Are the Markets all Manipulated or not?

It is. You can check the laws of pretty much every state in the country.

doesn't gambling assume a level playing field? isn't cheating in Poker (wasn't it anyway) dealt with by a bullet?

also, from a trading perspective, I can tell you categorically that most traders are gambling.

its like playing the One Arm Bandit, you cannot win consistently, fairly.
 
When I suggest that poker isn't gambling, my point is that if you have more money that the other guys then you don't need to guess, you just bust them one by one.

As for Warren Buffet and the others you mention, none of them actually had the money they were using in the game. Ponzi schemes will never work because there will come a stage when you can service the level of return. If, on the other hand, you are a very large banking corporation that is effectively backed by other large corporations and governments, then you just make a market, send out the right information and then sit back and reap the rewards before making a very hasty exit and leaving everyone else to pick up the pieces.

To kevsta's point, yes I believe that traders are just gamblers with quick fingers. Just get up a couple of levels above the desk and it all becomes as clear as day.

Unfortunately it becomes necessary to throw someone under the bus, Lehmans being probably the biggest bank name and Bob Diamond being the biggest individual.

Does 1 + 1 = 2 after it has been lent, unitised, leveraged, re-unitised, re-leveraged etc ....... nope, we just learned that it probably equals diddly squat !
 
doesn't gambling assume a level playing field? isn't cheating in Poker (wasn't it anyway) dealt with by a bullet?

In most gambling games, the house has a margin. I don't know whether you consider that cheating.

There appears to be large scale cheating among Far Eastern betting syndicates.

also, from a trading perspective, I can tell you categorically that most traders are gambling.

I can buy that.

its like playing the One Arm Bandit, you cannot win consistently, fairly.

Well yes, and no. If you're a speculator (large trades based on short term holding) then I consider that to more akin to gambling and your luck is going to run out eventually.

If you're and investor then there's no reason to presume that you cannot win if you define winning as beating inflation. If winning is classed as beating the market then I'd say it's more difficult but apparently not impossible.

The Income and Growth fund I've held for the past 21 years has, over that period, consistently beaten the FTSE100 and FTSE250 and has always provided a positive return. In the main this is due to the fact that the investments have been relatively high yielding and very conservative so trading conditions for most of the last 21 years have favoured that kind of find.
 
In most gambling games, the house has a margin. I don't know whether you consider that cheating.

haha, yes at one time I used to run more than 100 such machines, there's an adjustable payout level potentiometer in them, around about 32% was the sweetspot in our locations. any less and usage went down, you have to pay out enough to keep them keen.

There appears to be large scale cheating among Far Eastern betting syndicates.

elaborate please?

Well yes, and no. If you're a speculator (large trades based on short term holding) then I consider that to more akin to gambling and your luck is going to run out eventually.

luck doesn't come into it, electronic markets are very much more efficient than one arm bandits.

If you're and investor then there's no reason to presume that you cannot win if you define winning as beating inflation. If winning is classed as beating the market then I'd say it's more difficult but apparently not impossible.

I am talking more specifically about traders large and small when I reference "markets" and granted investors can win, I would say that is as much down to luck as judgement. ie macro luck, as even if you have chosen a strong horse, quite often global events can radically mess with your bets.

you are after all playing a game of chance, where other very much larger players have the ability to destroy both themselves and everything else including your portfolio due to outside circumstances, at almost any point.

can you get in and out over a period with profit? maybe. lot of chance involved though, isn't there?

again, I can tell you categorically, as a trader once you put your money live into a trade, and it is in the marketmaker's open float, (they regard that as theirs then - this is my opinion only) but the odds are very much in their favor, of you not getting it back. (this isn't, I stand by this)

much less likely than pure chance.

The Income and Growth fund I've held for the past 21 years has, over that period, consistently beaten the FTSE100 and FTSE250 and has always provided a positive return. In the main this is due to the fact that the investments have been relatively high yielding and very conservative so trading conditions for most of the last 21 years have favoured that kind of find.

so the last sentence kind of agrees the element of chance, (or good luck) ie the markets went the right way for quite a long time?
 
Last edited:
predictability..

so in the cynical world of an average trader, looking at the relentless decline in US macro figures rolling over, coupled with the ridiculous unstoppable equities at nominal all time highs, and where every new figures miss is greeted with another +10 S&P points, it would seem some things can be predicted.

S&P showing weakness this morning and looking like falling though 1585..

This Is What A Stop Hunt Looks Like

When the largest currency cross in the world spikes 70 pips on no news and starts trading like a penny stock, you know that beneath the calm surface of all-time high nominal stock prices, something is brewing... Of course, as we tweeted earlier, there is another reason for the ramp...

@zerohedge

It's momentum ignition time. Who goes first EURUSD or USDJPY?

11:41 AM - 30 Apr 2013

Retail needs to see S&P 500 at 1600... and in the face of macro data and micro earnings, there's only one way that is going to happen.

obvious playbook is obvious.

Updated

Just after the open of stock trading today, when the evil forces of selling and shorting seemed on the verge of a momentous victory over the heroic forces of toner and cartridge and cause a historic 0.1% crash in the S&P, ( :D) we made an assessment:

zerohedge @zerohedge

Market is in desperate need of horrible Chicago PMI miss
1:34 PM - 30 Apr 2013


Minutes later we got just that out of Chicago.

And confirming that the "market" has become the biggest manipulated joke, inside a farce, wrapped in Kevin Henry's VWAP algo, as expected the S&P just went green.
 
Last edited:
haha, yes at one time I used to run more than 100 such machines, there's an adjustable payout level potentiometer in them, around about 32% was the sweetspot in our locations. any less and usage went down, you have to pay out enough to keep them keen.

I didn't even think about one-armed bandits :o

I was thinking more about the statistical advantage the house enjoys with games like roulette and craps and when they prevent card counting at blackjack (which I guess is the house cheating).

elaborate please?

Lots of cases in UK press about bribing sports people to get the right result.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/fo...wered-by-illegal-betting-markets-in-Asia.html


luck doesn't come into it, electronic markets are very much more efficient than one arm bandits.

I am talking more specifically about traders large and small when I reference "markets" and granted investors can win, I would say that is as much down to luck as judgement. ie macro luck, as even if you have chosen a strong horse, quite often global events can radically mess with your bets.

you are after all playing a game of chance, where other very much larger players have the ability to destroy both themselves and everything else including your portfolio due to outside circumstances, at almost any point.

can you get in and out over a period with profit? maybe. lot of chance involved though, isn't there?

again, I can tell you categorically, as a trader once you put your money live into a trade, and it is in the marketmaker's open float, (they regard that as theirs then - this is my opinion only) but the odds are very much in their favor, of you not getting it back. (this isn't, I stand by this)

much less likely than pure chance.

so the last sentence kind of agrees the element of chance, (or good luck) ie the markets went the right way for quite a long time?

If you're a speculator then I agree with you 100% - eventually your luck will run out.

If you're well diversified then you're less exposed to individual pieces of luck. If you're an investor and you choose conservative investment vehicles then you're less exposed to individual pieces of luck.

I've been (conservatively) invested in the market since the late 1980s, my Father has been conservatively invested in the markets since the mid 1950s. We've both had positive returns over those period despite individual failures of specific trades or investments (in my Dad's case it was Consolidated Gold options in the 1980s, in my case it was bank shares in the last few years). Both of these were painful but due to diversification merely a blip.

In my case I lost a few thousand on the bank shares but other investments made up for it, I have no idea how much my Dad lost but he still managed to retire with very comfortable investment savings (many, many times the original investment) despite being a comparatively poorly paid UK teacher for most of his career.

So sure, there could be a cataclysmic set of circumstances that cause the market to crash and stay there. Specifically with respect to my last point, it's the volatility of the market with the downturns in the early 90s, the popping of the tech bubble and the last set of unpleasantness which has made the conservative investments I have got seem to have performed so comparatively well. If the market had been going gangbusters throughout the whole of that period, my 450% return over that period (hardly stellar but at least inflation beating) would look very poor indeed.
 
I dont really feel like I can disagree with much of the above, so have a picture. its not my whole thesis, but its not off topic either.

SSCentralPlanning_zps1cb6d705.jpg


Timmeh!! on the bong is the best bit
 
Last edited:
no, its not a given, and I am not saying "control" either, that was the Swiss guys. they dont "control" the world, but the evidence everywhere I look seems to point to a good deal of manipulating things as suits.

It is difficult to maintain such schemes for long without political protection but it can and does happen. People should be far less tolerant of rent seeking than they are.
 
I am talking more specifically about traders large and small when I reference "markets" and granted investors can win, I would say that is as much down to luck as judgement. ie macro luck, as even if you have chosen a strong horse, quite often global events can radically mess with your bets.

you are after all playing a game of chance, where other very much larger players have the ability to destroy both themselves and everything else including your portfolio due to outside circumstances, at almost any point.
Day trading is definitely a mug's game but investing in blue chip stocks for long term growth is still viable in spite of what might be happening behind the scenes with the big boys.
 
Day trading is definitely a mug's game but investing in blue chip stocks for long term growth is still viable in spite of what might be happening behind the scenes with the big boys.

biased much? a successful traders POV.. :D

Investing in blue chip stocks for long term growth is is definitely a mug's game but Day trading is still viable in spite of what might be happening behind the scenes with the big boys
 
doesn't gambling assume a level playing field? isn't cheating in Poker (wasn't it anyway) dealt with by a bullet?

also, from a trading perspective, I can tell you categorically that most traders are gambling.

its like playing the One Arm Bandit, you cannot win consistently, fairly.

No.

I didn't even read it, but no. I feel quite confident. No.
 
When I suggest that poker isn't gambling, my point is that if you have more money that the other guys then you don't need to guess, you just bust them one by one.

As for Warren Buffet and the others you mention, none of them actually had the money they were using in the game. Ponzi schemes will never work because there will come a stage when you can service the level of return. If, on the other hand, you are a very large banking corporation that is effectively backed by other large corporations and governments, then you just make a market, send out the right information and then sit back and reap the rewards before making a very hasty exit and leaving everyone else to pick up the pieces.

To kevsta's point, yes I believe that traders are just gamblers with quick fingers. Just get up a couple of levels above the desk and it all becomes as clear as day.

Unfortunately it becomes necessary to throw someone under the bus, Lehmans being probably the biggest bank name and Bob Diamond being the biggest individual.

Does 1 + 1 = 2 after it has been lent, unitised, leveraged, re-unitised, re-leveraged etc ....... nope, we just learned that it probably equals diddly squat !

No. 100%, no.
 
No.

I didn't even read it, but no. I feel quite confident. No.

doesn't gambling assume a level playing field? isn't cheating in Poker (wasn't it anyway) dealt with by a bullet?

also, from a trading perspective, I can tell you categorically that most traders are gambling.

its like playing the One Arm Bandit, you cannot win consistently, fairly.

When I suggest that poker isn't gambling, my point is that if you have more money that the other guys then you don't need to guess, you just bust them one by one.

As for Warren Buffet and the others you mention, none of them actually had the money they were using in the game. Ponzi schemes will never work because there will come a stage when you can service the level of return. If, on the other hand, you are a very large banking corporation that is effectively backed by other large corporations and governments, then you just make a market, send out the right information and then sit back and reap the rewards before making a very hasty exit and leaving everyone else to pick up the pieces.

To kevsta's point, yes I believe that traders are just gamblers with quick fingers. Just get up a couple of levels above the desk and it all becomes as clear as day.

Unfortunately it becomes necessary to throw someone under the bus, Lehmans being probably the biggest bank name and Bob Diamond being the biggest individual.

Does 1 + 1 = 2 after it has been lent, unitised, leveraged, re-unitised, re-leveraged etc ....... nope, we just learned that it probably equals diddly squat !

No mater what the GB's posted, it's wrong. That's the beauty of being a skeptic. You can accurately predict that the GB's are spectacularly wrong. No matter what they post.
 
GS Sachs quant algo programmer jailed for theft of "market manipulating" program.

the original piece in 2009 http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=aFeyqdzYcizc

It wasn’t just Goldman that faced imminent harm if Aleynikov were to be released, Assistant U.S. Attorney Joseph Facciponti told a federal magistrate judge at his July 4 bail hearing in New York. The 34-year-old prosecutor also dropped this bombshell: “The bank has raised the possibility that there is a danger that somebody [else] who knew how to use this program could [also] use it to manipulate markets in unfair ways.”

How could somebody do this? The precise answer isn’t obvious -- we’re talking about a black-box trading system here. And Facciponti didn’t elaborate. You don’t need a Goldman Sachs doomsday machine to manipulate markets, of course. A false rumor expertly planted using an ordinary telephone often will do just fine.
 
No mater what the GB's posted, it's wrong. That's the beauty of being a skeptic. You can accurately predict that the GB's are spectacularly wrong. No matter what they post.

the evidence strongly suggests that skeptics of your type couldn't accurately predict their breakfast.
 
Last edited:
the evidence strongly suggests that skeptics of your type couldn't accurately predict their breakfast.

As a skeptic, I don't pretend to be able to predict the price of any one single thing at any one specific time in the future. My approach (and that of many cautious investors) is to have a diversified portfolio, much of which is low-risk. At least this way the risks are minimised.

After the 10 year gold and silver bull market, metal maniacs were predicting ongoing exponential price growth. This hasn't happened but instead of just considering whether it was some kind of market cycle or that there may be underlying fundamentals at work (lower industrial demand, less hedging demand, speculators using shorts as a mechanism to make money) the failure of the market to meet their forecasts is down to large scale manipulation of the market (for 2 years and counting) rather than flaws in their predictions.

Turk and his ilk have one message "gold and silver prices will rise" and they were right for a long period of time. I believe it's because their prediction happened to align with market movement and since that has changed they are no longer right.
 
@The Central Scrote .... I'm beginning to warm to you ........ You must operate hedge funds as you are always on the other side of the fence !
 
As a skeptic, I don't pretend to be able to predict the price of any one single thing at any one specific time in the future. My approach (and that of many cautious investors) is to have a diversified portfolio, much of which is low-risk. At least this way the risks are minimised.

you are different kind of skeptic altogether.

After the 10 year gold and silver bull market, metal maniacs were predicting ongoing exponential price growth. This hasn't happened but instead of just considering whether it was some kind of market cycle or that there may be underlying fundamentals at work (lower industrial demand, less hedging demand, speculators using shorts as a mechanism to make money) the failure of the market to meet their forecasts is down to large scale manipulation of the market (for 2 years and counting) rather than flaws in their predictions.


Turk and his ilk have one message "gold and silver prices will rise" and they were right for a long period of time. I believe it's because their prediction happened to align with market movement and since that has changed they are no longer right.

your history is not so strong on this subject is it? does it not count that these same people were calling it was coming back in 1998 at (sub) $300? so having had exponential price growth for a decade or more, despite ongoing manipulation since at least the mid 90s (according to significant amounts of evidence amassed but ignored over the years) and having seen their predictions be correct for a long time, they have (made the mistake of?) assuming their fundamental analysis was correct and that their ultimate conclusions would be reached eventually.

he also predicted issues with ever being able to give back the German gold, in 2001.

First, a couple of months ago I was analyzing the 1998 and 1999 balance sheets of the ESF. Being an ex-banker, I know a little bit about accounting, including where to find the big holes through which the proverbial truck can be driven. And suffice it to say, I found one of those, which could suggest that in these two years 975 tonnes of gold came into the market from the ESF. Interestingly, after reaching this conclusion, I wanted to test it. So I called a top gold market expert whose supply/demand analyses are second to none, and who believes that gold from the US reserves has been coming into the market for several years.

Without telling him about my analysis of the ESF balance sheet, I asked him how much gold he thought came out of the Treasury/ESF in 1998 and 1999 in total. His response was 1,000 tonnes, a mere 25 tonnes difference from what I deduced from the ESF financial statements. When I told him this, that we had both reached the same conclusion from different sources, he chuckled but was not in the least bit surprised, being so convinced that the Treasury/ESF has been a major source of metal for years. I have thoroughly reviewed his supply/demand numbers since 1994 and have determined that as much as 2,000 tonnes of gold from the US reserve may have entered the market in order to make the gold price as low as it is, which leads me to the second tidbit that I would like to share with you. It is just as intriguing.

This same individual told me several months ago about some astonishing intelligence he had learned from a source in Europe. He told me that the Bundesbank's gold vault was empty, which seemed so preposterous that I found it hard to believe. He also admitted that this news startled him when he learned about it, and that he did not have an adequate explanation for it. He knew that the Bundesbank was an active lender of gold, but he had a difficult time accepting the possibility that all 3,400 tonnes that it owned had been loaned. Yet he was confident that his source had provided him with accurate information.

We now know what has happened. The Bundesbank has loaned 1,700 tonnes, one-half of its 3,400 tonnes reserve; the other 1,700 tonnes were swapped for gold in the US reserves, requiring the change in the West Point vault from Gold Bullion Reserve to Custodial Gold. In other words, the Bundesbank's vault is empty because one-half of their gold is stored in West Point not Europe, and the other half has been loaned out.

Turk's writings and archives go back to 1995, so i think it is intellectually dishonest to judge on the last 2 years.

James Turk 2001 "The Smoking Gun"
I provided substantive proof that the Exchange Stabilization Fund was intervening in the gold market.

[ history of the ESF http://www.marketskeptics.com/2011/06/the-esf-and-its-history.html ]

..from publicly available reports prepared by the Federal Reserve, I established that the weight of gold held as a component of the US Reserve Assets has been changing, and that these changes – some of which are of significant size – result from activity by the ESF. These Federal Reserve reports conclusively demonstrate that the ESF has been intervening in the gold market since at least 1996.

Though these Federal Reserve reports make clear that the ESF is involved in the gold market up to its 'earmarks', a lot of people remain skeptical. I don't know why that is. It is worth noting that many of the most obstinate skeptics who deny US government involvement in the gold market live overseas and have little, if any, experience or understanding of the way the US government really works.

But even Americans find it difficult to accept that the US government intervenes in the gold market. Ironically though, they readily admit that the government intervenes in the debt markets, foreign currency markets, and according to a growing number of people, even in the US stock market. It is therefore most baffling that they do not concede the ESF's involvement in the gold market.

Maybe people are skeptical because they haven't bothered to take the time to read the Federal Reserve reports for themselves. Maybe it's because it's easier to accept the word of some government bureaucrat who denies ESF involvement in the gold market than it is to seek out and look for the truth. Maybe they don't want to believe that the US government is lying to them when Treasury official after Treasury official denies any involvement by the ESF in the gold market.

I don't know. Or maybe it's because they think that government officials work for the American people – and not for vested interests – in their deliberative sessions behind closed doors. Wouldn't it be refreshing if we could peek-in behind those closed doors to see what really is being said?

If anybody would really like to gain a more accurate and in-depth understanding of more typical actual longterm "Goldbug" thinking (rather than all this insane racist nonsense) I would recommend thorough digestion of these 1998 writings from "Another"

http://www.usagold.com/goldtrail/archives/another1.html

viewed in hindsight it is fairly obvious the writer was/is an insider of some sort, and whatever your views, there will almost certainly be a different look at how the rest of the world (ie the physical buyers, not paper gamblers) views gold. and, possibly a hint at an answer to the question "what is the relationship between the gold & oil price", which I have hinted at in other threads.

When the once highly secretive London Bullion Market Association (LBMA) -- its venerable membership comprising the world's largest gold dealers -- published its daily clearing volume for the first time in January 1997 it rocked the tight-knit world of international gold traders and analysts. According to this first of many subsequent LBMA press releases, thirteen hundred tonnes of gold (representing more than 50% of the world's annual mine production) changed hands daily in this fog-shrouded center of the global gold market. This figure represented over $10 billion per day and $4 trillion per year in bullion banking activity!
The gold market had always stood in austere, quiet contrast to the highly charged, mega-volume world of stocks and bonds. Now this first LBMA report forced analysts, investors, and brokers to reassess their understandings of the gold market.

While some revelled in the glow of the large LBMA numbers, others began to raise some very important and rather unsettling questions. First, Why was this much gold on the move? Second, Where was all this gold going? And third, Where was all this gold coming from?
Then, in October of 1997 at the internet's only gold discussion forum of the day (hosted by Kitco), a series of remarkable postings began appearing under the pseudonym "ANOTHER", offering plausible answers to those questions. What followed in a seemingly incongruous stream of thought over many months was, in the fullness of time, seen to blend into a logical whole by many astute readers following the complete text.

If you are not similarly moved to at least reassess your own view of the international financial scene after reading what's revealed below, then you are either firmly entrenched in your world view, or you've been numbed by too many hours of Wall Street's cheerleader (CNBC) and too many Friday nights with Louis Ruykeyser.l

in hindsight we can assess his writings, with what actually was going on back then, the 98 bullion bank blowup that required Brown to ditch the UKs gold, the surprising changes to LMBA membership after hundreds of years of participation etc.

the type of skeptic that thinks it is correct without having to even read other's arguments, or possessing the faintest idea what it is talking about, will of course not read anything that may challenge it's (already correct) worldview in any way.

I don't believe you are that type.
 
Last edited:
I stand by my summary. James Turk and his ilk continually say that that the price of gold will rise. While the price of gold rises then they are correct.

When the price of gold stays static or fall then rather than saying that they were wrong they suggest market manipulation.

Specifically with respect to James Turk:

  • The issues regarding German gold have yet to be proven. What we appear to have is a German politician who likes to visit the German gold reserves. The Bundesbank seem happy to entertain his whims, the Fed less so. What we have is the Fed refusing to allow access to the gold reserve for security reasons and people choosing to say that this is because the reserves do not exist. That's speculation, not hard evidence
  • Turk's "substantive proof" of ESF involvement in the gold market looks to me like creative dot joining
  • I cannot find a reasoned analysis of the 1997 LBMA actions
 
I stand by my summary. James Turk and his ilk continually say that that the price of gold will rise. While the price of gold rises then they are correct.

Turk and his ilk continually say that physical gold is substantially undervalued and will eventually correct this spectacularly.

thus far it has been going on for approaching two decades, and when viewed in that context they are still right. of course in that period, the price will also have pullbacks, sometimes for months or years, it does not invalidate the longterm thesis.

When the price of gold stays static or fall then rather than saying that they were wrong they suggest market manipulation.

Specifically with respect to James Turk:

  • The issues regarding German gold have yet to be proven. What we appear to have is a German politician who likes to visit the German gold reserves. The Bundesbank seem happy to entertain his whims, the Fed less so. What we have is the Fed refusing to allow access to the gold reserve for security reasons and people choosing to say that this is because the reserves do not exist. That's speculation, not hard evidence

the factual 7 year delay to return a small amount of gold (unclear whether 150 or 300 tons) when the ECB can supply 350 tons to 10 banks in a few months is not speculation.

the Fed supposedly has 6720 tons of gold stored. seven years, and you cant see it when you visit? :rolleyes:

What is news is that courtesy of the supplied calendar of events in the Buba statement, it will take the Fed some seven years to procure Germany's 300 tons of gold. This is the same Fed that, in its own words, holds some "216 million troy ounces of gold" or some 6720 tons, in its vault 80 feet below ground level.

Putting the above in perspective, (Chart) the amount of gold that Germany will have to wait 7 years for is shown in red. The amount of gold the Fed supposedly holds, is shown in yellow with a shade of tungsten. Why it will take the Fed 7 years to part with an amount of gold that is less than 5% of its total holdings is anyone's guess...

unless of course, the bulk of the gold in the column on the right has been rehypothecated numerous times to serve as collateral for countless counterparties, and it is no longer clear just who own what to anyone.


  • Turk's "substantive proof" of ESF involvement in the gold market looks to me like creative dot joining
  • I cannot find a reasoned analysis of the 1997 LBMA actions

As exact details of the dealings they discuss are all classified top secret as matters of national security, unfortunately hard evidence of the type you require is a little difficult to come by.

as was hard evidence of LIBOR rigging even without national security laws preventing disclosure of relevant facts, until well..
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom