Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Something to bear in mind with posters from other countries is how different their experiences can be. In the USA it is hard to get past 'You don't believe in God? Aren't you afraid of going to hell?'. In some other countries you're presumed atheist unless you indicate otherwise, in those countries it would be understandable if atheists focused more on what they are rather than what they're not. Perhaps this is the case with BB's country. Or maybe the language problem is that he's from Minnesota.
 
Yes mister, you are right. The religious movements in my country (norway) is very passive, and there are noone pushing this down your throat. I think the biggest difference is peoples relationship with religion. There are no fundamentalists so on, just alot of 'atheist' liberalists who think the, excuse my expression, ILLNESS of religion is as agressive in our country as it is in, let's say USA.

And with this as premiss, I would say I wanted to be critic towards atheism, not because it's my very own opinion, but because it's in MY nature to be a oppisition towards every belief, because I think every opinion needs to be challenged.

I was trying to explain my train of thought here, but I obviously tracked off, and for that I'm sorry! Some very kind words here motivated me to try again some other time, thanks guys very friendly of you :)
 
It's unforgiveable in my eyes, as I think it's every humanbeings obligation to find their own truth. Mocking someones belief without ever having one yourself is, in this context, very hipocrisy.
cj.23 is both a theist and poster on this forum. I am an atheist and he and I disagree about many things. I afford him respect because he is willing to engage me in discussion and is willing to respect my views and opinions while challenging those positions.

The ability to form an opinion is not a valid reason to be respected. On the contrary, many opinions should be mocked (see those who use metaphysical claims to prey on others).

If yrreg truly wants respect then he needs to learn some social skills and treat others in a manner that he would like to be treated.
 
Last edited:
Godless Dave:

Because I think it's our obligation to cease something bigger than ourself. To break free from the subliminal massconformities, and the mind-forged manacles. To live your own way, and live happy with understanding and wonder.

A man who sacrifieses knowledge for happines, deserves neither.

. Very sorry for making this more Off Topic!
 
Last edited:
Godless Dave:

Because I think it's our obligation to cease something bigger than ourself. To break free from the subliminal massconformities, the mind-forged manacles. To live your own way, and live happy with understanding and wonder.
Fine with me but what does that have to do with anything?

A man who sacrifieses knowledge for happines, deserves neither.
Keep your day job. No one is suggesting that anyone sacrifice knowledge for happiness or for that matter, happiness for knowledge. Nor do we demand conformity.

Most posters here I know only want people to make informed choices while employing skepticism and critical thinking.
 
If you are asking me why I think it's every humans obligation to find the truth, well then my answer is subjective, and cannot be explained further. Some things just cannot be expl ained, assuming you realized this, I wanted to give my personal opinion on the matter.

What are you really asking about mate?
 
Your personal opinion seems to involve a view of atheism that no one actually holds. You clearly haven't read many of the opinions of people here, but you want us to accept your rather bizarre and incoherent straw man.

I don't agree that every human has "an obligation to find the truth", but I do think that humans owe it to themselves and others to understand as many true things as possible and believe as few false things. I see no evidence that there are any divine truths or that any supernatural explanations are real... I see that people who believe in such things tend to be less able to understand actual factual knowledge as it is learned. It doesn't make sense to believe in invisible entities for which there is no evidence whatsoever-- whether you call that entity God, Satan, Xenu, a guardian angel, or a wormhole incubus. Sometimes, it's even dangerous. I think it's dangerous to encourage anyone to imagine they are getting divine knowledge from beyond--who knows what the voices in their head they think of as god will tell them next. Fly into the trade center? Refuse a blood transfusion? Kill a witch? Spread bigotry about atheists?

I think it's bizarre to conclude that it's honest or truthful or noble to believe in such things. I find such beliefs self-aggrandizing, childish, incoherent, and stupefying. They certainly have nothing to do with anything I recognize as "truth".

bbq-- you have insulted others here without knowing them at all in order to build up your own opinion about your own viewpoint. And then you ask questions showing that you think everyone else is out of line when they don't show your opinion any more respect than you have shown theirs.

Why would you expect people to respect your opinion, when it's rather insulting of a number of people and you haven't even bothered to read anyone else to understand why you are basing your opinion on a straw man-- a belief about atheists that don't really seem to fit any atheists here.

I don't think faith is ennobling in anyway, and I don't think believing in incoherent concepts or invisible entities is anything to feel proud of. I also don't think anyone "embraces" atheism any more than they embrace the other things they don't believe in. I feel the same way about gods that I feel about demons and sprites and spirits... I don't believe consciousness can exist without a material brain because I see no evidence of such and lots of evidence that people are easily fooled in this area. But I don't embrace my disbelief in these things-- I just don't believe. I don't claim to "know"-- but I also recognize that if I can't know that some invisible undetectable entity is real, than neither can anyone else.
 
Last edited:
Yes mister, you are right. The religious movements in my country (norway) is very passive, and there are noone pushing this down your throat. I think the biggest difference is peoples relationship with religion. There are no fundamentalists so on, just alot of 'atheist' liberalists who think the, excuse my expression, ILLNESS of religion is as agressive in our country as it is in, let's say USA.

This isn't entirely true (But it can certainly seem that way in everyday life, so I'm not accusing you of telling a lie here). Norway certainly has its share of fundies, and some of them really do want to push it down our throats. It's just that overall, they simply don't have the same sphere of influence. Most of the time, it's the moderates that gets to have a say in the media (like bishop Gunnar Stålsett).

But the fundies are there. Everyone with a satelite dish* has sooner or later zapped past stuff like "verdikanalen" (translation: The Value Channel), and of course, it was a fairly well-known fundie priest (the one who runs one of those tv networks) who once tried to report to the cops that a tv show co-host was burning the American flag on prime-time television. (Can't really remember what law this was supposedly against, but just in case anyone's worrying: The cops just shut the case.)

But, at the same time, it's important to note that even most Norwegian fundies are more about being "leave us alone, you godless heathens" and staying within their own, fairly closed (not amish-closed) societies.

At least, that's my impression from living here.

And with this as premiss, I would say I wanted to be critic towards atheism, not because it's my very own opinion, but because it's in MY nature to be a oppisition towards every belief, because I think every opinion needs to be challenged.

I was trying to explain my train of thought here, but I obviously tracked off, and for that I'm sorry! Some very kind words here motivated me to try again some other time, thanks guys very friendly of you :)

By all means, if you want a real discussion (unlike yrreg), then do go ahead! If you think it's problematic with getting your thoughts down on digital paper properly, I could maybe give you a little help in translating? As you have probably gathered, I'm also a Norwegian, but I consider myself to know English as well as I know Norwegian. (Of course, then you have to wonder how well I know Norwegian in the first place. :D)


*Sat dishes are far more common in Norway, and without the redneck stigma that it seems to have in the US. Main reason for this is probably that cable wasn't a real option for quite a bit longer. And many places, sat dishes are still the main (and indeed only) choice if you want more than a handful of channels.
 
I am no theist? I am as much atheist as you are, altho I dont represent myself as one when I present my veiws.

I find this very frustrating, because every time I read what I write, it comes out wrong. And I hate to blame language or anything, but I would like to withdraw from this discussion. You can say I dont have anything to back what I mean up etc, dont mind :)

you guys seems like a bright bunch, love to see you discuss, rock on.
You're doing well, despite the language barrier. You've been attacked in this thread for expressing your opinion, and while it may have been badly expressed, you shouldn't let it discourage you. Keep lurking, look around a number of threads, and as someone else has mentioned, keep an eye out for cj.23. He's one of the most interesting theists here.
 
Representing one's self as atheist merely states something in which you don't believe. It doesn't indicate closemindedness. That would require additional statements, such as a declaration that no evidence would make you change your mind.

I like that. Though it could be problematic to change one's mind should evidence appear. There could be an investment in not-believing that could blind an atheist to god, should he show up.

Isn't that sort of what theists are suffering, regarding ignoring evidence?

Replacing God with 'flying saucers' illustrates this point.
Do you 'believe' or not-believe in flying saucers?

Well, I've never seen one, and don't care much about the subject.
I'm fairly certain people lie about them, and I'm tainted by the whack-jobs.

But to not believe in flying saucers seems unnecessary.
One would nearly have to look away if some ever appeared.
 
I like that. Though it could be problematic to change one's mind should evidence appear. There could be an investment in not-believing that could blind an atheist to god, should he show up.

Which is why No True Atheist puts sugar on his porridge.

Isn't that sort of what theists are suffering, regarding ignoring evidence?

Sort of. Kind of. Sometimes. Maybe.

Replacing God with 'flying saucers' illustrates this point.
Do you 'believe' or not-believe in flying saucers?

I think they are possible, but I have never seen one. I realize if they do exist, and do come here, they may be of a nature I will not recognize, or one I may mistake for something else.

Well, I've never seen one, and don't care much about the subject.
I'm fairly certain people lie about them, and I'm tainted by the whack-jobs.

I don't spend my time looking for them, but I have examined previous evidence presented, and none of that was proven to be extra-terrestrial, although some of it remains unidentified.

But to not believe in flying saucers seems unnecessary.

It's not necessary. It's just one opinion I hold.

One would nearly have to look away if some ever appeared.

That's my definition of "closed-minded," not open.
 
If you are asking me why I think it's every humans obligation to find the truth, well then my answer is subjective, and cannot be explained further. Some things just cannot be expl ained, assuming you realized this, I wanted to give my personal opinion on the matter.

What are you really asking about mate?
Who are you directing the question to?

If me then this is a non-sequitur. I've no idea what obligations anyone has and I don't really care. If you think so then fine. I'm happy with your opinion but please understand that I was giving you mine.

Welcome to the jungle.
 
Last edited:
Babies are born artheists... and atheists simply lack belief in God...

[...]

Yrreg said:
Just choose, one or two or all three of the following:

1. Atheists have no working brain.

2. Atheists' brain lacks belief in God.

3. Atheists' brain is still in the state of babies' brain.​


Atheists lack belief in God.



I like to ask you if you subscribe to the statement time and again made by atheists that babies are born atheists.

Next, you do subscribe to the statement that atheists simply lack belief in God?


I seem to get the impression that atheists give themselves the credit of intelligence in the formulation of those two statements.


Let's focus on the first statement:

Babies are born atheists.​




Yrreg
 
Babies are born atheists.
Yes. I agree with this statement. Unless you can demonstrate to me that babies believe in God, then newborn babies are atheists.

To your other point, that atheists lack belief in God, this is also true - but it is more or less misleading because there are many shades of atheism, some of which adopt stronger language. But all of them have in common the lack of belief in God.
 
Last edited:
Now we're getting somewhere. I can feel it. The momentum is building. I'm so excited... I shiver with anticipation.
 
I like to ask you if you subscribe to the statement time and again made by atheists that babies are born atheists.

Babies are born atheist.

Next, you do subscribe to the statement that atheists simply lack belief in God?

Atheists simply lack belief in God.

I seem to get the impression that atheists give themselves the credit of intelligence in the formulation of those two statements.

To restate: Babies are born simply lacking belief in God.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom