Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

I see you gave a direct answer for once:


So you cannot accept it on faith alone? Why?
I am not sure whether or not you are adressing me (the actual author of that line) or Yrreg, owing to confusing and often poorly formatted exchanges.

In any case, that statement came from me, not from Yrreg, and I cannot accept god on faith alone, simply because I find it impossible.
 
Now that some here have given an account of what Xenu is, I want you to use your brain intelligently and answer this question:


Is that Xenu in the possession of the most essential attribute of the God that I know to exist outside my brain, and which my brain can intelligently arrive at a conclusion of, that He does exist?​


Here is again my definition of God:

Maker of heaven and earth and everything,​


Compare what you people write about Xenu and tell me is that the maker of heaven and earth and everything?


That is why I call you atheists tergiversators, because you know all the while that Xenu is not the maker of heaven and earth but you keep on psychologically equating Xenu with God, to the end of if nothing else, to obfuscate your brain.

That is a perversion of your brain.



All other points you are trying to make any issue of are just so many tergiversating gimmicks.

Why? Because you fail the very first distinction between God and Xenu, God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything, but Xenu?



Now, here is what you can do and must do if you want to emphasize that the point you are stressing is some commonality of identity between Xenu and God.


1. Don't use the word Xenu, because it is already a compromised word.

2. Use another name for what you want to compare God to, on the basis of their commonality of identity.

3. Try for example to formulate any name like say "Soeht", and define the name as maker of heaven and earth and everything.

4. Now, you can say that in your brain there is the lack of belief for God as for Soeht.
​

Otherwise, it is all tergiversations with your bringing in Xenu and flying spaghetti and whatever else you want to borrow from whatever sources your tergiversating heart and tergiversating perverted brain want to bring up.




For the rest of you who have brought up some honest and intelligent -- apparently intelligent insofar as worthy of a working brain in a sane and right-thinking human, I am studying your thoughts.





Yrreg

So you read minds as well? I'm not too worried because if your mental comprehension is as bad as your reading comprehension then our thoughts are safe.
 
Yrreg, what are we supposed to do with this thread now?

I mean, you lied. Openly, transparently lied. We have proved it, can prove it again, any time.

You poisoned the thread. You tergiversated.




...Now what?
 
Yrreg, what are we supposed to do with this thread now?

I mean, you lied. Openly, transparently lied. We have proved it, can prove it again, any time.
Which lie are you referring to?
There's been a couple.
 
I have always said that investigating atheists is more rewarding than discussing.

I have the impression that atheists are tergiversators.

Atheists wantonly use the word lying and liar on me.



That is to me an impasse.

But I am more correct and more civil in expressing my impression that I find atheists to be tergiversators, while atheists here are as per their routine into namecalling.



Now, readers here, watch out, atheists here will react with more tergiversations and end up with more namecalling.







You are right, whoever said that in effect I am now through with this thread.


I am going to find scientists and philosophers of unimpeachable brain versatility and prolificity who are believers in God maker of heaven and earth and everything, and find out what their reasons for believing are.


So, my next thread will be on reasons for belief or knowledge of God's existence as the maker of heaven and earth and everything, in a human brain of great versatility and prolificity and learning and of course at the same time of great gentility, like Sir Isaac Newton a theist and Anthony Flew a discoverer of God from his erstwhile atheism, who both don't engage in namecalling in discussing God or no God with theists, and definitely don't practice tergiversation.




Now, readers here, watch out, atheists here will resort to namecalling again, as their last volleys here.



I have always said that investigating atheists is more rewarding than discussing with them -- what motivations keep their brains in the lack of belief in God, what advantages they find so irresistible and so addictive as to dwell wilfully in the lack of belief in God by which they lock up their brain?




Yrreg
 
I am not sure whether or not you are adressing me (the actual author of that line) or Yrreg, owing to confusing and often poorly formatted exchanges.

In any case, that statement came from me, not from Yrreg, and I cannot accept god on faith alone, simply because I find it impossible.

My mistake..I was addressing Yrreg. :o I share your opinion here.
 
Yrreg, you asked me to provide a logical argument for atheism. One that would verify that such a position can be obtained intelligently.

Since you have not been able to find a flaw in my logic, I am left to assume that you admit your OP was false. Indeed, it is possible to be intelligent and be an athiest.


Your avoidance of my argument while simultaneously pretending intellectual superiority does nothing to support your position. Unfortunately, this thread has merely served to weaken any credibility you may have had.

This is a minor point, but one of utmost importance to you. Threads are perserved on the internet and available via google search. If you use the same screen name at other sites, it becomes easy for one to determine your reputation by simply searches.


So, I welcome you to start a new thread. I also welcome you to improve your debate skills. I will grow and learn. Will you?
 
Last edited:
Yep, read that many times before, but I've also seen your evasion of answering direct questions many times (You know, those "get to the heart of the matter" type questions you avoid).

The maker of heaven and earth and everything....How and in what manner did you discover this? What is your evidence to back up this claim and did you give your god a name or did you hear the name claimed somewhere else?
How do you know this god made everything? Did it tell you?

I know these questions would make you tergiversate, because if you answer them truthfully, the argument then comes down to how you acquired your belief in a god.

Bump for ya Yrreg..Inquiring minds want to know.
 
Yrreg:


But when challenged to describe empirical evidence in not more than twenty words, no one was willing to hazard any definition in not more than twenty words of his own drafting.
was a lie. There is a word applied to people who utter lies. If you don't like the label, don't lie.
And I also asked atheists there what are the organs of experience, no one mentioned the brain which is the principal and essential organ of experience without which the impressions from the so-called five senses mean nothing.
This is, if not an actual lie, a disingenuous statement (look that one up in your Funk and Wagnall's!). You asked what are the organs of experience. Declining to give the answer you wanted is not the same as declining to answer. A person who cannot tell the difference should not bother to ask questions at all, because he is clearly too stupid to notice when they have been answered.
 
So now that yrreg has admitted that a brain is the "essential organ of experience", has he given up his belief in souls and immaterial god?

Wow, I never thought I'd see the day.

You finally see that not believing in such things is very intelligent--it takes an "organ of experience" to be intelligent at the very minimum.
 
I have always said that investigating atheists is more rewarding than discussing with them -- what motivations keep their brains in the lack of belief in God, what advantages they find so irresistible and so addictive as to dwell willfully in the lack of belief in God by which they lock up their brain.


This is a discussion forum. It's not a laboratory to perform experiments on atheists. You come here with the preconception that atheists behave a certain way and then you do whatever you can to provoke that behavior so you can say "see, I was right about atheists."

I don't think any reasonable person reading these threads would conclude that you are a master of interviews and debate and that the reason these threads turn into train wrecks is all because the atheists are being unreasonable. No, sir. I don't think so at all.
 
Dear Yrreg,

I am one of the readers of your threads. I don't think I've ever posted in one of your threads. It is quite clear from reading that you claimed no one was able to come up with a definition for you in under twenty words ect. ect.

Immediately after the "atheist" posters showed that you had either mistyped or lied about that claim. You then warned readers (like me) that they are just resorting to name calling. But you never did explain the mistake/lie.

From a completely arbitrary position as an un-posted reader of this thread I think your response was quite irresponsible and dishonest. Further more I feel that if you would really like to have readers go through these discussions between you and the "atheist" posters, you should be willing to explain or admit your own mistakes/lies. I will not be reading any more threads until this has been dealt with. I can only hope the other readers that you send warnings to will follow my lead.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom