Are antioxidants woo?

Is this woo too?

How often does this happen?
More dangerous and even more woo:
BBC News said:
Secret filming revealed homeopaths were claiming their preparations could be used instead of anti-malarial drugs to protect travellers in high risk areas such as sub-saharan Africa.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/newsnight/5178122.stm

Homeopaths that I've met say many of their patients come to them in despair after years of ineffective mainstream medical treatment.
So what?
Do homeopaths actually offer something instead of water and ripping off people in actual need?
Does the failure of modern medicine make their magic claims true?
 
If you can make 10% of the population feel better, shouldn't you do that?
Or, shouldn't it be understandable that some people would feel justified in doing that?
No. It is not justified to lie to people and offer them false hope.
Do you apply the same standards to doctors?
"Oh Mrs. Smith, you don't have terminal cancer. You have many many years of life and not the 1 month that we originally thought. Drink some magic juice. Everything will be alright."
As far as I know, woo is rarely forced down someone's throat.
The same people that are inclined to bite the woo-bait are the same group that have the best chance of getting the bogus/not so bogus buzz from their twisted belief system.
No. Much of woo is disguised as valid modern science. Many homeopaths and other woo practitioners claim to be scientifically valid just as these magic fruit juice vendors claim some sort of "study" as evidence of their magic juice's powers. Casual shoppers will believe this.

But, as I've mentioned, there are a lot of people for whom 'alternative' medicine is the only alternative...they simply can't afford the 'good' stuff.
So? For some diabetics, they are unable to afford insulin therefore the "alternative" stuff is somehow justified?

If we ever manage to come up with a global health care system, the woo will fall off, like dead leaves in autumn.
Not likely. See the woo in Canada, the UK, France and Germany.
 
I suspect so - I think it's desperation that drives a lot of this belief in faith healing and this search for alternative cures. People are attracted to such things to some extent because they haven't received satisfaction from conventional medicine, whether that be because the medical advances that could really help them just haven't been made yet, whether they can't afford them or whatever.

I'm pretty sure this isn't really an important input. Mostly because in Canada, medical care is available without charge, although some people have to cover prescriptions. Nevertheless, healthfraud thrives here, and is quite the export industry.

I believe the origins are multiple, but can't help but notice that the most successful quackery promotes itself as ordinary scientific findings, and when asked why doctors don't agree, they use a variety of emotional appeals: The products are too new. The products threaten big pharma's profit margin and doctors are either sincere and misled by big pharma's advertising campaigns or co-conspirators in suppression of the new product.

There is also a pervasive anti-science culture, with emotional appeals. eg: "Do you want chemicals in your body? Or do you want to take healthy supplements instead?"

Just to give you an example from the last week here at my work... the employer offered free flu vaccine to employees. An RN visited each facility across the country and gave injections all day. Some employee who is a naturopath wrote the executive vice president of human resources a screed about how the company was now willfully poisoning its staff. The naturopath recommended a 'safe' alternative. Now, in addition to the vaccine, all employees have the option of getting a 'homeopathic' vaccine either instead of - or in addition to - the conventional vaccine. Here's what we were offered as a 'homeopathic flu vaccine': [PASCOLEUCYN®]

I didn't want to be hostile, but when I mentioned to a coworker that this was clearly not homeopathic, she got very angry with me. The homeopath also offered take-home kits for $10 each. My coworker bought ten of these, and is going to inject her extended family with this over the weekend.

My observation was that about half of the employees chose to get vaccinated at all, and about half of those chose the conventional vaccine, and just over half chose the homeopathic vaccine, and there was some overlap group that had both.



My belief at this time is that the level of healthfraud in a country is dependent on the strength of anti-healthfraud legislation and its enforcement. Companies continue to sell antioxidants because there is demand for antioxidants, and this demand is fuelled by advertising which falsely educates the customer that this stuff works. It has never been shown that antioxidants are beneficial, and all advertising saying so has been fraudulent. But nobody's ever enforced it, and the supplement manufacturers learned quickly that in this industry fibbing is very profitable and free of consequences. They hired lobbyists to keep things this way, and this is why we're in the state we're in.
 
Last edited:

I don't pay much attention to homeopathy debates but whenever I do this one example is being recyled along with the AIDS stuff. Is there anything else?



Read what I was responding to to find out.


Do homeopaths actually offer something instead of water and ripping off people in actual need?

Time, caring attention and being human.

Does the failure of modern medicine make their magic claims true?

No, I never claimed it did. Calm down! Have a cup of herb tea!

I was curious as to whether sanguine's anti-woo is itself woo woo woo.
 
Last edited:
I don't pay much attention to homeopathy debates but whenever I do this one example is being recyled along with the AIDS stuff. Is there anything else?
Why do I need anything else?

Read what I was responding to to find out.
I did. Homeopaths do divert patients from proper medical care.
Time, caring attention and being human.
...and doctors don't do that?
Is that justification for homeopathy's ineffective magic juice? If you don't have anything that works or people pay out of pocket, you sure have to spend a lot of time on your patients.
No, I never claimed it did. Calm down! Have a cup of herb tea!
Sure seems like you were:
Homeopaths that I've met say many of their patients come to them in despair after years of ineffective mainstream medical treatment.
Herbal tea sucks. I prefer a good green tea and some oolong on occasion.
I was curious as to whether sanguine's anti-woo is itself woo woo woo.
Is being anti-woo because woo practitioners are harmful woo to you?
 
Is that justification for homeopathy's ineffective magic juice?

No, it was an answer to your question.

Sure seems like you were:

It probably seemed like that because it wasn't black, white or a declaration of war.

Is being anti-woo because woo practitioners are harmful woo to you?

Sorry, too many woos. Incomprehensible.
 
Last edited:
Being anti-woo is like being pro-woo, because woo thrives on being anti anti-woo.
Some people seek woo because science dicks hurt their feelings.

woo is colorful, no matter how much you hate it. Woosters have fun doing woo stuff with their woo friends. And they always know some skeptic that's a dick, and his wife even hates him, and it smells so nice at the crystal store.

If we ever get past woo, will have to invent some.
It helps motivate skeptics.
 
(yes, I know it kills and robs people. The degree to which that is so is often exagerated on this forum. Its like a zit on a fat scientist.)
 
yes, that's what I was after. sorry about the poor wording.

Sorry Quarky, I misread you.

No, I do not have any stats to back up my comment, but I felt my comment was general enough as to not warrant it.

Perhaps studies will say that it is more prevalent in the USA compared to Canada...all I know is it is way too godamn prevalent here, regardless of its state in the USA.

TAM:)
 
(yes, I know it kills and robs people. The degree to which that is so is often exagerated on this forum. Its like a zit on a fat scientist.)

So it's OK to rob and kill people as long as you don't do it very much.

If people in general were more skeptical, more logical and thought more, not only would they avoid being killed and defrauded by woosters, they might make more reasoned choices in all sorts of other areas.
 
Yes.

At least according to the Cochrane Collaboration.


And according to The American Heart Association.



And most recently, according to the WAFACS study.



So, why are we focusing all our energy on homeopaths? Why aren't we going after Pom, Emergen-C, and all the other "health drinks" which cost a fortune and do nothing?

Just curious.
I certainly go after the supplements for colds and flu woo on a regular basis. And I think we address the supplement industry on the whole as woo the same way we address homeopathy. My take on our group is that there are many sub-group interests from bad medicine, anti-vaxers, homeopaths, CTers, to psychics, and so on.

The antioxidants are merely a small subset of the supplement woo.
 
So it's OK to rob and kill people as long as you don't do it very much.

If people in general were more skeptical, more logical and thought more, not only would they avoid being killed and defrauded by woosters, they might make more reasoned choices in all sorts of other areas.

Non-woosters make all manner of bad decisions. It is quite possible to be a scientist with a horrible diet. The woo of anti-oxidants is small; the price is low; the negative effects are nominal.

I'm seemingly defending woo (again) which is bizarre for me, because my role in my real world is the opposite.

My "horse" in this race is more about exposing the fundamentalism that anti-woo is prone to. Its too arrogant for my tastes. Especially in light of some of the failings of the anti-magic approach.

Its significant to recognize some of the failings of science; not the method, but the end product. Woosters know about the Love canal, and they see it as the heavy hand of science, whether or not that is justified. Science has a way of poisoning us, even if it also knows the anecdote.
 
e.

My "horse" in this race is more about exposing the fundamentalism that anti-woo is prone to. Its too arrogant for my tastes. Especially in light of some of the failings of the anti-magic approach.

The anti-wooers certainly seem to get a big hit every time they say woo.

It's ugly.
 
Non-woosters make all manner of bad decisions. It is quite possible to be a scientist with a horrible diet. The woo of anti-oxidants is small; the price is low; the negative effects are nominal.

I'm seemingly defending woo (again) which is bizarre for me, because my role in my real world is the opposite.

My "horse" in this race is more about exposing the fundamentalism that anti-woo is prone to. Its too arrogant for my tastes. Especially in light of some of the failings of the anti-magic approach.

Its significant to recognize some of the failings of science; not the method, but the end product. Woosters know about the Love canal, and they see it as the heavy hand of science, whether or not that is justified. Science has a way of poisoning us, even if it also knows the anecdote.

You make my point exactly. It wasn't science that produced the Love canal incident, it was woolly minded people who irrationally decided to build on a known toxic waste dump.
 
Must... resist... posting in YET ANOTHER anti-antioxidant thread....

Damn, I failed again.

Why, oh why dear JESUS LORD OF THE HEAVENS everyone has to judge the efficacy of the anti-oxidants by whether they reduce mortality ? And why are ALL antioxidants grouped together as if they were not completely different substances with a multitude of properties ?

There is this great site which until recently was kept secret by Buddhist monks but recently they have decided to share it with the Western World: www.pubmed.com People can go there and search for specific antioxidants and see which claims are substantiated and which are not.

Sorry I lapsed again.

Wrong. None of those studies was specifically about mortality. Infact, the Cochrane report effectively proved that NONE of the stated benefits of the class of chemicals known as "antioxidants" was met by ANY antioxidants.

Sorry, but you've utterly failed to provide any evidence at all. Pointing me at a library and saying "there is proof of aliens there" doesn't prove anything. Give us a specific antioxidant which fulfills its claims, preferrably with documentation of said proof.

I certainly go after the supplements for colds and flu woo on a regular basis. And I think we address the supplement industry on the whole as woo the same way we address homeopathy. My take on our group is that there are many sub-group interests from bad medicine, anti-vaxers, homeopaths, CTers, to psychics, and so on.

The antioxidants are merely a small subset of the supplement woo.

Agreed. Point made and taken. Antioxidants are merely the current strain of supplement woo.
 
If we ever manage to come up with a global health care system, the woo will fall off, like dead leaves in autumn.

I disagree. Plenty of very wealthy people fall for the stupid stuff. The woo will not fall off. We must cut it off.
 
The trouble is when trials take place and drug companies hide some of the data. For instance:


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/panorama/3454873.stm
You are absolutely right and it is completely unacceptable.

The main difference between real medicine and woo is there are no doctors ignoring the new evidence, claiming that such trials are inappropriate to that particular drug or say there was one trail that disputes the findings so they'll carry on regardless.

Deception is unacceptable, mistakes are regrettable but to do as the woo will do, to ignore or deny the evidence to continue the deception and compound the mistake is unspeakably low.

"When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?" Keynes.
 
This kind of tomfoolery doesn't invalidate medical science as a whole. Homeopathy as a whole is a waste of time. We know it does not work. Some people doing medical science incorrectly does not invalidate the approach when applied properly.

And no one has ever claimed it did. Flagging up the harm drug companies can do does not mean you're invalidating medical science.

Oh, look what I've found: First, you market the disease... then you push the pills to treat it - Brendan I Koerner on the ugly truth about doctors, PR firms and drug companies

Criticizing the failings of such is just as important as criticizing things like homeopathy. More so if they do more damage.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom