Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

You think my questions are not intelligent or too intelligent for you?



Posted by yrreg

Suppose you tell us what is Xenu.


I have already time and again given my definition of God, here again in more plain English.

God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Now, please answer intelligently, and no tergiversation:


You have a brain? Yes No.

Evidence of anything is stored in your brain as a piece of accepted information? Yes No.

But you don't have a piece of evidence on the existence of God in your brain? Yes No.

And you want people who have evidence of God's existence in their brain to share with you their evidence? Yes No.


I know what is evidence.

Suppose you tell me:

1. What is evidence for you, and


2. How much is needed and sufficient for you to come to the acceptance of God in your brain.


Remember, you atheists are the ones harping on evidence all the time; so if anyone should know evidence you are the guys, tell us then what is evidence for you.

And how much is required by you and sufficient for you to come to the acceptance of God's existence.

​

[...]



You still have not told the readers international ones, and local ones in your country, what is Xenu.


Please tell people what is Xenu, since you bring up that word.



And don't take refuge in the excuse about my not getting the point whatever you are referring to, just answer the questions above.

Stating with telling people what is Xenu.


And all the other questions above.


Don't think even though your brain is not explicitly aware of it, that you are smart in taking refuge in the accusation that I don't get your point, what I ask you to do is tell people what is Xenu, and also to answer according to the best intelligence of your brain the other questions above.



The rest of you here, if you want to save the time of readers and save the forum bandwidth, just also attend to the questions I direct here to bruto.





Yrreg
 
The rest of you here, if you want to save the time of readers and save the forum bandwidth, just also attend to the questions I direct here to bruto.
Could you have a little decency to respond to our posts and questions?
 
You still have not told the readers international ones, and local ones in your country, what is Xenu.

Please tell people what is Xenu, since you bring up that word.

And don't take refuge in the excuse about my not getting the point whatever you are referring to, just answer the questions above.

Stating with telling people what is Xenu.

And all the other questions above.

Don't think even though your brain is not explicitly aware of it, that you are smart in taking refuge in the accusation that I don't get your point, what I ask you to do is tell people what is Xenu, and also to answer according to the best intelligence of your brain the other questions above.

The rest of you here, if you want to save the time of readers and save the forum bandwidth, just also attend to the questions I direct here to bruto.

Yrreg

You're certainly full of spunk, tonight!
 
Now read this, international audience and enrich your English vocabulary.

Best regards to international readers and happy addition to your plain English vocabulary, I am one really most partisan in regard to plain English as in plain speech which tergiversation is an enemy to.

If any international reader can't apprehend my English, just send me a pm or email me, you can get my email address from my profile link here.
Yrreg, plain English isn't about using big words, or long sentences, however grammatically correct they may be. It's about using words that ordinary people can understand without having to reaching for a dictionary.

I'd like to relate a quick story to you, in the hope that you might gain a little insight.

My cousin was raised to believe that he was the cleverest little boy in the whole world. His parents had made him read all sorts of classic literature, including philosophy, that very few children would have the vocabulary to even read, let alone understand. As a result, he was a pretentious little twonk. One year, around christmas time, my aunt and uncle had a party. My cousin, who was 14 at the time, was proudly announcing to a group of us that he had a logical proof that he was actually God. My sister (who was 16 and had left school that summer, with no qualifications, and had just started training as a hairdresser) wandered in, and asked what we were talking about, so my cousin proudly repeated his claim. "Go on then," said my sister, "tell us your proof." So my cousin did, using long words, and long complex sentences. My sister listened intently until he'd finished. She then asked about the meanings of some of the words he'd used, which he told her. Then, using short words, and short simple sentences, she tore his argument apart from the ground up. I am sure it was amongst the most humiliating experiences of his life.

My point is this - intelligence is not measured by the words you use, or the lengths of your sentences, or whether or not they are grammatically correct (my sister wouldn't know correct grammar if it smacked her in the head), but by the arguments you make.

If she were taking part in this debate the first thing she'd ask you would be, "What does tergiversate mean?" And having been given the definition she'd respond, "You mean evade? Why don't you ****ing say that you snobby ****?"

I should add that this is not meant as an attack on you, or your argument, but a note on your posting style. Reading your posts is difficult, even for highly educated native English speakers, because you unnecessarily use uncommon words and long convoluted sentences.

I have learned a very important lesson from my sister. If you want to convey an idea, and have people understand it, it's best to use everyday words, and short simple sentences.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You still have not told the readers international ones, and local ones in your country, what is Xenu.

Please tell people what is Xenu, since you bring up that word.

And don't take refuge in the excuse about my not getting the point whatever you are referring to, just answer the questions above.

Stating with telling people what is Xenu.

And all the other questions above.

Don't think even though your brain is not explicitly aware of it, that you are smart in taking refuge in the accusation that I don't get your point, what I ask you to do is tell people what is Xenu, and also to answer according to the best intelligence of your brain the other questions above.
So you don't know how to type down "Xenu" into Google?
Sad.
The rest of you here, if you want to save the time of readers and save the forum bandwidth, just also attend to the questions I direct here to bruto.
Why don't you start acting like a human being and actually answer other people's questions? You are not doing your cause any good.
 
Last edited:
Sigh. The founder of Scientology wrote that Xenu was an evil galactic dictator who brought billions of people in stasis to Earth millions of years ago and exterminated them with hydrogen bombs. Their surviving psychic essences (known as Thetans) supposedly cause psychological problems, which can only be effectively treated with Scientologist 'technology'.
 
If you are serious and intelligent and verbally skilled, you can use not more than a hundred words.


Then we can continue from that point onward in this thread on whether atheists are acting intelligently in embracing atheism or is atheism an intelligent worldview.
To this request I gave the following reply
I will answer this form of your question:
how the working brain of an atheist comes to not believing in God.

3 reasons:
1.) Through the observation and testing of our world, it is clear that there exist no known real processes, events and/or objects that require a god to explain their existence.
2.) The number of descriptions of god that do exist (e.g., Christian, Islamic, Hindu...) all contain multiple problems and contradictions with reality and themselves, serving only to complicate our universal understanding.
3.) The only description of god that does not have these inherent contradictions is the deist god, the god of non-involvement. Since the existence/non-existence of this god is functionally identical to my life, I assume it does not exist.
100 words.
Since this post, you've
made a post giving a vocabulary lesson.
If any international reader can't apprehend my English, just send me a pm or email me, you can get my email address from my profile link here.

made an evasive post
Now, please answer intelligently, and no tergiversation:
and made another evasive post.
The rest of you here, if you want to save the time of readers and save the forum bandwidth, just also attend to the questions I direct here to bruto.

I get the sense that you do not want to address my response. I propose that my argument demonstrates that it is fully possible to "intelligently embrace athiesm"

QED
 
Yrreg, plain English isn't about using big words, or long sentences, however grammatically correct they may be. It's about using words that ordinary people can understand without having to reaching for a dictionary.

I'd like to relate a quick story to you, in the hope that you might gain a little insight.

My cousin was raised to believe that he was the cleverest little boy in the whole world. His parents had made him read all sorts of classic literature, including philosophy, that very few children would have the vocabulary to even read, let alone understand. As a result, he was a pretentious little twonk. One year, around christmas time, my aunt and uncle had a party. My cousin, who was 14 at the time, was proudly announcing to a group of us that he had a logical proof that he was actually God. My sister (who was 16 and had left school that summer, with no qualifications, and had just started training as a hairdresser) wandered in, and asked what we were talking about, so my cousin proudly repeated his claim. "Go on then," said my sister, "tell us your proof." So my cousin did, using long words, and long complex sentences. My sister listened intently until he'd finished. She then asked about the meanings of some of the words he'd used, which he told her. Then, using short words, and short simple sentences, she tore his argument apart from the ground up. I am sure it was amongst the most humiliating experiences of his life.

My point is this - intelligence is not measured by the words you use, or the lengths of your sentences, or whether or not they are grammatically correct (my sister wouldn't know correct grammar if it smacked her in the head), but by the arguments you make.

If she were taking part in this debate the first thing she'd ask you would be, "What does tergiversate mean?" And having been given the definition she'd respond, "You mean evade? Why don't you ****ing say that you snobby ****?"

I should add that this is not meant as an attack on you, or your argument, but a note on your posting style. Reading your posts is difficult, even for highly educated native English speakers, because you unnecessarily use uncommon words and long convoluted sentences.

I have learned a very important lesson from my sister. If you want to convey an idea, and have people understand it, it's best to use everyday words, and short simple sentences.

Your sister sounds like a hoot (yes, fine, owl pun intended).

Another thing I've noticed is that people who genuinely have a masterful command of one or more languages manage to use a variety of words without being pretentious about it. If a familiar word is sufficient to convey an idea they will usually choose it over one that is obscure. And they will use a variety of words rather than repeat the same arcane term ad nauseam. And when they do use an abstruse phrase you can be damned sure that the sentence containing that word is impeccably constructed. People who repeat a single $25.00 word in a bunch of $3.00 sentences in an attempt to seem intellectually accomplished ain't foolin' nobody.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I get the sense that you do not want to address my response.

The problem is that you refuse to return the response that Gerry has planned for. I mean come on! He's been rehearsing this with his imaginary strawmen over and over and they never see the shrewd trap he's laid out for them. They fall into it every time. When he asks "is this your card?" you aren't supposed to point out that he's holding a bouquet of plastic flowers.
 
The problem is that you refuse to return the response that Gerry has planned for. I mean come on! He's been rehearsing this with his imaginary strawmen over and over and they never see the shrewd trap he's laid out for them. They fall into it every time. When he asks "is this your card?" you aren't supposed to point out that he's holding a bouquet of plastic flowers.

And wearing big shoes and funny makeup.
 
Suppose you tell us what is Xenu.


I have already time and again given my definition of God, here again in more plain English.

God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything.

You gave five objects of evidence for your argument, but you haven't explained how this proves an existence of god.
Now, please answer intelligently, and explain why your conclusion (In your mind) is the more intelligent one.

Do not use the tergiversation evasion tactic here


Evidence of anything is stored in your brain as a piece of accepted information? Yes No.

Any curious subject matter in My brain, after it's been proven by solid evidence, is accepted information.

But you don't have a piece of evidence on the existence of God in your brain? Yes No.

You need to clarify "piece of evidence on the existence of God" as to what evidence is acceptable and why.

And you want people who have evidence of God's existence in their brain to share with you their evidence? Yes No.

There's a jury here still waiting for you to make a solid case..so when are you going to start doing this?

I know what is evidence.

Can you present it here in the immediate future so you do not waste anymore of the reader's time and this forums' bandwidth?
 
I'd like to relate a quick story to you, in the hope that you might gain a little insight.

You are unbelievably optimistic. :)

I should add that this is not meant as an attack on you, or your argument, but a note on your posting style. Reading your posts is difficult, even for highly educated native English speakers, because you unnecessarily use uncommon words and long convoluted sentences.

And he uses those uncommon words in long convoluted sentences with terrible grammar. As mentioned before, it is for this reason that he isn't fooling anyone here.
 
You still have not told the readers international ones, and local ones in your country, what is Xenu.


Please tell people what is Xenu, since you bring up that word.



And don't take refuge in the excuse about my not getting the point whatever you are referring to, just answer the questions above.

Stating with telling people what is Xenu.


And all the other questions above.


Don't think even though your brain is not explicitly aware of it, that you are smart in taking refuge in the accusation that I don't get your point, what I ask you to do is tell people what is Xenu, and also to answer according to the best intelligence of your brain the other questions above.



The rest of you here, if you want to save the time of readers and save the forum bandwidth, just also attend to the questions I direct here to bruto.





Yrreg

Xenu is a preposterous and silly deity or something of the sort (it hardly really matters) , in the so-called religion of scientology. I see that you remain as ignorant of Xenu as the day you were born.

Unlike you, I do not consider your continuing failure to "know" Xenu as a failure of intelligence or as evidence of infantile naiveté, even though you are as much an a-scientologist now as you were when you were born. Because nothing in your life, your social background or your religious indoctrination has led you to perceive evidence of Xenu, your continuing disbelief is entirely sensible.

You really do miss my point, if you do not see that your utterly laughable attempt to frame the question of belief in your own idea of god as a matter of intelligence versus naiveté is just as absurd as it would be to suggest that ignorance of false gods, idols, demiurges and lies is simply a matter of naive ignorance.

Your trivial and arrogant attempt to reduce theology to an accusation that those who disagree with you are not using their brains well is an insult not only to intelligent atheists, but to other Christians who have used their own brains in pursuit of the truth with far greater effect than you have come even close to showing here, and who would never stoop to such sophomoric buffoonery as we've seen here.
 
Now that some here have given an account of what Xenu is....

Now that some here have given an account of what Xenu is, I want you to use your brain intelligently and answer this question:


Is that Xenu in the possession of the most essential attribute of the God that I know to exist outside my brain, and which my brain can intelligently arrive at a conclusion of, that He does exist?​


Here is again my definition of God:

Maker of heaven and earth and everything,​


Compare what you people write about Xenu and tell me is that the maker of heaven and earth and everything?


That is why I call you atheists tergiversators, because you know all the while that Xenu is not the maker of heaven and earth but you keep on psychologically equating Xenu with God, to the end of if nothing else, to obfuscate your brain.

That is a perversion of your brain.



All other points you are trying to make any issue of are just so many tergiversating gimmicks.

Why? Because you fail the very first distinction between God and Xenu, God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything, but Xenu?



Now, here is what you can do and must do if you want to emphasize that the point you are stressing is some commonality of identity between Xenu and God.


1. Don't use the word Xenu, because it is already a compromised word.

2. Use another name for what you want to compare God to, on the basis of their commonality of identity.

3. Try for example to formulate any name like say "Soeht", and define the name as maker of heaven and earth and everything.

4. Now, you can say that in your brain there is the lack of belief for God as for Soeht.
​

Otherwise, it is all tergiversations with your bringing in Xenu and flying spaghetti and whatever else you want to borrow from whatever sources your tergiversating heart and tergiversating perverted brain want to bring up.




For the rest of you who have brought up some honest and intelligent -- apparently intelligent insofar as worthy of a working brain in a sane and right-thinking human, I am studying your thoughts.





Yrreg
 
Looks like more yrregiversating.

Here is again my definition of God:

Maker of heaven and earth and everything,​

By the way, your definition of "God" is insufficient to me. (And selfcontradictory if taken at face value. Hint: Anything, such as makers, is by definition part of everything.)
 
Last edited:
Now that some here have given an account of what Xenu is, I want you to use your brain intelligently and answer this question:


Is that Xenu in the possession of the most essential attribute of the God that I know to exist outside my brain, and which my brain can intelligently arrive at a conclusion of, that He does exist?​


Here is again my definition of God:

Maker of heaven and earth and everything,​


Compare what you people write about Xenu and tell me is that the maker of heaven and earth and everything?


That is why I call you atheists tergiversators, because you know all the while that Xenu is not the maker of heaven and earth but you keep on psychologically equating Xenu with God, to the end of if nothing else, to obfuscate your brain.

That is a perversion of your brain.



All other points you are trying to make any issue of are just so many tergiversating gimmicks.

Why? Because you fail the very first distinction between God and Xenu, God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything, but Xenu?



Now, here is what you can do and must do if you want to emphasize that the point you are stressing is some commonality of identity between Xenu and God.


1. Don't use the word Xenu, because it is already a compromised word.

2. Use another name for what you want to compare God to, on the basis of their commonality of identity.

3. Try for example to formulate any name like say "Soeht", and define the name as maker of heaven and earth and everything.

4. Now, you can say that in your brain there is the lack of belief for God as for Soeht.
​

Otherwise, it is all tergiversations with your bringing in Xenu and flying spaghetti and whatever else you want to borrow from whatever sources your tergiversating heart and tergiversating perverted brain want to bring up.




For the rest of you who have brought up some honest and intelligent -- apparently intelligent insofar as worthy of a working brain in a sane and right-thinking human, I am studying your thoughts.





Yrreg

Since I do not accept the essential idea that you find requisite: that the universe is the creation of a deity, answering your question in the way you wish is difficult, if not impossible. I can certainly say that "in my brain" I have knowledge neither of what you claim God to be, nor of any other, arbitrarily reverse-named entity that might be claimed as the maker of "heaven earth and everything." I have yet to see convincing evidence that the universe is the intentional creation of any entity, and though I made a pretty good try in my youth, I cannot accept it on faith alone.

Although I have spoken and studied with many intelligent and thoughtful people who believe in God, and who believe that God is the creator of the universe, and even some who believe (as you appear to) that God makes his presence known directly without the use of the five senses, I have not ever met anyone who confused the experience of God with his definition.
 
Yrreg, the problem with your argument is that you argue from a standpoint that you "know" God exists, that the evidence is obvious, and that therefore anyone who says otherwise must be an idiot.

Unfortunately what you offer as evidence is scant, and proves precisely nothing. All of it has naturalistic explanations, which can be used to show that there is no need for a God, whatever you may believe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom