This is an ode to relativism and an oversimplification.
No, it's really not.
The fact though is that every proposition is either true or false,
I never said otherwise.
and some people honestly look for the truth with that in mind and happen to be on one side of an argument. What is valuable is not the side, but the arguments.
We could use your argument with science and homeopathy. They are "two sides" in a debate as well, and both claim the other is wrong. But which one is right?
The side that's right is right. I mean, where did I say otherwise? Where did I say that because there are two sides to an issue, that both must be right or that the truth must lie somewhere in the middle? You're reading something into my posts that isn't there.
My point is actually the opposite of yours. I'm saying that, yes, excluding matters of subjective taste, it will often (maybe always, depending on how clearly-defined the proposition is) be the case that one side is right and the other is wrong. And the side that is wrong, once it has been apprised of the "correct" facts (so that ignorance or misinformation are no longer possibilities) must be using faulty reasoning.
I think you didn't get the point. The point of the blog isn't about just having another way of saying "you're wrong". It's about "why you're wrong". It's about the fact that there are certain basic rules which characterize skepticism, and that ignoring these simple rules is not skeptical thinking.
Are the use of straw man arguments valid?
Are ad hominems valid?
That was the point? Really? The 34023471056742310572343rd sermon on this forum to the virtues of skeptical thinking and decrying the use of fallacies? Jesus H. Christ. Talk about an exercise in triviality.
Ok, just so we're clear:
Hooray for skepticism!
Beliefs should be based on evidence and reason!
Logical fallacies are fallacious and should be avoided!
Any other utterly uncontroversial propositions I need to affirm for you?
It seemed to me that the OP was trying to make some broader point that we need to "rationally examine" the supposed phenomenon of ""leading" figures in the skeptic community taking an approach which was the very anti-thesis of skeptical."
In other words, because some people are (in the OP's opinion) engaging in bad reasoning on this one issue, we must make some deeper inquiry. (Maybe a purge of bad skeptic leaders!)
And my point is, there are always skeptics, including "leading figures" who are supposedly engaging in bad reasoning because they don't agree with other skeptics on a particular issue. Because people in this community turn
every issue into "if you don't agree with my conclusion, you must not be practicing proper skepticism."
Have you looked at the examples provided by the OP in his blog? Do you agree?
Yes? No? The middle is excluded.
I'm not interested in discussing the specifics of ElevatorGate any further.
Look, by all means, discuss any instances you think you have of poor reasoning by anyone, "leaders" or otherwise. Have at it, that's what discussion forums are for. I'm just saying that the professions of "shock, shock!" that other skeptics are using what some skeptics consider to be bad reasoning is pretty laughable. Anyone who's been around this community for any length of time has seen it happen over and over again.
Trying to start some meta-discussion about why certain people are bad skeptics because they've made bad arguments on issue X is only going to turn into a wankfest by that subset that agrees on issue X. Case in point: I've been trying to make a general point about disagreements among skeptics, but everyone keeps trying to drag the discussion back to Watson and the Elevator. Because that's all this is, apparently: yet another ElevatorGate thread. So I'll leave you to it.