Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

If I was stuck on an unihabited island, with one other person,. and I got to choose between a foxy young female theist, or a crusty, old male atheist, like myself, I'd drop the atheist.

There is some shame in admitting this, right?

Why would there be?

The "god question" may be the most important thing in a philosophical sense, but as a practical matter it isn't that critical. I don't even know the theological beliefs of many of my friends.

Stranded on a desert island, there are a whole bunch of traits, social, intellectual, and aesthetic, that are more important in a companion.
 
By the way, yrreg, the reason your threads get so convoluted is not because the atheists here are "tergiversating." It's because you insist on playing games rather than just stating an argument.

How yrreg expects his threads to go:

yrreg: Do you agree with X?
Atheists: Why, yes, of course we do.
yrreg: Do you agree with Y?
Atheists: Sure.
yrreg: Do you agree with Z?
Atheists: Uh, I guess so.
yrreg: HA! HA! GOTCHA! If X and Y and Z, then God exists and atheists are poopyheads!

How yrreg's threads actually go:

yrreg: Do you agree with X?
Atheists: Well, no, actually.
yrreg: Stop tergiversating!

Stop thinking that you're so much more clever than us and will "trap" us into something. If you're looking for an honest exchange of ideas, then just state you whole argument. Or, if you insist on doing the step-by-step routine, then expect it to take a while, and don't complain about people disagreeing with the premises of your argument.
 
Yrreg, if you look at the actual history of mankind, the fact that people tend toward religion looks to me like a dead end for your purposes.

What use is it for the Christian point of view to point out that people naturally tend to become religious, when the history of mankind shows that that natural tendency has resulted in an incompatible assortment of monotheists, idolaters, pantheists, buddhists, sun-worshippers, and so on?

Even if you conclude that the god you worship is the only truth, and even if you are right in doing so, and even if you are right and others here are wrong, that your religion is the best, most rational choice available, you know perfectly well that that truth came to you from teaching and preaching, not some innate wisdom. You can apply all sorts of theological arguments, logic, research, and meditation to that teaching afterwards, to justify it, strengthen it, prove it or improve it, but it's wishful thinking and self-deception to reverse-engineer your faith and pretend that you'd have come to it through mere intelligence anyway. To suggest that is not only to insult others here, but to credit yourself with much much more intelligence than we have yet seen evidence for.
 
By the way, yrreg, the reason your threads get so convoluted is not because the atheists here are "tergiversating." It's because you insist on playing games rather than just stating an argument.

How yrreg expects his threads to go:

yrreg: Do you agree with X?
Atheists: Why, yes, of course we do.
yrreg: Do you agree with Y?
Atheists: Sure.
yrreg: Do you agree with Z?
Atheists: Uh, I guess so.
yrreg: HA! HA! GOTCHA! If X and Y and Z, then God exists and atheists are poopyheads!

How yrreg's threads actually go:

yrreg: Do you agree with X?
Atheists: Well, no, actually.
yrreg: Stop tergiversating!

Stop thinking that you're so much more clever than us and will "trap" us into something. If you're looking for an honest exchange of ideas, then just state you whole argument. Or, if you insist on doing the step-by-step routine, then expect it to take a while, and don't complain about people disagreeing with the premises of your argument.

That is a good description of what is going on. The sad part is he thinks we don't get what he is doing. I doubt he has ever met a person face-to-face that really is a non-believer. If he did he would be confronted by positions that deify his self constructed stereotypes.

His ultimate failure is that he cannot get that his arguments fail at the first premise, thus rendering the conclusions irrelevant. The end result is that he learns nothing and we only learn what his bias is.

Marcus Aurelius once said that where there is no controversy, there is no advance in truth. In the case of Yerrg, we cannot even start to argue because even the premise of his arguments cannot be agreed upon. If he ever drops his a horrendously bad assumptions, a meaningful dialog may happen. Until then, it is just an unending stream of BS from somebody who cannot even identify his own crap, let alone anyone else's.
 
Last edited:
How yrreg's threads actually go:

yrreg: Do you agree with X?
Atheists: Well, no, actually.
yrreg: Stop tergiversating!

Stop thinking that you're so much more clever than us and will "trap" us into something. If you're looking for an honest exchange of ideas, then just state you whole argument. Or, if you insist on doing the step-by-step routine, then expect it to take a while, and don't complain about people disagreeing with the premises of your argument.

And this is how it will continue because all of us can see where Yrreg is going with this argument. Now, his only defense is that we are tergiversating.

Move on to your next point Yrreg! (If you have any)
 
Last edited:
The topic of this thread is

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, "Is atheism an intelligent worldview?"
Why did you ask yrreg? My hunch is that you, rather than wanting answers, merely want to assert more of your woo

Please, prove me wrong

Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself
that God exists, by the use of his brain.
<snip/>
that God does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?
If you have a point to make, I suggest that you quit farting around and, instead, simply make it
 
What if the baby thinks the sun is god? Is he acting intelligently?

What if the baby comes to the conclusion that good things are do to invisible sprites... is he acting intelligently?

What if he concludes that his dead ancestors are god watching over him... is she acting intelligently?

Yrreg... your leading questions are going nowhere.

Humans evolved to look for meaning and agency and reasons-- but they tend to plug in the first answer that comes to them... not the right answer. It seems humans would rather believe a lie that feel the discomfort of not knowing much of the time. Fortunately we have opportunities to learn what generations past could not... although some people have their minds hobbled by faith.
 
Anyone remember when yrreg started using the word tergiversate? I wonder if it was approximately on November 14, 2008.

http://www.yourdictionary.com/wotd/tergiversate

Because I'm certain he either got it from a word of the day calendar or a fortune cookie. I'll have to do a search on his posts to find out when this began. I'll return to this thread in 24 hours. ;)
 
If I was stuck on an unihabited island, with one other person,. and I got to choose between a foxy young female theist, or a crusty, old male atheist, like myself, I'd drop the atheist.

I'd choose the one who was better at catching fish and climbing trees.
 
Anyone remember when yrreg started using the word tergiversate? I wonder if it was approximately on November 14, 2008.

http://www.yourdictionary.com/wotd/tergiversate

Because I'm certain he either got it from a word of the day calendar or a fortune cookie. I'll have to do a search on his posts to find out when this began. I'll return to this thread in 24 hours. ;)
My candidate would be this post, a couple of weeks later.
 
Here's how to answer an essay type test on reading and writing intelligently.
1. Read carefully the question topic given.
​


2. Answer the question directly as to give the main and essential thrust of your answers to the particular questions presented.

3. Explain your answers but briefly.
​
And read again whether you might be tergiverating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.

In which case, go through the procedure again as to avoid tergiversating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.


I will be back later in the evening.




Yrreg

At least we are moving forward, although I'm tempted to ask the question "Is yrreg acting intelligently when proceeding so inefficiently in a debate?"

To the questions, however:

1) Q: Is a baby who, as he grows up, embraces either religion or atheism due to indoctrination doing this as an act of intelligence?
A : Not necessarily. If he adopts his position purely as a response to indoctrination then, no. (This might be debated, but I rest it here for the purpose of this discussion).

2) Q: Is a baby who, as he grows up, embraces either religion or atheism based on his own thought processes, and the evidence available to him, doing this as an act of intelligence?
A: Yes. The process of reaching an abstract position based on evidence and thought processes is an act of intelligence, under any useful definition of 'intelligence'.

Note that I'm not bothering to discuss the possible connotations from the term 'embrace'. I don't consider it to make any important difference, in this case.

Next question?

Hans
 
Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God exists, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?


Now, suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?

It is impossible to answer this question without further information. You're trying to make it a black-or-white scenario when it clearly isn't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom