Are the Markets all Manipulated or not?

Turk and his ilk continually say that physical gold is substantially undervalued and will eventually correct this spectacularly.

thus far it has been going on for approaching two decades, and when viewed in that context they are still right. of course in that period, the price will also have pullbacks, sometimes for months or years, it does not invalidate the longterm thesis.

....particularly if the basic thesis is unfalsifiable. Even if gold prices remained static or dropped significantly over the next 1, 2, 5, 10, 20 or 50 years they could still make that claim.

Their claim aligned with a gold bull market that lasted 12 years. It hasn't for the last couple.
 
No mater what the GB's posted, it's wrong. That's the beauty of being a skeptic. You can accurately predict that the GB's are spectacularly wrong. No matter what they post.

:jaw-dropp

I find it quite ironic that you seem not to scrutinze things very closely and carefully before shooting from the hip, despite your hinting nick's empty undertaking to do so.

I find it rather moronic that you can find justification in skepticism for your poorly thought-through blanket statement on how you determine validity in som-one's points.

I bet I can make a couple of very accurate predictions on your thoughts on the above and below, but would have to break almost all the rules in one post in order to do so, so I'll leave it there.

:D


You might be surprised to know that many more people are actually reading this thread and gaining immense value from it, than the few posting in it, and that your posts in here are, in my opinion, the least helpful of all by far.

I'm positive your hit-and-run type contribution might be valued by many in certain circumstances, but how's about facilitating some continuity in this discussion and getting properly engaged in the discussion, if you have something of value to add ?
 
the factual 7 year delay to return a small amount of gold (unclear whether 150 or 300 tons) when the ECB can supply 350 tons to 10 banks in a few months is not speculation.

Actually the link to the Bundesbank only contains how much gold they intend to hold and where they intend to hold it. It says nothing about the timetable for making the changes or any reasons for that timetable.

The idea that there is a 7 year delay, or that the Fed is in any way scrambling to get the gold is pure speculation. That speculation could of course be right, but it's still speculation.

the factual 7 year delay the Fed supposedly has 6720 tons of gold stored. seven years, and you cant see it when you visit? :rolleyes:

I don't know what the protocol is for one country to allow access to its gold reserve storage facility to another country.
 
Last edited:
...
As exact details of the dealings they discuss are all classified top secret as matters of national security, unfortunately hard evidence of the type you require is a little difficult to come by.

as was hard evidence of LIBOR rigging even without national security laws preventing disclosure of relevant facts, until well..

Sure yes, but you do see the resemblance of that position to most other CTs don't you ?

Don't get me wrong, I think you make a number of valid points, and am willing to acknowledge that I can not match your comprehension on the subject, but a few things don't tie up for me.

The situation in my country, South Africa is similair to many others. Stocks are at an all-time high, interest rates are at 15 odd-year lows, reported inflation is at 10 odd-year lows (actual felt inflation is very different to this), and Gold is up 100% in the last 5 years, up 30% last 2 years and up 2.5% last year, but have been beaten down 16% from it's all time high in Oct 2012.

Our government can not even rig a stupid municipal tender without being caught, leave alone the JSE and SA's Gold market. Why these similarities then ? Could it actually be the partially oiled market machine turning the right cogs in the economic gearbox ? It does seem so.

When negative global economic news hits, our currency decreases in value and if during this period the gold price takes a beating, this maintains my gold holdings' value in my own currency in the short term and then still grows in the long term. It's acting like a store of wealth, just like it should.

I would have thought that if market manipulation was at play here, the developing markets would be hardest hit ? They don't seem to be ?

If it's global control and manipulation of ALL markets in ALL countries over the range of ALL financial instruments ASWELL as metals, well then their simulation is pretty convincing and as good as the real thing ?
 
Actually the link to the Bundesbank only contains how much gold they intend to hold and where they intend to hold it. It says nothing about the timetable for making the changes or any reasons for that timetable.

The idea that there is a 7 year delay, or that the Fed is in any way scrambling to get the gold is pure speculation. That speculation could of course be right, but it's still speculation.

granted. however, if the problems were real, what would happen if they just told the truth? could they ever do that, given their parts in the play?

I don't know what the protocol is for one country to allow access to its gold reserve storage facility to another country.

youre not allowed to see it.

http://www.spiegel.de/international...-see-gold-in-us-federal-reserve-a-864068.html

As a result, in addition to safeguarding the reserves of over 60 countries, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York continues to hold 1,536 metric tons of German gold -- or nearly half of Berlin's reserves. This enormous hoard of gold is stored in the fifth subfloor of the bank's building on Liberty Street, 25 meters (80 feet) below street level, and 15 meters below sea level. According to the bank's website, the vault rests on the bedrock of Manhattan Island.

[ note, a few metres from JPMs currently fast-emptying commercial gold vault ] http://www.cmegroup.com/trading/energy/files/Gold_Stocks.xls

and a timely quote from the head of the CME group yesterday..:D

What’s interesting about gold, when we had that big break two weeks ago we saw all the gold stocks trade down significantly, we saw all the gold products trade down significantly, but one thing that did not trade down, was gold coins, tangible real gold. That’s going to show you, people don’t want certificates, they don’t want anything else. They want the real product.

- Terrence Duffy, President and Executive Chairman of CME Group Inc,. on Bloomberg TV yesterday (April 29, 2013)

(back to Speigel)
Tourists are allowed to venture below street level to see the vault. After descending in an elevator, they stand in front of an enormous steel cylinder that pivots like a door in a 140-ton steel-and-concrete frame. But not even the owners are allowed to view their own gold. According to the Federal Audit Office report, the Fed explained that "in the interest of security and of the control process" no "viewings" are possible.

Finally, in 2007, "following numerous enquiries," Bundesbank staff members were allowed to see the facility, but they reportedly only made it to the anteroom of the German reserves.

In fact, auditors from the Bundesbank made a second visit in May 2011.

This time one of the nine compartments was also opened, in which the German gold bars are densely stacked. A few were pulled out and weighed. But this part of the report has been blacked out -- out of consideration for the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

"I would like more transparency on the issue," says Bundesbank board member Thiele. The Americans are very sensitive, though, when it comes to security procedures in their gold storage facilities. In their second major depository, the legendary Fort Knox, practically no one in recent decades has been allowed to view the gold reserves.

and a general question, WHY is this? WHY all the secrecy? :confused:
 
Sure yes, but you do see the resemblance of that position to most other CTs don't you ?

yes of course :D

much of the time I have deep suspicions but partially play devils advocate to see if anybody has better information and can convince me otherwise.

Don't get me wrong, I think you make a number of valid points, and am willing to acknowledge that I can not match your comprehension on the subject, but a few things don't tie up for me.

The situation in my country, South Africa is similair to many others. Stocks are at an all-time high, interest rates are at 15 odd-year lows, reported inflation is at 10 odd-year lows (actual felt inflation is very different to this), and Gold is up 100% in the last 5 years, up 30% last 2 years and up 2.5% last year, but have been beaten down 16% from it's all time high in Oct 2012.

Our government can not even rig a stupid municipal tender without being caught, leave alone the JSE and SA's Gold market. Why these similarities then ? Could it actually be the partially oiled market machine turning the right cogs in the economic gearbox ? It does seem so.

When negative global economic news hits, our currency decreases in value and if during this period the gold price takes a beating, this maintains my gold holdings' value in my own currency in the short term and then still grows in the long term. It's acting like a store of wealth, just like it should.

I would have thought that if market manipulation was at play here, the developing markets would be hardest hit ? They don't seem to be ?

If it's global control and manipulation of ALL markets in ALL countries over the range of ALL financial instruments ASWELL as metals, well then their simulation is pretty convincing and as good as the real thing ?

I'm not saying "control" that's a whole other level. I am saying systemic and endemic manipulation as and when, but not all things at all times (except for the FX markets which pretty much are IMO)

and as for doing it without getting caught, its levels of sophistication, the long history of the ESF (thoroughly documented on link above, (here) on 5 long videos with all sources linked below) clearly shows they have been active on a covert basis for many many years in all kinds of things. and they answer to no-one, as far as I can gather.

I would like to see some of the JREF team look at all of this, as they have looked at 911. nobody's interested though apparently.

..and as good as the real thing? ..maybe, if it lasts.. ..if it is real, then it will all last and all good again, I can get back to living the millionaire life I'm obviously entitled to based on unlimited credit creation.. :D
 
Last edited:
....particularly if the basic thesis is unfalsifiable. Even if gold prices remained static or dropped significantly over the next 1, 2, 5, 10, 20 or 50 years they could still make that claim.

Their claim aligned with a gold bull market that lasted 12 years. It hasn't for the last couple.

A secular bull market lasts a long time

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_trend#Secular_market_trend

A secular market trend is a long-term trend that lasts 5 to 25 years and consists of a series of primary trends. A secular bear market consists of smaller bull markets and larger bear markets; a secular bull market consists of larger bull markets and smaller bear markets.

In a secular bull market the prevailing trend is "bullish" or upward-moving. The United States stock market was described as being in a secular bull market from about 1983 to 2000 (or 2007), with brief upsets including the crash of 1987 and the market collapse of 2000-2002 triggered by the Internet Technology Bubble.

In a secular bear market, the prevailing trend is "bearish," or downward-moving. An example of a secular bear market occurred in gold between January 1980 to June 1999, culminating with the Brown Bottom. During this period the nominal gold price fell from a high of $850/oz ($30/g) to a low of $253/oz ($9/g),[4] and became part of the Great Commodities Depression.

..as does a secular Bear, which gold and stocks curiously swapped across to play each others roles around the 98-2000 period.

(not to be confused with a "truculent bear" which I have been called, once or twice :D )
 
Last edited:
granted. however, if the problems were real, what would happen if they just told the truth? could they ever do that, given their parts in the play?

"If" being the operative word.


One politician has a hair up his rear, Peter Gauweiler, and while the Bundesbank is happy to pander to his whims, the gold storage facility in another country is not willing to go to the time and expense of pandering to him.

[ note, a few metres from JPMs currently fast-emptying commercial gold vault ] http://www.cmegroup.com/trading/energy/files/Gold_Stocks.xls

And that one got punted off to conspiracy theories where it belongs..

and a timely quote from the head of the CME group yesterday..:D

Yes, investors are buying into the hype.

(back to Speigel)

and a general question, WHY is this? WHY all the secrecy? :confused:

So you cannot see the difference between allowing tourists access to a specially constructed viewing area and allowing a crank German politician access to the Fed vaults ?

Even at Highland Park tourists can see some of the stock through a viewing window but only employees and the customs and excise get to access the full stock.

What WOULD be a story is if Fed broke the terms of the contract under which the German gold is held.
 
So you cannot see the difference between allowing tourists access to a specially constructed viewing area and allowing a crank German politician access to the Fed vaults ?

only a crank German politician? did you miss the Bundesbank Auditors?

and "crank" is in the eye of the beholder, I would have to say.

It will be the Swiss next. http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/swiss_n...central_bank_gold_reserves_.html?cid=35278920

one by one all the cranks will want their gold back and then where will we be? :D

ps my girlfriend is Swiss and is confident a referendum of the people will be gold positive. we shall see.

pps

And that one got punted off to conspiracy theories where it belongs..

my personal definition of conspiracy theory differs slightly from the norm here, to me a CT is just a potential conspiracy that has not been proven.

there are many and varied and some are way more plausible than others. but that's just me.
 
Last edited:
only a crank German politician? did you miss the Bundesbank Auditors?

No,

In fact, auditors from the Bundesbank made a second visit in May 2011. This time one of the nine compartments was also opened, in which the German gold bars are densely stacked. A few were pulled out and weighed. But this part of the report has been blacked out -- out of consideration for the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

Nowhere in here does it state that the auditors were denied access nor that they were dissatisfied with the access they got.



Back to Bundesbank board members:

"I would like more transparency on the issue," says Bundesbank board member Thiele. The Americans are very sensitive, though, when it comes to security procedures in their gold storage facilities. In their second major depository, the legendary Fort Knox, practically no one in recent decades has been allowed to view the gold reserves

So the U.S. are very sensitive when it comes to their gold storage facilities - that's not too surprising.
 
What WOULD be a story is if Fed broke the terms of the contract under which the German gold is held.

yes. where can we check the contract to see what the terms are? ie are they allowed to lease this gold out? and have they? is the gold still there?

doh, its all secret isnt it :D

as I understand this, the gold belongs to the people of Germany, and the people of the USA? But they cant know what is done with it (swaps and lease-wise) for reasons of national security, and nobody can ever see it or most definitely not properly and independently audit it.

Oh, and on the very day of a vote about auditing properly it another 1-5000 year event happened, and some naughty runaway algorithms randomly flashcrashed the DOW 1000 points in 5 minutes while the vote is on. lulz.

maybe my relatively brief time in recruitment totally destroyed my belief in human nature, possibly irreversibly, I fear.

anyway, Im a scumbag speculator, that is my job, I am allowed to speculate, on all kinds of things ;)
 
Sorry for the cliché, but extraordinary claims (and beating the market like has been claimed, "advanced guys" or not, is extraordinary) require extraordinary evidence. Will that be forthcoming?

Check your PMs. Date and time stamped evidence provided, with subsequent spectacular results.
 
The recent fiasco on COMEX was blatant manipulation. There are a lot of voices out there decrying the open criminal behavior that is happening. Professional voices. Voices of authority who know what they are talking about. It has become common knowledge this is going on.

And when you have the Attorney General of the United States saying he is not going to prosecute the crooks because that would shake up the markets, then you have a situation where the bad guys have been given official approval to continue to steal from every man, woman, and child on the planet.

Wake. Up. You are being robbed in broad daylight, and when the crooks are caught, they are given a fine that is relatively small compared to the profits of their crimes. The cops are letting them keep your stuff!

You are going to have a much smaller nest egg than you should have when you retire. So if you want to slam your hands over your eyes and ears, go right ahead, rubes.
 
Last edited:
Check your PMs. Date and time stamped evidence provided, with subsequent spectacular results.

right, so Adman doesn't believe you, and gets the good stuff, while I am willing to suspend disbelief and ask polite questions about what you trade and strategy and get ignored. :D

where is he anyway, did you hear back post "evidence supplied"?

anyway, back to OP - coke hookers and Libor manipulation, all in a weeks work

WSJ- Clubby London Trading Scene Fostered Libor Rate-Fixing Scandal
 
Check your PMs. Date and time stamped evidence provided, with subsequent spectacular results.


Thanks for your PMs and the links. As I mentioned in my reply, that was a very good call that you made. But as I said, one good call doesn't impress me, and as you don't make online predictions other than that one, there's no easy way to verify your claims of beating the market consistently.

So I remain skeptical, but good luck. :)
 
http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/05/02/jpmorgan-caught-in-swirl-of-regulatory-woes/

Government investigators have found that JPMorgan Chase devised “manipulative schemes” that transformed “money-losing power plants into powerful profit centers,” and that one of its most senior executives gave “false and misleading statements” under oath.

The findings appear in a confidential government document, reviewed by The New York Times, that was sent to the bank in March, warning of a potential crackdown by the regulator of the nation’s energy markets.

Mr. Dimon acknowledged in a recent letter to shareholders that “unfortunately, we expect we will have more” enforcement actions in “the coming months.” He apologized for letting “our regulators down” and vowed to “do all the work necessary to complete the needed improvements.”

Still, the broad regulatory scrutiny — at least eight federal agencies are investigating the bank — presents a threat to JPMorgan at a time when it is raking in record profits.

Mr. Dimon acknowledged in a recent letter to shareholders that “unfortunately, we expect we will have more” enforcement actions in “the coming months.” He apologized for letting “our regulators down” and vowed to “do all the work necessary to complete the needed improvements.”

Still, the broad regulatory scrutiny — at least eight federal agencies are investigating the bank — presents a threat to JPMorgan at a time when it is raking in record profits.
 
well, as people seem to have stopped attacking me (and nobody ever even tried to address the content, just the usual "shoot the messenger" approach) does this mean we are close to proving the thread title? :)

here's another article covering what (the thoroughly machine-gunned) Taibbi was talking about

http://www.moneymorning.com.au/20130503/the-next-wall-street-financial-scandal-has-arrived.html

Well, it looks like the major financial institutions can’t learn a lesson. They’re neck deep in yet another financial scandal of global proportions.

U.S. and international securities regulators investigating manipulation of LIBOR, the world’s most important set of benchmark interest rates, have uncovered another price-rigging scheme, this one in the $379 trillion market for interest rate swaps.

$379 Trillion, not Billion. Trillion.

[sounds a lot doesnt it, but it's only 1/3 of the annual Forex market size]

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has already issued subpoenas to Wall Street’s biggest banks and is interviewing a dozen former and current brokers from the Jersey City, NJ, offices of ICAP Plc

Big Banks in Big Trouble, Again?

Mega-banks primarily facilitate interest rate swaps by initially taking the other side of customers’ trades and are responsible for establishing pricing of these instruments in conjunction with a handful of brokers.

Similarly to how LIBOR is calculated, the ISDAFIX, the benchmark series of rates used to price interest rate swaps for U.S. dollar denominated swaps, is convened by a ‘panel’ of banks. The panel, according to the International Swaps and Derivatives Association consists of:

Bank of America Corp., Barclays, BNP Paribas SA, Citigroup Inc., Credit Suisse AG, Deutsche Bank AG, Goldman Sachs Group Inc., HSBC Holdings Plc, JPMorgan Chase & Co., Mizuho Financial Group

Manipulation of rate pricing is easy. ICAP posts rates, supposedly based on transactions and bid and offer quotes it receives and enters manually into what’s known as the 19901 screen (named for the Reuters screen page number).

Banks don’t have to submit their own rates as part of the panel; they can use the suggested rates ICAP posts. Or they submit their own rates to ICAP to be forwarded to Thompson Reuters who calculates the final numbers.

ICAP sits in the middle, entering by-hand prices and rates from the transactions that occur through their brokerage desk, which average a staggering $1.4 trillion a day.

Not only can banks ask ICAP brokers to post whatever quote benefits the bank’s internal trading book, whether it’s to affect a positive mark-to-market closing price for accounting and profit and loss (bonus) calculations, or manipulate an entry price on a new trade with a counterparty, they allegedly ask ICAP brokers to delay entry of actual transactions until after ISDAFIX rates are disseminated.

The delay can easily create a beneficial entry price on a trade that would otherwise be priced based on fresh data. Manipulation of prices and rates has huge profit and loss and mark-to-market implications in terms of capital reserve ratios and other bank balance sheet metrics.

and is anybody noticing any crossover here between:

the top 10 Forex trading banks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_market

and the LMBA "market-maker" bullion banks? http://www.lbma.org.uk/pages/index.cfm?page_id=63&title=full_members
 
Thanks for your PMs and the links. As I mentioned in my reply, that was a very good call that you made. But as I said, one good call doesn't impress me, and as you don't make online predictions other than that one, there's no easy way to verify your claims of beating the market consistently.

So I remain skeptical, but good luck. :)

ok, but would details of the information you have seen, tend to back up or disprove claims of achieving the result by understanding regular manipulation of some sort?

(as I contend my ongoing figures do) April to close of trading @ end week 1 May below

April-week1-May.png


As April was going so well I gave myself a couple of weeks off from the 18th onwards but opened 2 trades on the 30th which I closed on 01 May so have taken the 5 week period.

8% from 2 trades per week on an ongoing basis would be acceptable :D
 
Last edited:
I really don't know a lot about the markets, but I've been reading this thread with some interest.

One thing I noted was that the posts of one particular poster seemed to lack any substance, just seemed to be a series of blank statements with nothing to back them up:



I always get my financial news from Rolling Stone.

Nothing of substance here.

Those are Rolling Stones. :)

Nor here

CT is thataway =======>

Again, nothing here

Exactly.

I wonder why it won't happen?

Still not. Surely there's something along in a minute that will be better than unsupported denial...


The answer is no. The Jews....errr...I mean the "banks" are not manipulating the "markets". Whatever that means.

It would be illegal to do so. One wonders why the author or the gold bugs don't call the police or the SEC or some other regulatory or enforcement agency. I bet I know why.

No, still nothing. A bet that he knows why, but he doesn't tell us why he knows why.


Great. Then we will have an answer soon. I suspect it will not be what the OP expects.

Still nothing.


tl;dr

We'll find out soon enough. What will you say when the answer is confirmed as "no"?

Well, this is question begging, so it's a little more interesting, but it's still not useful for actual debate.


Blah blah blah blah blah....demo account....blah blah blah

Translation: play money.

In a related story, I've made billions playing Monopoly!!!!

Nope, nothing here, just a snide comment


Of course!!! The evil Big Oil(tm) companies have been colluding with each other for decades. That's why the price of oil keeps going up and up and up, and never comes down.

Oh......wait....


Now this nearly reached the point of evidence, but seemed to stop before the interesting bit


He's particularly popular with gold bugs and POtards. As a result, this thread should probably be in the CT section.

This just seems like insults. Still nothing useful


Wow. Please tell me this is not a serious question. I didn't see a winking smiley.



No, they haven't. Unless you plan on providing an extensive list.

Still nothing


You are incorrect.

================================>

Nope. Nothing more is needed.

These two are brilliant. 'I've won and I don't have to tell you why.' is not a good argument


I didn't sign up to debate. The poster is incorrect. I stated it most succinctly. Why waste extra words "debating", when you already know the answer?


You just keep telling us he's wrong. That's all you're doing. Over and over again. I still haven't seen you offer up an actual argument.

I'm here to educate. The E in JREF.

Well, you can't post paranoid fantasies in a business and economics forum and not expect skeptics and critical thinkers to tell you you're wrong. :)

The whole financial system is NOT "a world-wide game of poker". Because it's not gambling. Or maybe it is if you don't know what you are doing.

Riiight. So, erm, evidence?

It is. You can check the laws of pretty much every state in the country.



Really? So explain Warren Buffett. Charlie Munger. Ben Graham. John Bogle. Bill Miller.

This should be entertaining.

Still nothing of substance. Anyone else getting bored?



No.

I didn't even read it, but no. I feel quite confident. No.

Have you applied for the million dollar challenge? Still no actual debate though


No. 100%, no.

Useful...


No mater what the GB's posted, it's wrong. That's the beauty of being a skeptic. You can accurately predict that the GB's are spectacularly wrong. No matter what they post.


So, after goodness knows how many posts on the subject, you've managed to post nothing of substance just a constant repetition of your unsupported (at least in this thread) opinion that the OP is wrong.

Got any actual arguments, Mr Scrutinizer?
 
Last edited:
I really don't know a lot about the markets, but I've been reading this thread with some interest.

One thing I noted was that the posts of one particular poster seemed to lack any substance, just seemed to be a series of blank statements with nothing to back them up:

Nothing of substance here.

...

So, after goodness knows how many posts on the subject, you've managed to post nothing of subsistence just a constant repetition of your unsupported (at least in this thread) opinion that the OP is wrong.

Got any actual arguments, Mr Scrutinizer?

:D in 40,000+ posts, Im going to go all psychic and predict you wont find a single one.

thanks for reading my somewhat provocative nonsense anyway.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom