Are antioxidants woo?

And no one has ever claimed it did. Flagging up the harm drug companies can do does not mean you're invalidating medical science.

Oh, look what I've found: First, you market the disease... then you push the pills to treat it - Brendan I Koerner on the ugly truth about doctors, PR firms and drug companies

Criticizing the failings of such is just as important as criticizing things like homeopathy. More so if they do more damage.

Provided you are simply pointing out the bad apples, rather than calling from high "Look at that rotten bunch of apples"

TAM:)
 
Provided you are simply pointing out the bad apples, rather than calling from high "Look at that rotten bunch of apples"

TAM:)

Yes, I agree. I can't imagine anyone wanting to go back to the time before medical science really got going. Mankind is much, much better off because of it, or at least those with access to it.

Actually there are people who oppose it, like some "healers" who are influential in their third world communities, who think their power and influence will wane if people start seeking the aid of modern healthcare facilities that have been set up for them. Modern health clinics have sometimes failed in some areas of poverty, partly because of malicious campaigns to discredit them carried out by people who see their own power and business ebbing away as a result.
 
Yes, I agree. I can't imagine anyone wanting to go back to the time before medical science really got going. Mankind is much, much better off because of it, or at least those with access to it.

Actually there are people who oppose it, like some "healers" who are influential in their third world communities, who think their power and influence will wane if people start seeking the aid of modern healthcare facilities that have been set up for them. Modern health clinics have sometimes failed in some areas of poverty, partly because of malicious campaigns to discredit them carried out by people who see their own power and business ebbing away as a result.

Access is whole different issue. Here in Canada access is universal, however timely access is poor as a result.

I will say this.

Here in Canada, if you need an emergency CT scan or MRI, you get it. The wait lists that everyone complains about here are for routine appointments and tests.

TAM:)
 
Same here. But waiting lists can still mean people are in chronic pain or suffering a debilitating condition for some time; and while they are, the temptation to visit alternative practitioners will be heightened.

My comment about some self-serving community "healers" in the third world spreading malicious propaganda to stop people going to modern health clinics was not one about access, but one about one way in which alternative practice can succeed at the expense of modern healthcare.
 
I don't live in the most sophisticated place on earth. In my world, I know lots more people that are having trouble with legal, prescribed drugs, than those that are having supplement woes. And the supplements are much cheaper

Some people turn to woo to get off the nightmare of xanax, valium, ambien, trazadone, synthetic opiates with crap-loads of tylenol, etc, etc. They didn't start out woo.
They were straight up failed by modern medicine.

They are also failed by woo, but its not as bad as a crappy drug problem, and you don't have to have a doctor's appointment to get the 'stuff'.

Crud, maybe its only where I live. I better 'google' legal drug woes, to see if its pervasive.
 
I don't live in the most sophisticated place on earth. In my world, I know lots more people that are having trouble with legal, prescribed drugs, than those that are having supplement woes. And the supplements are much cheaper

Some people turn to woo to get off the nightmare of xanax, valium, ambien, trazadone, synthetic opiates with crap-loads of tylenol, etc, etc. They didn't start out woo.
They were straight up failed by modern medicine.

They are also failed by woo, but its not as bad as a crappy drug problem, and you don't have to have a doctor's appointment to get the 'stuff'.

Crud, maybe its only where I live. I better 'google' legal drug woes, to see if its pervasive.

I see where you are coming from.

As a health professional, let me give you my opinion on what you have said...

1. No doubt, the drugs you have mentioned, are problems. I deal with those meds, their side effects, and even more importantly, the dependence on them that patients suffer. Most of my patients never get those meds, from me, for that reason.

2. Those drugs, prescribed judiciously, and with proper instruction on their LIMITED use, can help people who are in desperate situations. So can various forms of non medicinal therapies.

3. The issue is not with the "troubles" people are having with supplements versus traditional medicines. In fact, I would expect from a side effect and addiction potential pov, for people to do better with "supplements" versus traditional medicines precisely because of the reasons why I have trouble with them...they are, for the most part, harmless BUT ALSO USELESS vitamins, minerals, and other food stuffs. The reason many "conventional" medicines have side effects, and other issues (such as addiction) is because they ACTUALLY WORK. They do what they say they will do, but sometimes, for some people, at a price.

4. I really despise the use of the word "failed" here. That implies, no success. In most cases, there is some success, but not complete healing or recovery. If you want to find out how much modern medicine has failed a chronic pain patient, tell them to stop all of their pain meds, and then ask them what their pain levels are like? Not everyone of course, but most of them will laugh at the very thought of stopping their meds. Despite still having pain, they know that the pain would be much more horrible without their meds...trust me, I have dealt with many such cases.

5. Often times it is the expectations people have of modern medicine to make everything better, to have a cure for all, that is too high. This where the snake oil salesmen really rot me, because the expectations that the public has for them is nil...if it works, great, if not, oh well...move on...right?

Anyway, that is a bit of a rant, but you get my point(s) right?

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom