Are the Markets all Manipulated or not?

oh look somebody made a wiki page about this one :D

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forex_scandal

The forex scandal (also known as the forex probe) is a financial scandal that involves the revelation, and subsequent investigation, that banks colluded for at least a decade to manipulate exchange rates for their own financial gain. Market regulators in Asia, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and the United States began to investigate the $5.3 trillion-a-day foreign exchange market (forex) after Bloomberg News reported in June 2013 that currency dealers said they had been front-running client orders and rigging the foreign exchange benchmark WM/Reuters rates by colluding with counterparts and pushing through trades before and during the 60-second windows when the benchmark rates are set.

The behavior occurred daily in the spot foreign-exchange market and went on for at least a decade according to currency traders.[3]

hmm. I dont know, maybe I imagined it, or it's make-believe, or some such other rational explanation.. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
http://money.cnn.com/2015/09/28/news/companies/bank-investigation-metals-market-switzerland/

decades more deluded conspiracy theories in PMs.(nope no Forex marketmaking banks here lulz)

Here we go again. Switzerland's competition regulator has begun probing seven major banks for rigging prices in the precious metals market, including gold and silver.

The banks named in the investigation are UBS (UBS), HSBC (HSBC), Morgan Stanley (MS), Barclays (BCS), Julius Baer (JBAXY), Deutsche Bank (DB) and Mitsui (MITSY).

The regulator said Monday that the banks are suspected of colluding while trading gold, silver, platinum and palladium.

Julius Baer and Mitsui bank said they were cooperating with the authorities.

The other firms did not provide comment on the matter.

U.S. regulators and the European Commission are also reportedly investigating similar trading issues in the metals market.
 
Let me guess--make-believe "proven" market manipulation, to go with all the make-believe money you've made?

Hope it's not too complicated for a muppet to understand!

this site needs a "Tumbleweed - Silenced by the Evidence" smilie.

or is it just too complicated after all?
 
kevsta, the best way to think of markets is that they are like a rubber band. You can stretch them this way and that way, but eventually they resume their natural shape. I agree with anyone who suggests that price history can help determine when they are being stretched, and when they are returning to underlying value. Nelson Bunker Hunt proved how they can be temporarily stretched with silver in the 80s. During this stretching process we can see a market 30% overvalued on its way to being 200% overvalued. All those seething with anger at the 30% mark and shorting become like the indispensable man in the graveyard.
 
kevsta, the best way to think of markets is that they are like a rubber band. You can stretch them this way and that way, but eventually they resume their natural shape. I agree with anyone who suggests that price history can help determine when they are being stretched, and when they are returning to underlying value.


Just "help", huh? You've changed your tune.

I wouldn't argue against that.

:D
 
this site needs a "Tumbleweed - Silenced by the Evidence" smilie.

or is it just too complicated after all?

?

Tumbleweed.gif
 
Just "help", huh? You've changed your tune.

I wouldn't argue against that.

:D
A technical view can allow one to buy in grossly overvalued markets quite safely. I don't change tunes, I don't believe any of the bigger markets can be reasonably called manipulated. There is no doubt small individual stocks definitely can, and often to help a player unload to a sucker, or vice versa.
 
oh look, gold and silver were manipulated after all... :D

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/artic...ettles-silver-price-fixing-claims-lawyers-say

Deutsche Bank AG has reached settlements in lawsuits over allegations it manipulated gold and silver prices, lawyers for traders of the commodities said in court filings.

Attorneys for futures contract traders in two private lawsuits said in letters filed Wednesday and Thursday in Manhattan federal court that the bank has executed term sheets and is negotiating final details for the accords.

The German financial firm also agreed to help the plaintiffs pursue similar claims against other banks as part of the settlements, according to the letters. Vincent Briganti and Robert Eisler, attorneys for traders in the silver-fixing lawsuit, said Deutsche Bank will turn over instant messages and other communications to help further their case. Financial terms of the settlements weren’t disclosed.

"In addition to valuable monetary consideration to be paid into a settlement fund, the term sheet also provides for other valuable consideration such as provisions requiring Deutsche Bank’s cooperation in pursuing claims against the remaining defendants," attorneys Daniel Brockett and Merrill Davidoff said in their letter Thursday in the gold-fixing lawsuit.

Silver and gold futures traders sued groups of banks in 2014 alleging they rigged prices for the precious metals and their derivatives. Silver traders brought claims against Deutsche Bank, HSBC Holdings Plc, Bank of Nova Scotia and UBS AG. Gold traders additionally sued Barclays Plc and Societe Generale SA.

The traders alleged the banks abused their positions of controlling daily silver and gold fixes to reap illegitimate profits from trading and hurting other investors in those markets who use the benchmark in billions of dollars of transactions, according to versions of the complaints filed in 2015. Of those banks, only Deutsche Bank has reached a settlement.

This is getting to be quite a lot of "Conspiracy Theories" that were actually always just Conspiracies now, isn't it?

there must be quite a lot of embarrassed "Skeptics" out there too, starting to inwardly doubt their other long-held and espoused assumptions, if only privately.. :D
 
oh look, gold and silver were manipulated after all... :D

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/artic...ettles-silver-price-fixing-claims-lawyers-say



This is getting to be quite a lot of "Conspiracy Theories" that were actually always just Conspiracies now, isn't it?

there must be quite a lot of embarrassed "Skeptics" out there too, starting to inwardly doubt their other long-held and espoused assumptions, if only privately.. :D

Hey Kevsta, long time no see! Sure are a lot of crickets in this thread. :)
 
hey mate, how's tricks? and haha yes, Tumbleweed abounds.

I'm doing well. Been long metals forever, and they're starting to move again, similar to what happened prior to 2008. I'm not sure whether JPM is taking their foot off of the necks of the metals, if the market is overriding them, or if the Shanghai Exchange is changing the game, but something is up.

I haven't posted here in a long time, but I decided to come back and see what's going on. Looks like the same old :)
 
Another "Conspiracy Theory" Confirmed: ECB Finds Widespread Trading On Leaked Inside Information

"information of many macroeconomic announcements is known by some market participants in advance" - European Central Bank
Remember when it was merely another conspiracy theory that "some" traders "trade" (with zero risk) with the benefit of leaked material non-public information? As of moments ago it is merely the latest conspiracy fact, confirmed by none other than the ECB, which earlier today published a research paper which finds substantial "informed" trading before the official release in seven of 21 market-moving U.S. macroeconomic announcements.

The paper has studied trading patterns from Jan. 2008 to March 2014 and finds that "prices begin to move in the ‘correct’ direction about 30 minutes before the release time. The pre-announcement price drift accounts on average for about half of the total price adjustment."


Translation: chronic insider trading, which until recently was an allegation that the serious outlets would relentlessly mock as another conspiracy by tinfoil hat fringe websites.

The paper also finds "strong evidence of pre-announcement drift" in ahead of releases such as the Conference Board's consumer confidence index; NAR existing home and pending home sales; preliminary GDP; Federal Reserve’s industrial production (yes, even Fed data has been leaked repeatedly); ISM manufacturing and non- manufacturing indexes, and countless other examples.

ECB source document
 
the ECB does not blame the entire "drift" on leaks of insider information, saying instead that "the evidence suggests that the pre-announcement drift likely comes from a combination of information leakage and superior forecasting" it is clear what the real culprit is for outperformance ahead of major data release, and - spoiler alert - it isn't "superior forecasting."
This is silly. If - without 'inside' information - nobody should be able to predict an announcement with even the slightest accuracy, then traders should only be permitted to make random bets based on no information at all. Is this really how we want the system to work?

"Public information, such as internet activity data, predicts the surprise in a few cases"
Or perhaps the 'surprise' isn't always entirely unexpected? But no, that couldn't be. Any trader who accurately 'predicts' an announcement must be in on it! :rolleyes:

Translation: the entire market is rigged
Nonsense. Some traders may be taking advantage of 'leaks', others may just be better at making predictions. That doesn't make the entire market 'rigged'.
 
^There has been plenty of evidence that the market was rigged going all the way back to the Junk Bond Kings. That's how they made their millions to begin with.
 
Allow me to call your bluff.

You haven't been "riding piggyback" on anything, nor has it been "quite profitable" for you.

Why do I know this? Because I know how the market works, and I know this kind of advantage, when it exists, is limited and extremely short-lived. It's the nature of the market.

Your claims are false.

Actually they are not, you should watch the movie the big short and see just how rigged the system is. (according to the movie, during 2009, the markets should have been obliterated, but apparently, due to government manipulation and bought out regulation and so it wasn't. In the movie, the premise was the markets were shorted in an option called a credit default swap but they had to sell those options to Morgan Stanley in order to see a profit. I think they said that the reason for for that is not selling to them would have made the options reduced to 0.
 
Last edited:
Actually they are not, you should watch the movie the big short and see just how rigged the system is. (according to the movie, during 2009, the markets should have been obliterated, but apparently, due to government manipulation and bought out regulation and so it wasn't. In the movie, the premise was the markets were shorted in an option called a credit default swap but they had to sell those options to Morgan Stanley in order to see a profit. I think they said that the reason for for that is not selling to them would have made the options reduced to 0.


Thanks for your recommendation and sharing your understanding of The Big Short movie. Here's mine--read the book and maybe at least you'll get the year right.
 
Thanks for your recommendation and sharing your understanding of The Big Short movie. Here's mine--read the book and maybe at least you'll get the year right.

So I got the year wrong. Ok what's your take on it as relates to this thread? (and stop snickering at me.) Please realize I don't have a bone in the game
 
So I got the year wrong. Ok what's your take on it as relates to this thread? (and stop snickering at me.) Please realize I don't have a bone in the game


You were the one that brought up The Big Short apparently to help show I was wrong.

At least demonstrate that you know what you are talking about.

EDIT: And I meant it about reading the book. The movie, while pretty good and entertaining, by necessity simplifies a lot of what happened.
 
Last edited:
you should watch the movie the big short
I watched it a few days ago. Fun movie. Educational? Not so much.

"All names, characters, and incidents portrayed in this production are fictitious. No identification with actual persons, places, buildings, and products is intended or should be inferred."

What the ‘Big Short’ Movie Gets Right—and Wrong—About the Financial Crisis
The idea that mortgage-industry insiders systematically profited by selling mortgages they knew would fail is at odds with what actually happened...Trader Mark Baum (played by Steve Carell) concludes the banks knew what they were doing but assumed they would be bailed out.

In fact, as the Fed paper notes, insiders took on so much exposure because they, like most home buyers, thought housing prices would never go down. This is also why underwriting standards collapsed: Proof of income didn’t matter if the loan could always be repaid by selling off the appreciated collateral.

The truth is - the big banks weren't 'manipulating' the market, they just had an unjustified faith in free-market capitalism.

But the movie did illustrate one thing - that the market is ultimately driven by individuals, most of whom are indeed attempting to 'manipulate' a small part of it in their favor. Some may even stoop to outright fraud and deception - but that doesn't mean that the market itself is 'rigged'.

It was outsiders, such as hedge-fund manager Michael Burry (played in the movie by Christian Bale) and John Paulson, another hedge-fund manager not profiled in “The Big Short,” who made a killing.

In a perfect world all traders would know exactly how much the market was worth, and therefore they would all have 'inside' information. But who wants that? You buy gold because you know better than the poor schmucks who still think fiat currency has value, right? If so then you are attempting to manipulate the market by conning ignorant people. You are no better than those hedge fund managers in The Big Short.
 
I watched it a few days ago. Fun movie. Educational? Not so much.

"All names, characters, and incidents portrayed in this production are fictitious. No identification with actual persons, places, buildings, and products is intended or should be inferred."

What the ‘Big Short’ Movie Gets Right—and Wrong—About the Financial Crisis

The truth is - the big banks weren't 'manipulating' the market, they just had an unjustified faith in free-market capitalism.

But the movie did illustrate one thing - that the market is ultimately driven by individuals, most of whom are indeed attempting to 'manipulate' a small part of it in their favor. Some may even stoop to outright fraud and deception - but that doesn't mean that the market itself is 'rigged'.



In a perfect world all traders would know exactly how much the market was worth, and therefore they would all have 'inside' information. But who wants that? You buy gold because you know better than the poor schmucks who still think fiat currency has value, right? If so then you are attempting to manipulate the market by conning ignorant people. You are no better than those hedge fund managers in The Big Short.

I GUESS YOU MISSED ALL THAT GOVERNMENT BAIL OUT TALK. OBAMA SAID THAT THE BANKS WERE TOO BIG TO FAIL BUT DON'T YOU THINK WALL STREET INFLUENCE HAD ANYTHING TO DO WITH IT AT ALL? APPARENTLY NOT BASED ON WHAT YOU ARE WRITING? ACCORDING TO THE MOVIE THERE WERE LOSERS IN THE CRISIS. 401K HOLDER AND PENSION FUNDS APPARENTLY WERE LEFT HOLDING THE BAG. WHATEVER.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom