Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

yrreg:

1. Are theists who have been indoctrinated into woo-think and unable to see truth when confronted with it acting intelligently?

2. Are theists who become atheists because they are able to see rational truth acting intelligently?

You may only choose one, yrreg. Don't tergiversate. I'll be back in 24 minutes for your answer. Don't spam the thread, don't flood the thread, don't depreciate non-depreciable items.
 
How does one "come to" a lack of knowledge?


Wouldn't it be better to ask if they would remain ignorant of [whatever]?


ETA: And the answer, I think, is yes, they would "remain ignorant" of a specific God, unless somehow informed of what God is.
If they arrive at any god-conclusion, the chances of it matching the God of the Bible (assuming they come to the god-conclusion entirely uncoached and uninfluenced) are infinitesimal.
 
Last edited:
Just answer the question first, then explain; othrwise it's all tergiversation.

It is not actually for you to say what is relevant Yrreg. I do not know why you find that so hard to grasp but it is true: discussion is not a one way thing.

I have not brought up anything I consider irrelevant. I do not think there is such a thing as a "lack of knowledge of God's existence" because that implies god exists. I do not think god exists. If you rephrase to say something like:

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's existence

or

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's non-existence.

then the phrases are comparable. As you have put it you are trying to smuggle the answer into the question and that won't do

So, what implication do you think you have led us to if not that?

If the baby comes to the conclusion there is not god, what then?


Atheists are the people who say that babies are born atheists, and that they atheists lack belief in God, and that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.


And they are the people who say that babies don't have the knowledge of God or the belief in God unless and until they are indoctrinated by other humans.


--------------------


This thread is about the question:

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview.


I bring up the first criterion of intelligence as the possession of a working brain.


So, my question is "Do babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge God's existence?


Answer that question this way:

Yes, babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.

Or

No, babies don't need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.


Then explain.​


Otherwise you are giving the impression of tergiversating.




Yrreg
 
Otherwise you are giving the impression of tergiversating.

I posted the definition of tergiversate earlier in this thread. You may want to take a look at it because it seems that after all this you don't actually know what it means.

Tergiversating IS NOT giving an answer that you don't expect.
Tergiversating IS NOT giving an answer that you don't want to hear.
Tergiversating IS NOT pointing out that you are posting a false dichotomy.

This is what happens when you try to use words that are beyond your comprehension. I once had an excellent English professor who would love you. Nothing annoyed him more than people using big, unnecessary words. 20 dollar words as they were called earlier in this thread. In fact, at the beginning of every class he would give us a fun little K.I.S.S. (keep it simple stupid) exercise. He had a common English phrase written on the board, but written using ridiculously fancy words and we had to translate it into actual English. Much like most of us have to do with your posts.
 
That is very good, now which use of brain is more intelligent.

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's existence

or

Using the brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.​




Yrreg

This question can be answered in many ways, but it can't be measured on an intelligence scale because of the unknown variables the person(s) has/have used to formulate their conclusion(s).
Be more specific Yrreg if you want a more specific evaluation.
 
Atheists are the people who say that babies are born atheists, and that they atheists lack belief in God, and that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.


And they are the people who say that babies don't have the knowledge of God or the belief in God unless and until they are indoctrinated by other humans.


--------------------


This thread is about the question:

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview.


I bring up the first criterion of intelligence as the possession of a working brain.


So, my question is "Do babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge God's existence?


Answer that question this way:

Yes, babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.

Or

No, babies don't need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.


Then explain.​


Otherwise you are giving the impression of tergiversating.




Yrreg

A fundamental error here: you cannot simply use the term "lack of knowledge" of something's existence to the conclusion that something does not exist. Do you simply "lack knowledge" of the existence of Xenu? Or do you, in fact, lack credible evidence that Xenu exists, and thus continue, as you have since the moment of your birth, not to believe in Xenu?

The fact that an intelligent, considered conclusion can be reached about the existence of something that happens to coincide with the condition of never having thought of it in the first place does not make the conclusion less intelligent.

Your ridiculous dichotomy could be applied to any false belief, any lie, and any delusion. It is, simply put, not a clever argument!

Seriously, Yrreg, do you consider your continued denial of the existence of Xenu to be an act of infantile ignorance? I am assuming here that you are not a scientologist, and do not believe the preposterous doctrine of which Xenu is an element. Why would it be a mistake to call your lack of knowledge of Xenu evidence that you have failed to use your brain intelligently?
 
yrreg, have you stopped beating your wife? There are only two possible answers:

Yes, I have stopped beating my wife.
No, I have not stopped beating my wife.

Anything else is tergiversating.
 
yrreg,
we are not avoiding your question.
we are not evading you.
we are not using semantic games.
we are not being tricky.

You've asked a loaded question. It has a false premise.

You cannot have a lack of knowledge in something that does not exist.


Please rephrase your question.
 
yrreg said:
Otherwise you are giving the impression of tergiversating.

I'm reminded of other sagacious verbosity:

Milhous said:
"I've used the phrase 'Jiminy Jillikers' so many times, it's lost all its meaning!"
 
Yes, the old wife beating trick.

I feel a bit feisty, so I'm willing to allow that an uninformed, isolated baby, might very well conclude that there was a God, or gods, or great spirit, etc.

Certainly said person would be less likely to believe in galaxies, having never studied astronomy. They would lean toward woo explanations, using their well developed brain, much as most of our ancestors did.

There is some something different in willfully ignoring what it is humans have collectively learned. Its not as intelligent as fabricating a mythology when you have no access to real data.

Another possibility is that God exists; some people come to know him through an unexplainable series of events, independently. Those whom haven't had that experience are essentially uninformed about the underlying big truth of everything; and some people that know the big truth feel compelled to spread the news; and some of them don't know how to write well or make an intelligent argument...which should have no bearing on the message.

I'm ready for the straight up message, if there is one.
I'd like to know what yrreg's getting on about.

(Hey, he knows how to keep a thread alive with nominal effort. That says something.)
 
You can explain afterwards, but first answer the questions.

You can explain afterwards, but first answer the questions.


Otherwise you are into tergiversations.


In the explanation you can elucidate all your reservations, qualifications, and corrections of the questions posed and the answers you give.


If you don't have the mental capability of answering first, then please don't write any messages here, because you are wasting readers' time and the forum's bandwidth.


Just answer the question first, then explain; otherwise it's all tergiversation.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Originally Posted by Fiona
It is not actually for you to say what is relevant Yrreg. I do not know why you find that so hard to grasp but it is true: discussion is not a one way thing.

I have not brought up anything I consider irrelevant. I do not think there is such a thing as a "lack of knowledge of God's existence" because that implies god exists. I do not think god exists. If you rephrase to say something like:

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's existence

or

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's non-existence.

then the phrases are comparable. As you have put it you are trying to smuggle the answer into the question and that won't do

So, what implication do you think you have led us to if not that?

If the baby comes to the conclusion there is not god, what then?​


Atheists are the people who say that babies are born atheists, and that they atheists lack belief in God, and that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.


And they are the people who say that babies don't have the knowledge of God or the belief in God unless and until they are indoctrinated by other humans.


--------------------


This thread is about the question:

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?
In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview.


I bring up the first criterion of intelligence as the possession of a working brain.


So, my question is "Do babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge God's existence?


Answer that question this way:

Yes, babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.

Or

No, babies don't need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.


Then explain.

Otherwise you are giving the impression of tergiversating.




Yrreg


So, what are you waiting for?



Yrreg
 
So, what are you waiting for?
For an honest question.

Here are more honest, alternative phrasings.

No, babies don't need a working brain to have a lack of the knowledge of God.

Yes, babies need a working brain to determine that there is no such thing as god.
 
All right. You will not give us an honest question and you will not understand that you have been answered honestly. So I will play your game in the hope that you might, just once, make an argument.

The question is:

Yes, babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.

Or

No, babies don't need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.

There is no such thing as a baby without a working brain: without a working brain it is not a baby: so the answer is yes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom