Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Here is again my definition of God:

Maker of heaven and earth and everything,​

Yep, read that many times before, but I've also seen your evasion of answering direct questions many times (You know, those "get to the heart of the matter" type questions you avoid).

The maker of heaven and earth and everything....How and in what manner did you discover this? What is your evidence to back up this claim and did you give your god a name or did you hear the name claimed somewhere else?
How do you know this god made everything? Did it tell you?

I know these questions would make you tergiversate, because if you answer them truthfully, the argument then comes down to how you acquired your belief in a god.
 
I see you gave a direct answer for once:
I have yet to see convincing evidence that the universe is the intentional creation of any entity, and though I made a pretty good try in my youth, I cannot accept it on faith alone.

Although I have spoken and studied with many intelligent and thoughtful people who believe in God, and who believe that God is the creator of the universe, and even some who believe (as you appear to) that God makes his presence known directly without the use of the five senses, I have not ever met anyone who confused the experience of God with his definition.

So you cannot accept it on faith alone? Why?
 
Last edited:
Ok, I have to point out the sheer illogic of the OP question here.

What's this "embrace" codswallop, anyhow?

Atheism is simply the result of NOT ACCEPTING SOMETHING ELSE. There is nothing to "embrace".

All atheism amounts to is a failure to embrace an unproven, untestable, unverifiable claim to something that's never been demonstrated.

A "failure to embrace" is not "embracing" anything.

So the OP is a faulty question, and one that deserves no answer, only exposure for the faulty propaganda it is.
 
I was gonna jump in here, but my apprehension about my comprehension required a suspension of my usual turgid attention to clear verbal elucidation. So, on balance, I went and opened a Diet Coke instead.

Cheers.





PS - Any god I'd respect (not necessarily worship) would have to be shown to have executed the Sagan-Contact criteria or an equivalent. If you have some proof about that, do please let me know. See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4233256&postcount=105
 
Last edited:
Not only evidence from the five senses but essentially from the brain.

Since I do not accept the essential idea that you find requisite: that the universe is the creation of a deity, answering your question in the way you wish is difficult, if not impossible. I can certainly say that "in my brain" I have knowledge neither of what you claim God to be, nor of any other, arbitrarily reverse-named entity that might be claimed as the maker of "heaven earth and everything." I have yet to see convincing evidence that the universe is the intentional creation of any entity, and though I made a pretty good try in my youth, I cannot accept it on faith alone.

Although I have spoken and studied with many intelligent and thoughtful people who believe in God, and who believe that God is the creator of the universe, and even some who believe (as you appear to) that God makes his presence known directly without the use of the five senses, I have not ever met anyone who confused the experience of God with his definition.


I never say that "God makes his presence known directly without the use of the five senses."



The question of evidence was also taken up in my previous thread on "Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?"

And atheists there say that evidence means empirical evidence.

But when challenged to describe empirical evidence in not more than twenty words, no one was willing to hazard any definition in not more than twenty words of his own drafting.

And I also asked atheists there what are the organs of experience, no one mentioned the brain which is the principal and essential organ of experience without which the impressions from the so-called five senses mean nothing.

I kept insisting that without the brain organ a human person cannot have consciousness thereby not able to experience anything at all, much less use reason and proceed to think intelligently.


Anyway I said that for me the empirical evidence of God consists in the knowledge in my brain of communication satellites, the knowledge in my brain that the moon exists, and reasoning with my brain from these two pieces of accepted information in my brain, I come to the conclusion that God is the maker of the moon, etc., etc., etc.


And I call all that collection of pieces of information in my brain and reasoning therefrom as the empirical evidence for the existence of God, the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


That is why I am here again asking people to tell us what they know to be evidence, and how much is required and sufficient for them to come to the knowledge of God's existence.

So far again no one has come up with any knowledge from his brain what is evidence and how much he needs so that it would be sufficient for him to come to the knowledge of God's existence.




I will ask again the same questions as earlier stated above.

[...]

Suppose you tell us what is Xenu.


I have already time and again given my definition of God, here again in more plain English.

God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything.​


Now, please answer intelligently, and no tergiversation:


You have a brain? Yes No.

Evidence of anything is stored in your brain as a piece of accepted information? Yes No.

But you don't have a piece of evidence on the existence of God in your brain? Yes No.

And you want people who have evidence of God's existence in their brain to share with you their evidence? Yes No.​


I know what is evidence.

Suppose you tell me:

1. What is evidence for you, and


2. How much is needed and sufficient for you to come to the acceptance of God in your brain.
​

Remember, you atheists are the ones harping on evidence all the time; so if anyone should know evidence you are the guys, tell us then what is evidence for you.

And how much is required by you and sufficient for you to come to the acceptance of God's existence.


For the rest of you, I have the impression very strong that you are into tergiversation.


That is why if ever I have the time and leisure I like to write a book that is very easy for people with skill in plain speech to know why I call atheists tergiversators.


Consider bruto above, he is again bringing in the tergiversating gambit of Xenu, when if he were to use his brain with versatility and prolificity* he should know that theists today have come to know God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything -- no matter what Xenu is supposed to be in the brains of Xenu's proponents.

Next they will bring up flying spaghetti, and that is why if I may be humorous atheists don't do anything with their brain except to stuff it with spaghetti for a storage, and think thereby that they are so smart.



Yrreg

*Versatility and prolificity, look up the standard English dictionary for the meanings of these two terms, if you still can't comprehend what is versatility and prolificity in a brain, then pm me or send me an email, and I will enlighten you.



Now, atheists here, just tell me what you know to be evidence and give some examples, so that I can get the kind of evidence which you are acquainted with and acceptable to you.


Otherwise you are just into tergiversations.


Addressing bruto, you think you are intelligent and cannot meet any empirical evidence for God's existence, perhaps you might care to know that some people much more intelligent than you have come to empirical evidence of God, for example Sir Isaac Newton, and for contemporaries I am sure you do know of scientists of unimpeachable fame who know God from empirical evidence.


But you know what? owing to the tergiversating heart and mind of the bigoted atheists, they cannot admit that such people have come to the knowledge of God, instead they attribute the acceptance of God by these great minds as owing to old age.

What indeed is the difference between you and these brilliant people whose greatness of heart and mind you can never ever even dream to aspire after?

They are much more more intelligent than you, with a far greater brain than yours, and they have not suppressed their brain to see evidence of God everywhere.





Yrreg
 
I never say that "God makes his presence known directly without the use of the five senses."



The question of evidence was also taken up in my previous thread on "Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?"

And atheists there say that evidence means empirical evidence.

But when challenged to describe empirical evidence in not more than twenty words, no one was willing to hazard any definition in not more than twenty words of his own drafting.
Lie.

Empirical evidence is evidence from observations, either natural or experimental. 10 words.

Anything I can engage with my senses, and examine using my cognition, experience, and reason.

Any measurable quality which allows me to distinguish what is real from a delusion or illusion.

In order to evade answering these posts you moved the goalposts to require one specific poster to come up with a definition.

I am still waiting for Dave to write his account of what is empirical evidence in not more than twenty words.
You may think we're stupid, but some of us do have good memories.
 
Now, atheists here, just tell me what you know to be evidence and give some examples, so that I can get the kind of evidence which you are acquainted with and acceptable to you.

Are you blind? Have you no comprehension? Two threads and you're still saying this?:boggled:

ETA: Did Dinosaurs exist Yrreg? Yes or no
 
Last edited:
What indeed is the difference between you and these brilliant people whose greatness of heart and mind you can never ever even dream to aspire after?
I don't care much for appeals to authority but I'm on the side of National Academy of Sciences. Some of the most brilliant people in the world.

They are much more more intelligent than you, with a far greater brain than yours, and they have not suppressed their brain to see evidence of God everywhere.
What is this evidence and why won't you show us?
 
Anyway I said that for me the empirical evidence of God consists in the knowledge in my brain of communication satellites, the knowledge in my brain that the moon exists, and reasoning with my brain from these two pieces of accepted information in my brain, I come to the conclusion that God is the maker of the moon, etc., etc., etc.

That's it? That's the sum total of your evidence for the existence of an invisible, supernatural entity that can't be detected and whose end results are indistinguishable from natural processes that don't need such an entity for them to occur?

And you accept that as evidence for such an entitiy that defies consistent laws of physics?

And you dare to ask atheists if they're intelligent?

Let me ask you a question that you can't and won't answer. Do you believe babies growing up without any outside influence, who come to the conclusion that a moss covered rock is the creator of the moon, the earth, and everything, are acting intelligently? YES or NO, yrreg. No tergiversation.
 
The question of evidence was also taken up in my previous thread on "Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?"

And atheists there say that evidence means empirical evidence.

But when challenged to describe empirical evidence in not more than twenty words, no one was willing to hazard any definition in not more than twenty words of his own drafting.

Others have already said it, but that is a bald-faced lie. There were at least 3 definitions given in the thread that met your criteria, you just willfully ignored them.


Anyway I said that for me the empirical evidence of God consists in the knowledge in my brain of communication satellites, the knowledge in my brain that the moon exists, and reasoning with my brain from these two pieces of accepted information in my brain, I come to the conclusion that God is the maker of the moon, etc., etc., etc.
Yes, you leap straight from knowledge of things that plainly exist to asserting that the reason those things exist is because of a thing you call God, bypassing the whole body of scientific investigation and explanation.

And I call all that collection of pieces of information in my brain and reasoning therefrom as the empirical evidence for the existence of God, the maker of heaven and earth and everything.

A very important part of empiricism is structuring your claims so that people who are skeptical of your conclusions can test those claims for themselves. How do we do that, Gerry?


Addressing bruto, you think you are intelligent and cannot meet any empirical evidence for God's existence, perhaps you might care to know that some people much more intelligent than you have come to empirical evidence of God, for example Sir Isaac Newton, and for contemporaries I am sure you do know of scientists of unimpeachable fame who know God from empirical evidence.

Sir Issac Newton was a brilliant man. He also seriously believed in alchemy (and spent more time pursuing it than optics, mathematics, and physics) and lost a fortune in the South Seas bubble (which he did nothing to prevent or alleviate, despite being the master of the king's mint at the time).

Being brilliant does not prevent someone from holding inane beliefs or making stupid decisions.
 
Last edited:
You've got to admire it, it's a beautiful piece of circular reasoning.

God is that which made heaven, the Earth, Moon, and everything. The Moon exists, which proves God exists, because everything was made by God.
 
Anyway I said that for me the empirical evidence of God consists in the knowledge in my brain of communication satellites, the knowledge in my brain that the moon exists, and reasoning with my brain from these two pieces of accepted information in my brain, I come to the conclusion that God is the maker of the moon, etc., etc., etc.


The existence of communication satellites is not evidence that God exists, because they were made by people. The existence of the Moon is not evidence that God exists, as there are perfectly good explanations for the formation of the Moon that do not need to invoke God.
 
TERGIVERSATION

If you’ve ever observed somebody wriggling and evasive, trying to avoid giving a straight answer to a straight question, then you have observed tergiversation in action.

Which is odd considering how many straight answers you've gotten so far.
 
I never say that "God makes his presence known directly without the use of the five senses."
If God does not make his presence known directly to the mind, then your knowledge of his existence is inferred from other evidence. You need to find a better understanding of what empirical evidence is.
The question of evidence was also taken up in my previous thread on "Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?"

And atheists there say that evidence means empirical evidence.

But when challenged to describe empirical evidence in not more than twenty words, no one was willing to hazard any definition in not more than twenty words of his own drafting.
I don't think that''s true. You may not have seen the definitions, but they were there.
And I also asked atheists there what are the organs of experience, no one mentioned the brain which is the principal and essential organ of experience without which the impressions from the so-called five senses mean nothing.
Obviously one must first decide what you mean by an organ of experience, and what experience is being had. The brain is not a sense organ, and thus, I would contend that it cannot be called an organ of experience for anything outside itself.
I kept insisting that without the brain organ a human person cannot have consciousness thereby not able to experience anything at all, much less use reason and proceed to think intelligently.
Semantics. Of course you need a brain for this. So what?
Anyway I said that for me the empirical evidence of God consists in the knowledge in my brain of communication satellites, the knowledge in my brain that the moon exists, and reasoning with my brain from these two pieces of accepted information in my brain, I come to the conclusion that God is the maker of the moon, etc., etc., etc.


And I call all that collection of pieces of information in my brain and reasoning therefrom as the empirical evidence for the existence of God, the maker of heaven and earth and everything.
I contend that that is not empirical evidence. As soon as you use words such as "reasoning" and "conclusion," you are at a remove from what can be called empirical evidence. You are processing empirical evidence and using your brain to interpret it. Your continual mistake is to assume that the interpretation is empirical, and your conclusion that this makes the interpretation inevitable and necessary, and marks those who do not share it as idiots, is your failure. The arrogance of that failure makes you ridiculous.
That is why I am here again asking people to tell us what they know to be evidence, and how much is required and sufficient for them to come to the knowledge of God's existence.

So far again no one has come up with any knowledge from his brain what is evidence and how much he needs so that it would be sufficient for him to come to the knowledge of God's existence.




I will ask again the same questions as earlier stated above.





Now, atheists here, just tell me what you know to be evidence and give some examples, so that I can get the kind of evidence which you are acquainted with and acceptable to you.


Otherwise you are just into tergiversations.


Addressing bruto, you think you are intelligent and cannot meet any empirical evidence for God's existence, perhaps you might care to know that some people much more intelligent than you have come to empirical evidence of God, for example Sir Isaac Newton, and for contemporaries I am sure you do know of scientists of unimpeachable fame who know God from empirical evidence.
Once again, reasoning from empirical evidence does not total up to empirical evidence itself.
But you know what? owing to the tergiversating heart and mind of the bigoted atheists, they cannot admit that such people have come to the knowledge of God, instead they attribute the acceptance of God by these great minds as owing to old age.
I have not heard anyone here attribute the acceptance of god to old age. That would indeed be nonsense. That does not mean that the acceptance of God is "knowledge" of God. You have jumped to a conclusion here, based on your poor understanding of what empirical evidence actually is.
What indeed is the difference between you and these brilliant people whose greatness of heart and mind you can never ever even dream to aspire after?

They are much more more intelligent than you, with a far greater brain than yours, and they have not suppressed their brain to see evidence of God everywhere.
You will never really understand either faith or atheism if you adopt that arrogant attitude, which insults both those who have no faith and those do, but have actually considered what it means.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom