Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?

But it is possible one of them does lack skepticism.

Well, yes, of course. In fact, if one uses the definition of skepticism I provided -- which seems fairly close to how people here generally use it -- then it follows logically that at least one "side" of every discussion is lacking skepticism.

My point is not that it's wrong to accuse someone of a lack of skepticism if you're using this definition. It's that it's just a trivial accusation because it's basically another way of saying "you're wrong."*

So threads like this that ask whether "elements of the skeptic community" are failing to be skeptical are really just a hyperbolic way of saying "self-identified skeptics are sometimes wrong (as evidenced by their disagreement with me on this particular topic on which I am correct)."

*-- That is, once you've stated your argument, so that the other side can no longer (in your view) be simply looking at the wrong or incomplete evidence. And assuming we're not accusing the other side of actually "knowing" that I'm right but just lying or trolling.
 
Well, yes, of course. In fact, if one uses the definition of skepticism I provided -- which seems fairly close to how people here generally use it -- then it follows logically that at least one "side" of every discussion is lacking skepticism.

My point is not that it's wrong to accuse someone of a lack of skepticism if you're using this definition. It's that it's just a trivial accusation because it's basically another way of saying "you're wrong."*

So threads like this that ask whether "elements of the skeptic community" are failing to be skeptical are really just a hyperbolic way of saying "self-identified skeptics are sometimes wrong (as evidenced by their disagreement with me on this particular topic on which I am correct)."

*-- That is, once you've stated your argument, so that the other side can no longer (in your view) be simply looking at the wrong or incomplete evidence. And assuming we're not accusing the other side of actually "knowing" that I'm right but just lying or trolling.
Sounds like you didn't read Dave's blog. If you did, have you any comments on the specific things he pointed out that were not skeptical and why? Or are you unskeptically dismissing the possibility he actually has a point?
 
Sounds like you didn't read Dave's blog. If you did, have you any comments on the specific things he pointed out that were not skeptical and why? Or are you unskeptically dismissing the possibility he actually has a point?

First of all, I wasn't commenting on Dave's blog post. I was responding to devnull's post (as indicated by the fact that I quoted it) and making a general point about how people here are constantly accusing those who disagree with them of failing to be skeptical. And as I clarified in my response to you, they're not necessarily wrong given the way they've defined skepticism.

I have read Dave's blog post, and it really doesn't address my point. It's simply a lengthy argument about how people who disagree with him on a particular issue (ElevatorGate) are not being skeptical. I have no interest in getting into yet another discussion of that issue.

My point is that this is really nothing new or noteworthy: as long as self-identified skeptics disagree with each other, they will accuse each other of not being skeptical (at least with respect to that particular issue).

Team Watson will accuse Team Dawkins of not being skeptical, and vice versa.

Team Amanda Knox is guilty will accuse Team No She Isn't of not being skeptical, and vice versa.

Libertarian Skeptics will accuse Non-Libertarian Skeptics of not being skeptical of government, and the NLSs will accuse the LSs of not being skeptical of the claimed powers of the free market.

Etc. Pick any thread in this forum where "regulars" are disagreeing with each other, and you'll see the accusations of nonskepticism and citation of logical fallacies fly.

On each particular issue, one side may be entirely correct in its accusations and the other side entirely wrong. And maybe some people are consistently on the "correct" side and others consistently on the "wrong" side.

My point is that this is not a sign of some disturbing new development in the skeptical community, and doesn't really merit some meta-discussion about how some "elements" of the community aren't sufficiently skeptical. It all just another variation on "some people who call themselves skeptics disagree with me on an issue, and I think they're wrong."
 
Well, yes, of course. In fact, if one uses the definition of skepticism I provided -- which seems fairly close to how people here generally use it -- then it follows logically that at least one "side" of every discussion is lacking skepticism.

My point is not that it's wrong to accuse someone of a lack of skepticism if you're using this definition. It's that it's just a trivial accusation because it's basically another way of saying "you're wrong."*

So threads like this that ask whether "elements of the skeptic community" are failing to be skeptical are really just a hyperbolic way of saying "self-identified skeptics are sometimes wrong (as evidenced by their disagreement with me on this particular topic on which I am correct)."

*-- That is, once you've stated your argument, so that the other side can no longer (in your view) be simply looking at the wrong or incomplete evidence. And assuming we're not accusing the other side of actually "knowing" that I'm right but just lying or trolling.

This is an ode to relativism and an oversimplification. The fact though is that every proposition is either true or false, and some people honestly look for the truth with that in mind and happen to be on one side of an argument. What is valuable is not the side, but the arguments.

We could use your argument with science and homeopathy. They are "two sides" in a debate as well, and both claim the other is wrong. But which one is right?

I think you didn't get the point. The point of the blog isn't about just having another way of saying "you're wrong". It's about "why you're wrong". It's about the fact that there are certain basic rules which characterize skepticism, and that ignoring these simple rules is not skeptical thinking.

Are the use of straw man arguments valid?
Are ad hominems valid?

Have you looked at the examples provided by the OP in his blog? Do you agree?

Yes? No? The middle is excluded.
 
This is an ode to relativism and an oversimplification.

No, it's really not.

The fact though is that every proposition is either true or false,

I never said otherwise.

and some people honestly look for the truth with that in mind and happen to be on one side of an argument. What is valuable is not the side, but the arguments.
We could use your argument with science and homeopathy. They are "two sides" in a debate as well, and both claim the other is wrong. But which one is right?

The side that's right is right. I mean, where did I say otherwise? Where did I say that because there are two sides to an issue, that both must be right or that the truth must lie somewhere in the middle? You're reading something into my posts that isn't there.

My point is actually the opposite of yours. I'm saying that, yes, excluding matters of subjective taste, it will often (maybe always, depending on how clearly-defined the proposition is) be the case that one side is right and the other is wrong. And the side that is wrong, once it has been apprised of the "correct" facts (so that ignorance or misinformation are no longer possibilities) must be using faulty reasoning.

I think you didn't get the point. The point of the blog isn't about just having another way of saying "you're wrong". It's about "why you're wrong". It's about the fact that there are certain basic rules which characterize skepticism, and that ignoring these simple rules is not skeptical thinking.

Are the use of straw man arguments valid?
Are ad hominems valid?

That was the point? Really? The 34023471056742310572343rd sermon on this forum to the virtues of skeptical thinking and decrying the use of fallacies? Jesus H. Christ. Talk about an exercise in triviality.

Ok, just so we're clear:

Hooray for skepticism!
Beliefs should be based on evidence and reason!
Logical fallacies are fallacious and should be avoided!

Any other utterly uncontroversial propositions I need to affirm for you?

It seemed to me that the OP was trying to make some broader point that we need to "rationally examine" the supposed phenomenon of ""leading" figures in the skeptic community taking an approach which was the very anti-thesis of skeptical."

In other words, because some people are (in the OP's opinion) engaging in bad reasoning on this one issue, we must make some deeper inquiry. (Maybe a purge of bad skeptic leaders!)

And my point is, there are always skeptics, including "leading figures" who are supposedly engaging in bad reasoning because they don't agree with other skeptics on a particular issue. Because people in this community turn every issue into "if you don't agree with my conclusion, you must not be practicing proper skepticism."

Have you looked at the examples provided by the OP in his blog? Do you agree?

Yes? No? The middle is excluded.

I'm not interested in discussing the specifics of ElevatorGate any further.

Look, by all means, discuss any instances you think you have of poor reasoning by anyone, "leaders" or otherwise. Have at it, that's what discussion forums are for. I'm just saying that the professions of "shock, shock!" that other skeptics are using what some skeptics consider to be bad reasoning is pretty laughable. Anyone who's been around this community for any length of time has seen it happen over and over again.

Trying to start some meta-discussion about why certain people are bad skeptics because they've made bad arguments on issue X is only going to turn into a wankfest by that subset that agrees on issue X. Case in point: I've been trying to make a general point about disagreements among skeptics, but everyone keeps trying to drag the discussion back to Watson and the Elevator. Because that's all this is, apparently: yet another ElevatorGate thread. So I'll leave you to it.
 
First of all, I wasn't commenting on Dave's blog post. I was responding to devnull's post (as indicated by the fact that I quoted it) and making a general point about how people here are constantly accusing those who disagree with them of failing to be skeptical. And as I clarified in my response to you, they're not necessarily wrong given the way they've defined skepticism.

I have read Dave's blog post, and it really doesn't address my point. It's simply a lengthy argument about how people who disagree with him on a particular issue (ElevatorGate) are not being skeptical. I have no interest in getting into yet another discussion of that issue.

My point is that this is really nothing new or noteworthy: as long as self-identified skeptics disagree with each other, they will accuse each other of not being skeptical (at least with respect to that particular issue).

Team Watson will accuse Team Dawkins of not being skeptical, and vice versa.

Team Amanda Knox is guilty will accuse Team No She Isn't of not being skeptical, and vice versa.

Libertarian Skeptics will accuse Non-Libertarian Skeptics of not being skeptical of government, and the NLSs will accuse the LSs of not being skeptical of the claimed powers of the free market.

Etc. Pick any thread in this forum where "regulars" are disagreeing with each other, and you'll see the accusations of nonskepticism and citation of logical fallacies fly.

On each particular issue, one side may be entirely correct in its accusations and the other side entirely wrong. And maybe some people are consistently on the "correct" side and others consistently on the "wrong" side.

My point is that this is not a sign of some disturbing new development in the skeptical community, and doesn't really merit some meta-discussion about how some "elements" of the community aren't sufficiently skeptical. It all just another variation on "some people who call themselves skeptics disagree with me on an issue, and I think they're wrong."
So your whole rant is simply that a particular ad hom is often meaningless. OK, now that that's clear... :rolleyes:

Knox is either guilty or she is not, one side is very likely not adhering to good skeptical analysis.
Dave's blog is very specific about the skeptic failures over elevatorgate. He didn't just toss out a meaningless ad hom, he's skeptical and they aren't.

Politics and economics do have empirical facts that can legitimately predict the best course, but the facts are ignored quite often in those areas of discussion.


You make it sound like you don't believe there is a real reality out there. It's all opinion, never resolvable. I don't agree.
 
Last edited:
For a lot of people here, that follows logically from their definition of skepticism.

If "skepticism" = "basing one's beliefs on logical conclusions reached from examining the evidence" (or something similar), and Sally Skeptic believes that "X" is the logical conclusion from the available evidence on issue A, then Sally is almost inevitably going to conclude that Critical Thinker Chris is suffering from a lack of skepticism if he doesn't agree with Sally once Sally has posted her evidence and reasoning.

Which is why almost every time there is a topic here that doesn't break down on neat "skeptic vs. woo" lines (and that isn't an obvious subjective matter of taste), there are accusations that "Sally" or "Chris" (or both) isn't being skeptical, often followed by people lamenting the supposed lack of critical thinking here, and sometimes even generating a spinoff thread specifically to discuss the supposedly "puzzling" lack of skepticism.

Shorter version: if you define "fails to agree with me after hearing my argument" as "lacks skepticism," then any remotely controversial topic is going to result in accusations of an alleged lack of skepticism. Ho hum.

flip side: time was you could have balanced and interesting discussion between skeptics and non skeptics, in the last two years a certain sub population has resorted to belittling crap that has driven most non skeptics, is that the goal?
 
You make it sound like you don't believe there is a real reality out there. It's all opinion, never resolvable. I don't agree.

I don't agree with that, either, which is why I didn't say it.

(races to start a new thread on "Are There Elements of the Skeptic Community Flailing At Strawmen?")

flip side: time was you could have balanced and interesting discussion between skeptics and non skeptics, in the last two years a certain sub population has resorted to belittling crap that has driven most non skeptics, is that the goal?

I'm really not sure what you're getting at here.

I'm not a tone troll; I'm all for blunt discussions even if some people are offended. So I'm probably not as concerned about alleged "belittling" as you are.

I would say that the difference between "skeptics" and "non skeptics" is not as big as some like to think. There is, of course, a certain subset of the population that really does think that it's fine in general to base beliefs on what you wish was true or feel in your heart rather than what you have evidence for, but it's rather small.

There's a larger subset that doesn't agree with that generally, but carves out an exception for one particular belief or set of beliefs (usually religion). But for the most part, the things that "skeptics" think define them aren't really that rare. It's really not that controversial to tell a group of "non skeptics" (by which I mean simply people who don't call themselves skeptics, and may not even know what that term means) that we should base our beliefs on evidence. Hell, most "woos" are trying to use evidence and logic to support their positions (or at least are pretending to).

So I think sometimes people arrive at places like the JREF Forum and think "wow, finally, a group of people who, like me, has totally seen through the bogus arguments people use to support [religion, psychics, Bigfoot, etc.] These are my people! We employ reasoning and critical thinking, unlike those other people!" And then an issue comes up where it turns out that "my people" don't agree with me, and suddenly I notice that they too are making bad arguments and engaging in sloppy thinking, and now the bloom is off the rose.
 
Mikeyx: Everybody is a skeptic and a non-skeptic, depending on the topic.

The main issue for me is when people claim skepticism cannot be, or is not allowed to be, applied to certain topics. Many theists claim this, as we have seen time and time again on these forums. I have seen evidence of this concerning the topic of feminism. The Pharyngula thread concerning the rape of the hotel maid is a classic example - anybody questioning the facts, or merely raising the idea that the maid is perhaps not being completely truthful is labelled a misogynistic a-hole.

Personally, while I understand that I sometimes fail to apply skepticism to every situation, I refuse to relinquish my right to apply skepticism to any and all situations. Skeptical inquiry and the scientific method are the best tools we have for confirming objective reality, to the best of our abilities as great apes.
 
Politics and economics do have empirical facts that can legitimately predict the best course, but the facts are ignored quite often in those areas of discussion.

While this is true, I don't think it's quite as widespread. Often the problem is different ideas of what 'best' means when deciding the best course of action.
 
While this is true, I don't think it's quite as widespread. Often the problem is different ideas of what 'best' means when deciding the best course of action.
Clearly the beliefs in what is "best" are sincere, but that doesn't mean there isn't an actual evidence based "best". The problem is too many people don't know the difference between ideology and evidence.
 
Greetings folks - Apologies for making my first post such a potentially off putting one, I've been a lurker on here sometime and a contributing guest author to the site so I thought I'd get your opinions on this subject.

Reading these forums I see the vast majority of posters are skeptics in the classical sense - without being rude, they will disagree, ask for clarification or evidence and there are little traces of dogmatic thinking. Yet interestingly enough in the wake of the 'elevatorgate' debacle there were many examples of "leading" figures in the skeptic community taking an approach which was the very anti-thesis of skeptical. There were also several examples of logical fallacies, as well as a creeping wave of people trying to marry skepticism to ideology. Evidently this was an emotive issue but it saddened me that a cause I think so worthwhile is at risk of being deemed hypocritical. I've written about it here, I'd be grateful if you'd take a look and share your thoughts.

goo.gl/raSxB


What do others think ? I realise this may be an entrenched issue but it would be very disheartening, as a skeptic community, if we couldn't rationally examine it...

I can only speak for myself and my personal experience on this forum: James Randi was the person who made me realize I was a skeptic deep down inside. That no matter how hard I wanted to believe in some wacky things (for example, OBE's) that I still had a tendency to not settle with simple explanations that pleased the ear, and that I was always behind a honest truth, even if that meant something that didn't conform to what I wanted.

After joining this forum, I began to exchange with other skeptic people and to test my own beliefs. On some occasions I had to find out that on some topics I was being as irrational as any christian fundamentalist and I had to adapt my initial hunches. This forum has served as a way to check my initial beliefs and test them against reality. And for that I am thankful.

But I still keep making mistakes every once in a while. I still let the emotions get the best of me and cloud my ability to analyze something. And my biggest challenge is to realize in which fields am I doing this and how can I teach myself better.

Additionally, my interactions with theists and other woos have served as a way to exercise my ability to interact with people who believe in weird things, and try to find a way to have a coherent conversation in which either one of us will learn from the other, rather than turn it into a battle of egos to see who is right (which by the way, is an almost inescapable temptation).

I have also seen that, contrary to popular belief, skeptics are not just following another cult and James Randi is not their leader. I remember an occasion where a thread was opened criticizing James Randi for encouraging someone to sabotage someone else's e-mail folder by sending them a bunch of e-mails (something like that, I don't remember how the story went exactly). And skeptics from this forum expressed their honest disagreement with this, yet in a way that was respectful. But the bottom line is, that is precisely what differentiates skeptics from cult members: We do not follow a cult blindly and we do not bow to Randi. We hold Randi to the same scrutiny of critical thinking that we hold ourselves or anyone.

That has been my experience here and I am eternally grateful.
 
Last edited:
As "skepticism" (critical thinking, free thinking, whatever you call it) becomes more popular, a larger percentage of the "movement" will be there because of the social aspect. You see it in churches all the time. People who really don't "believe" everything the church says, but they appreciate the social connections. I already see it in the skeptical "movement" including some groups who seem to take advantage of it. It's inevitable.

There's also a growing segment who simply share a common belief with many skeptics even though they applied little if any critical thinking to arrive at their positions. They can tell you that homeopathy is bunk, but they couldn't begin to explain why it's bunk. Throw something new into the mix, and they wait to see which way the wind blows, then parrot what they hear.

These people get accepted by the mainstream, which in turn feeds the social aspect. At the same time you have people who think critically and attack all arguments demanding evidence and solid reasoning. When they seem to oppose or at least contest what the mainstream believes, they are ostracized, an inevitable result of the social aspect of the skeptical "movement."

It's sad to me that so many bloggers fear "fracturing" of the skeptical movement because of disagreements. I think that's the best thing that could happen. Skepticism is a process. When the FDA cracks down on the latest quack medical device, do we really need 50 skeptical bloggers writing about it? Does it actually do any good?

Give me Elevatorgate any day of the week. I've seen some of the best applications of critical thinking I've seen in a while. Epepke's timeline is awesome. FLS' poignant questions are worth reading repeatedly. Skeptic Ginger's requests for evidence are a breath of fresh compared to the JREF's reaction to the social aspect telling people not to make unwanted sexual advances.

And best of all, the dissection of the seriously flawed arguments floating around are what skepticism is all about. If we can't be skeptical about ourselves, how can we ask anyone else to be skeptical about their beliefs?
 
Last edited:
Give me Elevatorgate any day of the week. I've seen some of the best applications of critical thinking I've seen in a while. Epepke's timeline is awesome. FLS' poignant questions are worth reading repeatedly. Skeptic Ginger's requests for evidence are a breath of fresh compared to the JREF's reaction to the social aspect telling people not to make unwanted sexual advances.

And best of all, the dissection of the seriously flawed arguments floating around are what skepticism is all about. If we can't be skeptical about ourselves, how can we ask anyone else to be skeptical about their beliefs?

You might have a point there. I'm all for it, provided you don't accuse those who question as sexist :) That was my whole bone of contention. That certain elements (PZ Myers, Plait, Oulette, RW etc...) were painting anyone who disagreed as a repressor of women seemed against the very ethod of skepticism.

But yes, I agree totally - skeptics should cast the same magnifying glass over their own beliefs! If nothing else it's good practice, and it would be hypocritical to not do so..
 
Last edited:
Are you claiming there is no real Universe, or not enough evidence to draw a conclusion?

Neither, I'm saying the point you made is insufficient to draw the conclusion that an evidence based "best" exists.

Since Beth's point related to people using different interpretations of the meaning of "best", no amount of evidence will lead to determining a single answer without resolving that ambiguity first.
 
Neither, I'm saying the point you made is insufficient to draw the conclusion that an evidence based "best" exists.

Since Beth's point related to people using different interpretations of the meaning of "best", no amount of evidence will lead to determining a single answer without resolving that ambiguity first.
Yes, if you are rich and greedy, I imagine best is not the same for you as it is if you are poor and needy. So in that respect, I agree with you.

But if 'best' is defined as best for the person who would be voting and or whose political ideology should be in their own best interest, then a lot of people believe wrongly what the evidence supports regarding their own goals. Thus you have the Ron Pauls, for example, who believe we'd all be better off financially if the economy collapsed and the country was forced to go back to the gold standard. His fantasy is not based on real world evidence.

I'd be happy if people just had the truth and the facts. I believe the 'best' would then follow.
 
Last edited:
To be honest I lost a little bit of respect for PZ from this....... where feminism is concerned he seems to fall into the trap of "if you dont agree with me or if you in any way question what I am saying then you are a clueless fool".
That's PZ's default position generally. It's just less noticeable on matters of science and education because he's right and people who disagree with him are clueless fools.
 
Thanks for people's feedback on this - I've noticed that the people on this forum aren't as militant as many skeptic bloggers have been. In fact, almost all the discourse I've seen has been rational without resort to name calling. This is most encouraging.

But I must admit, I have come across two types of skeptic blog - those written from the point of view of critical thinking and those written from an ideological position first with skepticism tacked on.

There is no problem with having a personal ideology - I'm a left leaning (European sense, read democratic socialist) liberal humanist who feels male - female equility is vital and human rights paramount yet it becomes a problem if you allow your personal viewpoint to influence your critical thinking. For me, it would be against my scientific ethos to include any of my political or social slants when I'm writing about skepticism - with the same evidence, two skeptics, regardless of personal ideology should, if they're truly applying the term skepticism correctly, find the same conclusion.

It's human to err and to get emotive, but I think for true skepticism it is important to check your baggage at the door - and perhaps not everyone can do that.

On an aside, I think it's time we left elevatorgate behind as a lesson in how not to conduct public discourse :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom