Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Indeed. It takes indoctrination to make children believe that an invisible entity is watching over them and doing magical things... and further indoctrination to feel virtuous for holding such a belief.

Children have no reason to distrust the authority figures in their lives nor do they have the ability to separate a belief from a fact. They tend to accept whatever those authority figures claim as truth.

It was the conflict between the scientific claim that the earth was a sphere and my indoctrination about hell being "down" and heaven being "up" that gave me my first inkling that not all claims from the adults I trusted were equally trustworthy. Santa was my second clue.
 
I like to ask you if you subscribe to the statement time and again made by atheists that babies are born atheists.
Yes
Next, you do subscribe to the statement that atheists simply lack belief in God?
Yes

I seem to get the impression that atheists give themselves the credit of intelligence in the formulation of those two statements.
I've really no idea what you mean by that. Could you restate it another way?


Let's focus on the first statement:

Babies are born atheists.​
Ok, I've got my reading glasses on, I'm focusing... Now what?
 
Last edited:
That is not my point, my point is that you should think of an alternative reason and by that label yourself, instead of calling yourself an atheist, wich is basicly directed to theism. I think everyone should make up their minds as for what THEY believe, and how we came to be. Most atheists replace any alternative beliefs with "atheism" and that is unforgivable!

What in the blue hell are you talking about ? "Atheism" is a LACK of belief.

Atheism is not more intelligent than religious if you look at the big picture

Which "big picture" is that ?
 
*snip*
Let's focus on the first statement:
Babies are born atheists.
​


Yrreg
Affirmative. This is verifiable. Since babies grow up and adopt any or no religion based on their upbringing it follows that they are born atheists. Otherwise, a large proportion of babies would be in opposition to the teaching they receive.

Hans
 
Actually, you did.

In that context, belief and believe is not the same thing. If you want to bend words, you can say that "you believe there is no god", on the same level as "I dont believe", and this is why they use the word belief in religious contexts.

Although I want to blame my crappy formulated english in that statement.
 
In that context, belief and believe is not the same thing. If you want to bend words, you can say that "you believe there is no god", on the same level as "I dont believe", and this is why they use the word belief in religious contexts.

Although I want to blame my crappy formulated english in that statement.


Nope, not trying to bend your words, I was trying to understand them. In the previous post referred to, I had asked if you think that theists are open-minded, since you had said that atheists are close-minded. That's what I was hoping for an answer to.
 
But then your comment becomes meaningless... how can we can we make the stuff we don't believe in a higher priority than what others do believe in-- whether we're talking god, astrology, or the IPU?

There's lots of things we don't know about and lots of proposed invisible entities and supernatural forces that we can't detect-- that doesn't mean it isn't smart to dismiss such claims until or unless evidence becomes available. Not all magical stories are equally likely... and as far as I can tell, no claims of divine truths or invisible entities have any evidence in support of them. Why should we respect those who "believe in" such things? They are believing in such things due to indoctrination... not critical thinking or examination of evidence. How is that different than being delusional and why is it something to respect? I mean, you can respect it all you want, but I don't.
 
I'm saying that the majority of atheists present themself as an atheist instead of what they believe in. And I think that is wrong.

Again, what in the blue hell are you talking about ? I also present myself as an animal, a man, a person, a heterosexual, amongst other things. What does that have to do with anything else ? I'm an atheist because I don't believe in gods. That has nothing to do with any other belief or lack thereof that I might hold.

In that context, belief and believe is not the same thing.

Hilarious.

The picture of something we dont know for certain.

Such as ?
 
To say that babies are born atheistic is a bit misleading.
I see them as agnostics; the lot.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom