Modern economics is in fact, Woo.
Re: your sig, can you tell me exactly when the world will find out it's bankrupt?
I'm not a trader or economist. I'm a working stiff with a 401(k). I use my wages to buy food, shelter, energy, cars, etc. But the bulk of my net worth is the 401(k) which is value based largely on opinion. If everybody tried to cash out, pretty soon no one could cash out. It's even the same with a passbook savings account (can those exist at interest rates near 0%?)
When I try to understand economics I am hampered by primitive thinking, to whit: So-called "wealth" means nothing to me except that some day I'll use it to buy
stuff. Even the value of gold is an opinion - based on a trend for hundreds/thousands of years. I'll always be able to trade the gold for stuff, presumably, except for clean water when there is no clean water, gasoline when there is no gasoline or food when there is no food.
I must be truly primitive because it's the only way I can think. My withheld 401(k) contributions did OK, on paper, because I was/am content just to beat inflation. Even that's not so great because the premise is when I retire I will be in a lower tax bracket than I was when I received the wages, which is probably not true. My higher-earning field went bust and I'm in a lower-earning field. It's OK, because every month I get enough cash to pay for the shelter/food/energy I need that month. I don't care about "things" beyond a few obvious items like a reliable car. I also like to consume "travel," which isn't a thing but which is based on things(!) like the value of airplanes and jet fuel and surplus shelter in the form of "lodgings."
Can you tell where this is going? Even if I had a "foolproof" moneymaking scheme, it doesn't matter, because "money" is abstract. This bugged me even when I was a kid. The stuff that holds its value is ... stuff, if it's maintained, or in its original wrapper, or whatever. So I thought, does that mean canned food and bottled water, firewood, a bicycle, a physical house? But if it comes to that ... well, the world wakes up and finds everyone's is broke, because their 401(k) statement is a piece of paper. And their cash. And gold, well, gold is pretty, but it's still an opinion.
On further thought I realized there is only
one safe investment - guns and ammo. Because then if I don't have stuff I can take someone else's.
Through the 401(k) I bought a bunch of "income" vs. "growth" stocks/bonds because I didn't think things could keep growing forever, you know? When I bought my house, I didn't consider it an investment. A tax write-off, sure, but the idea that housing would increase infinitely in value was just
wrong, IMO. No, if we were overbuilt on houses, they would just be surplus lumber or stucco (what is
that good for?). Termite food. And as far as I can tell this is what happened. Houses for a lot of people seemed like a sure thing and interest rates were low and demand drove prices up, to the point where it made sense to build them on spec.
The builder wanted a contract to build my house. They were built one at a time. Then a subdivision next door sprang up very quickly and remained virtually vacant. Lights went on and off, trash bins moved to curbs but I never
saw anyone. I later looked up ownership and almost all the names were Chinese, Vietnamese or Armenian. It seemed clear that a group of investors (speculators) had built them, then the bubble burst and millions of people could either not obtain a mortgage or service the one they had.
Now: Is my "stuff" view insane? Is reality the sum on the bank statement, or is reality that all economic well-being comes down to stuff?
Sorry if this is off-topic. Market manipulation (this is sad) doesn't bother me as long as they let me keep a little - enough to compensate for loss of purchasing power when I paid in. The thing that scares me most is the possibility I'm right.