I suspect so - I think it's desperation that drives a lot of this belief in faith healing and this search for alternative cures. People are attracted to such things to some extent because they haven't received satisfaction from conventional medicine, whether that be because the medical advances that could really help them just haven't been made yet, whether they can't afford them or whatever.
I'm pretty sure this isn't really an important input. Mostly because in Canada, medical care is available without charge, although some people have to cover prescriptions. Nevertheless, healthfraud thrives here, and is quite the export industry.
I believe the origins are multiple, but can't help but notice that the most successful quackery promotes itself as ordinary scientific findings, and when asked why doctors don't agree, they use a variety of emotional appeals: The products are too new. The products threaten big pharma's profit margin and doctors are either sincere and misled by big pharma's advertising campaigns or co-conspirators in suppression of the new product.
There is also a pervasive anti-science culture, with emotional appeals. eg: "Do you want
chemicals in your body? Or do you want to take healthy
supplements instead?"
Just to give you an example from the last week here at my work... the employer offered free flu vaccine to employees. An RN visited each facility across the country and gave injections all day. Some employee who is a naturopath wrote the executive vice president of human resources a screed about how the company was now willfully poisoning its staff. The naturopath recommended a 'safe' alternative. Now, in addition to the vaccine, all employees have the option of getting a 'homeopathic' vaccine either instead of - or in addition to - the conventional vaccine. Here's what we were offered as a 'homeopathic flu vaccine': [
PASCOLEUCYN®]
I didn't want to be hostile, but when I mentioned to a coworker that this was clearly not homeopathic, she got very angry with me. The homeopath also offered take-home kits for $10 each. My coworker bought ten of these, and is going to inject her extended family with this over the weekend.
My observation was that about half of the employees chose to get vaccinated at all, and about half of those chose the conventional vaccine, and just over half chose the homeopathic vaccine, and there was some overlap group that had both.
My belief at this time is that the level of healthfraud in a country is dependent on the strength of anti-healthfraud legislation and its enforcement. Companies continue to sell antioxidants because there is demand for antioxidants, and this demand is fuelled by advertising which falsely educates the customer that this stuff works. It has never been shown that antioxidants are beneficial, and all advertising saying so has been fraudulent. But nobody's ever enforced it, and the supplement manufacturers learned quickly that in
this industry fibbing is very profitable and free of consequences. They hired lobbyists to keep things this way, and this is why we're in the state we're in.