Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

You say:
No, babies don't need a working brain to have a lack of the knowledge of God.
​
You also mean thereby on implication that adult atheists who lack the knowledge of God's existence or lack belief in God don't need a working brain either to come to such a condition.
No. Having a lack of knowledge of god is not the same as lacking a belief in god.

I mean by implication that
adults' don't need a working brain to have a lack of knowledge of god.

That is why also I see atheists in embracing atheism to be not acting intelligently because they don't need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence or lack of belief in God.
This doesn't follow. You are defining intelligence by the conclusion that one draws. Intelligence is described by the process not the conclusion.

Example:
Statement 1: Since I had 2 apples, and you gave me 2 more apples, I now have 4.
Statement 2: I just pooped my pants, therefore I have 4 apples.

Statement 1 is intelligent. Statement 2 isn't.

You don't need a working brain to come to such a worldview.
False.
You need a working brain to have a worldview.
You do not need a brain to have a lack of knowledge.
These are two different concepts.
You also say:

Yes, babies need a working brain to determine that there is no such thing as god.
​
I assume also that you mean by implication adult atheists need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence or lack of belief in God.
NO. That isn't what I said.
By implication,
Adults atheists need a working brain to determine that there is no such thing as god.

Now, for the sake of readers here, just tell us how the working brain of an atheist comes to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence or lack of belief in God/

If you are serious and intelligent and verbally skilled, you can use not more than a hundred words.

I will answer this form of your question:
how the working brain of an atheist comes to not believing in God.

Through the observation and testing of our world, it is clear that there exists no known real processes, events and objects that require a god to explain their existance. The number of descriptions of god that do exist (e.g., christian, islamic, hindu...) all contain multiple problems and contradictions with reality and themselves, serving only to complicate our universal understanding. The only description of god that conforms with our understanding of the world is the diest god, a god of non involvement.

3 reasons:
1.) Through the observation and testing of our world, it is clear that there exist no known real processes, events and/or objects that require a god to explain their existence.
2.) The number of descriptions of god that do exist (e.g., Christian, Islamic, Hindu...) all contain multiple problems and contradictions with reality and themselves, serving only to complicate our universal understanding.
3.) The only description of god that does not have these inherent contradictions is the deist god, the god of non-involvement. Since the existence/non-existence of this god is functionally identical to my life, I assume it does not exist.
100 words.
 
A baby who is not indoctrinated in any way will not come to any God-conclusion. Therefore, the only path to belief in God is through indoctrination by others.

Most of us are indoctrinated from earliest childhood to believe in God. Only atheists demonstrate the intelligence to think for themselves and see through the indocrination.

Therefore, atheists are acting more intelligently by rejecting God than theists are by accepting God.

That's the final answer to your question, yrreg.
 
Absence of evidence in a brain is not evidence of absence.


Arguing to the absence of God on the absence of evidence in the brain of an atheist is not evidence of the absence of God except to the brain of the atheist not having the evidence of God in his brain.

The task then for the atheist is if he be sincerely seeking God to use his brain with more versatility and prolificity and thus attain to the evidence of God's existence.


In other words, he should use his brain better, i.e., more intelligently.




Yrreg

Yrreg, without the evidence for the existance of a thing means that you cannot say that that thing exists. All you can say that thing may exists.

To say that something exists with any level of certainty you have to have evidence for it's existance.

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. But absence of evidence certainy is no evidence for existance either.



Tell how you used your intelligence to arrive to the conclusion that god exists.
Please regale us with your superior "intelligence". Show us this evidence you have for the existance of god.


Go ahead, dazzel us.


Or are you going to tergiversate?
 
Last edited:
Its possible that yrreg is laughing his ass off with his buddies, showing them how he can make smart people jump through hoops, with very little effort.
 
Absence of evidence in a brain is not evidence of absence.


Arguing to the absence of God on the absence of evidence in the brain of an atheist is not evidence of the absence of God except to the brain of the atheist not having the evidence of God in his brain.

The task then for the atheist is if he be sincerely seeking God to use his brain with more versatility and prolificity and thus attain to the evidence of God's existence.

You speak as though you have found evidence of a god that exists. Perhaps you can show how you have arrived to this conclusion and present the evidence your brain has detected?
 
Last edited:
Here is an addition to your plain English vocabulary.

​


Do you really think that readers of this forum can not tell what you are attempting to do?

Also, please stop using that word [ tergiversation ]. When communicating with international audiences you may wish to write in a manner that considers the needs of the reader. See the Plain English movement.


​


[...]



Now read this, international audience and enrich your English vocabulary.

Yrreg said:
Yesterday (011809 Sun), 05:48 AM (local date and time) #427

http://www.randi.org/forumlive/showpost.php?p=4354829&postcount=427


Title of post: Just in case you don't know, here is your definition of TERGIVERSATION!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TERGIVERSATION


[ Bolding from Yrreg ]

If you’ve ever observed somebody wriggling and evasive, trying to avoid giving a straight answer to a straight question, then you have observed tergiversation in action. The Romans observed this phenomenon as often as we do, and already had the word for it, tergiversari, to turn one’s back, shuffle, or practise evasion, from tergum, back, and vertere, to turn. One of its English senses, in older dictionaries often given as the main one, is of a deserter from a party, a renegade or apostate. An example appeared in Blackwood’s Magazine in 1831: “ ‘I am liberal in my politics’, says some twenty-times tergiversated turncoat”. Dickens seems to be using it in the more modern sense in A Tale of Two Cities: “He knew ... that flight was impossible; that he was tied fast under the shadow of the axe; and that in spite of his utmost tergiversation and treachery in furtherance of the reigning terror, a word might bring it down upon him”. As those who tergiversate in either sense usually show similar symptoms of ducking and weaving, as John Barsad was doing in Dickens’ book, the link between the two senses is clear enough, and in fact it’s sometimes difficult to decide which sense was meant. The turncoat sense is still sometimes encountered, but the main one is now of someone trying to weasel out of an untenable position.
http://www.worldwidewords.org/weirdwords/ww-ter1.htm

[ Citation courtesy of Yrreg ]

​



Best regards to international readers and happy addition to your plain English vocabulary, I am one really most partisan in regard to plain English as in plain speech which tergiversation is an enemy to.

If any international reader can't apprehend my English, just send me a pm or email me, you can get my email address from my profile link here.



Yrreg
 
Now read this, international audience and enrich your English vocabulary.





Best regards to international readers and happy addition to your plain English vocabulary, I am one really most partisan in regard to plain English as in plain speech which tergiversation is an enemy to.

If any international reader can't apprehend my English, just send me a pm or email me, you can get my email address from my profile link here.



Yrreg

you mean comprehend, not apprehend.

And the above should be re-written:

Best regards to international readers and happy addition to your plain English vocabulary. (Full stop)

(But the next sentence I can't re-write, because it doesn't make enough sense for me to re-phrase it.)
 
Now read this, international audience and enrich your English vocabulary.
Now read this, yrreg, please stop being evasive. We've asked you serious and sincere questions. We've answered your questions honestly. Now please do the same.
 
If any international reader can't apprehend my English, just send me a pm or email me, you can get my email address from my profile link here.



Yrreg

Bolding by me.

Would someone please apprehend Yrreg's English!
 
Last edited:
If any international reader can't apprehend my English, just send me a pm or email me, you can get my email address from my profile link here.
I followed your request and answered your question in plain english with less than 100 words.

If anyone wishes to ask for a clarification of my point, I'd be happy to provide it. Please be honorable and provide the same courtesy I've shown you.


Note: When you wish to admonish others for poor vocabulary, it is best to make sure you are using words correctly.
 
If i wanted to believe what yrreg believes, what would I believe?

I predict he'll snap before 25 pages and become a devout atheist.
 
Let's not tergiversate but just be intelligent ane answer intelligently.

A person arrives at the "lack of knowledge" of God in exactly the way a person arrives at the "lack of knowledge" of Xenu. That is, in part, by determining that phrasing it in the way Yrreg has is extremely stupid.

41 words, now how about a reasonable response rather than your usual rubbish.


Suppose you tell us what is Xenu.


I have already time and again given my definition of God, here again in more plain English.

God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Now, please answer intelligently, and no tergiversation:


You have a brain? Yes No.

Evidence of anything is stored in your brain as a piece of accepted information? Yes No.

But you don't have a piece of evidence on the existence of God in your brain? Yes No.

And you want people who have evidence of God's existence in their brain to share with you their evidence? Yes No.


I know what is evidence.

Suppose you tell me:

1. What is evidence for you, and


2. How much is needed and sufficient for you to come to the acceptance of God in your brain.


Remember, you atheists are the ones harping on evidence all the time; so if anyone should know evidence you are the guys, tell us then what is evidence for you.

And how much is required by you and sufficient for you to come to the acceptance of God's existence.


For the rest of you, I have the impression very strong that you are into tergiversation.


That is why if ever I have the time and leisure I like to write a book that is very easy for people with skill in plain speech to know why I call atheists tergiversators.


Consider bruto above, he is again bringing in the tergiversating gambit of Xenu, when if he were to use his brain with versatility and prolificity* he should know that theists today have come to know God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything -- no matter what Xenu is supposed to be in the brains of Xenu's proponents.

Next they will bring up flying spaghetti, and that is why if I may be humorous atheists don't do anything with their brain except to stuff it with spaghetti for a storage, and think thereby that they are so smart.



Yrreg

*Versatility and prolificity, look up the standard English dictionary for the meanings of these two terms, if you still can't comprehend what is versatility and prolificity in a brain, then pm me or send me an email, and I will enlighten you.
 
Now read this, international audience and enrich your English vocabulary.

[quoted post containing definition]
Best regards to international readers and happy addition to your plain English vocabulary...


:wow2: You must have really missed the whole point of the Plain Language movement if you think re-posting the definition of the word makes everything so much easier for people to read.



If any international reader can't apprehend my English, just send me a pm or email me, you can get my email address from my profile link here.


How does that make your post simpler to read?


By the way, I posted this reply in your Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God? thread. In it, among other things, I addressed the word tergiversation.

I will reproduce the relevant section here:

You accuse atheists of tergiversation but this word has more than one meaning:

From 5 dictionaries:

1. To use evasions or ambiguities; equivocate. To be evasive or ambiguous. To be deliberately ambiguous or unclear in order to mislead or withhold information. Trying to avoid giving a straight answer to a straight question. Someone trying to weasel out of an untenable position. To be ambivalent or indecisive. To equivocate using subterfuge; to deliberately obfuscate.

2. To change sides; apostatize. To change sides or loyalties. Abandon one's beliefs or allegiances. A deserter from a party, a renegade or apostate. To reverse position, to apostatize, to go over to the other side. To abandon one's cause or party usually to join another.​


Don't you WANT the atheists to tergiversate? Don't you WANT them to reverse their position and abandon atheism? Don't you WANT them to desert atheism and join the other side?​

yrreg said:
God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything.
yrreg said:
Suppose you tell us what is Xenu.


Suppose you tell us what is heaven.
 
Consider bruto above, he is again bringing in the tergiversating gambit of Xenu,

It is untenable to claim that any evidence of God is also evidence of Xenu?

With your definition of God, "God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything," how is your God distinguishable from the big bang?

Tell me why your God, as defined by you, has any relevance to humanity, beyond a historical footnote?

Remember that any claim you make becomes part of the definition, for which you will have to provide additional evidence.

I eagerly await your answer, that I am certain will not be full of tergiversation about how atheists are evasive.
 
Consider bruto above, he is again bringing in the tergiversating gambit of Xenu, when if he were to use his brain with versatility and prolificity* he should know that theists today have come to know God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything -- no matter what Xenu is supposed to be in the brains of Xenu's proponents.

Yrreg

* is that where you live?

It must be exciting!
 
Suppose you tell us what is Xenu.


I have already time and again given my definition of God, here again in more plain English.

God is the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Now, please answer intelligently, and no tergiversation:


You have a brain? Yes No.

Evidence of anything is stored in your brain as a piece of accepted information? Yes No.

But you don't have a piece of evidence on the existence of God in your brain? Yes No.

And you want people who have evidence of God's existence in their brain to share with you their evidence? Yes No.


I know what is evidence.

Suppose you tell me:

1. What is evidence for you, and


2. How much is needed and sufficient for you to come to the acceptance of God in your brain.


Remember, you atheists are the ones harping on evidence all the time; so if anyone should know evidence you are the guys, tell us then what is evidence for you.

And how much is required by you and sufficient for you to come to the acceptance of God's existence.


For the rest of you, I have the impression very strong that you are into tergiversation.


That is why if ever I have the time and leisure I like to write a book that is very easy for people with skill in plain speech to know why I call atheists tergiversators.


Consider bruto above, he is again bringing in the tergiversating gambit of Xenu, when if he were to use his brain with versatility and prolificity* he should know that theists today have come to know God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything -- no matter what Xenu is supposed to be in the brains of Xenu's proponents.

Next they will bring up flying spaghetti, and that is why if I may be humorous atheists don't do anything with their brain except to stuff it with spaghetti for a storage, and think thereby that they are so smart.



Yrreg

*Versatility and prolificity, look up the standard English dictionary for the meanings of these two terms, if you still can't comprehend what is versatility and prolificity in a brain, then pm me or send me an email, and I will enlighten you.

It does not surprise me that you miss my point. It does not matter what or who Xenu is. I could name any nonsensical belief. The point - and the ONLY point I am making at this time is this: to equate rejection of an idea you have no evidence for, or no use for, with infantile lack of knowledge is a very very stupid argument. It is ridiculous. No matter how many times you re-state it or rephrase it, or how many dictionaries you consult. It's stupid.

Most of the intelligent theists I know and have known base their acceptance of God on faith, not on assumptions of direct experience, and also have the intelligence and discernment to realize that even if they do accept direct experience of God, they cannot have direct experience of the qualities they ascribe to him, such as his creation of the universe. This is a simple concept to grasp if you think about it, and would make you a more rational theist as well as a better representative for faith. It's unfortunate that you lack the ability to grasp this very simple idea.
 
Now read this, international audience and enrich your English vocabulary.
If they followed your standard, Gerry, their English would be an inedible bowl of word salad.

Best regards to international readers and happy addition to your plain English vocabulary, I am one really most partisan in regard to plain English as in plain speech which tergiversation is an enemy to.
"Tergiversation" is decidedly not plain English, and you are certainly militant in your quest to avoid speaking in plain English terms.

If any international reader can't apprehend my English, just send me a pm or email me, you can get my email address from my profile link here.
Yes, if anyone catches Gerry's english, please have it locked up for grammar abuse. There is a reward.

Seriously, highly fluent native speakers of English find it difficult to understand what you are saying, Gerry.

"Perfection is reached, not when there is no longer anything to add, but when there is no longer anything to take away."

Meditate upon that when crafting your next post.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom