Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?

Personality cults and insistance on atheist orthodoxy are two that I run across all the time.

Of course I'm a religious apologist for being concerned about the latter and (since I posted this in a thread precipitated by Elevatorgate) the former makes me a privilaged white male misogynist who "doesn't get it."
 
Thanks for people's feedback on this - I've noticed that the people on this forum aren't as militant as many skeptic bloggers have been. In fact, almost all the discourse I've seen has been rational without resort to name calling. This is most encouraging.

You're welcome, jerkface.
 
For a simple reason - in theory I've been long overdue in joining this forum. But I wanted to be sure you're not all jerks first ;)

You tend to get the kind of forum you deserve.
 
As "skepticism" (critical thinking, free thinking, whatever you call it) becomes more popular, a larger percentage of the "movement" will be there because of the social aspect. You see it in churches all the time. People who really don't "believe" everything the church says, but they appreciate the social connections. I already see it in the skeptical "movement" including some groups who seem to take advantage of it. It's inevitable.

There's also a growing segment who simply share a common belief with many skeptics even though they applied little if any critical thinking to arrive at their positions. They can tell you that homeopathy is bunk, but they couldn't begin to explain why it's bunk. Throw something new into the mix, and they wait to see which way the wind blows, then parrot what they hear.

These people get accepted by the mainstream, which in turn feeds the social aspect. At the same time you have people who think critically and attack all arguments demanding evidence and solid reasoning. When they seem to oppose or at least contest what the mainstream believes, they are ostracized, an inevitable result of the social aspect of the skeptical "movement."

It's sad to me that so many bloggers fear "fracturing" of the skeptical movement because of disagreements. I think that's the best thing that could happen. Skepticism is a process. When the FDA cracks down on the latest quack medical device, do we really need 50 skeptical bloggers writing about it? Does it actually do any good?

Give me Elevatorgate any day of the week. I've seen some of the best applications of critical thinking I've seen in a while. Epepke's timeline is awesome. FLS' poignant questions are worth reading repeatedly. Skeptic Ginger's requests for evidence are a breath of fresh compared to the JREF's reaction to the social aspect telling people not to make unwanted sexual advances.

And best of all, the dissection of the seriously flawed arguments floating around are what skepticism is all about. If we can't be skeptical about ourselves, how can we ask anyone else to be skeptical about their beliefs?

The moment that it succumbs to dogma it no longer is free thinking, you can see the same kind of crap on the BFF, the cult-stink there as an example is so thick you can taste it on back of your tongue. If you question ANYTHING to some (Mulder), you become the enemy.
 
names could be mentioned from that, especially pertaining to the atheist comment, is it a skeptical forum or an atheist one?
This comes up over and over, the theism double standard. One can believe in all the gods one wants to, but they shouldn't try to rationalize said god beliefs using skeptical principles. It's tough cookies for skeptics who are also theists but for an atheist to apply skeptical principles to god beliefs is consistent with those skeptical principles.

No one expects the same double standard be applied to a skeptic who also happens to have a skeptic blind spot when it comes to acupuncture or something. Why is it being presented as a dichotomy, an atheist who is also a skeptic is somehow being offensive or not properly accommodating if god beliefs are addressed based on evidence. It's as if we have some obligation to consider gods could exist because an absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Well an absence of evidence is not a reason to consider the possibility gods exist either.
 
Last edited:
The moment that it succumbs to dogma it no longer is free thinking, you can see the same kind of crap on the BFF, the cult-stink there as an example is so thick you can taste it on back of your tongue. If you question ANYTHING to some (Mulder), you become the enemy.
Sometimes a conclusion based on overwhelming evidence is dismissed as dogma. Especially when it comes to atheism. Calling atheism dogma is a common means of dismissing the debate. One has to distinguish between dogma and a solidly supported conclusion. A person holding the latter belief remains open to alternative evidence should it ever be found.
 
Last edited:
Ah, I see I was imprecise. I was referring to skeptic forums and specifically this one. :)

And maybe still are, my point observationally is, many if not all the forums on JREF see a quasi bullying by folks who assume the JREF to be officially atheist in it's stance, my question is, is that actually the case, the JREF forum as a forum is or not officially atheist in it's stance. Many of the membership act that way.
 
And maybe still are, my point observationally is, many if not all the forums on JREF see a quasi bullying by folks who assume the JREF to be officially atheist in it's stance, my question is, is that actually the case, the JREF forum as a forum is or not officially atheist in it's stance. Many of the membership act that way.

Unless something has changed since the last thread on this question, the answer is No. It is not officially atheist.
 
I think it's the BigFoot Forum.

Obviously a place where all the high-power skeptics hang out.

I think Dawkins got banned for spamming tho'.


I'm skeptical of this claim. I find it highly doubtful that Richard Dawkins would waste his time posting in any Bigfoot Forums.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom