Just answer the question first, then explain; otherwise it's all tergiversation.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally Posted by Fiona
It is not actually for you to say what is relevant Yrreg. I do not know why you find that so hard to grasp but it is true: discussion is not a one way thing.
I have not brought up anything I consider irrelevant. I do not think there is such a thing as a "lack of knowledge of God's existence" because that implies god exists. I do not think god exists. If you rephrase to say something like:
Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's existence
or
Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's non-existence.
then the phrases are comparable. As you have put it you are trying to smuggle the answer into the question and that won't do
So, what implication do you think you have led us to if not that?
If the baby comes to the conclusion there is not god, what then?
Atheists are the people who say that babies are born atheists, and that they atheists lack belief in God, and that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.
And they are the people who say that babies don't have the knowledge of God or the belief in God unless and until they are indoctrinated by other humans.
--------------------
This thread is about the question:
Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?
In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview.
I bring up the first criterion of intelligence as the possession of a working brain.
So, my question is "Do babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge God's existence?
Answer that question this way:
Yes, babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.
Or
No, babies don't need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.
Then explain.
Otherwise you are giving the impression of tergiversating.
Yrreg