Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

quarky,

Yes, however when you consider that

1.) Religious beliefs seem to be based in human nature. The need to believe in something bigger than themselves to enable themselves to trust their parents, and to integrate into a society

That is a very serious over-generalization. It can be argued that religious beliefs are based on observation of matter organization toward a purpose leading to the inference of a guiding planning mind. All religionists have this as a basis.


2.) Believe in Paranormal and Religion originates in the fact that a false-positive is less dangerous as a false negative. A person nearly sees someone get killed by an animal -- prior to that there was russelling in the trees. The person sees a russling in the trees they decide to operate under the principle that there might be an animal there (if they decided to believe there was nothing there and there was -- they'd be killed). This ultimately evolves into a confirmation bias...

That's fallacious reasoning-agreed. But again, that does not necessarily account for the basic reason why people believe in an ID.

3.) Many religious experiences such as NDE's can be duplicated at least to some extent using hallucinogens including DiMethylTryptamine which can be produced by the Pineal Gland which is in the brain and is also linked to the visuals in dreams. It can also be produced by other body tissues.

Agreed. Yet again that doesn't eliminate the basic reason for belief in an ID

4.) Feedback loops appear to eliminate any magical or supernatural, or quantum explanation behind consciousness. It seems to enable the job to be done simply with the brain and associated neuro-transmitters.

Remember, whatever observations you or any other human who is neurally hardwired as you are must interpret what is perceived in accordance with that hardwiring. That makes any claim to omniscience unjustified since we are limited to what we can perceive and what we can perceive is of necessity subjective.

These pieces of evidence are basically all I need to say there's no God or any Afterlife. Do I like it? No. It is the truth though, so I accept it.

It is YOUR personal truth as you choose to see it. Is it a convenient personal-truth? Perhaps. Is it a logically-based personal-truth? I don't think so.
 
Last edited:
No, I don't think it can.
It can be argued... just not very convincingly

INRM said:
1.) Religious beliefs seem to be based in human nature. The need to believe in something bigger than themselves to enable themselves to trust their parents, and to integrate into a society
That is a very serious over-generalization. It can be argued that religious beliefs are based on observation of matter organization toward a purpose leading to the inference of a guiding planning mind. All religionists have this as a basis.
To me, INRM's point is relevant to a discussion that asks if 'atheists are acting intelligently in embracing atheism' insofar as it recognises that we humans are, like all 'pack animals', subject to group-think - community/clan/etc enhancing rules (aka morals and ethics), whereas Radrook's point isn't a point at all - instead it's a blunt, delusion-enforcing, irrelevant, banal, inane, flawed attempt at obfuscation
 
Last edited:
That is a very serious over-generalization. It can be argued that religious beliefs are based on observation of matter organization toward a purpose leading to the inference of a guiding planning mind. All religionists have this as a basis.

It could be argued... but that doesn't make the argument valid. As for your last quote, I'd say that all religionists have such a "bias"-- not a basis.

That's fallacious reasoning-agreed. But again, that does not necessarily account for the basic reason why people believe in an ID.

He didn't claim it did. But so far there doesn't seem to be any logical basis behind any religion's creation story--not even yours.

Agreed. Yet again that doesn't eliminate the basic reason for belief in an ID

The basic reason for believing in ID, is the same reason people once believed the earth to be flat... it seems true, and if the people you trust are telling you it's true, it takes critical thinking to understand why it's not. But faith discourages critical thinking while elevating subjective means of "knowing".

Remember, whatever observations you or any other human who is neurally hardwired as you are must interpret what is perceived in accordance with that hardwiring. That makes any claim to omniscience unjustified since we are limited to what we can perceive and what we can perceive is of necessity subjective.

The atheist doesn't claim omniscience... in fact the atheist doesn't make a claim to "divine knowledge" or "divine truths". That tends to be the providence of religionists. They claim to know things about invisible immeasurable entities that no one can kno wanything about--and they feel good for "believing in" such things. They are the ones "embracing" a belief or faith based notion. People don't really "embrace" the myriad of woo they don't subscribe too. God woo is the same as Truther woo unless there's evidence to show otherwise. It's a misinterpretation of the facts at best... that's why there are so many versions of it, while there is only one objective reality.

It is YOUR personal truth as you choose to see it. Is it a convenient personal-truth? Perhaps. Is it a logically-based personal-truth? I don't think so.

There is no such thing as "personal truths"--though religionists get fuzzy here. There are personal opinions, beliefs, ideals, ethics, thoughts, preferences, notions, etc. But the truth is the same for everybody regardless of what they believe. The earth was a sphere long before humans evolved... and creatures were evolving long before humans figured out that we arose from them.
 
Last edited:
That is a very serious over-generalization. It can be argued that religious beliefs are based on observation of matter organization toward a purpose leading to the inference of a guiding planning mind. All religionists have this as a basis.

But again, that does not necessarily account for the basic reason why people believe in an ID.
People believe in ID out of ignorance of science.
Science has shown that a creator is not needed to explain life. This doesn't mean there is/isn't a creator, but simply shows the evidence arguing for a creator does not exist.
 
Indeed. Radrook believes because he has been indoctrinated to believe-- he feels noble for believing whatever it is he believes and fears losing faith. No amount of evidence would change his mind. And yet any real god worth believing in would know exactly what kind of evidence was needed to verify his existence and compel belief in his magical goodness. If there was a god, it seems obscene for him not to have been clear or done so. It's would also be twisted to let so many people fervently believe patently untrue things about him as surely the vast majority do if any single one religion's claims are true. And yet all religionists they are the ones "chosen" to have the true inner knowingness about the invisible man in the sky.
 
I never said atheism is a belief? I'm saying that the majority of atheists present themself as an atheist instead of what they believe in. And I think that is wrong.
OK... first of all why and then how do you suggest I stop being 'wrong' in your eyes?

Please note: It is only in 'philosophical' discussions that I use the term atheist to describe myself and - in such discussions - I make a conscious effort to refrain from employing the term belief to describe concepts that I regard as true or highly probable, preferring instead the terms know and think and understand, etc

I know that six times seven is forty two
but I ain't, philosophically, a decimal mathematist​
I think that the 60 second, 60 minute, 24 hour clock is an efficient an effective 'tool' for measuring time
but I ain't, philosophically, a base-60 chronist​
I understand that radians are an efficient an effective 'tool' for measuring angles
but I ain't, philosophically, a 180/π trigonist​
 
yrreg:

I agree that babies are born lacking a belief - or even an awareness - of any divine supernatural entity. Likewise, animals, plants, and sub-life lack belief or awareness of divine supernatural entities.

Belief in God requires indoctrination and a lack or suspension of critical thinking skills. We're taught from early childhood to accept what our superiors tell us unquestioningly, while we're only introduced to critical thinking at laters stages of life, once the religious brainwashing is already well in effect. If left free of the indoctrination factors of family, church, and community, I suspect any infant raised to adulthood and trained from early childhood in the arts of critical thinking would never accept a deity-concept. An infant's mind is unformed and uneducated. The average adult mind is formed, but only barely educated. It takes a more advanced and/or specific education to recognize the flaws in faith, and to reject faith for more concrete reasoning.

As such, I believe that atheists are acting more intelligently in rejecting theism than theists are in embracing theism.
 
What if I told you that I am an atheist only because I view atheism to be more conducive to my long term goals and desires?

What if I told you that I am more interested in what benefits me than in what is true and embrace atheism because of that?

As a rational creature, is that not the definition of intelligence -- making decisions according to which result will benefit me the most?
 
Yes. Babies lack belief in God.

Does that mean that Atheists are just like babies? Ooohhhh.. I see what you're doing there.
 
yrreg:

I agree that babies are born lacking a belief - or even an awareness - of any divine supernatural entity. Likewise, animals, plants, and sub-life lack belief or awareness of divine supernatural entities.

Belief in God requires indoctrination and a lack or suspension of critical thinking skills. We're taught from early childhood to accept what our superiors tell us unquestioningly, while we're only introduced to critical thinking at laters stages of life, once the religious brainwashing is already well in effect. If left free of the indoctrination factors of family, church, and community, I suspect any infant raised to adulthood and trained from early childhood in the arts of critical thinking would never accept a deity-concept. An infant's mind is unformed and uneducated. The average adult mind is formed, but only barely educated. It takes a more advanced and/or specific education to recognize the flaws in faith, and to reject faith for more concrete reasoning.

As such, I believe that atheists are acting more intelligently in rejecting theism than theists are in embracing theism.

Excellent response, Z. Too bad it will likely be ignored by yyreg...
 
Well, that would depend on the frequency of the pretentious wanking.

And judging from yrreg's posts I'd say he/she should be pretty sore by now.
I've heard that pretentious wanking could make your insight go blind.
 
Last edited:
Yrreg, your Atheist threads have become boring and repeticious.

Could you go back to not understanding buddhism for a bit? Or maybe another belief, such as hinduism or Wicca.

You know, I've never seen an ignorant anti Shinto tirade before. What do you say to that as a change of pace?
 
Last edited:
I've heard that pretentious wanking could make blind your insight.

Wich would lead you to believe that baby Jesus would cry too!


Hey! I wonder, was baby Jesus an athiest? I know that if there was a god, it would be athiest too. God wouldn't believe in a god would it? I mean god had no creator so god would not believe in a higher being than himself so therefore god would be an athiest.

Nice to be in such great company as an athiest.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom