Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

How? Anyhow, the question is his intelligent use of his brain.


Read again my post, and answer my questions as you would answer them intelligently in an essay test on reading comprehension, where you cannot ask any questions of the guy watching that you don't do anything dishonest like copying from some texts surreptitiously brought in -- you are only allowed to bring with you your working brain, but paper as much as you need and ball pens are freely provided.




Please don't tergiversate and think that you are so smart.


Don't waste readers' time and this forum's bandwidth.




Yrreg
Again with the demands. Unaccompanied by any of the requested responses. Yawn. I won't answer any of your questions until you tell me which fictional character you are mad at.
 
If you are referring to atheism as a philosophical position, it is ridiculous to call a newborn baby an atheist.

Atheism isn't a philosophical position. You're thinking of (skeptic) naturalism.

If I was stuck on an unihabited island, with one other person,. and I got to choose between a foxy young female theist, or a crusty, old male atheist, like myself, I'd drop the atheist.

There is some shame in admitting this, right?

No. Any reasonably sane heterosexual person would take the opportunity to tell an attractive member of the opposite sex to "be fruitful and multiply. ;)

Do you sit on babies?

They call it babysitting for a reason.
 
The are the ones, atheists, who say that babies are born atheists.

Defining religion as the behavior of an infant is funny to me somehow, but not really persuasive, you know?
I also like the suggestion that atheism is an indoctrination, as if it is an extreme position rather than a natural one, it is hard to argue with that degree of blindness.
To answer your question: what do you mean embrace? It is not a religion.


Smackety, I have not read yet the posts coming after yours.

Someone might have a good message in answer to my questions, instead of tergiversating, among the posts coming after yours.

----------------

I just want to remind you that atheists keep saying that babies are born atheists, i.e., lacking belief in God, unless and until someone indoctrinates them.


And I am asking them about when babies just indoctrinate themselves with their working brain to come to the knowledge of God, have they been acting intelligently?

And to compare these babies with ones which have not indoctrinated themselves so that they lack belief in God, to see whether these latter babies are using their brain or not, i.e., acting intelligently.




Yrreg
 
...using their brain or not, i.e., acting intelligently
If you equate the two then - it's abso-bloody-lutely obvious that the answer to your inane questions is YES

Why, I wonder, do you expend so much bandwidth to convey so little information?
 
Babies using their brain to know God's existence are acting intelligent? Yes No.

Is someone who posts on an internet forum, who continually and habitually posts lines separated by blank lines rather than posting continuous paragraphs of line, acting intelligently?

The simple fact of the matter is that there are several ways of getting the message across yet there is a fundamental difference in those that are able to read the message and those that cannot.

Eg: Implicit and explicit atheism. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implicit_and_explicit_atheism Yrreg - I hope you see this because I think it answers your points about babies etc.

In essence a person or baby cannot have any understanding of either atheism or theism because they are incapable of understanding what the arguments or criteria are, however, therefore they are agnostic because they have no knowledge. Someone who has no knowledge cannot possibly believe therefore they must be atheist.


And if you read my posts carefully, I am telling or asking you that when babies use their brain to indoctrinate themselves to the knowledge of God's existence, are they acting intelligently or not.

Because atheists tell us that babies are born atheists, lacking belief in God, like also grown-ups who are atheists, i.e., lacking belief in God.


Here, in other words, two questions:


1. Can babies acting alone by the use of their brain -- without indoctrination from other humans -- come to the knowledge of God's existence?

2. Is that an intelligent use of their brain, are they acting intelligently in coming to the knowledge of God's existence?​

-------------------

That is what I have always noticed about atheists, they will bring in things but when they are brought to the implications of those things, they will tergiversate to not face up to the implications of the things they bring up, like for example, that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.



By the way the title of this thread is

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?




Yrreg
 
That is very good, now which use of brain is more intelligent?

If a person grows up all by themselves and comes up with either decision they will have used intelligence to form a conclusion.

Any more questions Yrreg?


That is very good, now which use of brain is more intelligent.

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's existence

or

Using the brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.​




Yrreg
 
That is very good, now which use of brain is more intelligent.

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's existence

or

Using the brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.​

Doesn't that rather depend on what the evidence is?
 
That is very good, now which use of brain is more intelligent.

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's existence

or

Using the brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.

Lovely use of language there. No trying to steer the answer is there?

Tell you what: how about you rephrase that just to satisfy me you are not biased?
 
And if you read my posts carefully, I am telling or asking you
This illustrates one of the many fundamental flaws in your approach to forum discussions: although you have no idea what you are thinking, you are under the mistaken assumption that your vacuous style somehow equates to a stimulating and worthwhile contribution

that when babies use their brain to indoctrinate themselves to the knowledge of God's existence, are they acting intelligently or not.
It seems that your level of understanding with regard to early childhood development is only surpassed by your debating skills

Because atheists tell us that babies are born atheists, lacking belief in God, like also grown-ups who are atheists, i.e., lacking belief in God.
Yes, yrreg... this point has been made so many times that what you are doing now is surely nothing more than spamming

Here, in other words, two questions:


1. Can babies acting alone by the use of their brain -- without indoctrination from other humans -- come to the knowledge of God's existence?​
Serious question: Why don't you ask one?

2. Is that an intelligent use of their brain, are they acting intelligently in coming to the knowledge of God's existence?

That is what I have always noticed about atheists,
What? That they can spot your confirmation bias a mile off?

they will bring in things but when they are brought to the implications of those things, they will tergiversate to not face up to the implications of the things they bring up, like for example, that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.
This is almost unintelligible waffle - the only message that I can decipher is that you don't want to accept the responses to your threads

By the way the title of this thread is

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?
Yeah... I know... we've established that a few times, haven't we?

Who here is derailing this thread with inane obfuscations?
 
Yrreg said:
they will bring in things but when they are brought to the implications of those things, they will tergiversate to not face up to the implications of the things they bring up, like for example, that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.

Ok I will assume for one mad moment that you are not a troll and not trying to preach nor to confuse; so what, in your opinion. is the implication you have brought us to? As is usual with you you have not stated anything

Babies are born atheist: that is they lack a belief in God. Babies do not grow up apart from other human beings normally: so they cannot be immune from influence one way or another. But assuming that they could: and assuming they grow up atheist, then what?
 
That is very good, now which use of brain is more intelligent.

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's existence

or

Using the brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.​




Yrreg
So basically you have presented us with a question of this form (you can plug in any subject here):

Is it better to use your brain to believe in fairies, or is it better not to think about fairies at all?

It kind of depends on whether the subject you use your brain to "come to the knowledge of" is true or not, doesn't it?
 
Babies need to be raised by someone... it doesn't seem that any baby is likely to come to any language based conclusions unless raised with humans who have language. The baby will tend to adopt the beliefs or lack of beliefs of his culture.

I suppose some primitive sort without any indoctrination can conclude that the sun is god or that dead relatives watch over them or any other such thing... and convince their fellow humans. But it's all beside the point as to atheists are "intelligent" in "embracing" (????) atheism.
 
Just answer the question, don't tergiversate.

[...]


Babies are born atheist: that is they lack a belief in God. Babies do not grow up apart from other human beings normally: so they cannot be immune from influence one way or another. But assuming that they could: and assuming they grow up atheist, then what?


Then answer the question:


When they use their brain, will they come to the knowledge of God's existence, or will they come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.​


In very concrete words:

Do babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence?​


And don't bring in so many things which are of no relevance to the thread:

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?





Yrreg
 
Yes.

Atheism is an intelligent worldview and atheists have higher I.Q.'s on average than their more religious peers.
 
It is not actually for you to say what is relevant Yrreg. I do not know why you find that so hard to grasp but it is true: discussion is not a one way thing.

I have not brought up anything I consider irrelevant. I do not think there is such a thing as a "lack of knowledge of God's existence" because that implies god exists. I do not think god exists. If you rephrase to say something like:

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's existence

or

Using the brain to come to the knowledge of God's non-existence.

then the phrases are comparable. As you have put it you are trying to smuggle the answer into the question and that won't do

So, what implication do you think you have led us to if not that?

If the baby comes to the conclusion there is not god, what then?
 
Last edited:
I wonder if Yrreg tells his pastor or priest or whatever about how he's working so hard to bring Jesus to the skeptics (or whatever it is that he imagines himself to be doing).

If another woo of another faith was doing this sort of semantic manipulation nonsense to him, do you think he'd get a clue as to how he's coming across to atheists?
 
Then answer the question:


When they use their brain, will they come to the knowledge of God's existence, or will they come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence.​


In very concrete words:

Do babies need a working brain to come to the lack of the knowledge of God's existence?​


And don't bring in so many things which are of no relevance to the thread:

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?





Yrreg

Gerry, we know that you think you are being terribly clever and that you are leading us into a trap. We know because it is pathetically obvious and not clever in the least.

Let me ask you this: Do babies need a working brain to come to the lack of knowledge of Buddhism?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom