Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?

Greetings folks - Apologies for making my first post such a potentially off putting one, I've been a lurker on here sometime and a contributing guest author to the site so I thought I'd get your opinions on this subject.

Reading these forums I see the vast majority of posters are skeptics in the classical sense - without being rude, they will disagree, ask for clarification or evidence and there are little traces of dogmatic thinking. Yet interestingly enough in the wake of the 'elevatorgate' debacle there were many examples of "leading" figures in the skeptic community taking an approach which was the very anti-thesis of skeptical. There were also several examples of logical fallacies, as well as a creeping wave of people trying to marry skepticism to ideology. Evidently this was an emotive issue but it saddened me that a cause I think so worthwhile is at risk of being deemed hypocritical. I've written about it here, I'd be grateful if you'd take a look and share your thoughts.

goo.gl/raSxB


What do others think ? I realise this may be an entrenched issue but it would be very disheartening, as a skeptic community, if we couldn't rationally examine it...

yes some of them absoluteky do and you're about to strike a nerve with them.
 
yes some of them absoluteky do and you're about to strike a nerve with them.

Haha, so far so good! PZ Myers, whom I have disagreed with previously, was kind enough to comment on my blog. Someone else made an interesting post, signed as John - let me copy and paste part that is interesting to me....

" You speak to much like a scientist, as likely do you female peers. Others have pointed out that the riff seems to be related to both professional background and age. Scientist like yourself talking about skepticism and journalist/English majors (Watson, Oulette, Marcotte, etc). talking about sexism. Reminds me of the old CP Snow book on two cultures. The other dimension is age perhaps represented by 1,2,3 wave feminisism. We also don't want a community of chicks and their subservient boyfriends unwilling to be skeptical of feminist dogma. "

Do you think there is some merit to this? Interesting, I'd never considered the option before...
 
Last edited:
Sorry Slimething, but if you want to have a discussion with me, I need a more friendly tone from you.
Just wondering why you injected civility in a discussion of skeptics lapsing into non-skepticism. While I agree that emotion plays a large role therein, it's not the only cause.

So, from your response, we see that same mechanism at work, yes? You detected condescention, as I did in yours, and you reacted negatively and uncivilly. You even forgot a comma. Pot, meet kettle. ;)

I'm not going to belabor the point because I consider it definitely OT. If you don't like the Forum, there's an easy solution for you.
 
Could you please, oh-so-pretty-please, read the post Caniswalensis was responding to before making yourself an example of the exact point Caniswalensis was making?
Could you, please, oh-so-pretty-please, point to anything that Caniswhatever stated that is on-topic? You know, skeptics not being skeptical? Anything?

Skepticality and civility were being equated. Do you want to champion that one, KL?

It's OT. Period.
 
Could you, please, oh-so-pretty-please, point to anything that Caniswhatever stated that is on-topic? You know, skeptics not being skeptical? Anything?

Skepticality and civility were being equated. Do you want to champion that one, KL?

It's OT. Period.

For latecomers, I will summarise the conversation so far in my own words:

drg85: "The vast majority of people here are not rude".

Caniswalensis: "Many people here are in fact rude".

Slimething: "So, in your mind, rudeness is tantamount to non-skeptical thinking? Could you please, oh-so-pretty-please, elaborate on that one?"

Kevin_Lowe: "That does not in any way resemble what he actually said. Go back and read what Caniswalensis was replying to".

Slimething: "I think I'll try to change the topic to whether this discussion is OT or not. I know a minute ago I was baiting Caniswalensis to elaborate on this point, but now I'm going to try to pretend I was playing topic-cop all along".

In doing so you illustrate Caniswalensis' post that lots of posters here (such as yourself) are not "skeptics in the classical sense" because rudeness is their first resort. That's not your biggest problem of course, because in addition to being rude you were attacking a straw man born only of your own poor reading comprehension, but rudeness is certainly part of the equation.

Also, to parallel you own comment to Caniswalensis, if you don't like getting called out for straw-manning and rude behaviour there's an easy solution for you.
 
For latecomers, I will summarise the conversation so far in my own words:
...
... if you don't like getting called out for straw-manning and rude behaviour there's an easy solution for you.
It is to laugh. oh, bolding mine. :)

Seriously, are you going to add anything to the topic or did you just post to paint yourself the protector of all that is good? Let's get right to the point.

Skeptics stop acting skeptically for all the same reasons anyone else does. My opinion. Nothing really arms a skeptic for any stimulus that his/her psyche is not conditioned to tolerate. Becoming a skeptic may/may not afford greater introspection or maturity.

Do you want to argue that? :confused:
 
Just wondering why you injected civility in a discussion of skeptics lapsing into non-skepticism.

In spite of your continuing uncivil tone, I will answer this one question of yours.

The answer is that I injected nothing. I was commenting on a statement by the OP using the OP's own word; "rude".

That's all I have to say on the subject.

Regards, Canis
 
It is to laugh. oh, bolding mine. :)

Seriously, are you going to add anything to the topic or did you just post to paint yourself the protector of all that is good? Let's get right to the point.

Skeptics stop acting skeptically for all the same reasons anyone else does. My opinion. Nothing really arms a skeptic for any stimulus that his/her psyche is not conditioned to tolerate. Becoming a skeptic may/may not afford greater introspection or maturity.

Do you want to argue that? :confused:

No thank you, I believe we have fed the troll already.
 
yes some of them absoluteky do and you're about to strike a nerve with them.

Your mistake here is that you assume that because people dont agree with you about your pet topic, they arent being skeptical.

I think most everyone here would agree that it is a given that most, if not all, skeptics fail to apply skepticism about something-or-other.

No nerves are being struck here. This is human nature.
 
Why would anyone lurk on a forum?

To me it sounds like an even bigger waste of time than participating.

For a simple reason - in theory I've been long overdue in joining this forum. But I wanted to be sure you're not all jerks first ;)
 
For a simple reason - in theory I've been long overdue in joining this forum. But I wanted to be sure you're not all jerks first ;)

All human life is here,jerks included. One must take the rough with the smooth. Welcome.
 
...snip...

I think most everyone here would agree that it is a given that most, if not all, skeptics fail to apply skepticism about something-or-other.

No nerves are being struck here. This is human nature.

All human life is here,jerks included. One must take the rough with the smooth. Welcome.

I agree with you but (of course there is a but!) just because it is human nature doesn't mean that we shouldn't comment when other people and ourselves engage in a behaviour which is not supporting a purported goal we have. So if we want to demonstrate that critical thinking can help someone to understand the world about them it doesn't help if we don't use "critical thinking" when explaining this.

Also I am of the opinion that sometimes rudeness can be as effective or even more so as politeness; it is learning when to use the appropriate manner of communication that is the difficult bit.
 
Interesting that a "Don't Be a Dick" debate should spring up in a thread where Dave included this in his list of unskeptical things:
By the same measure I think it's time Plait's "Don't be a dick" mantra is treated in much the same way. Though laudable as it may be, "being a dick" is subjective, dogmatic and just begging to be abused. It allows all manner of straw man arguments and the censure of valid critical approaches.
:id:
 
An excellent well stated blog, Dave. I shall be quoting it in the elevator threads because you made the points much better than I have been making them.

My only objection, which I posted in your blog comments, is that causes and skepticism are not mutually exclusive. Perhaps they just require greater care to remain skeptical.
 
Your mistake here is that you assume that because people dont agree with you about your pet topic, they arent being skeptical.

For a lot of people here, that follows logically from their definition of skepticism.

If "skepticism" = "basing one's beliefs on logical conclusions reached from examining the evidence" (or something similar), and Sally Skeptic believes that "X" is the logical conclusion from the available evidence on issue A, then Sally is almost inevitably going to conclude that Critical Thinker Chris is suffering from a lack of skepticism if he doesn't agree with Sally once Sally has posted her evidence and reasoning.

Which is why almost every time there is a topic here that doesn't break down on neat "skeptic vs. woo" lines (and that isn't an obvious subjective matter of taste), there are accusations that "Sally" or "Chris" (or both) isn't being skeptical, often followed by people lamenting the supposed lack of critical thinking here, and sometimes even generating a spinoff thread specifically to discuss the supposedly "puzzling" lack of skepticism.

Shorter version: if you define "fails to agree with me after hearing my argument" as "lacks skepticism," then any remotely controversial topic is going to result in accusations of an alleged lack of skepticism. Ho hum.
 
For a lot of people here, that follows logically from their definition of skepticism.

If "skepticism" = "basing one's beliefs on logical conclusions reached from examining the evidence" (or something similar), and Sally Skeptic believes that "X" is the logical conclusion from the available evidence on issue A, then Sally is almost inevitably going to conclude that Critical Thinker Chris is suffering from a lack of skepticism if he doesn't agree with Sally once Sally has posted her evidence and reasoning.
But it is possible one of them does lack skepticism.

Which is why almost every time there is a topic here that doesn't break down on neat "skeptic vs. woo" lines (and that isn't an obvious subjective matter of taste), there are accusations that "Sally" or "Chris" (or both) isn't being skeptical, often followed by people lamenting the supposed lack of critical thinking here, and sometimes even generating a spinoff thread specifically to discuss the supposedly "puzzling" lack of skepticism.

Shorter version: if you define "fails to agree with me after hearing my argument" as "lacks skepticism," then any remotely controversial topic is going to result in accusations of an alleged lack of skepticism. Ho hum.
I thought Dave made a pretty clear skeptic vs woo argument in his blog.
 
From the main elevator thread, Marko thinks Rebecca makes her case in the video linked from this Skepchick blog:
»Sorry I forgot to post on this earlier, but last week I was asked to appear on a thing called BLoggingheads, where two people record themselves discussing a topic and then video of them each staring at their computers goes online to accompany the audio.« (http://skepchick.org/2011/07/a-weird-time-on-bloggingheads/)...
I admit to not being able to stomach the 70 minutes required to listen to the interview, though I'm tempted given the blog entry and comments.

A large number of comments on that blog are downright nauseating and reinforce the fact a lack of critical thinking is rampant in this discussion. They are consistent with other petty comments I read from RW about McGraf. It's not only embarrassing for skeptics, that kind of jr high cliquery is embarrassing for women.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom