Are the Markets all Manipulated or not?

I watched it a few days ago. Fun movie. Educational? Not so much.


In a perfect world all traders would know exactly how much the market was worth, and therefore they would all have 'inside' information.

when in fact it is the market-making function of the major Forex banks and their traders who can see BOTH sides of the order flow, and collude to flow their large orders at the appropriate times to make it go where they want.

in LIBOR, Forex, (and therefore ETFs and stock indices) and yes, Gold & Silver where governmental rigging is also at play (via central banks and their Gold rigging trading arm, the BIS)

If so then you are attempting to manipulate the market by conning ignorant people. You are no better than those hedge fund managers in The Big Short.

er, not really, no.

edit. referring back to the film, do we remember the tense months at the end when the banks refused to mark the instruments accurately until they had finished off-loading them, and then suddenly their price started to reflect the truth? nope, no rigging there either huh.
 
Last edited:
In fact, as the Fed paper notes, insiders took on so much exposure because they, like most home buyers, thought housing prices would never go down. This is also why underwriting standards collapsed: Proof of income didn’t matter if the loan could always be repaid by selling off the appreciated collateral.

some maybe, the more astute knew what they were doing. the Fed clearly didn't though, Bernanke famously said so in his "Contained" speech, didn't he.

"We have never seen a nationwide decline in house prices, so I guess I reject your premise"
or something like that..?

however at local mortgage broker level I am sure you are largely correct, because while Peter Schiff was trying to recruit investors to his new Short-Subprime Hedge Fund, by giving talks at an annual Mortgage Bankers convention in 2005 (no video exists) and 2006 (here) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jj8rMwdQf6k

..out of 2000 bubble-riding bankers, only ONE had the foresight to actually invest in it :D .. so yea, they were largely pretty stupid too it seems..
 
Last edited:
some maybe, the more astute knew what they were doing. the Fed clearly didn't though, Bernanke famously said so in his "Contained" speech, didn't he.

or something like that..?

however at local mortgage broker level I am sure you are largely correct, because while Peter Schiff was trying to recruit investors to his new Short-Subprime Hedge Fund, by giving talks at an annual Mortgage Bankers convention in 2005 (no video exists) and 2006 (here) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jj8rMwdQf6k

..out of 2000 bubble-riding bankers, only ONE had the foresight to actually invest in it :D .. so yea, they were largely pretty stupid too it seems..

Peter Schiff is one of those perpetual bears, sometimes these people turn out to be right but only after a long history of being wrong. His predictions are worth nothing.
 
Peter Schiff is one of those perpetual bears, sometimes these people turn out to be right but only after a long history of being wrong. His predictions are worth noting.

ftfy.

how about you watch that presentation I linked to, from 2006, where he precisely defines what will happen to sub-prime, several years in advance and tell me that again. :rolleyes:

I have listened to every single episode of Wall Street unspun, from 2002 to 2009, and have made my own mind up. you have not, therefore your opinions on him are of no interest to me.

and this argument

turn out to be right but only after a long history of being wrong.

is inane, as when you are making macro predictions ie calling a bubble, by definition you are wrong while everybody else is *right* sometimes for years, right up until fundamental reassert themselves again, and it was a bubble after all.
 
ftfy.

how about you watch that presentation I linked to, from 2006, where he precisely defines what will happen to sub-prime, several years in advance and tell me that again. :rolleyes:

I have listened to every single episode of Wall Street unspun, from 2002 to 2009, and have made my own mind up. you have not, therefore your opinions on him are of no interest to me.

and this argument



is inane, as when you are making macro predictions ie calling a bubble, by definition you are wrong while everybody else is *right* sometimes for years, right up until fundamental reassert themselves again, and it was a bubble after all.

Peter Schiff is wrong far more often than he is right. I think gold should have passed like $5,000 by now according to his specific, time sensitive predictions. The fact that he has been sort of right a few times does not give him any credibility. A broken clock is right twice a day..and that's what Schiff is.
 
Peter Schiff is wrong far more often than he is right. I think gold should have passed like $5,000 by now according to his specific, time sensitive predictions. The fact that he has been sort of right a few times does not give him any credibility. A broken clock is right twice a day..and that's what Schiff is.

yada yada yada. as I said your uninformed opinion is of no interest to me
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom