If I was stuck on an unihabited island, with one other person,. and I got to choose between a foxy young female theist, or a crusty, old male atheist, like myself, I'd drop the atheist.
There is some shame in admitting this, right?
Why would there be?
The "god question" may be the most important thing in a philosophical sense, but as a practical matter it isn't that critical. I don't even know the theological beliefs of many of my friends.
Stranded on a desert island, there are a whole bunch of traits, social, intellectual, and aesthetic, that are more important in a companion.