Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

See? readers here, they atheists here are as always tergiversating.
I didn't avoid your question.*
I answered this.

The intelligent use of his brain isn't measured by the answer but by the process that the answer was derived. It is the only way to distinguish between a logical intelligent answer and a lucky guess.
Now, please don't avoid my answer.



*why use a 20 dollar word, when a 2 dollar word is clearer? Especially in today's economy.
 
See? readers here, they atheists here are as always tergiversating.


Just in case atheists don't know what is to tergiversate, just look up that word in five good standard well-patronized English dictionaries.




Yrreg

Now your just wasting us readers' time and this forum's bandwidth. If you have a point to make, why don't you get right to it instead of tergiversating?
 
Last edited:
Babies are born atheists.
Technically, yes, but it is a worthless distinction. Squids are born atheists. Zygotes are atheist. Rocks are atheists when formed.

If you are referring to atheism as a philosophical position, it is ridiculous to call a newborn baby an atheist.
 
Here's how to answer an essay type test on reading and writing intelligently.

Here's how to answer an essay type test on reading and writing intelligently.

1. Read carefully the question topic given.​

yrreg said:
I like to ask you if you subscribe to the statement time and again made by atheists that babies are born atheists.

Next, you do subscribe to the statement that atheists simply lack belief in God?


I seem to get the impression that atheists give themselves the credit of intelligence in the formulation of those two statements.


Let's focus on the first statement:

Babies are born atheists.



Yrreg


You all seem to agree among yourselves that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.

I see that some bring up the matter of indoctrination, saying that babies are born atheists unless or until they are indoctrinated in the belief in God.


The topic of this thread is

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, "Is atheism an intelligent worldview?"


Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God exists, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?


Now, suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?





Yrreg



2. Answer the question directly as to give the main and essential thrust of your answers to the particular questions presented.

3. Explain your answers but briefly.​


And read again whether you might be tergiverating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.

In which case, go through the procedure again as to avoid tergiversating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.


I will be back later in the evening.




Yrreg
 
Here's how to answer an essay type test on reading and writing intelligently.
1. Read carefully the question topic given.
​


2. Answer the question directly as to give the main and essential thrust of your answers to the particular questions presented.

3. Explain your answers but briefly.
​
And read again whether you might be tergiverating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.

In which case, go through the procedure again as to avoid tergiversating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.


I will be back later in the evening.




Yrreg
I have twice.

Bravo! These are great questions, yrreg.
The answer to both of your questions depends upon HOW the person came to those conclusions and not the conclusions themselves.

Your person could be atheist/thiest for intelligent or unintelligent reasons. It all depends on the person in question.

If the person says,
God makes the sun appear in the sky every day to provide light. Why else would the sun appear in the sky? That would be reasonable, as he is unaware of the valid heliocentric solar system model.

If he was to say, god makes leaf-doodoo pie and therefore god loves me. Well, that would be just crazy jibberish.
I answered this.

The intelligent use of his brain isn't measured by the answer but by the process that the answer was derived. It is the only way to distinguish between a logical intelligent answer and a lucky guess.
now answer mine.

I didn't avoid your question.*

Now, please don't avoid my answer.
 
2. Answer the question directly as to give the main and essential thrust of your answers to the particular questions presented.

3. Explain your answers but briefly.​


And read again whether you might be tergiverating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.

In which case, go through the procedure again as to avoid tergiversating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.


I will be back later in the evening.




Yrreg

That is exactly what we did. Deal with it.

ETA: No reasonable person, believer on non-believer is likely to give you a different answer. So lets save some bandwidth here. Save us all some time and tell us what answer you wanted to hear.
 
Last edited:
Here's how to answer an essay type test on reading and writing intelligently.

1. Read carefully the question topic given.​





2. Answer the question directly as to give the main and essential thrust of your answers to the particular questions presented.

3. Explain your answers but briefly.​


And read again whether you might be tergiverating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.

In which case, go through the procedure again as to avoid tergiversating and wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.


I will be back later in the evening.




Yrreg

Defining religion as the behavior of an infant is funny to me somehow, but not really persuasive, you know?
I also like the suggestion that atheism is an indoctrination, as if it is an extreme position rather than a natural one, it is hard to argue with that degree of blindness.
To answer your question: what do you mean embrace? It is not a religion.
 
That is exactly what we did. Deal with it.

ETA: No reasonable person, believer on non-believer is likely to give you a different answer. So lets save some bandwidth here. Save us all some time and tell us what answer you wanted to hear.

I'm almost certain that he wants to prove that Atheists are stupid, and unintellectual for rejecting god. Look jat the big words he's using. He MUST be smarter than all of us.. right?
 
Are theists acting intelligently when they blindly follow whatever their religious leaders tell them without questioning or thinking for themselves?
 
You all seem to agree among yourselves that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.

I see that some bring up the matter of indoctrination, saying that babies are born atheists unless or until they are indoctrinated in the belief in God.


The topic of this thread is

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, "Is atheism an intelligent worldview?"


Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God exists, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?


Now, suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?





Yrreg
Is someone who posts on an internet forum, who continually and habitually posts lines separated by blank lines rather than posting continuous paragraphs of line, acting intelligently?

The simple fact of the matter is that there are several ways of getting the message across yet there is a fundamental difference in those that are able to read the message and those that cannot.

Eg: Implicit and explicit atheism. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implicit_and_explicit_atheism Yrreg - I hope you see this because I think it answers your points about babies etc.

In essence a person or baby cannot have any understanding of either atheism or theism because they are incapable of understanding what the arguments or criteria are, however, therefore they are agnostic because they have no knowledge. Someone who has no knowledge cannot possibly believe therefore they must be atheist.
 
I'm almost certain that he wants to prove that Atheists are stupid, and unintellectual for rejecting god. Look jat the big words he's using. He MUST be smarter than all of us.. right?

Lord help yrreg if he loses his thesarus.

yep. yrreg's line of argument is pretty transparent. Don't expect much from yrreg's argument if his/her "false trichotomy" is any indication.
 
If a person grows up all by themselves and comes up with either decision they will have used intelligence to form a conclusion.

Any more questions Yrreg?
 
Many athiests I know started out as thiests. When asked about what made them change thier beliefs, thier answer usually started out as " I started thinking about....."

Personally, I was raised roman catholic. I was even an altar boy at one time (no molestation as far as I know) My conversion to agnosticisim began when I started to think about and ask questions about my beliefs. My growing interest in science started me on that road.
 
See? readers here, they atheists here are as always tergiversating.

Gerry, the attempt to represent yourself as being possessed of lingual sophistication with the use of the word "tergiversate" ad nauseam is belied by your exceptionally poor grammar.

Did you read the script I posted from the comedy sketch about the guy who perpetually says "ascertain"? If you could only get that joke you would comprehend why you have become a joke to the members of this forum.
 
Crap.

I'm starting to dislike God and No-God equally.
Soon i won't even want to make an argument.

I hate when that happens.

If I was stuck on an unihabited island, with one other person,. and I got to choose between a foxy young female theist, or a crusty, old male atheist, like myself, I'd drop the atheist.

There is some shame in admitting this, right?
 
In answer to Yrreg's question.

I think that a baby growing up without any indoctrination might well come to the conclusion that there is a god, or gods, but only because it has no access to the prior knowledge that science provides. That's what has happened to mankind as the centuries have passed, each generation builds on the knowledge of their forebears, and our knowledge continues to increase. One consequence of this has been to push god into the background, from a living entity, involved in the everyday lives of its followers, to a deist god, who set the Universe in motion and sat back to watch. Ignoring the mechanical nature of the Universe is naive in the extreme.

A world-view based solely on the reasoning and observations of an individual isolated from the rest of humanity from birth is likely to be filled with misconceptions and errors, however intelligent that individual might be.
 
Crap.

I'm starting to dislike God and No-God equally.
Soon i won't even want to make an argument.

I hate when that happens.

If I was stuck on an unihabited island, with one other person,. and I got to choose between a foxy young female theist, or a crusty, old male atheist, like myself, I'd drop the atheist.

There is some shame in admitting this, right?
Not at all. My wife is a Catholic and she's a cutie.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom