Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?

Last edited:
I found it quite enlightening for identifying people whose lack of skeptical posts and blogs I might have previously had undeserved respect for.

To be honest I lost a little bit of respect for PZ from this....... where feminism is concerned he seems to fall into the trap of "if you dont agree with me or if you in any way question what I am saying then you are a clueless fool". I dont know if its merely a knee-jerk reaction to the type of fauminism Ive seen expounded on pharyngula or whether he actually believes it. Either way, when it comes to feminism, he seems to have completely abandoned any resemblance of an even-handed, level-headed approach to the problem.

Its the same as gay marriage - we wont win that one by screaming "YOU SUX0RZ!!! YOU DAMN HOMOPHOBES!!!! BAHAHAHAHAA" at passing politicians, but rather by a level-headed approach which includes the sustained provision of secular reasoning as to why gay marriage is just and moral.

Feminism is obviously a more multi-faceted problem, but we wont win (for example) the battle of work-place equality by screaming "I AM WIMMINZ!!! GIVE ME TEH JOBZ YOU BASTS!" but by a moderate approach where workplace inequality is defined and identified, and then a plan to ensure equality is maintained is outlined and enforced, hopefully leading to a time where such things become second nature and explicit policy is no longer necessary.

Like I said - counter-productive. However, apparently voicing such things gets one labelled as a misogynistic prick. Sigh.
 
I find this thread very interesting. I read drg85's opinion and I mostly agree with everything he says.

There's something I wanted to say about the dogmatic aspect of ideologies. I think I understand what he says, but ideologies and skepticism overlap when it comes to dealing with facts. I'll try to explain it later with more time.
 
I realize that it is not central to the issue, but I must respectfully disagree on this point.

The smart-aleck-ry, insults, bickering, and dismissive or downright hostile rude behavior is endemic to this forum. It is a part of the culture here. There are posters that are well mannered and civil, but this rude behavior is everywhere and inescapable.

The worst threads are those that deal with fringe topics and started by or posted in by members that have earned a reputation as not being ernest or being unwilling to adopt the viewpoints of others. Even normally well-behaved members seem to take that as an invitation to throw out civility and to make blatant ad hominums against the people they perceive as being unworthy of a civil discussion.

Regards, Canis


You know, I've been thinking about this a lot over the past couple weeks because of the recent activity in GS&P around the subject of UFO culture.

On one hand, I feel there's got to be some way to bridge the gap that doesn't involve condescending and demeaning language. That's clearly no way to win somebody over to a more difficult and disciplined way of thinking. But on the other hand, there's a sense of entitlement about some "woo" purveyors, who seem to feel they have a right to redefine the boundaries of reason to include support for their pet beliefs.


How to deal with this?

I'm not exactly new to this kind of argument. For several years now, I've tried on various Internet forums to explain the fundamentals of reason and critical analysis to people who are firmly entrenched in the habits of credulous, magical and conspiratorial thinking. It can be really frustrating, and that frustration sometimes leads to emotional outbursts that end up widening the ideology gap even further.

Most of my experience has come from dealing with conspiracy theorists, who seem to be especially argumentative and derisive in their rhetoric. I'm afraid that the acquired habit of counteracting that especially abrasive approach might have rubbed off on my own debating style, to my own disadvantage.

Unfortunately, I'm afraid I often allow my ego to run away from me and I unwittingly adopt a bitter, condescending attitude out of frustration. I can only imagine that the mode of thinking that appears normal and rational to me must come off as stuffy and constricting to the true believers I'm arguing against, and it's difficult to give up enough ground to allow them to figure it out at their own pace.

Then there's the added pitfall of stereotyping all believers along the same criteria as the familiar die-hards who've maintained their position against all appeals to reason, and the prevalent culture of ridicule that has calcified around these radical promoters of popular "woo" topics.

Given all these obstacles, how does one go about the honest work of educating the credulous in the practice of critical thinking and skepticism? It ain't easy, but I feel an urgent need to to learn because I strongly feel that skepticism is a crucial skill that everybody needs in this "Age of Information," where sensationalistic, bunko nonsense is far more prevalent and accessible than reliable, verified facts.

If anybody has any advice for me, I'd certainly welcome it because I really don't think it's productive to alienate the very same people whom I honestly seek to help.
 
Last edited:
To be honest I lost a little bit of respect for PZ from this....... where feminism is concerned he seems to fall into the trap of "if you dont agree with me or if you in any way question what I am saying then you are a clueless fool".

I think it's simpler than that. He likes macho posturing (at least when he does it). Exaggerated protectionism of women is part of that. So is thrashing other men, claiming that he is one of the few enlightened. This can rather easily be couched in a certain kind of feminism, but basically, it's all male monkey chest-beating.
 
I think it's simpler than that. He likes macho posturing (at least when he does it). Exaggerated protectionism of women is part of that. So is thrashing other men, claiming that he is one of the few enlightened. This can rather easily be couched in a certain kind of feminism, but basically, it's all male monkey chest-beating.

Ohh, I hadnt thought of it like that.

Good call.
 
Ohh, I hadnt thought of it like that.

Good call.

Thanks, but I can't claim any special insight. I've just been reading his stuff for years, and that's his main pattern, no matter whom he is addressing or on what subject. He's a macho* put-down artist. It's just that people don't seem to notice as much when they agree on the badness of the targets. I notice it more, because it embarrasses me especially when people I agree with make use of bad arguments. I'm definitely in the minority, though.

*Note that this is a bit unfair to people in Spanish-speaking cultures, for whom "machismo" is a very different thing from bombastic chest-beating and Tarzan-whooping. Still, in English, the word works.
 
I think it's simpler than that. He likes macho posturing (at least when he does it). Exaggerated protectionism of women is part of that. So is thrashing other men, claiming that he is one of the few enlightened. This can rather easily be couched in a certain kind of feminism, but basically, it's all male monkey chest-beating.
Ohh, I hadnt thought of it like that.

Good call.


You mean, like William Murderface on Metalocalypse?

http://video.adultswim.com/metalocalypse/arent-you-the-bass-player.html
 
Last edited:
The smart-aleck-ry, insults, bickering, and dismissive or downright hostile rude behavior is endemic to this forum. It is a part of the culture here.
So, in your mind, rudeness is tantamount to non-skeptical thinking? Could you please, oh-so-pretty-please, elaborate on that one?
 
So, in your mind, rudeness is tantamount to non-skeptical thinking? Could you please, oh-so-pretty-please, elaborate on that one?

Could you please, oh-so-pretty-please, read the post Caniswalensis was responding to before making yourself an example of the exact point Caniswalensis was making?
 
This is really interesting, thanks - and do of course keep it up! It's funny - from the media coverage and tweets I read, it seemed like certain elements were appointing themselves spokes people for skepticism. I saw Phil Plait, PZ Myers quoted as speaking FOR skeptic women and something about that didn't fit.

On a tangent, I also suspect "don't be a dick" is dead - it's populist and far too subjective, well intentioned as it is.

PS: Apologies for hyperlink problem, still have my training wheels on :)
 
So, in your mind, rudeness is tantamount to non-skeptical thinking? Could you please, oh-so-pretty-please, elaborate on that one?

Sorry Slimething, but if you want to have a discussion with me, I need a more friendly tone from you.

I do not know if you intended it this way, but the tone of your post seems condesending and argumentitive.

I and my beautiful mind are not the subjects of this thread, but if anyone wants to ask questions about my thoughts on any subject, all they have to do is ask me in a civil and polite fashion. I love to talk about myself! :)

I do not think anything is really on the line here, and I do not see why we can't discuss the issue in a friendly and respectful manner.

Regards, Canis
 
So, in your mind, rudeness is tantamount to non-skeptical thinking? Could you please, oh-so-pretty-please, elaborate on that one?

Could you please, oh-so-pretty-please, read the post Caniswalensis was responding to before making yourself an example of the exact point Caniswalensis was making?

Thanks Kevin. You cut right to the heart of it here, and I appreciate your comment.
 
This is really interesting, thanks - and do of course keep it up! It's funny - from the media coverage and tweets I read, it seemed like certain elements were appointing themselves spokes people for skepticism. I saw Phil Plait, PZ Myers quoted as speaking FOR skeptic women and something about that didn't fit.
Yes, I have the same feeling. One of the reasons I have never made a peep about the elevator scene is that I do not feel like I can really say much. Having never been a woman, I am not sure if I can really understand on a gut level what their experiences are.

As for the male skeptic stance, Meyers & Dawkins are not people I would choose to represent me on any social issue. Plait? Maybe, I don't know.


On a tangent, I also suspect "don't be a dick" is dead - it's populist and far too subjective, well intentioned as it is.

I suspect your right, but I think it died because there are people out there that just enjoy being *****. If you are satisfied with ending a debate by shouting others down, that's a big advantage. Not really a win in my book though.
 
Last edited:
Interesting and on topic... PZ Myers is as we speak having a go at a female scientist friend of mine... interesting ,have a read.. and then the comment section he replies..

zenbuffy.com/2011/07/integrity-starts-at-home/

I like the guy, but I think he's utterly wrong here and fighting for someone who's conduct was awful (Jen Oulette in this case..)

PS: Sorry, still 5 posts away from hyperlinking!
 
Hello Dr Grimes,

First, thank you for the link to your blog. It is a most excellent read, and I look forward to reading a lot more of your writings.

Secondly, I think the answer to your question: "Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?" is an emphatic and obvious "Yes"

Any arguments that center around statements such as "RW is a _____, therefore her comments are ____" or "rich, white men are ___, therefore ___" or "members of ___ community are socially inept, therefore __" or "feminists are ___, therefore ___" or, well, you get the idea, are obviously promoting stereotypes over rational thinking.

No one really enjoys looking deeply at their own beliefs, knowing that it can result in realizing that we were wrong, our parents or other admired people taught us poorly, or that we just plain bought into a concept without thinking about it very much. I think skeptics sometimes have an even more difficult time with it than most, because we like to think that since we are so rational and logical in one area, we must be equally rational with everything we think. Or that since we successfully eradicated our irrational beliefs about religion or other wooish beliefs, that we therefore have eradicated ALL irrational beliefs from our brains. Utter hogwash, of course, but I think it persists.

We also, like everyone, tend to suffer from the Fundamental Attribution Error. We tend to think "If I think X, I have a damn good reason. If YOU think X, it's because you're a racist/misogynist/homophobe/insert-other-negative-thing here.

Which is certainly not to say that racism, sexism, homophobia, or other bigotries don't exist in our community. The fact that this has become "elevatorgate" speaks volumes, in my opinion.

Meg
 
Hello Dr Grimes,

First, thank you for the link to your blog. It is a most excellent read, and I look forward to reading a lot more of your writings.

Secondly, I think the answer to your question: "Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?" is an emphatic and obvious "Yes"

Any arguments that center around statements such as "RW is a _____, therefore her comments are ____" or "rich, white men are ___, therefore ___" or "members of ___ community are socially inept, therefore __" or "feminists are ___, therefore ___" or, well, you get the idea, are obviously promoting stereotypes over rational thinking.

No one really enjoys looking deeply at their own beliefs, knowing that it can result in realizing that we were wrong, our parents or other admired people taught us poorly, or that we just plain bought into a concept without thinking about it very much. I think skeptics sometimes have an even more difficult time with it than most, because we like to think that since we are so rational and logical in one area, we must be equally rational with everything we think. Or that since we successfully eradicated our irrational beliefs about religion or other wooish beliefs, that we therefore have eradicated ALL irrational beliefs from our brains. Utter hogwash, of course, but I think it persists.

We also, like everyone, tend to suffer from the Fundamental Attribution Error. We tend to think "If I think X, I have a damn good reason. If YOU think X, it's because you're a racist/misogynist/homophobe/insert-other-negative-thing here.

Which is certainly not to say that racism, sexism, homophobia, or other bigotries don't exist in our community. The fact that this has become "elevatorgate" speaks volumes, in my opinion.

Meg

Thanks so much Meg - means a lot that anyone reads it, I just put it up for some friends but if people do like it, may be encouragement to continue - don't say I didn't warn you!

Indeed, the points you make are what I've been mulling over myself. And in a most erudite manner, for which I have nominated you for wonderful prose. As to the subject in question; In any other arena I'd ignore it as inevitable human behaviour. But perhaps unfairly, I expect a higher standard from people that proclaim to be critical thinkers :) The object of critical thinking is to evaluate and use data to support those conclusions - not easy on emotive issues, but something I thought SHOULD be second nature to a hardened skeptic. Maybe my fallacy is to assume that people will always embody their aspirations ;)

Oh, and Dave is fine - Dr. makes me think I have students reading :D
 
Hi Dave :)

Thank you very much.

I too hold people that claim to be critical thinkers to a higher standard than other people. I suppose that's why I am so much more disappointed when we regularly demonstrate ourselves to be just as bigoted, arrogant, whiny, petty, or mean-spirited as everyone else on the internets.

I would like to think that we could find a way to discuss social issues in a way that valued evidence, cogent arguments and logical conclusions over snarky comments, back biting or ad hominem attacks. I think that if we could, much progress could be made. Unfortunately, I think we as a group are more a reflection of society as a whole, though, and treating people with respect, listening intently, and actually attempting to understand each other's point of view is not in fashion right now. The norm today seems to be to turn everything into a "one side vs another" and insult those not on "your team".

Perhaps if we were to concentrate on eradicating the sexist mythos from our psyches with as intense a fervor as we work to eradicate other woo, we could move forward.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom