the veracity of their ideas.

Naturally, on the other end of the contextual spectrum, there is the recently popular phenomenon of WikiLeaks. But that is a topic for another day.
You consider this to be a good argument?

Well I wouldn't consider it a particularly deeply though out argument, however it has been my experience that internet posters who give themselves grandiose names, or names of characters featuring in the masturbatory iconoclastic fantasies of pimply adolescents (e.g. John Galt, Spartacus, The Dark Lord, Tyler Durden etc) are more full of it than the average bear.

While the comment from ZeroHedge about content being all that matters my be true, you need some way to judge whether content is true, selectively filtered, spun or tweaked in some way. One way is to compare the content to multiple other sources with differing opinions, this takes a lot of time. A quick and dirty way is to see if the author is an uncritical fan of one of the most overrated, pseudo-deep films of the past 20 years.
 
Well I wouldn't consider it a particularly deeply though out argument, however it has been my experience that internet posters who give themselves grandiose names, or names of characters featuring in the masturbatory iconoclastic fantasies of pimply adolescents (e.g. John Galt, Spartacus, The Dark Lord, Tyler Durden etc) are more full of it than the average bear.

While the comment from ZeroHedge about content being all that matters my be true, you need some way to judge whether content is true, selectively filtered, spun or tweaked in some way. One way is to compare the content to multiple other sources with differing opinions, this takes a lot of time. A quick and dirty way is to see if the author is an uncritical fan of one of the most overrated, pseudo-deep films of the past 20 years.



Tell me, have you ever heard of a thing called 'critical thinking'? It deals with reality. I don't think the words 'quick and dirty' appear in any text on the subject, do you? In addition, do you really expect anyone here to take such justification seriously? Really? Would you? (Perhaps you would, if all your critical thinking methodology as stated above. You shouldn't, just so you know)


So far those who posit the argument that the markets are manipulated have brought a lot of evidence to this thread. Those that state the opposite only come with blank denial and a dismissal of any evidence and no substance.


'I do not like his name' is not an argument. It might be considered a dodge.
 
Tell me, have you ever heard of a thing called 'critical thinking'? It deals with reality. I don't think the words 'quick and dirty' appear in any text on the subject, do you? In addition, do you really expect anyone here to take such justification seriously? Really? Would you? (Perhaps you would, if all your critical thinking methodology as stated above. You shouldn't, just so you know)


So far those who posit the argument that the markets are manipulated have brought a lot of evidence to this thread. Those that state the opposite only come with blank denial and a dismissal of any evidence and no substance.


'I do not like his name' is not an argument. It might be considered a dodge.

Have you ever heard of a thing called reading comprehension? I have not stated a position on whether the markets are rigged, so don't need to provide evidence.

The main proponent of market rigging is kevsta and all he's provided are quotes from Brock Strongo et al on ZeroHedge.

ZeroHedge may be right, but choosing to name yourself after a figment of a madman's imagination in a film doesn't encourage readers to take you seriously.
 
Have you ever heard of a thing called reading comprehension? I have not stated a position on whether the markets are rigged, so don't need to provide evidence.

So I can safely apply no weight to any of your comments until you have stated a position. Thanks for the clarification, I shall do so.


The main proponent of market rigging is kevsta and all he's provided are quotes from Brock Strongo et al on ZeroHedge.

Tell me, have you heard of a thing called 'reading comprehension'? Have you even read the thread and the posts? Not that you need to, as you have no stated postion.


ETA: Go on, state a position. I double dare you! :D
 
Last edited:
I'm not a trader or economist. I'm a working stiff with a 401(k). I use my wages to buy food, shelter, energy, cars, etc. But the bulk of my net worth is the 401(k) which is value based largely on opinion. If everybody tried to cash out, pretty soon no one could cash out. It's even the same with a passbook savings account (can those exist at interest rates near 0%?)

Your 401k is loosely based on the discounted present value of the future free cash flows thrown off by the securities within it, more or less, with the propensity for monetary-induced asset bubbles to over or under value the stocks within it on occasion.

When I try to understand economics I am hampered by primitive thinking, to whit: So-called "wealth" means nothing to me except that some day I'll use it to buy stuff. Even the value of gold is an opinion - based on a trend for hundreds/thousands of years. I'll always be able to trade the gold for stuff, presumably, except for clean water when there is no clean water, gasoline when there is no gasoline or food when there is no food.

I must be truly primitive because it's the only way I can think. My withheld 401(k) contributions did OK, on paper, because I was/am content just to beat inflation. Even that's not so great because the premise is when I retire I will be

If you're content just to "beat inflation" using your investment portfolio, then you have a serious problem, because going concerns are typically supposed to generate profits in excess of inflation, and they have corresponding risks that you are exposing yourself to.

Can you tell where this is going? Even if I had a "foolproof" moneymaking scheme, it doesn't matter, because "money" is abstract. This bugged me even when I was a kid. The stuff that holds its value is ... stuff, if it's maintained, or in its original wrapper, or whatever. So I thought, does that mean canned food and bottled water, firewood, a bicycle, a physical house? But if it comes to that ... well, the world wakes up and finds everyone's is broke, because their 401(k) statement is a piece of paper. And their cash. And gold, well, gold is pretty, but it's still an opinion.

Money isn't really abstract, value is. What's concrete, is the ability of the issuers of fiat money to perpetually steal real goods and services ("stuff"), from those who save money, or even hold small balances of it. To the extent that people realize the social benefits of using gold as money, it prevents the issuers of money, be they central banks, banana republics, or illegal counterfeiters, from stealing from everyone else.

On further thought I realized there is only one safe investment - guns and ammo. Because then if I don't have stuff I can take someone else's.

Or, you can invest in US Treasury obligations, as a derivative of violent expropriation. The entire premise of owning US government debt is that big guys with guns stand ready to take "stuff" from other people in order to pay you, the creditor. This will of course continue to work until it doesn't anymore.

Now: Is my "stuff" view insane? Is reality the sum on the bank statement, or is reality that all economic well-being comes down to stuff?

Real wealth is represented by the ownership of assets, both real and financial assets, which presumably throw off cash flows which enable us to buy things that we all need and want. What you and most people don't yet grasp, is how central banking and the issuance of money represent a system for expropriating real wealth without working, or producing anything in exchange for it. This is of course rationalized by a bunch of false premises.

Sorry if this is off-topic. Market manipulation (this is sad) doesn't bother me as long as they let me keep a little - enough to compensate for loss of purchasing power when I paid in. The thing that scares me most is the possibility I'm right.

If market manipulation doesn't bother you, then you deserve exactly what you're likely to get.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom